BACKGROUND: Endogenous phospholipase A2 inhibitors from snake blood (sbPLIs) have been isolated from several species around the world, with the primary function of self-protection against the action of toxic phospholipases A2. In American snakes, sbPLIs were solely described in pit vipers, in which the natural protection role is justified. In this study, we described a sbPLI in Boa constrictor (popularly known as jiboia), a non-venomous snake species from America. METHODS: PLA2 inhibitory activity was tested in the blood plasma of B. constrictor using C. d. terrificus venom as the enzyme source. Antibodies developed against CNF, a sbγPLI from Crotalus durissus terrificus, were used to investigate the presence of homologues in the blood plasma of B. constrictor. A CNF-like molecule with a PLA2 inhibitory activity was purified by column chromatography. The encoding gene for the inhibitor was cloned from B. constrictor liver tissue. The DNA fragment was cloned, purified and sequenced. The deduced primary sequence of interest was aligned with known sbγPLIs from the literature. RESULTS: The blood plasma of B. constrictor displayed PLA2 inhibitory activity. A CNF-like molecule (named BcNF) was identified and purified from the blood plasma of B. constrictor. Basic properties such as molecular mass, composing amino acids, and pI were comparable, but BcNF displayed reduced specific activity in PLA2 inhibition. BcNF showed highest identity scores (ISs) with sbγPLIs from pit vipers from Latin America (90-100%), followed by gamma inhibitors from Asian viperid (80-90%). ISs below 70% were obtained for BcNF and non-venomous species from Asia. CONCLUSION: A functional sbγPLI (BcNF) was described in the blood plasma of B. constrictor. BcNF displayed higher primary identity with sbγPLIs from Viperidae than to sbγPLIs from non-venomous species from Asia. The physiological role played by sbγPLIs in non-venomous snake species remains to be understood. Further investigation is needed.
BACKGROUND: Endogenous phospholipase A2 inhibitors from snake blood (sbPLIs) have been isolated from several species around the world, with the primary function of self-protection against the action of toxic phospholipases A2. In American snakes, sbPLIs were solely described in pit vipers, in which the natural protection role is justified. In this study, we described a sbPLI in Boa constrictor (popularly known as jiboia), a non-venomous snake species from America. METHODS: PLA2 inhibitory activity was tested in the blood plasma of B. constrictor using C. d. terrificus venom as the enzyme source. Antibodies developed against CNF, a sbγPLI from Crotalus durissus terrificus, were used to investigate the presence of homologues in the blood plasma of B. constrictor. A CNF-like molecule with a PLA2 inhibitory activity was purified by column chromatography. The encoding gene for the inhibitor was cloned from B. constrictor liver tissue. The DNA fragment was cloned, purified and sequenced. The deduced primary sequence of interest was aligned with known sbγPLIs from the literature. RESULTS: The blood plasma of B. constrictor displayed PLA2 inhibitory activity. A CNF-like molecule (named BcNF) was identified and purified from the blood plasma of B. constrictor. Basic properties such as molecular mass, composing amino acids, and pI were comparable, but BcNF displayed reduced specific activity in PLA2 inhibition. BcNF showed highest identity scores (ISs) with sbγPLIs from pit vipers from Latin America (90-100%), followed by gamma inhibitors from Asian viperid (80-90%). ISs below 70% were obtained for BcNF and non-venomous species from Asia. CONCLUSION: A functional sbγPLI (BcNF) was described in the blood plasma of B. constrictor. BcNF displayed higher primary identity with sbγPLIs from Viperidae than to sbγPLIs from non-venomous species from Asia. The physiological role played by sbγPLIs in non-venomous snake species remains to be understood. Further investigation is needed.
Secretory phospholipases A2 are widely distributed as toxic components of
snake venoms. A number of snake species express endogenous snake blood phospholipase
A2 inhibitors (sbPLIs). This kind of molecules was first described in
venomous snakes with the primary function of self-protection against an eventual
presence of snake venom PLA2 (svPLA2) in their own blood
stream [1, 2]. According to the presence of known domains from mammal proteins -
C-type lectin-like, tandem leucine-rich repeats (LRRs), or three-finger motifs -
sbPLIs were grouped into alpha (α), beta (β) or gamma (γ) structural classes,
respectively [3]. Comparable inhibitors were
later identified in a number of non-venomous species [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9].
