Biqi Wang1, Kathryn L Lunetta1,2, Josée Dupuis1,2, Steven A Lubitz3,2,4,5, Ludovic Trinquart1,2, Lixia Yao6, Patrick T Ellinor2,7,4,5, Emelia J Benjamin3,2,8, Honghuang Lin2,9. 1. From the Department of Biostatistics (B.W., K.L.L., J.D., L.T.), Boston University School of Public Health, MA. 2. Boston University and National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute's Framingham Heart Study, Framingham, MA (K.L.L., J.D., L.T., E.J.B., H.L.). 3. Department of Epidemiology (E.J.B.), Boston University School of Public Health, MA. 4. Cardiac Arrhythmia Service (S.A.L., P.T.E.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. 5. Program in Medical and Population Genetics, The Broad Institute of Harvard and MIT, Cambridge, MA (S.A.L., P.T.E.). 6. Department of Health Sciences Research, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN (L.Y.), Boston University School of Medicine, MA. 7. Cardiovascular Research Center (S.A.L., P.T.E.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. 8. Department of Medicine, Sections of Preventive Medicine and Cardiovascular Medicine (E.J.B.), Boston University School of Medicine, MA. 9. Department of Medicine, Section of Computational Biomedicine (H.L.), Boston University School of Medicine, MA.
Abstract
Rationale: GWAS (Genome-Wide Association Studies) have identified hundreds of genetic loci associated with atrial fibrillation (AF). However, these loci explain only a small proportion of AF heritability. Objective: To develop an approach to identify additional AF-related genes by integrating multiple omics data. Methods and Results: Three types of omics data were integrated: (1) summary statistics from the AFGen 2017 GWAS; (2) a whole blood EWAS (Epigenome-Wide Association Study) of AF; and (3) a whole blood TWAS (Transcriptome-Wide Association Study) of AF. The variant-level GWAS results were collapsed into gene-level associations using fast set-based association analysis. The CpG-level EWAS results were also collapsed into gene-level associations by an adapted SNP-set Kernel Association Test approach. Both GWAS and EWAS gene-based associations were then meta-analyzed with TWAS using a fixed-effects model weighted by the sample size of each data set. A tissue-specific network was subsequently constructed using the NetWAS (Network-Wide Association Study). The identified genes were then compared with the AFGen 2018 GWAS that contained more than triple the number of AF cases compared with AFGen 2017 GWAS. We observed that the multiomics approach identified many more relevant AF-related genes than using AFGen 2018 GWAS alone (1931 versus 206 genes). Many of these genes are involved in the development and regulation of heart- and muscle-related biological processes. Moreover, the gene set identified by multiomics approach explained much more AF variance than those identified by GWAS alone (10.4% versus 3.5%). Conclusions: We developed a strategy to integrate multiple omics data to identify AF-related genes. Our integrative approach may be useful to improve the power of traditional GWAS, which might be particularly useful for rare traits and diseases with limited sample size.
Rationale: GWAS (Genome-Wide Association Studies) have identified hundreds of genetic loci associated with atrial fibrillation (AF). However, these loci explain only a small proportion of AF heritability. Objective: To develop an approach to identify additional AF-related genes by integrating multiple omics data. Methods and Results: Three types of omics data were integrated: (1) summary statistics from the AFGen 2017 GWAS; (2) a whole blood EWAS (Epigenome-Wide Association Study) of AF; and (3) a whole blood TWAS (Transcriptome-Wide Association Study) of AF. The variant-level GWAS results were collapsed into gene-level associations using fast set-based association analysis. The CpG-level EWAS results were also collapsed into gene-level associations by an adapted SNP-set Kernel Association Test approach. Both GWAS and EWAS gene-based associations were then meta-analyzed with TWAS using a fixed-effects model weighted by the sample size of each data set. A tissue-specific network was subsequently constructed using the NetWAS (Network-Wide Association Study). The identified genes were then compared with the AFGen 2018 GWAS that contained more than triple the number of AF cases compared with AFGen 2017 GWAS. We observed that the multiomics approach identified many more relevant AF-related genes than using AFGen 2018 GWAS alone (1931 versus 206 genes). Many of these genes are involved in the development and regulation of heart- and muscle-related biological processes. Moreover, the gene set identified by multiomics approach explained much more AF variance than those identified by GWAS alone (10.4% versus 3.5%). Conclusions: We developed a strategy to integrate multiple omics data to identify AF-related genes. Our integrative approach may be useful to improve the power of traditional GWAS, which might be particularly useful for rare traits and diseases with limited sample size.
