Chen Wang1,2, Xiao-Ping Zhao1, Fei-Fei Liu1, Yuming Chen3, Xing-Hua Xia2, Ju Li3. 1. Department of Chemistry, School of Science, China Pharmaceutical University, Nanjing, 211198, China. 2. State Key Laboratory of Analytical Chemistry for Life Science, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China. 3. Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering and Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, United States.
Abstract
Ion transport in an artificial asymmetric nanoporous membrane, which is similar to biological ion channels, can be used for biosensing. Here, a dendrimer-Au nanoparticle network (DAN) is in situ assembled on a nanoporous anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) surface, forming a DAN/AAO hybrid membrane. Benefiting from the high surface area and anion selectivity of DAN, the prepared DAN/AAO hybrid presents selective ion transport. Under a bias potential, a diode-like current-potential (I-V) response is observed. The obtained ionic current rectification (ICR) property can be tuned by the ion valence and pH value of the electrolyte. The rectified ionic current endows the as-prepared DAN/AAO hybrid with the ability of enhanced bioanalysis. Sensitive capture and detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) with a detection limit of 80 cells mL-1 as well as excellent reusability can be achieved.
Ion transport in an artificial asymmetric nanoporous membrane, which is similar to biological ion channels, can be used for biosensing. Here, a dendrimer-Au nanoparticle network (DAN) is in situ assembled on a nanoporous anodicaluminum oxide (AAO) surface, forming a DAN/AAO hybrid membrane. Benefiting from the high surface area and anion selectivity of DAN, the prepared DAN/AAO hybrid presents selective ion transport. Under a bias potential, a diode-like current-potential (I-V) response is observed. The obtained ioniccurrent rectification (ICR) property can be tuned by the ion valence and pH value of the electrolyte. The rectified ioniccurrent endows the as-prepared DAN/AAO hybrid with the ability of enhanced bioanalysis. Sensitive capture and detection of circulating tumorcells (CTCs) with a detection limit of 80 cells mL-1 as well as excellent reusability can be achieved.
Entities:
Keywords:
dendrimer-Au nanoparticle network; enhanced bioanalysis; hybrid membrane; ion selectivity; ionic current rectification
Ioniccurrent
rectification
(ICR) is seen in biological or artificial nanochannels,[1−4] where a nonlinear and asymmetriccurrent–potential (I–V) curve appears due to asymmetric ionic transport.
Generally, ICR can occur in the cases of symmetry breaking in the
structure, surface charge distribution, bulk electrolyte concentration,
or combinations of these factors.[5−7] The correlation between
ICR properties and the degree of symmetry breaking was precisely demonstrated,
taking the DNA-stuffed nanochannel as the model system.[4] Up to now, a variety of techniques have been
developed for the fabrication of ICR devices such as direct modification,
plasma grafting, and ion sputtering,[8−16] in nanofluidic devices including nanopores with an asymmetric geometry,[8,9] homogeneous nanochannels with asymmetric surface modifications,[10,11] hybrids composed of varied nanomaterials,[12−14] and dynamiccurvature nanochannels.[15] For example,
by laminating the polystyrene-b-poly(4-vinylpyridine)
membrane and polyethylene terephthalate membrane, a heterogeneous
polymer membrane displaying a highly ICR characteristic was constructed.[16] Recently, some inert or conductive nanochannels/nanopores
have been directly fabricated on thin metal films, on which detection
of nanoparticles,[17,18] biomolecules,[19] or asymmetric ionic transport[20] have been successfully performed.The network formed by functional
nanomaterials and ligands provides
a simple, robust, and highly efficient fabrication technique for the
construction of novel nanoporous structures.[21−24] Compared to traditional solid
nanoporous materials, the network has a more exposed surface area.