Whether venomous or not, some snake species express sbPLIs belonging to up to three
different structural classes simultaneously [3, 7, 10, 11].SbγPLIs are the most widely distributed inhibitors among elapid and viperid species
from the Old and New World [12, 13, 14].
Concerning non-venomous snakes, as far as we know, until now sbγPLIs were solely
purified from Asian species [4, 5, 6,
7, 8, 9]. With that in mind, we
investigated the presence of this kind of inhibitor in Boa
constrictor - a non-venomous tropical snake - popularly known as
jiboia. We identified a functional sbγPLI, cloned the encoding
gene from liver tissue and structurally characterized the deduced protein. The
sbγPLI was named BcNF by analogy with CNF (Crotalus neutralizing
factor), a prototype of this class of inhibitors previously isolated from the South
American rattlesnake, Crotalus durissus terrificus [15, 16].
Methods
Boa constrictor blood plasma and liver tissue
collection
Heparinized blood plasma and liver tissue fragments were collected from a
Boa constrictor specimen captured in the municipality of
Contagem (19º55'54" S, 44º03'13" W), in the Brazilian state of Minas Gerais. The
specimen was kept in captivity in the Serpentarium of Ezequiel Dias Foundation
until death by natural causes. The whole blood was collected immediately after
the animal death, centrifuged for plasma separation and clarified using a
0.22-µm microfilter. The total protein content was estimated by
spectrophotometry readings at 280 nm. One optical density unit was considered to
be equivalent to 1 mg/mL of protein. Liver fragments were collected in
DEPC-treated tubes and quickly frozen in liquid nitrogen. Whenever applicable,
blood plasma and tissue liver from C. d. terrificus specimens
were used as reference.
Fractionation of B. constrictor blood plasma
Five hundred microliters of B. constrictor blood plasma were
diluted to 10 mL with 25 mM Tris-HCl, 0.1 M NaCl pH 8.7 (buffer A) and dialyzed
against the same buffer to ensure ionic equilibrium. After centrifugation to
remove any insoluble material, the supernatant was loaded into an anion exchange
column (Hitrap QFF 1mL, GE HealthCare). Protein elution was performed with a
linear gradient of 25 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.7, containing 2.0 M NaCl (buffer B),
under a flow rate of 1 mL/min. Fractions with inhibitory activity (1 mL each)
were pooled, 4-fold diluted with a saturated ammonium sulfate (SAS) solution and
loaded into hydrophobic interaction columns connected in series [four columns
HiTrap Phenyl FF 5 mL (low sub) column, GE HealthCare]. Elution was performed
with a decreasing salt gradient under a flow of 5 mL/min. Total protein
concentration was estimated by optical density readings of the eluted fractions
at 280 nm.
Inhibition of PLA2 activity
The crude venom of C. d. terrificus was used as a source of
PLA2. Increasing volumes of snake blood plasma with known protein
concentration were preincubated with a fixed concentration (50 μg/mL) of
C. d. terrificus venom for 30 min at 37°C. The same
procedure was applied to purified fractions, after dialysis against 25 mM
ammonium formats, pH 6.5, whenever necessary. Residual PLA2 activity
was evaluated by measuring the clearing halos (in mm) of hydrolysis in agar gels
with incorporated hen egg yolk suspension [17]. Negative (PBS) and positive (no blood plasma) controls were run
in parallel. Inhibition curves were constructed by plotting the halo diameter
against protein concentration in logarithm scale. Data were analyzed by linear
regression using least squares method in the Graph Prism 6.0 for Mac OS X
(GraphPad software Inc., California). Curve limits were calculated with 95% of
confidence level. Specific activities were represented by curve slopes and
expressed by mean ± S.D. Whenever applicable, regression line slopes were
statistically compared in pairs.
SDS-PAGE and western blotting
B. constrictor blood plasma and purified BcNF were analyzed by
SDS-PAGE in a 15% homogeneous or in an 8-25% gradient Phast® gel (Phast System®,
GE HealthCare). Western blotting was revealed with rabbit anti-CNF IgG (0.5
mg/mL), followed by commercial anti-rabbit IgG-peroxidase antibody (A0545,
Sigma) at a 1:5000 dilution. The color reaction was developed with DAB (3,3'
diaminobenzidine tetrahydrochloride) in the presence of
H2O2.