Authors: M Ashburner; C A Ball; J A Blake; D Botstein; H Butler; J M Cherry; A P Davis; K Dolinski; S S Dwight; J T Eppig; M A Harris; D P Hill; L Issel-Tarver; A Kasarskis; S Lewis; J C Matese; J E Richardson; M Ringwald; G M Rubin; G Sherlock Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2000-05 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Marylyn D Ritchie; Emily R Holzinger; Ruowang Li; Sarah A Pendergrass; Dokyoon Kim Journal: Nat Rev Genet Date: 2015-01-13 Impact factor: 53.242
Authors: Patrick T Ellinor; Kathryn L Lunetta; Christine M Albert; Nicole L Glazer; Marylyn D Ritchie; Albert V Smith; Dan E Arking; Martina Müller-Nurasyid; Bouwe P Krijthe; Steven A Lubitz; Joshua C Bis; Mina K Chung; Marcus Dörr; Kouichi Ozaki; Jason D Roberts; J Gustav Smith; Arne Pfeufer; Moritz F Sinner; Kurt Lohman; Jingzhong Ding; Nicholas L Smith; Jonathan D Smith; Michiel Rienstra; Kenneth M Rice; David R Van Wagoner; Jared W Magnani; Reza Wakili; Sebastian Clauss; Jerome I Rotter; Gerhard Steinbeck; Lenore J Launer; Robert W Davies; Matthew Borkovich; Tamara B Harris; Honghuang Lin; Uwe Völker; Henry Völzke; David J Milan; Albert Hofman; Eric Boerwinkle; Lin Y Chen; Elsayed Z Soliman; Benjamin F Voight; Guo Li; Aravinda Chakravarti; Michiaki Kubo; Usha B Tedrow; Lynda M Rose; Paul M Ridker; David Conen; Tatsuhiko Tsunoda; Tetsushi Furukawa; Nona Sotoodehnia; Siyan Xu; Naoyuki Kamatani; Daniel Levy; Yusuke Nakamura; Babar Parvez; Saagar Mahida; Karen L Furie; Jonathan Rosand; Raafia Muhammad; Bruce M Psaty; Thomas Meitinger; Siegfried Perz; H-Erich Wichmann; Jacqueline C M Witteman; W H Linda Kao; Sekar Kathiresan; Dan M Roden; Andre G Uitterlinden; Fernando Rivadeneira; Barbara McKnight; Marketa Sjögren; Anne B Newman; Yongmei Liu; Michael H Gollob; Olle Melander; Toshihiro Tanaka; Bruno H Ch Stricker; Stephan B Felix; Alvaro Alonso; Dawood Darbar; John Barnard; Daniel I Chasman; Susan R Heckbert; Emelia J Benjamin; Vilmundur Gudnason; Stefan Kääb Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2012-04-29 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Elham Kayvanpour; Farbod Sedaghat-Hamedani; Ali Amr; Alan Lai; Jan Haas; Daniel B Holzer; Karen S Frese; Andreas Keller; Katrin Jensen; Hugo A Katus; Benjamin Meder Journal: Clin Res Cardiol Date: 2016-08-30 Impact factor: 5.460
Authors: Ingrid E Christophersen; Michiel Rienstra; Carolina Roselli; Xiaoyan Yin; Bastiaan Geelhoed; John Barnard; Honghuang Lin; Dan E Arking; Albert V Smith; Christine M Albert; Mark Chaffin; Nathan R Tucker; Molong Li; Derek Klarin; Nathan A Bihlmeyer; Siew-Kee Low; Peter E Weeke; Martina Müller-Nurasyid; J Gustav Smith; Jennifer A Brody; Maartje N Niemeijer; Marcus Dörr; Stella Trompet; Jennifer Huffman; Stefan Gustafsson; Claudia Schurmann; Marcus E Kleber; Leo-Pekka Lyytikäinen; Ilkka Seppälä; Rainer