Peter F Lawrence1, Donald T Baril1, Karen Woo2. 1. Division of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles, Calif. 2. Division of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles, Calif. Electronic address: kwoo@mednet.ucla.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Standardized databases such as the Vascular Quality Initiative and National Surgical Quality Improvement Project assess the quality of care related to common vascular surgery procedures, but are not designed for uncommon vascular diseases. We describe a method of assessing uncommon vascular diseases using a multi-institutional collaboration, the Vascular Low Frequency Disease Consortium (VLFDC). METHODS: Uncommon vascular diseases are identified through a systematic literature review. A disease-specific database is developed and tested at a single institution, then refined and circulated to participating VLFDC investigators. Detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria and data point definitions are provided, allowing for standardized data collection across institutions. Each participating institution identifies all patients over a specific time period and enters the data into a VLFDC-provided database. The data are then de-identified and transmitted to our centralized data center for analysis. RESULTS: Since 2003, the VLFDC has conducted and published nine studies and enrolled 4532 patients, involving 232 institutions and 271 investigators. The studies include renal artery aneurysms, isolated femoral artery aneurysms, spontaneous mesenteric dissection, adventitial cystic disease, carotid body tumors, and vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. Each published study reported on a minimum of 10 times the number of patients collected in previously published studies over the same time period, allowing stronger conclusions to be drawn from the larger sample size. Each study both confirmed previous management principles, which were based on small single-institution experiences, and challenged conventional management paradigms. CONCLUSIONS: When only small clinical series exist to provide guidance in managing uncommon vascular diseases, and/or where conflicting recommendations are made on the treatment of uncommon vascular diseases, a multi-institutional consortium can provide high-volume standardized data that either confirm or changes prior management principles.
BACKGROUND: Standardized databases such as the Vascular Quality Initiative and National Surgical Quality Improvement Project assess the quality of care related to common vascular surgery procedures, but are not designed for uncommon vascular diseases. We describe a method of assessing uncommon vascular diseases using a multi-institutional collaboration, the Vascular Low Frequency Disease Consortium (VLFDC). METHODS: Uncommon vascular diseases are identified through a systematic literature review. A disease-specific database is developed and tested at a single institution, then refined and circulated to participating VLFDC investigators. Detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria and data point definitions are provided, allowing for standardized data collection across institutions. Each participating institution identifies all patients over a specific time period and enters the data into a VLFDC-provided database. The data are then de-identified and transmitted to our centralized data center for analysis. RESULTS: Since 2003, the VLFDC has conducted and published nine studies and enrolled 4532 patients, involving 232 institutions and 271 investigators. The studies include renal artery aneurysms, isolated femoral artery aneurysms, spontaneous mesenteric dissection, adventitial cystic disease, carotid body tumors, and vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. Each published study reported on a minimum of 10 times the number of patients collected in previously published studies over the same time period, allowing stronger conclusions to be drawn from the larger sample size. Each study both confirmed previous management principles, which were based on small single-institution experiences, and challenged conventional management paradigms. CONCLUSIONS: When only small clinical series exist to provide guidance in managing uncommon vascular diseases, and/or where conflicting recommendations are made on the treatment of uncommon vascular diseases, a multi-institutional consortium can provide high-volume standardized data that either confirm or changes prior management principles.