For example, by grafting gold spheres on a glass nanopipette with
the DNA linker, a pH-responsive structure was successfully fabricated.[24] Owing to the tunable distance within Au nanoparticles
(AuNPs) by the DNA linker, the fabricated nanodevice presents varied
ICR properties under different pH values. The nonuniform geometry
and surface charge density endow the formed device with tunable ICR
properties. These interesting works provide new strategies to design
and develop multifunctional heterogeneous hybrid devices with a high
ICR response for seawater desalination,[13] energy conversion,[16] and bioanalysis/sensors.[8,9]Sensitive and selective cell capture and detection play important
roles in the prognosis and treatment of cancer.[25] Recently, we developed a nanochannel–ion channel
hybrid with an ICR property for the efficient capture and detection
of circulating tumorcells (CTCs).[26] Due
to the unique ICR characteristic, the CTCconcentrations ranging from
1 × 102 to 2 × 106 cells mL–1 can be successfully detected with a detection limit of 100 cells
mL–1. However, in that work, only the outer surface
of the anodicaluminum oxide (AAO) membrane can be used. The fewer
surface areas, as well as a relatively smooth surface, is a big challenge
for efficient cell capture. In addition, the ion channel dimensions
are fixed, and cannot be tuned flexibly. The super small size of the
ion channels may prevent the relatively bigger drug molecules or negatively
charged molecules from passing through, which will limit its applications
in cell downstream analysis, such as drug transport, screening, and
cancer therapy.Herein, we reported a new ionic rectification
device fabricated
by assembling the AuNPs network on the surface of the AAO membrane
for CTCs analysis. Dendrimer (poly(amidoamine) (PAMAM)) and carbon
disulfide (CS2) were used as the linkers to connect AuNPs,
forming a dendrimer–nanoparticle network (denoted as DAN in
the following work) film. This cross-linked DAN film can be in situ assembled onto the surface of AAO by chemical coupling
of the −N–C bond in DAN with amine-functionalized AAO,
forming the DAN/AAO hybrid. The high surface-to-volume ratio, as well
as exposed functional groups on the DAN film, will provide abundant
active sites for molecular anchoring, which is of critical importance
to efficient and selective cell capture. The symmetry breaking by
covering DAN on one side of AAO endows the hybrid with an excellent
ICR property, ensuring highly sensitive cell detection. Finally, the
captured cells can be released with nearly no damage under the action
of benzonase, endowing the hybrid with the ability to be reused with
excellent durability. Therefore, the present DAN/AAO hybrid is expected
to behave as a robust and sensitive biosensor toward cell analysis
and detection. Besides, the AuNPs in DAN film possesses an unique
localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) characteristic that would
enable highly accurate characterizations such as surface-enhanced
Raman scattering (SERS)[27] and electrochemistry[28] and open an avenue for combining fluidics with
plasmonics.
Results and Discussion
Fabrication and Characterization of the DAN/AAO
Hybrid
The fabrication process is illustrated in Figure A. AAO was prepared
using the method described
previously.[29] To obtain the amine-functionalized
AAO, AAO was immersed into a 1% (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (APTES)
solution for 12 h, followed by rinsing with ethanol and drying in
nitrogen gas. The prepared amine-functionalized AAO was then placed
at the bottom of a small vial containing a mixture consisting of 4-dimethylaminopyridine
(DMAP) stabilized AuNPs (∼7 nm),[30] CS2methanol solution, and PAMAM dendrimermethanol solution.
The gold nanoparticles were assembled on the top surface of AAO linked
by CS2, forming the DAN film. Following the completion
of the reaction, the remaining solution was removed, and the DAN/AAO
hybrid was obtained.
Figure 1
(A) Schematic illustration of the preparation of the DAN/AAO
hybrid.
(B–F) SEM images of the DAN/AAO hybrid. (B) Top of the DAN/AAO
hybrid. (C) Cross section of AAO. (D) DAN film. (E) Cross section
of the DAN/AAO hybrid. The inset is the enlarged image of the cross
section. (F) The thickness of the whole DAN/AAO hybrid. (G) The contact
angle of the DAN film. (H–I) XPS spectra of the DAN/AAO hybrid
((H) XPS curve of APTES; (I) XPS curve of AuNPs). (J) UV–vis
spectra of the prepared AuNPs and DAN film. Black curve: pure AuNPs
solution. Red curve: AuNPs containing the PAMAM dendrimer and CS2 solution. The inset shows the TEM image of the prepared AuNPs;
the scale bar is 20 nm. (K) SAXRD patterns for the DAN composites.
(A) Schematic illustration of the preparation of the DAN/AAO
hybrid.
