Kathryn A Birnie1, Katherine Dib2, Carley Ouellette2, Mary Anne Dib2, Kimberly Nelson2, Dolores Pahtayken2, Krista Baerg2, Jill Chorney2, Paula Forgeron2, Christine Lamontagne2, Melanie Noel2, Patricia Poulin2, Jennifer Stinson2. 1. University of Toronto and The Hospital for Sick Children (Birnie, Stinson), Toronto, Ont.; patient partner (K. Dib, M. Dib), Halifax, NS; patient partner (Ouellette), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; parent partner (Nelson), Windsor, Ont.; parent partner (Pahtayken), Onion Lake, Sask.; Department of Pediatrics (Baerg), University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Sask.; Dalhousie University and IWK Health Centre (Chorney), Halifax, NS; University of Ottawa (Forgeron, Lamontagne, Poulin); Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario (Lamontagne), Ottawa, Ont.; University of Calgary (Noel), Calgary, Alta.; The Ottawa Hospital (Poulin), Ottawa, Ont. kathryn.birnie@sickkids.ca. 2. University of Toronto and The Hospital for Sick Children (Birnie, Stinson), Toronto, Ont.; patient partner (K. Dib, M. Dib), Halifax, NS; patient partner (Ouellette), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; parent partner (Nelson), Windsor, Ont.; parent partner (Pahtayken), Onion Lake, Sask.; Department of Pediatrics (Baerg), University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Sask.; Dalhousie University and IWK Health Centre (Chorney), Halifax, NS; University of Ottawa (Forgeron, Lamontagne, Poulin); Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario (Lamontagne), Ottawa, Ont.; University of Calgary (Noel), Calgary, Alta.; The Ottawa Hospital (Poulin), Ottawa, Ont.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Chronic pain affects 1-3 million Canadian children and adolescents and their families. The primary objective of the Partnering For Pain project was to collaboratively identify the top 10 research priorities in pediatric chronic pain. METHODS: Partnering For Pain took a patient-oriented research approach and followed a modified James Lind Alliance Priority Setting Partnership (PSP) to identify the top research priorities in pediatric chronic pain according to people with lived experience (patients), family members and health care providers (clinicians). The PSP was completed in 4 phases between May and December 2018: 1) national survey of stakeholders, including those with lived experience with pediatric chronic pain, family members and clinicians who treat children with chronic pain, to gather priorities, 2) data processing, 3) interim prioritization by invited patients, family members and clinicians (former research participants or identified through pediatric chronic pain programs, patient partner organizations and steering committee member networks) and 4) in-person priority-setting workshop involving patients, family members and clinicians identified via steering committee networks and partner organizations, with evaluation of patient engagement. The process was led by a national steering committee of patient and parent partners, researchers and clinicians engaged in codesign, analysis and translation of project findings. RESULTS: In phase 1, 215 Canadians (86 patients [40.0%], 56 family members [26.0%] and 73 clinicians [34.0%]) submitted 540 potential priorities that were developed into 112 unique research questions (phase 2). Of the 112 questions, 63 were rated for importance by 57 participants (19 patients [33%], 17 family members [30%] and 21 clinicians [37%]) in phase 3. In phase 4, 20 participants (6 patients [30%], 6 family members [30%] and 8 clinicians [40%]) discussed the 25 most highly rated questions and reached consensus on the final top 10. INTERPRETATION: The final priorities address pediatric chronic pain prevention, impact and treatment, as well as delivery, access and coordination of care. The priorities reflect a directed and collaborative call to action to improve existing pediatric pain research and care. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Chronic pain affects 1 in 5 children and teens. This means that 1-3 million Canadian youth deal with pain lasting months to years. This pain gets in the way of being active, sleeping, going to school, and getting along with friends and family. Youth with chronic pain and their families are experts on what it's like to live with pain, but, until now, research has not asked what issues they care about most. The goal of the Partnering For Pain project was to develop a list of the 10 most important things we still need to learn about chronic pain during childhood according to people who live with it, their families and health care providers. We did this in 4 steps: 1) a survey with 215 people who shared 540 concerns they have about chronic pain in childhood, 2) turning those concerns into questions that can be answered by research, 3) a survey with 57 people who ranked how important each research question was and 4) an in-person discussion with 20 people who chose the top 10 research priorities. Each step included Canadians who have had chronic pain during childhood, their families and health care providers. The final top 10 list has questions about how to better prevent and care for children and teens with chronic pain. These priorities make sure that future research focuses on what is most important to people who will use it in their everyday lives. Project video: https://youtu.be/wA-RwrFiSPk. Project website: www.partneringforpain.com. Copyright 2019, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
BACKGROUND: Chronic pain affects 1-3 million Canadian children and adolescents and their families. The primary objective of the Partnering For Pain project was to collaboratively identify the top 10 research priorities in pediatric chronic pain. METHODS: Partnering For Pain took a patient-oriented research approach and followed a modified James Lind Alliance Priority Setting Partnership (PSP) to identify the top research priorities in pediatric chronic pain according to people with lived experience (patients), family members and health care providers (clinicians). The PSP was completed in 4 phases between May and December 2018: 1) national survey of stakeholders, including those with lived experience with pediatric chronic pain, family members and clinicians who treat children with chronic pain, to gather priorities, 2) data processing, 3) interim prioritization by invited patients, family members and clinicians (former research participants or identified through pediatric chronic pain programs, patient partner organizations and steering committee member networks) and 4) in-person priority-setting workshop involving patients, family members and clinicians identified via steering committee networks and partner organizations, with evaluation of patient engagement. The process was led by a national steering committee of patient and parent partners, researchers and clinicians engaged in codesign, analysis and translation of project findings. RESULTS: In phase 1, 215 Canadians (86 patients [40.0%], 56 family members [26.0%] and 73 clinicians [34.0%]) submitted 540 potential priorities that were developed into 112 unique research questions (phase 2). Of the 112 questions, 63 were rated for importance by 57 participants (19 patients [33%], 17 family members [30%] and 21 clinicians [37%]) in phase 3. In phase 4, 20 participants (6 patients [30%], 6 family members [30%] and 8 clinicians [40%]) discussed the 25 most highly rated questions and reached consensus on the final top 10. INTERPRETATION: The final priorities address pediatric chronic pain prevention, impact and treatment, as well as delivery, access and coordination of care. The priorities reflect a directed and collaborative call to action to improve existing pediatric pain research and care. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Chronic pain affects 1 in 5 children and teens. This means that 1-3 million Canadian youth deal with pain lasting months to years. This pain gets in the way of being active, sleeping, going to school, and getting along with friends and family. Youth with chronic pain and their families are experts on what it's like to live with pain, but, until now, research has not asked what issues they care about most. The goal of the Partnering For Pain project was to develop a list of the 10 most important things we still need to learn about chronic pain during childhood according to people who live with it, their families and health care providers. We did this in 4 steps: 1) a survey with 215 people who shared 540 