| Literature DB >> 32102819 |
Juliane Burghardt1, Ana Nanette Tibubos2, Danielle Otten2, Elmar Brähler2, Harald Binder3, Hans Grabe4, Johannes Kruse5, Karl Heinz Ladwig6,7, Georg Schomerus8, Philipp S Wild9,10,11, Manfred E Beutel2.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Mental health is marked by gender differences. We formed a multi-cohort consortium to perform GEnder-Sensitive Analyses of mental health trajectories and study their implications for prevention (GESA). GESA aims at (1) identifying gender differences regarding symptoms and trajectories of mental health over the lifespan; (2) determining gender differences regarding the prevalence, impact of risk and protective factors; and (3) determining effects of mental health on primary and secondary outcomes (eg, quality of life, healthcare behaviour and utilisation). METHODS AND ANALYSIS: We plan to perform secondary analyses on three major, ongoing, population-based, longitudinal cohorts (Gutenberg Health-Study (GHS), Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP), Cooperative Health Research in the Augsburg Region (KORA)) with data on mental and somatic symptoms, medical assessments and diagnoses in north-east, middle and southern Germany (n>40 000). Meta-analytic techniques (using DataSHIELD framework) will be used to combine aggregated data from these cohorts. This process will inform about heterogeneity of effects. Longitudinal regression models will estimate sex-specific trajectories and effects of risk and protective factors and secondary outcomes. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: The cohorts were approved by the ethics committees of the Statutory Physician Board of Rhineland-Palatinate (837.020.07; GHS), the University of Greifswald (BB 39/08; SHIP) and the Bavarian Chamber of Physicians (06068; KORA). Together with stakeholders in medical care and medical training, findings will be translated and disseminated into gender-sensitive health promotion and prevention. © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2020. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.Entities:
Keywords: assessment; common mental disorders; gender; prospective; sex
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32102819 PMCID: PMC7045246 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034220
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Figure 1Relationships between common mental disorders, risk and protective factors and outcomes. 1All studies are ongoing; up to three follow-ups conducted to date. 2Only in SHIP.
Overview of the participating cohorts
| GHS | MONICA/KORA | SHIP | Combined samples | |
| Sampling area in Germany | City of Mainz and County of Mainz-Bingen, Midwest | City and county of Augsburg, south | Western Pomerania, north-east | |
| Age at baseline | 35–74 | 25–74 | 20–79 | 20–79 |
| Inclusion criteria |
Residency in the study area. |
Residency in the study area. German nationality. |
Residency in the study area. German nationality. | |
| Exclusion criteria |
Physical or mental inability to participate at the study centre. Insufficient knowledge of the German language. | None | None | |
| Stratification | Age, sex and city/county of residence | |||
| Sample size baseline | S1: 15 010 | S1: 4022 | S1: 4308 | 45 413 |
| Participation rate | 53% | 70%–80% | 69% SHIP | 53%–80% |
| Years baseline examinations | S1 2007–2012 | S1 1984–1985 | SHIP 1997 –2001 | Starting 1984 |
| Number of follow-ups | 4 | 2–3 | 4 | 4 |
| Follow-up intervals | 2 ½ (CATI), 5 years | 5–7 years | After 5 years | 2.5–7 years |
| Non-responder | Structured questionnaires for non-responders including cardiovascular risk factor profile, concomitant diseases, sociodemography. | Depending on sample. | Information about non-responders includes age, gender and the reason for not taking part. | |
| Quality assurance | Computer-assisted structured interviews with hard and soft bounds for manual data entry. Tape-based backup (up to 6 months) for regular plausibility checks and quality control. | Tapes serve as a backup for plausibility checks, and a random sample was used to control interviewer performance. During data collection all researchers participating KORA study are required to provide a written internal quality control report about the protocol elements for which they are responsible in 3-month intervals. | All interview data were checked semiannually for interviewer bias during data collection. | |
CATI, computer-assisted telephone interview; GHS, Gutenberg Health Study; KORA, Cooperative Health Research in the Augsburg Region; MONICA, monitoring trends and determinants on cardiovascular diseases; SHIP, Study of Health in Pomerania.
Figure 2Overview of cohort samples and assessment years. CATI, computer-assisted telephone interview; F, follow-up; FF, follow-up of the follow-up; FFF, follow-up of the follow-up of the follow-up, GEFU, postal general health follow-up; GHS, Gutenberg Health Study; KORA, Cooperative Health Research in the Augsburg Region; MONICA, monitoring trends and determinants on cardiovascular diseases; S, sample; SHIP, Study of Health in Pomerania. 1Additionally, numerous smaller-scale examinations and surveys on special issues have taken place also older participants were examined within KORA age (includes participants ≥65 years from S1 to S4).