(B–F) SEM images of the DAN/AAO hybrid. (B) Top of the DAN/AAO
hybrid. (C) Cross section of AAO. (D) DAN film. (E) Cross section
of the DAN/AAO hybrid. The inset is the enlarged image of the cross
section. (F) The thickness of the whole DAN/AAO hybrid. (G) The contact
angle of the DAN film. (H–I) XPS spectra of the DAN/AAO hybrid
((H) XPS curve of APTES; (I) XPS curve of AuNPs). (J) UV–vis
spectra of the prepared AuNPs and DAN film. Black curve: pure AuNPs
solution. Red curve: AuNPscontaining the PAMAM dendrimer and CS2 solution. The inset shows the TEM image of the prepared AuNPs;
the scale bar is 20 nm. (K) SAXRD patterns for the DANcomposites.To characterize the morphology of the fabricated
AAO, scanning
electron microscopy (SEM) was used. Figure B–E indicates the successful formation
of the DAN/AAO hybrid. The fabricated AAO has regular pores of ∼40
nm in diameter (Figure B,C). The upper layer of AAO was covered by the DAN film (Figure D,E). The thickness
of the DAN film is around 40 nm (inset of Figure E). The entire thickness of the DAN/AAO hybrid
is ∼50 μm (Figure F). The contact angle on both sides of the hybrid was measured
(Figure G and Figure S1), indicating the hydrophilicity of
the DAN film and the hybrid. High-resolution spectra of X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (XPS) was used to further prove the successful assembly
of DAN. It is notable that the DAN/AAO hybrid exhibits singular signals
at 101.4 eV ascribed to −Si–O– from the coupling
reagent of APTES (Figure H) and two obvious Au 4f peaks at 82.5 and 86.5 eV, respectively,
from AuNPs (Figure I). In addition, energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) mapping of
the SEM images (Figure S2) was used to
identify the elemental distribution of Au, Si, N, O, and C.[31] It can be seen that the Au and Si atoms are
dispersed homogeneously in the architecture, indicating the formation
of the DAN film on the top of AAO. These results demonstrate the successful
formation of the DAN/AAO hybrid.To verify the formation mechanism
of the DAN film, UV–vis
spectra were used to examine the interaction between PAMAM and AuNPs.
The results are shown in Figure K, showing a dominant absorption peak at ∼518
nm (black curve in Figure J, an average diameter of 7 ± 1 nm in this work shown
in the inset of Figure J). This absorption resulted from the characteristic plasmonic absorption
of isolated AuNPs. After reaction with CS2 and the PAMAMdendrimer, the absorption peak shifted to ∼647 nm due to the
change in the dielectric environment (red curve in Figure J). The results are in accordance
with the previous work.[24] The interparticle
spacing for the DAN film was determined by the small-angle X-ray diffraction
(SAXRD) patterns (Figure K) using the Bragg diffraction eq (2θ = 2.4) is less
than 4.5 nm.[24] To further confirm the interparticle
spacing for the DAN film, AuNPs, PAMAM, and CS2 were assembled
in solution to form the same structure of the DAN film. The TEM image
(Figure S3) shows that the nanopores exist
among neighboring AuNPs in the DNP film with the size of interparticle
spacing ∼ 3.6 nm.
Ion Transport Properties of the DAN/AAO Hybrid
The
ion selectivity of the DAN/AAO hybrid was examined by cyclic voltammetry
(CV) using Ru (NH3)63+ or Fe (CN)63– as the electrochemical probes, respectively,
in 1 mM KCl aqueous solution. The electrochemical setup is schematically
shown in Figure A.
Then, 0.5 mM Ru (NH3)63+ or Fe (CN)63– was put into one of the two half cells
for CV measurements. Gold, Ag/AgCl, and platinum wire were used as
the working electrode, reference electrode, and auxiliary electrode,
respectively. Figure B,C shows the CVs obtained with bare AAO and the DAN/AAO hybrid.
Both Ru(NH3)63+ and Fe (CN)63– could transport through the bare AAO as evidenced
by the obvious redox peaks. In comparison with the bare AAO, the DAN/AAO
hybrid film shows anion selective transport properties due to the
existence of surface charges since only the redox current for the
ferricyanide anioncan be observed (Figure C). There is no redox current observable
for the electrochemical probe of Ru(NH3)63+ cation (Figure B). This suggests DAN is anion-selective, allowing only anions
to pass. Because the pKa of DMAP ligands
on the AuNPs surface is 9.6,[30] DAN should
be positively charged when the pH is less than 9.6. The interstitial
spacing in DAN is less than 4.5 nm, so it interacts very strongly
with ions that try to pass through the interstices of the network.
