| Literature DB >> 32252743 |
Ieva Salmane-Kulikovska1, Elita Poplavska2, Signe Mezinska3, Vita Dumpe4, Helena Dauvarte5, Lina Lazdina6, Aleksandr Marchockij7, Karolis Varzinskas7, Barbara J Mintzes8.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Interactions between pharmaceutical and medical device industries and students can lead to commercial influences on educational messages, with a potential to bias future treatment choice. This is the first study in the Baltic countries describing exposure and attitudes of medical, pharmacy and nursing students towards cooperation with industry.Entities:
Keywords: Education; Estonia; Latvia; Lithuania; Medical device industry; Medical students; Nursing students; Pharmaceutical industry; Pharmacy students
Year: 2020 PMID: 32252743 PMCID: PMC7137495 DOI: 10.1186/s12909-020-02008-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Med Educ ISSN: 1472-6920 Impact factor: 2.463
Demographic characteristics of the respondents
| Country | Latvia | Lithuania | Estonia | Total ( |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean age (SD) | 23.3 (SD 3.7) | 21.3 (SD 2.1) | 23.1 (SD 3.6) | 22.4 (SD 3.2) |
| Age range | 18–49 | 18–33 | 19–43 | 18–49 |
| Women, % | 89.2 | 78.9 | 78.8 | 81.4 |
| Men, % | 10.8 | 21.1 | 21.2 | 18.6 |
| Medical studentsa, % | 65.9 | 74.8 | 68.0 | 70.4 |
| Pharmacy studentsa, % | 18.4 | 16.5 | 14.0 | 16.1 |
| Nursing studentsa, % | 15.7 | 8.7 | 18.0 | 13.5 |
| Undergraduate studentsa (years 1–6), % | 97.7 | 99.7 | 100.0 | 99.4 |
| Residency in medicinea, % | 1.4 | 0.3 | – | 0.4 |
| Post-graduate studies (for pharmacy and nursing students)a, % | 0.9 | – | – | 0.2 |
| Working during their studiesa, % | 57.0 | 26.2 | 36.9 | 37.7 |
afrom all respondents within a country
Participation in the events and receipt of benefits from industry, %
| Participation in the events, organized or sponsored by industry | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medicine | Pharmacy | Nursing | Total | |
| Educational event aimed at students with a lecture from sales representatives, outside the study course | 39.3 (218/554) | (67/132) | (32/109) | 39.8 (317/796) |
| Conferences or meetings for healthcare providers, sponsored or organized by industry | 37.0 (205/554) | 42.1 (56/133) | (23/108) | 35.7 (284/795) |
| An industry-sponsored social event (dinner, sports event, etc.) | 29.7 (161/542) | (59/128) | (18/105) | 30.7 (238/775) |
| Presentations by sales representatives | (161/580) | (58/130) | 27.0 (30/111) | 30.3 (249/821) |
| Educational event as a part of the university course | (109/542) | (68/129) | 29.5 (33/112) | 26.8 (210/783) |
| Brochures, journals, magazines | (307/542) | (92/121) | 55.1 (54/98) | 59.5 (453/761) |
| Small gifts (value less than 10 EUR) | 49.9 (271/543) | (80/121) | (40/95) | 51.5 (391/759) |
| Free lunch, food, coffee, sweets, etc. | (144/522) | (68/119) | 25.3 (24/95) | 32.1 (236/736) |
| Drug samples | (119/545) | (52/120) | (10/98) | 23.7 (181/763) |
| Text book(s) | 10.6 (57/540) | 10.0 (12/120) | 10.3 (10/97) | 10.4 (79/757) |
| Gift of value more than 10 EUR | (28/537) | (16/120) | 4.2 (4/95) | 6.4 (48/752) |
| Medical device or instrument | 4.4 (24/543) | 1.6 (2/123) | 5.1 (5/98) | 4.1 (31/764) |
| Financial support for attending conferences | 2.8 (15/541) | 5.9 (7/119) | 2.1 (2/97) | 3.2 (24/757) |
| To participate in events | 5.7 (30/530) | (19/115) | 12.5 (12/96) | 8.2 (61/741) |
| To accept benefits | 4.3 (23/541) | 5.1 (6/118) | 5.3 (5/95) | 4.5 (34/754) |
Bolded text refers to responses that differ significantly from the total (adjusted standardized residuals value > 1.96 or < −1.96) at p < .05.
