Mark H Eckman1, E Steve Woodle2, Charuhas V Thakar3, Rita R Alloway3, Kenneth E Sherman4. 1. Division of General Internal Medicine and the Center for Clinical Effectiveness, University of Cincinnati Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH. Electronic address: mark.eckman@uc.edu. 2. Division of Transplantation, Department of Surgery, University of Cincinnati Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH. 3. Division of Nephrology, University of Cincinnati Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH. 4. Division of Digestive Diseases, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH.
Abstract
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Less than 4% of patients with kidney failure receive kidney transplants. Although discard rates of hepatitis C virus (HCV)-viremic kidneys are declining, ~39% of HCV-viremic kidneys donated between 2018 and 2019 were discarded. Highly effective antiviral agents are now available to treat chronic HCV infection. Thus, our objective was to examine the cost-effectiveness of transplanting kidneys from HCV-viremic donors into HCV-uninfected recipients. STUDY DESIGN: Markov state transition decision model. Data sources include Medline search results, bibliographies from relevant English language articles, Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients, and the US Renal Data System. SETTING & POPULATION: US patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis who are on kidney transplant waiting lists. INTERVENTION(S): Transplantation with an HCV-unexposed kidney versus transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney and HCV treatment. OUTCOMES: Effectiveness measured in quality-adjusted life-years and costs measured in 2018 US dollars. MODEL, PERSPECTIVE, AND TIMEFRAME: We used a health care system perspective with a lifelong time horizon. RESULTS: In the base-case analysis, transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney was more effective and less costly than transplantation with an HCV-unexposed kidney because of the longer waiting times for HCV-unexposed kidneys, the substantial excess mortality risk while receiving dialysis, and the high efficacy of direct-acting antiviral agents for HCV infection. Transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney was also preferred in sensitivity analyses of multiple model parameters. The strategy remained cost-effective unless waiting list time for an HCV-viremic kidney exceeded 3.1 years compared with the base-case value of 1.56 year. LIMITATIONS: Estimates of waiting times for patients willing to accept an HCV-viremic kidney were based on data for patients who received HCV-viremic kidney transplants. CONCLUSIONS: Transplanting kidneys from HCV-viremic donors into HCV-uninfected recipients increased quality-adjusted life expectancy and reduced costs compared with a strategy of transplanting kidneys from HCV-unexposed donors.
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Less than 4% of patients with kidney failure receive kidney transplants. Although discard rates of hepatitis C virus (HCV)-viremic kidneys are declining, ~39% of HCV-viremic kidneys donated between 2018 and 2019 were discarded. Highly effective antiviral agents are now available to treat chronic HCV infection. Thus, our objective was to examine the cost-effectiveness of transplanting kidneys from HCV-viremic donors into HCV-uninfected recipients. STUDY DESIGN: Markov state transition decision model. Data sources include Medline search results, bibliographies from relevant English language articles, Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients, and the US Renal Data System. SETTING & POPULATION: US patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis who are on kidney transplant waiting lists. INTERVENTION(S): Transplantation with an HCV-unexposed kidney versus transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney and HCV treatment. OUTCOMES: Effectiveness measured in quality-adjusted life-years and costs measured in 2018 US dollars. MODEL, PERSPECTIVE, AND TIMEFRAME: We used a health care system perspective with a lifelong time horizon. RESULTS: In the base-case analysis, transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney was more effective and less costly than transplantation with an HCV-unexposed kidney because of the longer waiting times for HCV-unexposed kidneys, the substantial excess mortality risk while receiving dialysis, and the high efficacy of direct-acting antiviral agents for HCV infection. Transplantation with an HCV-viremic kidney was also preferred in sensitivity analyses of multiple model parameters. The strategy remained cost-effective unless waiting list time for an HCV-viremic kidney exceeded 3.1 years compared with the base-case value of 1.56 year. LIMITATIONS: Estimates of waiting times for patients willing to accept an HCV-viremic kidney were based on data for patients who received HCV-viremic kidney transplants. CONCLUSIONS: Transplanting kidneys from HCV-viremic donors into HCV-uninfected recipients increased quality-adjusted life expectancy and reduced costs compared with a strategy of transplanting kidneys from HCV-unexposed donors.
Authors: Krista L Lentine; John D Peipert; Tarek Alhamad; Yasar Caliskan; Beatrice P Concepcion; Rachel Forbes; Mark Schnitzler; Su-Hsin Chang; Matthew Cooper; Roy D Bloom; Roslyn B Mannon; David A Axelrod Journal: Kidney360 Date: 2020-11-25
Authors: Mohsen Yaghoubi; Sonya Cressman; Louisa Edwards; Steven Shechter; Mary M Doyle-Waters; Paul Keown; Ruth Sapir-Pichhadze; Stirling Bryan Journal: Appl Health Econ Health Policy Date: 2022-08-09 Impact factor: 3.686
Authors: David A Axelrod; Krista L Lentine; Ramji Balakrishnan; Su-Hsin Chang; Terek Alhamad; Huiling Xiao; Bertran L Kasiske; Roy D Bloom; Mark A Schnitzler Journal: Transplant Direct Date: 2020-11-10
Authors: Meghan E Sise; David S Goldberg; Jens J Kort; Douglas E Schaubel; Rita R Alloway; Christine M Durand; Robert J Fontana; Robert S Brown; John J Friedewald; Stacey Prenner; J Richard Landis; Melissa Fernando; Caitlin C Phillips; E Steve Woodle; Adele Rike-Shields; Kenneth E Sherman; Nahel Elias; Winfred W Williams; Jenna L Gustafson; Niraj M Desai; Brittany Barnaba; Silas P Norman; Mona Doshi; Samuel T Sultan; Meredith J Aull; Josh Levitsky; Dianne S Belshe; Raymond T Chung; Peter P Reese Journal: J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2020-08-25 Impact factor: 10.121
Authors: Beatrice P Concepcion; Laura A Binari; Heidi Schaefer; Scott Rega; Irene Feurer; Saed Shawar; Ruchi Naik; Laura Hickman; Jasmine Walker; Meghan Kapp; Kelly A Birdwell; Anthony Langone; J Harold Helderman; Bonnie Ann Sarrell; Guneet Kochar; Bernard Dubray; Kristin Smith; Heather O'Dell; April DeMers; Princess Shelton; Roman Perri; David Shaffer; Rachel C Forbes Journal: Transplant Direct Date: 2021-09-07