Figure 2
(A) Setup
for CV measurements. The substrate in the figure is used
to fix the DAN/AAO hybrid. CVs of the DAN/AAO hybrid (red curve) and
bare AAO (blue curve) electrode in 1 mM KCl containing 0.5 mM Ru(NH3)63+ (B) and Fe(CN)63–(C). The scan rate was 50 mV s–1. (D) Schematic illustration of the setup for the measurement of I–V curves. (E) I–V curve
of AAO in 1 mM KCl at pH 7.0. (F) I–V curve
of the DAN/AAO hybrid in 1 mM KCl at pH 7.0. (G) Rectification ratio
of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different AuNP concentrations (30 mM, 6 mM,
3 mM, 0.6 mM, 0.3 mM). (H, I) Illustration of the ICR mechanism of
the DAN/AAO hybrid.
(A) Setup
for CV measurements. The substrate in the figure is used
to fix the DAN/AAO hybrid. CVs of the DAN/AAO hybrid (red curve) and
bare AAO (blue curve) electrode in 1 mM KClcontaining 0.5 mM Ru(NH3)63+ (B) and Fe(CN)63–(C). The scan rate was 50 mV s–1. (D) Schematic illustration of the setup for the measurement of I–V curves. (E) I–V curve
of AAO in 1 mM KCl at pH 7.0. (F) I–V curve
of the DAN/AAO hybrid in 1 mM KCl at pH 7.0. (G) Rectification ratio
of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different AuNPconcentrations (30 mM, 6 mM,
3 mM, 0.6 mM, 0.3 mM). (H, I) Illustration of the ICR mechanism of
the DAN/AAO hybrid.The ionic transport properties
of the DAN/AAO hybrid were investigated
using two Ag/AgCl electrodes (Figure D). For the pure AAO film, an Ohmic linear I–V curve is observed (Figure E). After DAN was modified to the AAO surface,
the ioniccurrent displays a diode-like I–V curve (Figure F)
due to the existence of asymmetry in the structure and surface charge
density from the linkers. To achieve the high-performance ICR device,
the influencing factors including AuNPsconcentrations, channel size,
and AAO thickness were investigated. Figure G shows the effect of AuNPconcentration
on ICR (the I–V curves refer to Figure S4). With an increasing AuNPconcentration,
the ICR ratio (f ≡ I+1 V/I–1 V, I+1 V is denoted as the current value at
+1.0 V, I–1 V is denoted as
the absolute current value at −1.0 V) significantly increases
to a maximum value of 19.3 when the film was prepared with 30 mM AuNPs.
It has been reported that decreasing the density of dendrimers between
particles will decrease the interparticle spacing.[32] To keep the same quantity of dendrimers, an increased AuNPsconcentration will decrease the ratio of dendrimers in the DAN layer,
resulting in a smaller interparticle spacing in the DAN film. The
ion transport is influenced by both ion selectivity and ion conductivity.
The ion conductivity of the hybrid will decrease as the interparticle
spacing in the DAN film gets smaller, resulting in a decrease of ioniccurrent (Figure S4). However, the ICR property
was determined by the distinct transport actions of co-ions and counterions
in the nanochannels.[10,33] The decreased channel size will
contribute to more excellent ion selectivity. Thus, a higher ICR ratio
can be expected in the case of a smaller interparticle spacing in
the DAN film. The effects of the AAOchannel size and thickness (Figure S5 and Figure S6) indicate that the channel size could influence the ICR property
efficiently, while AAO thickness does not. The effect of surface charges
will be weakened with the increase of channel size, which in turn
decreases the ICR efficiency. Interestingly, although there is little
influence of the AAO thickness on the dimensionless ICR ratio, it
was found that the ioniccurrent decreases slightly as AAO becomes
thicker (Figure S6A), caused by the increased
electric resistance for thicker AAO. Considering all factors in the
fabrication and device performance, the DAN/AAO hybrid prepared by
30 mM AuNPs and AAO with a 40 nm diameter was used in the following
measurements.The ICR mechanism of the present hybrid is schematically
shown
in Figure H,I. While
the pKa of pure AAO is around 6, the pKa of the primary amine group of the PAMAM dendrimer
and APTES is around 10.0,[34] so we expect
our amine-functionalized AAO to be positively charged when the pH
value is less than 10.0. Under a pH = 7 environment, therefore, both
DAN and AAO should be positively charged. When the electric field
is applied from the bottom (AAO) side to the top (DAN) side, cations
(K+) are driven from bottom to top, and anions (Cl–) from top to bottom. While Cl– can
freely pass the anion-selective DAN, K+ would be stopped
by the DAN and accumulate inside the AAO nanochannel. To maintain
electroneutrality, some Cl– would stay to accompany
K+, increasing the ionic strength. The increased ion concentration
within the AAO nanochannel results in a reduced electrical double
layer (EDL) thickness, and so more Cl– can pass
through the hybrid, unencumbered by the charge on amine-functionalized
AAO. We called this the “on” state (Figure H). In comparison, when the
electric field is applied from the top (DAN) side to the bottom (AAO)
side, the cations (K+) are driven from top to bottom, which,
however, will be excluded by DAN because it is anion-selective. Also,
those K+ previously stored inside the nanochannel will
be driven out and exit from the bottom. The Cl– are
driven from bottom to top, but they flow through DAN, so they are
not accumulated inside the AAO tubule either; therefore, the ions
within AAO nanochannels are depleted, resulting in a reduced ionic
strength, larger EDL, and decreased Cl– current.
