| Literature DB >> 31699711 |
Georgia B Black1, Angus I G Ramsay1, Abigail Baim-Lance2, Jeannie Eng3, Mariya Melnychuk4, Penny Xanthopoulou5, Martin M Brown6, Stephen Morris1, Anthony G Rudd7, Robert Simister8, Naomi J Fulop1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Seven-day working in hospitals is a current priority of international health research and policy. Previous research has shown variability in delivering evidence-based clinical interventions across different times of day and week. We aimed to identify factors influencing such variations in London hyperacute stroke units (HASUs).Entities:
Keywords: health policy; organisation of health services; qualitative research; stroke; stroke medicine
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31699711 PMCID: PMC6858131 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-025367
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Summary of activities observed during non-participant observations
| Activities observed | Total (of eight sites) |
| ‘Front door’ activity | 7/8 |
| Ward round | 6/8 |
| Multidisciplinary team | 7/8 |
| 16:00 catch up meeting | 3/4* |
| Nurse handover | 8/8 |
| Bed meeting | 6/8 |
| Discharge | 4/8 |
| Total conducted | 41 |
Purposive sampling of observations is described under Methods section.
*Only four hyperacute stroke units have this activity.
Summary of interviewees
| Profession | n |
| Consultant physician* | 11 |
| Junior doctor† | 15 |
| Senior nurse‡ | 7 |
| Stroke nurse | 8 |
| Research nurse | 1 |
| Physiotherapist | 10 |
| Occupational therapist | 8 |
| Speech and language therapist | 8 |
| Stroke coordinator§ | 8 |
| Total conducted | 76 |
*Includes lead consultants.
†Includes specialist registrars and senior house officers.
‡Includes matrons and ward managers.
§Includes stroke coordinators, facilitators and administrative staff.
Themes as they relate to consistently and inconsistently provided clinical interventions
| Theme | Impact | |
| Factors influencing temporally consistent care in nursing assessments, CT scans and thrombolysis | Adapting and extending roles |
At night the consultant was only called for positive confirmation if the registrar thought a patient eligible for thrombolysis. |
| Creating continuities between different times of day |
HASU staff created continuities between team members operating at different times of day/week. Handover meetings, multidisciplinary team meetings and ward rounds. | |
| Building relationships and trust |
Strong, trusting relationships with, eg, ED and neuroradiology staff. Reduced decision-making delays, helped maintain pace of assessment and delivery clinical interventions (especially when more than one patient in ED). | |
| Prioritisation of ‘front door’ interventions |
HASU staff relished the early stages of acute stroke care and the potential to see rapid positive outcomes. | |
| Unintended consequences of adaptations |
Threshold for admission to the HASU weakened (junior doctors more risk averse)—led to greater pressure on beds. | |
| Factors influencing temporally inconsistent care in ward admissions, consultant assessments in 12 and 24 hours and therapy assessments in 72 hours | Variations in medical, managerial and allied health professional staffing by time of day |
Likelihood of admission to HASU within 4 hours was influenced by the number of potential patients arriving at hospital. Undergoing consultant assessment within 12 hours and 24 hours depending on patients reaching the ward during period 09:00–12:00. |
| Variations in delivering therapist assessments |
Therapists worked ‘in hours’ shifts—patients arriving at hospital in the morning were less likely to be assessed within 24 hours unless assessed on the day of arrival. London standards specified therapy staffing levels to fully cover only 5 days per week. Various attempts to cover weekend working, but no current staffing model permits consistent therapy provision. | |
| Variations in repatriation processes |
Patients admitted at weekends less likely to be seen by therapists. Social services, care homes, stroke units and community rehabilitation units were significantly less likely to accept new cases at weekends. |
ED, emergency department; HASU, hyperacute stroke unit.
Figure 1Thrombolysis pathway (adapted from Catangui and Slark29). HASU, hyperacute stroke unit.
Figure 2Staff attending suspected stroke calls in emergency department. B6, band 6; CNS, clinical nurse specialist; HASUs, hyperacute stroke units; NHS, National Health Service; NIC, nurse-in-charge; SHO, senior house officer; SpR, specialist registrar. Notes: Banding refers to NHS standardised pay grades and increases according to seniority. Staffing may have altered since the time that this information was collected.
Summary of variations in care and outcomes identified by Melnychuk et al.24
| Type of variation | Examples |
| Time of day but not day of the week | Admission to hyperacute stroke units within 4 hours Most likely: arriving at hospital 00:00–04:00 Least likely: arriving at hospital 08:00–17:00 Most likely: arriving at hospital 00:00–04:00 Least likely: arriving at hospital 16:00–20:00 Most likely: arriving at hospital 16:00–20:00 Least likely: arriving at hospital 04:00–08:00 |
| Day of the week but not time of day | Therapist (Physiotherapist, Occupational Therapist, Speech and Language Therapist) assessments within 72 hours Patients admitted on Friday less likely to be assessed |
| Time of day and day of the week | Therapist assessments within 24 hours Variation during the day Monday–Friday (least likely arriving at hospital 04:00–12:00) Patients admitted on weekends less likely to be assessed |
| Outcome | Length of stay Longer for patients admitted at weekends |