Harmonised variables per cohort
| Constructed variables | Harmonisation process |
|
| |
| Depression | PHQ-9 scales or combination of PHQ-9 and BDI-2 recoded into binary variable |
| Suicidal ideation | Items from PHQ-9 and BDI-2, recoded into binary variable |
| Sleep problems | Question about falling asleep and PHQ-9 sleep item recoded into binary variable |
| Smoking status | Derived from several smoking variables including current and past habits, recoded into categories (regular/ irregular/ ex-smoker/ never smoked) |
| BMI | weight/height², continuous variable |
| Physical activity | Derived from variables of activities and doing sports, recoded into binary variable |
| Diabetes | Self-reported (diagnosed by doctor) and metabolic factors recoded into binary variable |
| Myocardial infarction | Self-reported (diagnosed by doctor), recoded into binary variable |
| Stroke | Self-reported (diagnosed by doctor), recoded into binary variable |
| Cancer | Self-reported, recoded into binary variable |
| Chronic disease | Any presence of diabetes, myocardial infarction, stroke and cancer, recoded into binary variable |
| Sex | Self-reported (male/ female) |
| Age (in years) | Self-reported or derived from birthday and study date |
| Education (in years) | Self-reported or derived from educational degree and work educational degree |
| Marital status | Recoded into categories married, not married/single, divorced, widowed |
| People per household | Self-reported participant and spouse, children etc., continuous variable |
| Living with partner | Similar questions in cohorts (yes/no) |
| Living alone | Derived from people per household (yes/ no) |
| Current employment | Derived from combination of employment variables, recoded into categories: no, fulltime, part-time, marginally employed |
| Household income | Ordinal variables with different categories per cohort, new metric variable constructed with mean value of income category per person |
|
| |
| Anxiety | Combination of GAD-7 and four CID items, recoded into binary variable (GAD-7≥9 as anxiety, any CID-S item score as anxiety) |
| PTSD | ICD-10 with four criteria: (A) traumatic event, (B) intrusion, (C) avoidance and (D) hyperarousal; fulfilment of A, B, C or D is coded as full PTSD, fulfilment of A and B, C or D is coded as partial PTSD, no fulfilment of A is coded as no PTSD |
| Alcohol consumption | Based on amounts and frequency of alcohol consumption, recoded into ordinal variable (categories: no, low, high) |
| Emotional abuse childhood | Combination of CTS item and CTQ item, similar answer categories, recoded into ordinal variable (five categories: not at all to very often) |
| Emotional neglect childhood | Combination of CTS and CTQ item, similar answer categories, recoded into one ordinal variable (five categories: not at all to very often) |
| Sexual abuse childhood | |
| Physical abuse childhood | |
| Physical neglect childhood | |
| Type 2 diabetes | Self-reported diabetes (diagnosed by doctor), metabolic factors and self-reported type of diabetes, recoded into ordinal variable (categories: no, yes, other type) |
| Parents with diabetes | Diabetes for mother and father each or combined, recoded into ordinal variable (no, father, mother, both) |
| History of myocardial infarction | Self-reported (diagnosed by doctor), recoded into binary variable |
| Hypertension | Blood pressure measures with same measurement units, recoded into continuous variable |
| Total cholesterol | Cholesterol measurement with different measurement units, recode measurement units and recoded into continuous variable |
| HDL-cholesterol | HDL-cholesterol measurement with different measurement units, recoded into continuous variable |
| Height (in cm) | Measured |
| Waist circumference (in cm) | Measured |
| Hip circumference (in cm) | Measured |
| Waist–height ratio | Waist circumference/height |
| Reason for retirement | Recoding categories and recoded into ordinal variable with three categories |
| Duration of unemployed (years and months) | Exact number or calculated from unemployment since certain date, recoded into continuous variable |
|
| |
| Pregnancy | Self-reported (yes/ no) |
| Lifetime unemployment | Recoded into binary variable |
| Children | Derived from having children and number of children, recoded into one continuous variable and one binary variable |
BDI, beck depression inventory; BMI, body mass index; CID-S, composite international diagnostic screener; CTQ, Child Trauma Questionnaire; CTS, Childhood Trauma Screener; GAD, generalized anxiety disorder; GHS, Gutenberg Health Study; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; KORA, Cooperative Health Research in the Augsburg Region; PHQ-9, Patient Health Questionnaire; PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder; SHIP, Study of Health in Pomerania.
Figure 3Overview of analysis plan GESA. GESA, GEnder-Sensitive Analyses of mental health trajectories and implications for prevention.