| Literature DB >> 32209104 |
Kim F E van de Loo1, José A E Custers2, Saskia Koene3,4, Inge-Lot Klein2, Mirian C H Janssen5, Jan A M Smeitink6, Christianne M Verhaak7.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Mitochondrial diseases (MD) are generally serious and progressive, inherited metabolic diseases. There is a high comorbidity of anxiety and depression and limitations in daily functioning. The complexity and duration of the diagnostic process and lack of knowledge about prognosis leads to uncertainty. In this study, we investigated the psychological well-being of children who are suspected for MD and their parents.Entities:
Keywords: Behavioral problems; Diagnostic process; Mitochondrial diseases; Parenting stress; Psychology; Quality of life
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32209104 PMCID: PMC7092429 DOI: 10.1186/s13023-020-1342-8
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Orphanet J Rare Dis ISSN: 1750-1172 Impact factor: 4.123
Demographic variables and disease/ health related characteristics
| Demographics | Children N (%, Total) | Family/ general information | Mothers | Fathers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean age | 8.4 years (0–17) | 38.7 (25–51) | 41.0 (24–54) | |
| Boys | 67 (54.9%, 122) | |||
| Child living at home | 115 (100%) | |||
| School/childcare | ||||
| • | 9 (7.8%, 115) | |||
| • | 85 (73.9%) | |||
| • | 21 (18.3%) | |||
| Nationality | 107 (97.3%, 110) | 94 (92.2%, 102) | ||
| Level of education: | ||||
| • | 0 (0%, 108) | 3 (2.9%, 105) | ||
| • | 13 (12.0%) | 8 (7.6%) | ||
| • | 7 (6.5%) | 9 (8.6%) | ||
| • | 56 (51.9%) | 52 (49.5%) | ||
| • | 26 (24.1%) | 19 (18.1%) | ||
| • | 6 (5.6%) | 14 (13.3%) | ||
| Having a job | 72 (65.5%, 110) | 95 (91.3%, 104) | ||
| Marital status: | ||||
| • | 87 (76.3%, 114) | |||
| • | 18 (15.8%) | |||
| • | 6 (5.3%) | |||
| • | 3 (2.6%) | |||
| Duration health complaints | ||||
| • | 11 (9.8%, 112) | |||
| • | 18 (16.1%) | |||
| • | 83 (74.1%) | |||
| Treatment in other care instances | 87 (75.0%, 116) | |||
| Involvement of other specialists in total | 85 (74.6%, 114) | |||
| • | 32 (28.1%, 114) | |||
| • | 63 (55.3%, 114) | |||
| • | 19 (16.7%, 114) | |||
| • | 13 (11.4%, 114) | |||
| • | 12 (10.5%, 114) | |||
| • | 32 (28.1%, 114) | |||
| • | 16 (14.0%, 114) | |||
| Care leave | 59 (56.7%, 104) | 65 (67.7%, 96) | ||
| Health problems: | 73 (63.5%, 115) | |||
| • | 46 (43.8%, 105) | 20 (19.8%, 101) | ||
| • | 43 (41.3%, 104) | |||
| Other concerns in general | 22 (20.8%, 106) | 11 (12.9%, 85) | ||
| Diagnoses | ||||
| • | 67 (54.9%) | |||
| • | 7 (5.7%) | |||
| • | 32 (26.2%) | |||
| • | 15 (12.3%) | |||
| • | 1 (0.8%) | |||
Child’s quality of life as reported by their parents (PedsQL)
| Quality of Life (PedsQL) | N* | Mean (SD) | Norms healthy population | Student’s t | Norms chronic ill population | Student’s t |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 84 | 59.57 (16.23) | 77.61 | T(83) = −10.19, | 64.05 | T(83) = −2.53, |
| Physical | 84 | 47.89 (24.60) | 79.20 | T(83) = −11.66, | 66.38 | T(83) = −6.89, |
| Emotional | 84 | 68.87 (20.01) | 77.65 | T(83) = −4.02, | 64.85 | T(83) = 1.84, |
| Social | 84 | 67.26 (18.41) | 79.51 | T(83) = − 6.10, | 63.45 | T(83) = 1.90, |
| School | 83 | 61.34 (16.40) | 73.12 | T(82) = −6.54, | 60.36 | T(82) = .55, |