RNA extraction and cDNA synthesis
Total RNA was isolated from about 50 mg of B. constrictor liver
tissue using Trizol® (Invitrogen, USA) following the manufacturer’s
instructions. RNA integrity was analyzed by gel electrophoresis in a 0.8%
agarose gel using TBE (89 mM Tris base, 89 mM boric acid, 2 mM EDTA, pH 8.0) as
running buffer. RNA bands were visualized under UV light, after staining with
ethidium bromide. After cDNA synthesis using 2 to 5 (g of total RNA and
oligo(dT)12-18 primer (First-Strand Synthesis kit, Invitrogen, USA), polymerase
chain reactions were carried out with specific oligonucleotides based on the
primary structure of CNF [15]:
3’CGCTCATGTGACTTTTGTCAC5’ (sense, amino-terminus), 3’TCAGAGGCTTGCCAATCTGATG5’
(antisense, carboxy-terminus). A housekeeping gene (β?actin) was PCR-amplified
in parallel, in the presence of adequate oligonucleotides.Fresh PCR products were cloned into the pGEM-T vector (Promega, USA) following
the manufacturer’s instructions. Insert-containing clones were isolated after
PCR screening of transformed NM522 E. coli. Negative control
contained no DNA. Amplified products were analyzed by electrophoresis in 1.0 %
agarose gels in TBE buffer, in the presence of ethidium bromide. DNA from three
positive clones were completely sequenced by the dideoxy chain termination
method [18] on an automated ABI Prism 310
Genetic Analyzer (Perkin Elmer Applied Biosystems, USA) with the Big Dye
Terminator Cycle Sequencing Ready Reaction (Perkin Elmer Applied Biosystems,
USA). M13 forward and M13 reverse oligonucleotides were used as primers.The cycling conditions were 3 min at 94°C, 35 cycles of 30 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at
55°C and 1 min at 72°C, followed by an extension period of 5 min at 72°C in a
TC412 thermocycler (Techne).
Primary/secondary structure predictions and multiple alignment
Three complete reads in both directions were assembled and aligned against each
other. The consensus sequence was used to deduce the primary structure and main
basic properties of BcNF. The secondary structure was predicted using the Chou
Fasman algorithm. Multiple sequencing alignments with primary structures of
other sbγPLIs were performed using the ClustalW algorithm and a Gonnet’s
similarity matrix was subsequently generated. Inclusion criterium for sbγPLIs
was the access to chemically determined or deduced primary structures in public
data bases. For species with two or more sequence deposits due to isoforms,
calculated consensus was taken as representative of the inhibitor. Signal
peptides were removed, whenever necessary. The sbγPLIs from the following snake
species were aligned: Bothrops alternatus (ABV91326/7),
Bothrops erythromelas (ABV91328/9), Bothrops
jararaca (ABV91330/1), Bothrops jararacussu
(ABV91332/3), Bothrops moojeni (ABV91332/5), Bothrops
neuwiedi (ABV91336/7), Crotalus durissus
terrificus (AAA19162), Elaphe climacophora
(BAH47550), Elaphe quadrivirgata (BAA83078), Gloydius
brevicaudus (formerly Agkistrodon blomhofii
siniticus) (BAA86970), Lachesis muta (AAR04437/8),
Malayopython reticulatus (formerly Python
reticulatus) (AAF73945), Notechis scutatus
(CAB56615/6/7), Oxyuranus microlepidotus (AAF23784),
Oxyuranus scutellatus (AAF23781), Protobothrops
flavoviridis (formerly Trimeresurus flavoviridis)
(BAA24502), Protobothrops elegans (BAJ14719/20/21),
Pseudonaja textilis (AAF23783), Sinonatrix
annularis (JN975878). All the procedures were
performed using the MacVector 16.0.10 software (Mac Vector Inc., USA) with
default parameters.
Results
Identification and purification of BcNF from B. constrictor
blood plasma
First, the blood plasma of B. constrictor was tested for
inhibition of C. d. terrificus venom PLA2 (Fig. 1). Inhibition was observed, although to
a lesser extent when compared to C. d. terrificus blood plasma
(positive control). Specific activities for PLA2 inhibition were:
-1.112 ± 0.1075 and -2.307 ± 0.1498 for B. constrictor and
C. d. terrificus blood plasma, respectively. These
activities were statistically different (p < 0.0001).
