Maria Eduarda Alonso Joaquim de Carvalho1, André Gusmão Cunha2. 1. Member of Trauma and Emergency Research Group, Salvador, Brazil; School of Medicine, Federal University of Bahia, Salvador, Brazil. Electronic address: dudalonso@hotmail.com. 2. Member of Trauma and Emergency Research Group, Salvador, Brazil; Department of Surgery, Federal University of Bahia, Salvador, Brazil.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Duodenopancreatic trauma is rare and presents high morbidity and mortality rates. Pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) is the only possible treatment indicated for the most complex injuries (grades IV and V). Although, it is commonly a one-stage procedure, damage control surgery corroborates with a two-stage PD performed on unstable trauma victims. OBJECTIVES: Compare the mortality rate of one and two-stage PD in trauma patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A systematic electronic search of PubMed, Elsevier, LILACS, Scielo, and Capes was conducted on all studies written in English, Portuguese and Spanish with no restriction to publication dates. Review articles, case reports, editorials, animal studies, pediatric and non-trauma scenarios were excluded. RESULTS: We selected twenty-two publications, with a total of 149 duodenopancreatic trauma victims who underwent PD, with an overall mortality rate of 42 patients (28.2%). Two-stage PD was exclusively performed on unstable patients (N = 31) with a mortality rate of 38.7%. In a sample of 79 patients submitted to a one-stage PD, 38 patients (48.1%) were unstable with a mortality rate of 34.2%. One-stage PD for stable patients had a mortality rate of 14.6% DISCUSSION: Since 1983, hemodynamic state impacts on surgery methods and strategies for trauma patients. Prior to that, one stage PD was not restricted to stable patients. CONCLUSION: There were no differences in mortality rates when comparing two and one-stage PD in hemodynamic unstable patients, who had duodenopancreatic lesions (grades IV or V).
INTRODUCTION:Duodenopancreatic trauma is rare and presents high morbidity and mortality rates. Pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) is the only possible treatment indicated for the most complex injuries (grades IV and V). Although, it is commonly a one-stage procedure, damage control surgery corroborates with a two-stage PD performed on unstable trauma victims. OBJECTIVES: Compare the mortality rate of one and two-stage PD in traumapatients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A systematic electronic search of PubMed, Elsevier, LILACS, Scielo, and Capes was conducted on all studies written in English, Portuguese and Spanish with no restriction to publication dates. Review articles, case reports, editorials, animal studies, pediatric and non-trauma scenarios were excluded. RESULTS: We selected twenty-two publications, with a total of 149 duodenopancreatic trauma victims who underwent PD, with an overall mortality rate of 42 patients (28.2%). Two-stage PD was exclusively performed on unstable patients (N = 31) with a mortality rate of 38.7%. In a sample of 79 patients submitted to a one-stage PD, 38 patients (48.1%) were unstable with a mortality rate of 34.2%. One-stage PD for stable patients had a mortality rate of 14.6% DISCUSSION: Since 1983, hemodynamic state impacts on surgery methods and strategies for traumapatients. Prior to that, one stage PD was not restricted to stable patients. CONCLUSION: There were no differences in mortality rates when comparing two and one-stage PD in hemodynamic unstable patients, who had duodenopancreatic lesions (grades IV or V).
Authors: Carlos A Ordoñez; Michael W Parra; Mauricio Millán; Yaset Caicedo; Natalia Padilla; Mónica Guzmán-Rodríguez; Fernando Miñan-Arana; Alberto García; Adolfo González-Hadad; Luis Fernando Pino; Fernando Rodríguez-Holguin; José Julián Serna; Alexander Salcedo; Ricardo Ferrada; Rao Ivatury Journal: Colomb Med (Cali) Date: 2020-12-30