| Psychosocial | 84 | 65.83 (14.47) | 76.76 | T(83) = −6.92, | 62.87 | T(83) = 1.88, |
| Total | 62 | 60.12 (16.87) | 77.61 | T(61) = −8.16, | 64.05 | T(61) = −1.83, |
| Physical | 62 | 48.27 (24.98) | 79.20 | T(61) = −9.75, | 66.38 | T(61) = −5.71, |
| Emotional | 63 | 69.52 (19.81) | 77.65 | T(62) = −3.26, | 64.85 | T(62) = 1.87, |
| Social | 61 | 68.87 (17.28) | 79.51 | T(61) = −4.85, | 63.45 | T(61) = 2.47, |
| School | 61 | 61.13 (16.43) | 73.12 | T(60) = −5.70, | 60.36 | T(60) = .37, |
| Psychosocial | 63 | 66.53 (14.73) | 76.76 | T(62) = −5.51, | 62.87 | T(62) = 1.97, |
* Of the 89 children who were 5 years or older, 84 parents filled in the PedsQL. Mother report only: N = 22, father report only: N = 0, mother and father report: N = 62
aNorms Varni et al., 2006 (the pedsql as a population health measure)
Child’s behavioral problems as reported by their parents (CBCL)
| Scale/subscale | Mothers report | Father report | Diagnosis vs no diagnosis, mothers report | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total score | 55.91 (10.04) | 18.6** | 54.15 (10.64) | 18.3* | T(110) = 1.64, |
| Internalizing | 59.35 (11.27) | 40.7** | 57.71 (11.58) | 32.9** | T(110) = 2.36, |
| Externalizing | 48.36 (10.08) | 7.9 | 47.84 (9.88) | 7.2 | T(111) = −.24, |
| Anxious/depressed | 55.66 (8.08) | 5.2 | 55.00 (7.52) | 3.6 | U = 1276, |
| Somatic complaints | 65.44 (10.37) | 36.8 | 63.40 (11.22) | 25.3 | T(111) = 1.49, |
| χ2(1) = 1.21, | |||||
| χ2(1) = 492, | |||||
| χ2(1) = 4.12, | |||||
| χ2(1) = 1.19, | |||||
| χ2(1) = .45, | |||||
| χ2(1) = .40, | |||||
| Withdrawn/depressed | 59.01 (8.47) | 12.3 | 57.77 (7.74) | 13.3 | T(111) = 1.71, |
| Withdrawn/depressedadj | 56.34 (7.54) | 7.0 | 55.65 (6.91) | 4.8 | T(111) = .62, |
| Attention problems | 58.26 (8.26) | 8.8 | 57.67 (8.80) | 8.4 | |
| Aggressive behavior | 53.69 (6.69) | 3.5 | 53.29 (5.97) | 2.4 | |
| Emotional reactive (1.5–5)a | 56.86 (9.96) | 8.6 | 56.83 (6.27) | 0 | |
| Sleep problems (1.5–5)a | 55.23 (6.85) | 2.9 | 52.86 (4.76) | 0 | |
| Social problems (6–18)b | 57.80 (7.68) | 5.1 | 57.17 (8.15) | 9.3 | |
| Thought problems (6–18)b | 58.13 (9.21) | 12.7 | 58.56 (9.46) | 16.7 | |
| Rule breaking behavior (6–18) b | 52.33 (4.12) | 1.3 | 52.54 (4.30) | 1.9 | |
*P < .05
**P < .001
aVersion 1.5–5 years, N = 35 mothers, 29 fathers
bVersion 6–18 years, N = 79 mothers, 54 fathers
cItem of the subscale somatic complaints. Rated as percentage of scores > 2 (‘very often/ true’ as response)
dpatients without a diagnosis have a higher mean score compared to patients with a diagnosis
Parental outcome measures: parenting stress (PSI) and social support (ISR)
| N | Mean (SD) | % in clinical range | Non-clinical population | Student’s t | Clinical population | Student’s t | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mothers | 85 | 47.80 (20.23) | 5.9% | 54.4a | T(84) = −3.009* | 85.9a | T(84) = −17.368** |
| Fathers | 72 | 49.10 (20.89) | 11.1% | 48.5a | T(71) = .243 | 70.4a | T(71) = −8.653** |
| Mothers | 111 | 17.01 (3.79) | 1.8% | 15.1b | T(110) = 5.302** | 14.5c | Wilcoxon, |
| Fathers | 89 | 16.82 (3.76) | 2.2% | 15.1b | T(88) = 4.318** | 14.5c | Wilcoxon, |
*P < .05
**P < .001
aNorms De Brock 1992
bNorms van Dam-Baggen and Kraaijmaat (1992)
cHuiskes Kraaijmaat Bijlsma 2004