PLA2 inhibition activity was significantly lower for B.
constrictor blood plasma.
Figure 1
Inhibition curves of PLA2 activity of C. d.
terrificus venom by the blood plasma of Boa
constrictor (white dots). The blood plasma of
C. d. terrificus was used as reference (black
dots). Curve equations: y = (-1.112 ± 0.1075)x + (17.22 ± 0.3193)
for B. constrictor and y = (-2.307 ± 0.1498)x +
(17.45 ± 0.4478) for C. d. terrificus, with
determination coefficient (R2) of 0.9145 and 0.9546,
respectively. The 95% confidence intervals of the best fit curves
are indicated by dashed lines.
Following, we investigated whether the observed inhibition could be due to the
presence of a sbγPLIs. Western blotting revealed the presence of a CNF-like
molecule in the blood plasma of B. constrictor. Two main
protein bands were recognized by anti-CNF antibodies (Fig. 2), with apparent molecular masses roughly
corresponding to glycosylated (ng) and non-glycosylated (ng-) monomers. A
fainter band was present with mol. mass of possible dimers (2ng/2ng-). The
result indicated the presence of a sbγPLIs, named BcNF, in the blood plasma of
B. constrictor.
Figure 2
(A) SDS-PAGE 15% after staining with Coomassie Blue and (B)
Western blotting revealed with anti-CNF IgG. Lanes: MM - molecular
marker (in kDa) (SeeBlue Plus 2 Pre-stained Protein Standard,
Invitrogen); 1 - CNF (20 µg); 2 - C. d. terrificus
blood plasma (80 µg); 3 - B. constrictor blood
plasma (80 µg). The arrows indicate non-glycosylated monomer (ng-),
glycosylated monomer (ng) and possible dimers (2ng/2ng-).
BcNF was isolated from B. constrictor blood plasma using two
chromatographic steps: an ionic exchange followed by a hydrophobic interaction.
The eluted fractions were assayed for PLA2 inhibition (Fig. 3). Fractions from the second
purification step presenting inhibitory activity were combined and submitted to
electrophoresis and Western blotting using anti-CNF IgG. A CNF-like molecule
(BcNF) was mostly eluted with 100% of ultrapure water (Fig. 4). BcNF and CNF (positive control) at varying
concentrations were assayed for PLA2 inhibition (Fig. 5). Calculated specific activities were -1.344 ± 0.1705
and -4.797 ± 0.3434 for BcNF and CNF, respectively. These activities were
statistically different (p < 0.0001). BcNF inhibited
PLA2 at a significant lesser extent compared to CNF.
Figure 3
Purification of BcNF from B. constrictor blood
plasma. (A) Anion-exchange and (B)
hydrophobic interaction chromatograms. Elution gradients are
indicated by dotted lines. PLA2 inhibitor-containing
fractions are indicated by horizontal bars.
Figure 4
(A) SDS-PAGE in 8-25% gel after silver staining and (B) Western
blotting developed with anti-CNF IgG. PC: positive control (CNF).
Lanes are numbered on top according to percentages of eluent B
(ultrapure water) in the hydrophobic interaction
chromatography.
Figure 5
Inhibition curves of PLA2 activity of C. d.
terrificus venom by BcNF isolated from B.
constrictor blood plasma (white dots). CNF from
C. d. terrificus snakes was used as positive
control for PLA2 inhibition (black dots). Curve
equations: y = (-1.344 ± 0.1705)x + (13.50 ± 0.4235) for BcNF, and y
= (-4.797 ± 0.3434)x + (19.13 ± 0.4478) for CNF, with determination
coefficient (R2) of 0.8860 and 0.9606, respectively. The
95% confidence intervals of the best fit curves are indicated by
dashed lines.
BcNF cloning from B. constrictor liver tissue
The integrity of extracted RNA from B. constrictor liver tissue
was confirmed by the unique presence of characteristic bands corresponding to
18S and 28S ribosomal RNAs (data not shown). After RT-PCR in the presence of
specific primers for CNF, an amplicon of about 545 bp confirmed the encoding of
a CNF-like protein in the liver tissue of B. constrictor (Fig. 6). The DNA fragment was cloned,
purified and sequenced for further analysis.