Under the extreme condition, nearly no Cl– ions
flow through the hybrid, and accordingly, the hybrid presents the
“off” state (Figure I).
Effect of pH on Ion Transport
The
pH value has a significant
influence on the ion transport behavior of the present DAN/AAO hybrid. Figure A shows the measured I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid under different
pH values. Figure B is the rectification ratio calculated from Figure A, which decreases as the pH value changes
from 3.0 to 10.0, then rapidly declines to f <
1 (reversed ICR direction) at pH 11.0. The pH-tunable ICR property
is schematically illustrated in Figure C. As has been described above, the present hybrid
is positively charged when the pH value is less than 10.0. At a lower
pH, the DAN/AAO hybrid surface will carry more positive charges that
attract more anions passing through the DAN/AAO hybrid. Thus, a higher
ICR property can be expected. With increasing the pH value to 10.0,
the ioniccurrent and ICR ratio decrease due to the declined positive
surface charge. It is furthermore observed that the I–V property of the DAN/AAO hybrid sustains reversion at pH 11.0 (f = 0.3). The amino groups are neutral at a high pH,[15] but the acylamion groups from PAMAM may partially
hydrolyze at a high pH value (pH 11.0) because the pKa of acylamion groups is around 10.0.[35] Therefore, the surface of AAO nanochannels is neutral,
but the DAN film might be negatively charged in this condition. The
ioniccurrent will be dominated by cations (K+) rather
than Cl– ions. Under this circumstance, the I–V properties of the DAN/AAO hybrid is reversed:
a high conducting (“on”) state for V < 0 and a low conducting (“off”) state for V > 0. When the solution pH is equal to pKa, the hybrid is electroneutral, and thus nearly no ICR
will be observed. To keep a constant pH value, the effect of temperature
on the mass transport property of the hybrid was also investigated
(Figure S7). The currents of both “on”
and “off” states increase as the temperature increases.
However, the current of the “on” state increases more
significantly than that in the “off” state, resulting
in an increased ICR ratio at a higher temperature. This result is
in accordance with previous work.[36]
Figure 3
I–V curves measured on the DAN/AAO hybrid
in solutions with different pH values. (B) Rectification ratio of
the DAN/AAO hybrid in solutions with different pH values. (C) Mechanism
of ion transport through the DAN/AAO hybrid in solutions with varied
pH values (brown spheres represent anions; blue spheres represent
cations). (D) The ζ potential of DAN fragments at different
pH values.
I–V curves measured on the DAN/AAO hybrid
in solutions with different pH values. (B) Rectification ratio of
the DAN/AAO hybrid in solutions with different pH values. (C) Mechanism
of ion transport through the DAN/AAO hybrid in solutions with varied
pH values (brown spheres represent anions; blue spheres represent
cations). (D) The ζ potential of DAN fragments at different
pH values.To further quantify the charge
change at different pH, the ζ
potential of the self-assembled DAN fragments was determined by mixing
AuNPs, CS2, and PAMAM dendrimer. As shown in Figure D, the measured ζ potentials
changed from 38.0 mV to 2.71 mV, indicating a decreased positive charge
density from pH 3.0 to pH 10.0. As expected, the ζ potential
changes to −12.7 mV at pH 11.0. The results demonstrate that
the solution pH can regulate the surface charges of the DAN/AAO hybrid
via protonization/deprotonization, which regulates the ICR properties.
Effect of Ions Concentration and Valence
To further
illustrate the ionic transport properties of the DAN/AAO hybrid, different
electrolyte concentrations at pH 7.0 were added into two half cells.
