Dario Trapani1, Giuseppe Curigliano1, Alexandru Eniu2. 1. Department of Oncology and Haematology, University of Milan, IEO, European Institute of Oncology IRCCS, Milan, Italy. 2. Department of Breast Tumours, Cancer Institute Ion Chiricuta, Cluj-Napoca, Romania.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Breast cancer is a cause of morbidity for more than half a million of patients in Europe, resulting in broad societal impacts that affect patients, families, and societies from a human, emotional, economic, and financial perspective. Expenditure for cancer medicines represents one of the principal driving costs of healthcare. The aim of this review is to describe the European policy and regulatory landscape of innovation uptake in breast oncology - with emphasis on value in cancer healthcare. SUMMARY: In Europe, several reimbursement models or policy tools have been developed by countries to compose their benefit packages. The most commonly applied scheme is the product-specific eligibility model, prioritizing selected medicines and their indications. Mixed models are commonly developed, addressing the protection of more vulnerable people, ensuring protection from impoverishment caused by cancer and containing disparities. However, the risk to incur significant out-of-pocket expenses for essential or newer medicines for cancer is still substantial in Europe, especially in low- and middle-income countries, determining greater financial distress and poorer outcome for patients. Value-based priority setting is an essential mechanism to ensure timely access to the most valuable medicines for breast cancer patients. Estimations of the value of medicines can be provided within health technology assessment services and networks and informed by benefit scales and tools. KEY MESSAGES: There is ample room for reciprocal support across the diverse cultural and legal realities in Europe. The aim is common: save cancer patients from premature death by ensuring the timely access to the best care, protecting from financial hardships and distress to leave no cancer patient behind in poverty. Steps are to be taken to promote value-based priority setting, paving the way toward universal health coverage in Europe, where health of people is protected, and affordable best quality care is the only standard pursued and acceptable.
BACKGROUND: Breast cancer is a cause of morbidity for more than half a million of patients in Europe, resulting in broad societal impacts that affect patients, families, and societies from a human, emotional, economic, and financial perspective. Expenditure for cancer medicines represents one of the principal driving costs of healthcare. The aim of this review is to describe the European policy and regulatory landscape of innovation uptake in breast oncology - with emphasis on value in cancer healthcare. SUMMARY: In Europe, several reimbursement models or policy tools have been developed by countries to compose their benefit packages. The most commonly applied scheme is the product-specific eligibility model, prioritizing selected medicines and their indications. Mixed models are commonly developed, addressing the protection of more vulnerable people, ensuring protection from impoverishment caused by cancer and containing disparities. However, the risk to incur significant out-of-pocket expenses for essential or newer medicines for cancer is still substantial in Europe, especially in low- and middle-income countries, determining greater financial distress and poorer outcome for patients. Value-based priority setting is an essential mechanism to ensure timely access to the most valuable medicines for breast cancer patients. Estimations of the value of medicines can be provided within health technology assessment services and networks and informed by benefit scales and tools. KEY MESSAGES: There is ample room for reciprocal support across the diverse cultural and legal realities in Europe. The aim is common: save cancer patients from premature death by ensuring the timely access to the best care, protecting from financial hardships and distress to leave no cancer patient behind in poverty. Steps are to be taken to promote value-based priority setting, paving the way toward universal health coverage in Europe, where health of people is protected, and affordable best quality care is the only standard pursued and acceptable.
Authors: G Curigliano; H J Burstein; E P Winer; M Gnant; P Dubsky; S Loibl; M Colleoni; M M Regan; M Piccart-Gebhart; H-J Senn; B Thürlimann; F André; J Baselga; J Bergh; H Bonnefoi; S Y Brucker; F Cardoso; L Carey; E Ciruelos; J Cuzick; C Denkert; A Di Leo; B Ejlertsen; P Francis; V Galimberti; J Garber; B Gulluoglu; P Goodwin; N Harbeck; D F Hayes; C-S Huang; J Huober; K Hussein; J Jassem; Z Jiang; P Karlsson; M Morrow; R Orecchia; K C Osborne; O Pagani; A H Partridge; K Pritchard; J Ro; E J T Rutgers; F Sedlmayer; V Semiglazov; Z Shao; I Smith; M Toi; A Tutt; G Viale; T Watanabe; T J Whelan; B Xu Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2017-08-01 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: C Wild; N Grössmann; P V Bonanno; A Bucsics; J Furst; K Garuoliene; B Godman; J Gulbinovič; J Jones; M K Pomorski; R Emprechtinger Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2016-08-08 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: Evelien Moorkens; Arnold G Vulto; Isabelle Huys; Pieter Dylst; Brian Godman; Simon Keuerleber; Barbara Claus; Maria Dimitrova; Guenka Petrova; Ljiljana Sović-Brkičić; Juraj Slabý; Robin Šebesta; Ott Laius; Allan Karr; Morgane Beck; Jaana E Martikainen; Gisbert W Selke; Susan Spillane; Laura McCullagh; Gianluca Trifirò; Patricia Vella Bonanno; Asbjørn Mack; Antra Fogele; Anita Viksna; Magdalena Władysiuk; Helder Mota-Filipe; Dmitry Meshkov; Marija Kalaba; Simona Mencej Bedrač; Jurij Fürst; Corrine Zara; Peter Skiöld; Einar Magnússon; Steven Simoens Journal: PLoS One Date: 2017-12-28 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Josep Tabernero; Malvika Vyas; Rosa Giuliani; Dirk Arnold; Fatima Cardoso; Paolo G Casali; Andres Cervantes; Alexander Mm Eggermont; Alexandru Eniu; Jacek Jassem; George Pentheroudakis; Solange Peters; Stefan Rauh; Christoph C Zielinski; Rolf A Stahel; Emile Voest; Jean-Yves Douillard; Keith McGregor; Fortunato Ciardiello Journal: ESMO Open Date: 2017-01-16
Authors: Dario Trapani; Kiu Tay-Teo; Megan E Tesch; Felipe Roitberg; Manju Sengar; Sara C Altuna; Michael J Hassett; Armando A Genazzani; Aaron S Kesselheim; Giuseppe Curigliano Journal: Curr Oncol Date: 2022-08-16 Impact factor: 3.109