Figure 6
Electrophoresis of RT-PCR products after amplification of liver
tissue with specific primers for CNF (left side) or β-actin (right
side). M: molecular marker 1 kb DNA ladder (Gibco-BRL). Lanes 1 and
4: B. constrictor liver; lanes 2 and 6: C.
d. terrificus liver (reference); lanes 3 and 7:
negative control (no DNA); lane 5: no reverse transcriptase in the
reaction.
Deduced primary structure and chemical properties predictions of BcNF
The deduced primary sequence of mature BcNF was compared to that of CNF. Both
proteins are composed of 181 amino acids, including 16 conserved cysteines and a
single putative N-linked carbohydrate site at Asn157. Fourteen amino
acid substitutions were noted in BcNF when compared to CNF, one of them
(R93/K93) within a segment proposed before for sbγPLIs
interaction with PLA2 (Fig. 7).
Basic properties of BcNF and CNF are summarized in Table 1.
Figure 7
Alignment of the deduced primary structure of BcNF (sbγPLI from
B. constrictor) and CNF (sbγPLI from C.
d. terrificus). Identical amino acids are in grey
background. Amino acid substitutions are in white background. The
decapentapeptide Q84PFPGLPLSRPNGYY98 is
indicated by a continuous black arrow above the numbering
line.
Table 1
Comparison of basic properties of BcNF (sbγPLI from B.
constrictor) and CNF (sbγPLI from C. d.
terrificus)
Property
BcNF
CNF
Molecular mass (Da)
20074.57
20058.69
Isoelectric point (pI)
5.51
5.55
Composing amino acids
Total (no.)
181
181
Chemical character (%)
Non-polar
30.4
30.9
Polar
43.0
42.4
Acidic
13.2
13.3
Basic
13.3
13.3
Amino acid substitutions, in general, lead to a decrease in the number of
α-helixes from three in CNF to one in BcNF, besides a displacement of beta
sheets in the predicted secondary structures of the proteins (Fig. 8).
Figure 8
Secondary structure predicted for BcNF (top) compared to CNF
(bottom). The differences are indicated by arrows on top of BcNF
structure, using the same color as in the structural
diagram.
Multiple sequence alignment of BcNF and other sbγPLIs
The deduced primary sequence of BcNF was multiply aligned with sbγPLIs from
venomous and nonvenomous snakes from Asia, Australia and Latin America
(available as Additional
file 1). A similarity matrix was generated (available as Additional file 2) and
the identity scores (ISs) were graphically represented (Fig. 9). For BcNF and sbγPLIs from Latin American pit
vipers, most ISs were within the last decile (90-100%). ISs above 80% were
obtained for Asian viperid snakes. On the other hand, when BcNF was compared to
sbγPLIs from non-venomous species from Asia, the ISs were below 70%. ISs below
70% were also obtained for Elapidae snakes.
Figure 9
Graphical representation of the identity scores (ISs) obtained in
Gonnet’s similarity matrix after multiple alignment of the deduced
primary structure of BcNF with known sbγPLIs. Black/white circle:
Colubridae, white triangle: Elapidae, white circle: Viperidae, black
rectangle: Pythonidae.
Discussion
Boa is a Neotropical genus of snakes that occurs almost
continuously from southern South America through to northern Mexico [19]. Historically recognized as monotypic,
recent data based on the distinct morphological traits, color patterns exhibited by
these snakes and the wide diversity of ecosystems they inhabit, collectively suggest
that the genus contains multiple species [20]. In Brazil, B. constrictor (sensu
lato) can be found all over the country, except in the extreme south [21]. It is an aglyphous species, devoid of
venom or Duvernoy’s glands. Similarly to other henophidian snakes (boas, pythons and
their kin), B. constrictor uses constriction to subdue and kill a
wide range of prey - including lizards, birds and mammals - through an interesting
modulated process mediated by the victim’s heartbeat [22]. Apparently, there is no need of an inhibitor for
self-protection against toxic svPLA2.The detection of sbPLIs in non-venomous snake species is not a novelty. The first
sbγPLIs was isolated from E. quadrivirgata [6]. The finding was later attributed to feeding habits of the
species on venomous snakes [7]. However,
another sbγPLI - named PIP for phospholipase A2 inhibitor from
Python - was soon described in the non-venomous and
non-ophiophagus species Malayopython reticulatus (formerly
Python reticulatus) [8].