As shown in Figure A, the DAN/AAO hybrid shows different rectified currents for different
ion concentrations. The transmembrane current increases with increasing
the ion concentration from 0.001 mM to 1 M due to the increased amount
of ions through the DAN/AAO hybrid. The ICR ratio (f) increases to 65.4 at 100 mM solution; then, it decreases with further
increasing of the ion concentrations (Figure B). It is clear the ICR ratio reaches a maximum
value when the surface charges are balanced by the counterions in
the EDL.[37] Note that the thickness of electrical
double layers is affiliated with the ionic Debye length, λD, with λD ∝1/(cb)1/2, where cb is the
bulk ionicconcentration.[38] Therefore,
upon increasing the ionic strength to 1 M, the thickness of EDL decreased,
suggesting the decrease of ionic selectivity due to the decline of
the EDL screening effect, and thus, the ICR ratio declines. For a
system with lower electrolyte concentrations, although the EDL overlapping
occurs, the ICR decreases due to fewer ions transported across the
channel,[37,39] thus leading to a decline of f.
Figure 4
(A) I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid at
different concentrations of KCl. (B) Rectification ratio of the DAN/AAO
hybrid at different concentrations of KCl. (C) I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different electrolytes (KCl, K2SO4, and MgCl2) with the same concentration
in 1 mM. (D) Current value at +1.0 V at different electrolytea (KCl,
K2SO4, and MgCl2) with different
concentrations. The inset was the enlargement of panel D at a low
concentration. (E) Rectification ratio of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different
electrolytes (KCl, K2SO4, and MgCl2) with the same concentration in 1 mM at a potential from +0.2 V
to +1.0 V. (F) Rectification ratio with different electrolytes under
different concentrations.
(A) I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid at
different concentrations of KCl. (B) Rectification ratio of the DAN/AAO
hybrid at different concentrations of KCl. (C) I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different electrolytes (KCl, K2SO4, and MgCl2) with the same concentration
in 1 mM. (D) Current value at +1.0 V at different electrolytea (KCl,
K2SO4, and MgCl2) with different
concentrations. The inset was the enlargement of panel D at a low
concentration. (E) Rectification ratio of the DAN/AAO hybrid at different
electrolytes (KCl, K2SO4, and MgCl2) with the same concentration in 1 mM at a potential from +0.2 V
to +1.0 V. (F) Rectification ratio with different electrolytes under
different concentrations.The valence is another important factor affecting the ion transport
characteristics in nanofluidics because it is directly related to
the charge inversion process.[40] In this
study, the I–V curves of the DAN/AAO hybrid
with different valence counterions were measured under different ion
concentrations (Figure C,D). As shown in Figure C, the ion current displays I(MgCl2) > I(KCl), I(K2SO4) > I(KCl), regardless of the applied
potential
bias. This phenomenon may correlate with two parameters in principle.[40] The first one is ion concentration, which is
higher for the divalent salt at a constant concentration. The second
possible factor could correspond to the charge of the ions. Figure E illustrates that
the largest ICR ratio of the DAN/AAO hybrid is obtained in a 1 mM
K2SO4 solution regardless of the applied potential
bias due to the anion-selective hybrid membrane. Figure F demonstrates that f has a local maximum (fmax)
with varying saltconcentrations. In our study, the fmax of KCl and K2SO4 is achieved
at 100 mM and 10 mM, respectively. It is reported that the f could reach its maximum value when the charge on the surface
of the DAN/AAO hybrid is balanced by counterions in the EDL.[37] For the DAN/AAO hybrid, the inner surface of
DAN/AAO exhibits a positive charge from the amino group at pH 7.0.
Since the sulfate ion carries charges as high as twice of the chloride
ion, the shielding effect will be stronger in the former case. Consequently,
the f of the former reaches the maximum value at
a lower electrolyte concentration. In a similar way, the electrolyte
concentration at which fmax occurs shifts
to a lower level when the cation valence increases. The fmax for the case of MgCl2 occurs at 10 mM.
These phenomena have been explained previously.[41] In addition, if two salts have the same total valences,
the saltconcentration at which fmax occurs
is the same, but the value of fmax depends
on ionic diffusivity.[40] For K2SO4 (1:2) and MgCl2 (2:1), the saltconcentrations
at which fmax occur are similar (10 mM).