In paranteses, the number of students who gave positive answer and the total number of those who answered the question is presented. Answers “I do not wish to answer” were excluded from the analysis
Positive attitudes towards cooperation with industry, %
| Agreement with statement | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statement | Medicine | Pharmacy | Nursing | Total |
| It is important for students to attend educational events organized or sponsored by industry | (243/465) | (92/109) | 67.4 (58/86) | 59.5 (393/660) |
| Industry should participate in the education of students at universities | (153/465) | (72/110) | (52/86) | 41.9 (277/661) |
| Universities should promote financial collaboration between industry and faculty | (121/453) | (69/104) | (45/79) | 36.9 (235/636) |
| Industry provides objective, reliable and high-quality information about medicines and medical devices | (132/437) | (57/106) | 43.2 (32/74) | 35.8 (221/617) |
| I have enough information/knowledge on how to ethically interact with industry | (136/441) | 39.8 (39/98) | 39.2 (31/79) | 33.3 (206/618) |
| Industry should be seen as equal partner in the health care system along with patients, health care providers and government institutions | (128/429) | 37.5 (36/96) | 39.2 (29/74) | 32.2 (193/599) |
Bolded text refers to responses that differ significantly from the total (adjusted standardized residuals value > 1.96 or < − 1.96).
In paranteses, the number of students who gave positive answer and the total number of those who answered the question is presented. Answers “I do not wish to answer” were excluded from the analysis
Attitudes suggesting scepticism, %
| Agreement with statement | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statement | Medicine | Pharmacy | Nursing | Total |
| Students should receive training about ethical aspects of interactions between health care providers and industry | 89.1 (443/497) | 91.2 (103/113) | 88.0 (79/89) | 89.4 (625/699) |
| Free drug samples are a marketing tool | 74.8 (363/485) | 65.2 (73/112) | 69.8 (60/86) | 72.6 (496/683) |
| Gifts, financial support (including travel grants for conferences, consultancy fees etc.) from industry can influence a professional’s prescribing/dispensing habits | 71.1 (335/471) | 61.6 (61/99) | 65.0 (52/80) | 68.9 (448/650) |
| If a lecturer received a gift, financial or intellectual support from industry, she/he must always disclose it to the audience | 61.1 (286/468) | 54.5 (54/99) | 63.4 (52/82) | 60.4 (392/649) |
| Gifts from industry to physicians, pharmacists and nurses must be limited | (164/468) | 23.8 (24/101) | (17/81) | 31.5 (205/650) |
| Gifts from industry to students must be limited | (140/444) | (20/100) | 23.8 (19/80) | 28.7 (179/624) |
| Funding from industry to the physicians, pharmacists and nurses must be limited | (80/464) | (6/109) | 16.3 (14/86) | 15.2 (100/659) |
| Funding from industry to students must be limited | 11.6 (55/473) | 5.7 (6/106) | 13.4 (11/82) | 10.9 (72/661) |
Bolded text refers to responses that differ significantly from the total (adjusted standardized residuals value > 1.96 or < − 1.96).
In paranteses, the number of students who gave positive answer and the total number of those who answered the question is presented. Answers “I do not wish to answer” were excluded from the analysis
Predictors of participation in events and receipt of benefits
| Predictor | OR | 95% CI | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Study year (per year of advancement) | 1.55 | 0.001 | 1.23–2.00 |
| Gender - male | 0.302 | 0.001 | 0.16–0.58 |
| Study programme pharmacy | 4.96 | 0.007 | 1.54–16.0 |
| Study year | 1.42 | 0.002 | 1.14–1.76 |