Since then, a number of sbγPLIs were detected in colubrid from Asia: Dinodon
rufozanatum [5], Elaphe
carinata [5], E.
climacophora [7], E.
rufodorsata [5], E.
teniura, Macropisthodon rudis [9], Synonatrix annularis [4], and Zaocys dhumnades [5], in addition to xenodermatid Achalinus
rufescens [5]. A
structurally-related PIP homolog was also described in the non-venomous rock python
(P. sebae) from Africa, although with poor PLA2
inhibition activity [23]. Regarding
non-venomous snakes living in the American continent, studies are lacking on any
sbPLI.B. constrictor inhibition of PLA2 was lower than that of
C. d terrificus blood plasma. Similarly, BcNF was less active
than CNF. Our results are in accordance with those described for E.
climacophora and E. quadrivirgata. Respective sbγPLIs
were detected at higher amounts in the former, and justified by the ophiophagous
habits of the species [7]. It is important to
note that, in addition to sbγPLIs, those Elaphe species express sbα? and sbβPLIs
simultaneously in the circulating blood. We used antibodies developed against CNF to
search for sbγPLI in B. constrictor. The detection of inhibitors
from other structural classes is a possibility that cannot be discarded.BcNF is highly similar to CNF, with 14 substitutions in a total of 181 amino acids
and an IS of about 90%. The molecular masses of the non-glycosylated monomers,
calculated from amino acid compositions, are very close (Table 1). Band migrations in gel electrophoresis also indicated
similar apparent molecular masses for monomers and oligomers (Fig. 7). Like CNF, BcNF is composed by a mixture of
non-glycosylated (20 kDa) and glycosylated (22-24 kDa) monomers. For CNF, which is
the main subject of study in our lab, the proportion between non-glycosylated and
glycosylated varies according to the preparation. The sample loaded in SDS-PAGE
(Fig. 2) was mostly non-glycosylated.
However, it has been shown that the carbohydrate moiety is not essential for
PLA2 inhibition by CNF [24].
The same might be true for BcNF. The tendency for oligomerization might be a shared
property, too. In fact, the 16th, 113th, 132nd and
166th tyrosinyl residues, which were previously suggested to form the
interface between monomers in the oligomerization of CNF, are maintained at the same
positions in BcNF. These residues might be involved in the oligomerization of the
latter also. BcNF was only tested against svPLA2 from C. d.
terrificus venom, but the possibility of inhibition of other
svPLA2 cannot be discarded. The decapentapeptide
Q84PFPGLPLSRPNGYY98, which was previously proposed to be
the best consensus motif possibly involved in the sbγPLIs interaction with
PLA2s is maintained in BcNF. The only amino acid replacement was
conservative (R93/K93).Interestingly, BcNF appeared more closely related to sbγPLIs from Latin American pit
vipers, and from Asian pit vipers to a lesser extent, than to those from
non-venomous snakes from Asia described so far.
Conclusion
A functional sbγPLI (BcNF) was described, for the first time, in the blood plasma of
B. constrictor, a non-venomous species from America. BcNF
displayed higher primary identity with sbγPLIs from pit vipers than with sbγPLIs
from non-venomous species from Asia. Even with a growing number of sbγPLI
identifications in the last years, the physiological role played by these proteins
in non-venomous snake species remains to be clarified.
Authors: Daren C Card; Drew R Schield; Richard H Adams; Andrew B Corbin; Blair W Perry; Audra L Andrew; Giulia I M Pasquesi; Eric N Smith; Tereza Jezkova; Scott M Boback; Warren Booth; Todd A Castoe Journal: Mol Phylogenet Evol Date: 2016-05-27 Impact factor: 4.286
Authors: Scott M Boback; Allison E Hall; Katelyn J McCann; Amanda W Hayes; Jeffrey S Forrester; Charles F Zwemer Journal: Biol Lett Date: 2012-01-18 Impact factor: 3.703
Authors: Jory van Thiel; Muzaffar A Khan; Roel M Wouters; Richard J Harris; Nicholas R Casewell; Bryan G Fry; R Manjunatha Kini; Stephen P Mackessy; Freek J Vonk; Wolfgang Wüster; Michael K Richardson Journal: Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc Date: 2022-05-17