However, the value fmax for the case of
K2SO4 (70.3) is larger than the value fmax for MgCl2(55.9). As described
above, the as-prepared hybrid membrane is anion-selective, and the
anions dominate the ICR property. The charge of a sulfate ion is twice
as high as a chloride ion. Keeping a similar liquid flowing rate,
more negative charges could be transported through the hybrid in the
case of sulfate ions, leading to a higher fmax for K2SO4 than MgCl2. These results
demonstrate the important role of ion valence in the charge inversion
and high ICR ratio in an asymmetric nanochannel.
Selective Cell
Capture, Detection, and Release
In our
DAN/AAOconcept, while AAO provides structural support,[42] the DANcovering has a large exposed surface
area to the external flowing medium and can be biofunctionalized.
Au is well-known to be a highly versatile substrate for chemical and
biological analyses. The high surface-to-volume ratio and exposed
functional groups on the DAN film provide abundant active sites and
room for probing molecular anchoring. Therefore, the prepared hybrid
is expected to behave as a biosensor. The performance of the fabricated
hybrid as a biosensor was then tested including sensitivity, selectivity,
and durability. First, the ability of the present hybrid for cell
capture and detection was investigated. As shown in Figure A, based on previous work,[26,43] the aptamers that could recognize the special protein on CTC membranes
are first immobilized on the DAN surface. As the sample flows through
the hybrid, the target CTCs will be captured due to molecular recognition.
The addition of benzonase nuclease leads to the cleavage of CTCs from
the hybrid surface. During the course of cell capture and release,
the ICR property will vary accordingly. The larger ioniccurrent value
with “on” state endows a sensitive capture, and detection
of CTCs can be realized. The characterizations of the aptamer immobilization,
the optimization of aptamer concentration, and the CTCs capture kinetics
are detailed described in Supporting Information and Figures S8–10. The electrochemical
assay was then adopted for the CCRF-CEMcell detection of various
concentrations. I–V curves with different
concentrations of CCRF-CEMcells captured were recorded and are shown
in Figure B. The ioniccurrent at +1.0 V versus cell concentrations is displayed in Figure C. Owing to the increasing
blockage effect by the captured cells, the currents decrease with
cell concentration. In addition, as shown in the inset of Figure C, the current (I) is inversely proportional to the logarithm of cell concentrations
from 300 to 1000 cells mL–1. The calibration equation
is I [μA] = −0.063log10C + 0.26 (where I is the current response
at different cell concentrations. C is the concentration
of CCRF-CEMcells in unit of cells/mL) with a correlation coefficient
of 0.99. The detection limit is 80 cells mL–1. Compared
with other CTCs detection methods (Table S1 in the Supporting Information), the present method could reach a
lower detection limit without the need for introducing any signal
amplification strategy.
Figure 5
(A) Schematic demonstration of the CTCs capture
and release processes
and the corresponding I–V curves of the DAN/AAO
hybrid. (B) I–V properties of the DAN/AAO
hybrid after capturing different concentrations of CCRF-CEM cells
(50, 80, 100, 300, 500, 700, 1000, 104, 105,
106, and 107 cells mL–1).
(C) Currents at +1.0 V vs CCRF-CEM cell concentration. Inset: the
linear calibration plot of the changed current value vs the logarithm
of cell concentrations at cell concentrations from 50 to 1000 cells
mL–1. (D) Ionic currents at +1.0 V after the capture
of different cells. (E) Ionic currents at +1.0 V vs enzyme incubation
time. (F) Fluorescence microscopic images of the captured CCRF-CEM
cells on the DAN/AAO hybrid, stained by PI/AO. The inset is the fluorescence
microscope image of the DAN/AAO hybrid after cells were released.
(G) Detection of CTCs in different samples. Results are obtained from
PBS buffer and human blood samples, respectively.
(A) Schematic demonstration of the CTCs capture
and release processes
and the corresponding I–V curves of the DAN/AAO
hybrid. (B) I–V properties of the DAN/AAO
hybrid after capturing different concentrations of CCRF-CEMcells
(50, 80, 100, 300, 500, 700, 1000, 104, 105,
106, and 107 cells mL–1).
(C) Currents at +1.0 V vs CCRF-CEMcell concentration. Inset: the
linear calibration plot of the changed current value vs the logarithm
of cell concentrations at cell concentrations from 50 to 1000 cells
mL–1. (D) Ioniccurrents at +1.0 V after the capture
of different cells. (E) Ioniccurrents at +1.0 V vs enzyme incubation
time. (F) Fluorescence microscopic images of the captured CCRF-CEMcells on the DAN/AAO hybrid, stained by PI/AO. The inset is the fluorescence
microscope image of the DAN/AAO hybrid after cells were released.