concerns they have about chronic pain in childhood, 2) turning those concerns into questions that can be answered by research, 3) a survey with 57 people who ranked how important each research question was and 4) an in-person discussion with 20 people who chose the top 10 research priorities. Each step included Canadians who have had chronic pain during childhood, their families and health care providers. The final top 10 list has questions about how to better prevent and care for children and teens with chronic pain. These priorities make sure that future research focuses on what is most important to people who will use it in their everyday lives. Project video: https://youtu.be/wA-RwrFiSPk. Project website: www.partneringforpain.com. Copyright 2019, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
Authors: Matthew S Shupler; John K Kramer; Jacquelyn J Cragg; Catherine R Jutzeler; David G T Whitehurst Journal: J Pain Date: 2018-11-29 Impact factor: 5.820
Authors: Susmita Kashikar-Zuck; Natoshia Cunningham; Soumitri Sil; Maggie H Bromberg; Anne M Lynch-Jordan; Daniel Strotman; James Peugh; Jennie Noll; Tracy V Ting; Scott W Powers; Daniel J Lovell; Lesley M Arnold Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2014-02-24 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Juan Pablo Domecq; Gabriela Prutsky; Tarig Elraiyah; Zhen Wang; Mohammed Nabhan; Nathan Shippee; Juan Pablo Brito; Kasey Boehmer; Rim Hasan; Belal Firwana; Patricia Erwin; David Eton; Jeff Sloan; Victor Montori; Noor Asi; Abd Moain Abu Dabrh; Mohammad Hassan Murad Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2014-02-26 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Anava A Wren; Alexandra C Ross; Genevieve D'Souza; Christina Almgren; Amanda Feinstein; Amanda Marshall; Brenda Golianu Journal: Children (Basel) Date: 2019-02-21
Authors: Oliver Boney; Madeline Bell; Natalie Bell; Ann Conquest; Marion Cumbers; Sharon Drake; Mike Galsworthy; Jacqui Gath; Michael P W Grocott; Emma Harris; Simon Howell; Anthony Ingold; Michael H Nathanson; Thomas Pinkney; Leanne Metcalf Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2015-12-16 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Laura Simons; Massieh Moayedi; Robert C Coghill; Jennifer Stinson; Martin S Angst; Nima Aghaeepour; Brice Gaudilliere; Christopher D King; Marina López-Solà; Marie-Eve Hoeppli; Emma Biggs; Ed Ganio; Sara E Williams; Kenneth R Goldschneider; Fiona Campbell; Danielle Ruskin; Elliot J Krane; Suellen Walker; Gillian Rush; Marissa Heirich Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2022-06-08 Impact factor: 3.006
Authors: Jananee Rasiah; Stephen Freedman; Lee Macdonald; Kassi Prisnie; Mohamed Eltorki; Yaron Finkelstein; Gareth Hopkin; Maria-Jose Santana; Jennifer Thull-Freedman; Antonia Stang; Matthew Prebeg; Isabelle J Gagnon; Margaret Steele; Ahmed Mater; Laurence Katz; Brian Greenfield; Laurie Plotnick; Suneeta Monga; Ellen Louise Lipman; Bruce Wright; Gina Dimitropoulos; Robert Porter; Katrina Hurley; Yazid N Al Hamarneh; Amanda Newton Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2022-06-17 Impact factor: 3.006
Authors: Helen Slater; Joanne E Jordan; Peter B O'Sullivan; Robert Schütze; Roger Goucke; Jason Chua; Allyson Browne; Ben Horgan; Simone De Morgan; Andrew M Briggs Journal: Pain Date: 2022-04-06 Impact factor: 7.926
Authors: Nathan Augeard; Geoff Bostick; Jordan Miller; David Walton; Yannick Tousignant-Laflamme; Anne Hudon; André Bussières; Lynn Cooper; Nicol McNiven; Aliki Thomas; Lesley Singer; Scott M Fishman; Marie H Bement; Julia M Hush; Kathleen A Sluka; Judy Watt-Watson; Lisa C Carlesso; Sinead Dufour; Roland Fletcher; Katherine Harman; Judith Hunter; Suzy Ngomo; Neil Pearson; Kadija Perreault; Barbara Shay; Peter Stilwell; Susan Tupper; Timothy H Wideman Journal: Can J Pain Date: 2022-01-11
Authors: Gloria A Aguayo; Catherine Goetzinger; Renza Scibilia; Aurélie Fischer; Till Seuring; Viet-Thi Tran; Philippe Ravaud; Tamás Bereczky; Laetitia Huiart; Guy Fagherazzi Journal: J Med Internet Res Date: 2021-12-23 Impact factor: 5.428
Authors: Tonya M Palermo; Gary A Walco; Unmesha Roy Paladhi; Kathryn A Birnie; Geert Crombez; Rocio de la Vega; Christopher Eccleston; Susmita Kashikar-Zuck; Amanda L Stone Journal: Pain Date: 2021-10-01 Impact factor: 6.961