Malik; Andrea R V R Horimoto; Marco Perez; Juha Sinisalo; Stefanie Aeschbacher; Sébastien Thériault; Jie Yao; Farid Radmanesh; Stefan Weiss; Alexander Teumer; Seung Hoan Choi; Lu-Chen Weng; Sebastian Clauss; Rajat Deo; Daniel J Rader; Svati H Shah; Albert Sun; Jemma C Hopewell; Stephanie Debette; Ganesh Chauhan; Qiong Yang; Bradford B Worrall; Guillaume Paré; Yoichiro Kamatani; Yanick P Hagemeijer; Niek Verweij; Joylene E Siland; Michiaki Kubo; Jonathan D Smith; David R Van Wagoner; Joshua C Bis; Siegfried Perz; Bruce M Psaty; Paul M Ridker; Jared W Magnani; Tamara B Harris; Lenore J Launer; M Benjamin Shoemaker; Sandosh Padmanabhan; Jeffrey Haessler; Traci M Bartz; Melanie Waldenberger; Peter Lichtner; Marina Arendt; Jose E Krieger; Mika Kähönen; Lorenz Risch; Alfredo J Mansur; Annette Peters; Blair H Smith; Lars Lind; Stuart A Scott; Yingchang Lu; Erwin B Bottinger; Jussi Hernesniemi; Cecilia M Lindgren; Jorge A Wong; Jie Huang; Markku Eskola; Andrew P Morris; Ian Ford; Alex P Reiner; Graciela Delgado; Lin Y Chen; Yii-Der Ida Chen; Roopinder K Sandhu; Man Li; Eric Boerwinkle; Lewin Eisele; Lars Lannfelt; Natalia Rost; Christopher D Anderson; Kent D Taylor; Archie Campbell; Patrik K Magnusson; David Porteous; Lynne J Hocking; Efthymia Vlachopoulou; Nancy L Pedersen; Kjell Nikus; Marju Orho-Melander; Anders Hamsten; Jan Heeringa; Joshua C Denny; Jennifer Kriebel; Dawood Darbar; Christopher Newton-Cheh; Christian Shaffer; Peter W Macfarlane; Stefanie Heilmann-Heimbach; Peter Almgren; Paul L Huang; Nona Sotoodehnia; Elsayed Z Soliman; Andre G Uitterlinden; Albert Hofman; Oscar H Franco; Uwe Völker; Karl-Heinz Jöckel; Moritz F Sinner; Henry J Lin; Xiuqing Guo; Martin Dichgans; Erik Ingelsson; Charles Kooperberg; Olle Melander; Ruth J F Loos; Jari Laurikka; David Conen; Jonathan Rosand; Pim van der Harst; Marja-Liisa Lokki; Sekar Kathiresan; Alexandre Pereira; J Wouter Jukema; Caroline Hayward; Jerome I Rotter; Winfried März; Terho Lehtimäki; Bruno H Stricker; Mina K Chung; Stephan B Felix; Vilmundur Gudnason; Alvaro Alonso; Dan M Roden; Stefan Kääb; Daniel I Chasman; Susan R Heckbert; Emelia J Benjamin; Toshihiro Tanaka; Kathryn L Lunetta; Steven A Lubitz; Patrick T Ellinor Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2017-04-17 Impact factor: 41.307
Authors: Casey S Greene; Arjun Krishnan; Aaron K Wong; Emanuela Ricciotti; Rene A Zelaya; Daniel S Himmelstein; Ran Zhang; Boris M Hartmann; Elena Zaslavsky; Stuart C Sealfon; Daniel I Chasman; Garret A FitzGerald; Kara Dolinski; Tilo Grosser; Olga G Troyanskaya Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2015-04-27 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Jelena Kornej; Vanessa A Hanger; Ludovic Trinquart; Darae Ko; Sarah R Preis; Emelia J Benjamin; Honghuang Lin Journal: Cardiovasc Res Date: 2021-06-16 Impact factor: 10.787