(G) Detection of CTCs in different samples. Results are obtained from
PBS buffer and human blood samples, respectively.To evaluate the selectivity of this present platform, k562cells
and Rajicells were used as the other two types of cell models. With
the same capture and detection processes as the CCRF-CEMcells, the
electrical current signals were obtained. As shown in Figure D, only CCRF-CEMcells show
a sharp drop of current, while k562cells and Rajicells show slight
changes. The reason is that only CCRF-CEMcell membranes possess a
type of transmembrane receptor, which can recognize with the aptamer
sgc8c,[44] thereby giving rise to the efficient
and selective CCRF-CEMcell capture on the DAN/AAO surface. The captured
cells cover the DAN/AAO hybrid surface, which efficiently blocks the
ions transport through the hybrid, leading to varied I–V properties. The result confirms the excellent selectivity of the
present method for cell capture and detection.Finally, the
successful release of CTCs from the DAN/AAO hybrid
after cell capture is investigated. Benzonase nuclease was used to
induce CCRF-CEMcell release.[26] To obtain
the proper cell release time, the cells captured on the DAN/AAO hybrid
were treated by enzyme solution (25 units mL–1 where
one unit is the enzyme amount that catalyzes the reaction of 1 nmol
of substrate per minute) for 5, 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 min, respectively.
As shown in Figure E, with the enzyme incubation time from 0 to 40 min, the current
signals first increase and then reach a plateau, which indicates that
the captured CCRF-CEMcells have been nearly released completely.
Moreover, the cell viability changes during the course of cell capture
and release were investigated by the Acridine Orange/Propidium Iodide
(AO/PI) assay. As shown in Figure F, almost 100% of the cells are alive after being captured
on the DAN/AAO hybrid. After release, there are no cells on the DAN/AAO
hybrid (inset in Figure F). The released CCRF-CEMcells from the DAN/AAO hybrid were collected,
and their viability was investigated. The fluorescent images in Figure S11 demonstrate that the benzonase nuclease
enzyme shows slight damage to the cells. To investigate the performance
of the present platform in a complex real blood sample, CCRF-CEMcells
were added in the prepared volunteer blood solution at concentrations
of 300, 500, 700, and 1000 cells mL–1. The results
are displayed in Figure G. A trend similar to that of the PBS solution is observed, verifying
the practical application of the CCRF-CEMcell sensor in complex blood
samples. The fact that most of the cells captured on DAN/AAO stay
alive provide means for multimodal study, for example, by SERS and
electrochemistry.The durability of the prepared hybrid device
is a critical factor
toward practical bioanalysis. We have repeatedly used one hybrid for
CTCcapture and detection after cell release. The very similar I–V curves and ICR properties (Figure S12) in a continuous 5 day test demonstrate the excellent
stability and reusability of the present hybrid toward CTCs capture,
detection, and release.In conclusion, we have demonstrated
an engineered heterogeneous
hybrid by chemically assembling DAN onto the top of AAO nanochannels.
Due to the high surface-to-volume ratio of the AuNPs and high density
of binding sites of PAMAM, the network formed has more surface area
and can expose more functional groups, which results in more asymmetries
in the structure and surface charge density of the DAN/AAO hybrid,
thus leading to obvious rectified ion transport. The presence of amino
groups on the DAN/AAO hybrid surface enables the anion-selective hybrid
membrane to process ionic rectification and also promotes anion selectivity.
Moreover, the ionic rectification properties can be tuned by ion valence
and pH of the bulk solution. Under optimal conditions, highly sensitive
circulating tumorcell detection based on this heterogeneous structure
was successfully achieved with a detection limit of 80 cells mL–1. This device also provides a sensitive multimodal
(chemical, electrical, and optical) platform to study cell adhesion
and cell behavior in situ.
Authors: Wen-Jie Lan; Martin A Edwards; Long Luo; Rukshan T Perera; Xiaojian Wu; Charles R Martin; Henry S White Journal: Acc Chem Res Date: 2016-09-30 Impact factor: 22.384
Authors: Gonzalo Pérez-Mitta; Ana S Peinetti; M Lorena Cortez; María Eugenia Toimil-Molares; Christina Trautmann; Omar Azzaroni Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2018-05-01 Impact factor: 11.189