Authors: Jacob W Loeffler; Hideaki Obara; Naoki Fujimura; Paul Bove; Daniel H Newton; Sara L Zettervall; Andre S van Petersen; Robert H Geelkerken; Kristofer M Charlton-Ouw; Sherene Shalhub; Niten Singh; Arnaud Roussel; Natalia O Glebova; Michael P Harlander-Locke; Warren J Gasper; Misty D Humphries; Peter F Lawrence Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2017-05-12 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Gloria Y Kim; Peter F Lawrence; Rameen S Moridzadeh; Kate Zimmerman; Alberto Munoz; Kuauhyama Luna-Ortiz; Gustavo S Oderich; Juan de Francisco; Jorge Ospina; Santiago Huertas; Leonardo R de Souza; Thomas C Bower; Steven Farley; Hugh A Gelabert; Marcus R Kret; E John Harris; Giovanni De Caridi; Francesco Spinelli; Matthew R Smeds; Christos D Liapis; John Kakisis; Anastasios P Papapetrou; Eike S Debus; Christian-A Behrendt; Edgar Kleinspehn; Joshua D Horton; Firas F Mussa; Stephen W K Cheng; Mark D Morasch; Khurram Rasheed; Matthew E Bennett; Jean Bismuth; Alan B Lumsden; Christopher J Abularrage; Alik Farber Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2017-06 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Jill Q Klausner; Peter F Lawrence; Michael P Harlander-Locke; Dawn M Coleman; James C Stanley; Naoki Fujimura Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2014-12-20 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Raghu L Motaganahalli; Matthew R Smeds; Michael P Harlander-Locke; Peter F Lawrence; Naoki Fujimura; Randall R DeMartino; Giovanni De Caridi; Alberto Munoz; Sherene Shalhub; Susanna H Shin; Kwame S Amankwah; Hugh A Gelabert; David A Rigberg; Jeffrey J Siracuse; Alik Farber; E Sebastian Debus; Christian Behrendt; Jin H Joh; Naveed U Saqib; Kristofer M Charlton-Ouw; Catherine M Wittgen Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2016-10-14 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Peter F Lawrence; Michael P Harlander-Locke; Gustavo S Oderich; Misty D Humphries; Gregory J Landry; Jeffrey L Ballard; Christopher J Abularrage Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2014-02 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Michael P Harlander-Locke; Liv K Harmon; Peter F Lawrence; Gustavo S Oderich; Robert A McCready; Mark D Morasch; Robert J Feezor; Wei Zhou; Jean Bismuth; William C Pevec; Mateus P Correa; Jeffrey Jim; Joseph S Ladowski; Panagiotis Kougias; Paul G Bove; Catherine M Wittgen; John V White Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2013-11-14 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Matthew R Smeds; Audra A Duncan; Michael P Harlander-Locke; Peter F Lawrence; Sean Lyden; Javariah Fatima; Mark K Eskandari Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2016-02 Impact factor: 4.268
Authors: Aaron S Fink; Darrell A Campbell; Robert M Mentzer; William G Henderson; Jennifer Daley; Janet Bannister; Kwan Hur; Shukri F Khuri Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2002-09 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Tristen T Chun; Dejah R Judelson; David Rigberg; Peter F Lawrence; Robert Cuff; Sherene Shalhub; Max Wohlauer; Christopher J Abularrage; Papapetrou Anastasios; Shipra Arya; Bernadette Aulivola; Melissa Baldwin; Donald Baril; Carlos F Bechara; William E Beckerman; Christian-Alexander Behrendt; Filippo Benedetto; Lisa F Bennett; Kristofer M Charlton-Ouw; Amit Chawla; Matthew C Chia; Sungsin Cho; Andrew M T L Choong; Elizabeth L Chou; Anastasiadou Christiana; Raphael Coscas; Giovanni De Caridi; Sharif Ellozy; Yana Etkin; Peter Faries; Adrian T Fung; Andrew Gonzalez; Claire L Griffin; London Guidry; Nalaka Gunawansa; Gary Gwertzman; Daniel K Han; Caitlin W Hicks; Carlos A Hinojosa; York Hsiang; Nicole Ilonzo; Lalithapriya Jayakumar; Jin Hyun Joh; Adam P Johnson; Loay S Kabbani; Melissa R Keller; Manar Khashram; Issam Koleilat; Bernard Krueger; Akshay Kumar; Cheong Jun Lee; Alice Lee; Mark M Levy; C Taylor Lewis; Benjamin Lind; Gabriel Lopez-Pena; Jahan Mohebali; Robert G Molnar; Nicholas J Morrissey; Raghu L Motaganahalli; Nicolas J Mouawad; Daniel H Newton; Jun Jie Ng; Leigh Ann O'Banion; John Phair; Zoran Rancic; Ajit Rao; Hunter M Ray; Aksim G Rivera; Limael Rodriguez; Clifford M Sales; Garrett Salzman; Mark Sarfati; Ajay Savlania; Andres Schanzer; Mel J Sharafuddin; Malachi Sheahan; Sammy Siada; Jeffrey J Siracuse; Brigitte K Smith; Matthew Smith; Ina Soh; Rebecca Sorber; Varuna Sundaram; Scott Sundick; Tadaki M Tomita; Bradley Trinidad; Shirling Tsai; Ageliki G Vouyouka; Gregory G Westin; Michael S Williams; Sherry M Wren; Jane K Yang; Jeniann Yi; Wei Zhou; Saqib Zia; Karen Woo Journal: J Vasc Surg Date: 2020-07-15 Impact factor: 4.860