| Literature DB >> 31694599 |
Ming-Gui Wang1, Lan Luo1, Yunxia Zhang2, Xiangming Liu1, Lin Liu3, Jian-Qing He4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Tuberculous meningitis is the most devastating presentation of disease with Mycobacterium tuberculosis. We sought to evaluate treatment outcomes for adult patients with this disease.Entities:
Keywords: Adults,; HIV; Outcomes,; Tuberculous meningitis,
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31694599 PMCID: PMC6833188 DOI: 10.1186/s12890-019-0966-8
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Pulm Med ISSN: 1471-2466 Impact factor: 3.317
Fig. 1Flow diagram of included studies
Characteristics of included studies
| Study | Study type | Location | Year of enrolment | Number of patients | Intensive phase | Continuation phase | Patients receiving corticosteroids | Follow-up (months) | Patients characteristics | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Treatment | Duration (months) | Treatment | Duration (months) | Age (years) | Female | Lost-to-follow-up | HIV | |||||||
| Hosoglu et al (1998) | RC | Turkey | 1985–1996 | 101 | HRSZ (group 1); HRSE (group 2) | 2–3 | HR | ≥ 6 | NR | NR (≥ 9) | 30.6 ± 13.0 | 40 | 5 | NR |
| Katrak et al (2000) | PC | India | 1992–1997 | 53 | HRZE | ≥ 6 | NR | 6 | 16–60 | NR | 0 | 22 | ||
| Chan et al (2003) | RC | China | 1997–2001 | 31 | HRZE | 3 | HR | 9 | NR | 12–60 | ≥ 14 | 17 | NR | 1 |
| Thwaites et al (2004) | PC | Vietnam | 2001–2003 | 545 | HRZS (group 1); HRZE (group 2) | 3 | HRZ | 6 | Some | 9 | 15–88 | 214 | 34 | 98 |
| Cagatay et al (2004) | RC | Turkey | 1991–2002 | 42 | HRZE | 2–3 | HR | 10 | Some | 12 | 16–60 | 28 | NR | 2 |
| Torok et al (2008) | PC | Vietnam | 2004–2005 | 58 | HRZE (group 1); HRZES (group 2) | 3 | HRZ | 6 | NR | NR (≥ 9) | 20–48 | 7 | 8 | 36/55 |
| Hsu et al (2010) | RC | China | 2000–2006 | 108 | HRZ (group 1); HRZE (group 2) | ≥ 6 | Some | ≥ 6 | 19–87 (54.9 ± 18.6) | 37 | NR | NR | ||
| Sinha et al (2010) | PC | India | 2008–2009 | 101 | HRZS | 2 | HR | 7 | All | 6 | 14–85 (30 ± 13) | 42 | NR | 0 |
| Anuradha et al (2010) | PC | India | 2008–2009 | 100 | HRZE | 2 | HR | 4 | All | 6 | > 14 (30 ± 13) | 41 | NR | 0 |
| Sharma et al (2011) | RC | India | 2008–2010 | 158 | HRZS | 2 | HR | 7 | All | ≥ 9 | > 14 (31.95 ± 13.96) | 91 | NR | 0 |
| Torok et al (2011) | RCT | Vietnam | 2005–2007 | 253 | HRZE (group 1); HRZES (group 2) | 3 | HR | 6 | All | ≥ 9 | ≥ 15 | 25 | NR | 253 |
| Marais et al (2011) | RC | South Africa | 2009 | 120 | HRZE (group 1); HRZES (group 2) | 2–3 | HR (group 1); HRE (group 2) | ≥ 4 (group 1); ≥ 5 (group 2) | Some | ≥ 6 | ≥ 18 | 60 | 12 | 106/114 |
| Raut et al (2013) | PC | India | 2010–2012 | 80 | HRZS | 2 | HR | 7 | NR | 6 | 14–68 | 37 | NR | 0 |
| Ruslami et al (2013) | RCT | Indonesia | 2010–2011 | 60 | HRZE (group1); HRZMfx (group 2) | 2 | HR | 4 | All | ≥ 6 | > 14 | 27 | NR | 7 |
| Imam et al (2014) | RC | Qatar | 2006–2012 | 80 | HRZE | ≥ 6 | Some | NR (≥ 6) | ≥ 18 | 15 | 1 | NR | ||
| Iype et al (2014) | PC | India | 2010–2011 | 45 | HRZS (group 1); HREZ (group 2) | 2–3 | HR | 7 | NR | NR (≥ 9) | 14–61 | 21 | 2 | NR |
| Chen et al (2014) | RC | China | 2002–2009 | 38 | HRZE | 2 | HRE | 10月16日 | Some | NR (12–18) | > 18 | 133 | 3 | 2 |
| Jha et al (2015) | PC | India | 2012–2014 | 118 | HRZS | 2 | HR | 7 | All | 6 | ≥ 14 | 61 | NR | 0 |
| Misra et al (2015) | RC | India | 2010–2014 | 74 | HRZE | 6 | HR | 12 | ALL | NR (≥ 18) | ≥ 14 | 28 | NR | NR |
| Tai et al (2016) | PC | Malaysia | 2009–2014 | 41 | HRZE | 2 | HR | 10月16日 | Some | NR (12–18) | 35.0 ± 13.7 | 19 | NR | 0 |
| Li et al (2017) | RC | China | 2012–2015 | 156 | HRZE | 2–4 | HR | 6月12日 | All | ≥ 8 | 16–82 | 69 | 14 | NR |
| Raberahona et al (2017) | RC | Madagascar | 2007–2014 | 75 | HRZE (group 1); HRZES (group 2) | 2 | HR (group 1); HRZE (group 2) | 6 (before 2012); 4 (after 2012) | NR | NR (≥ 6) | ≥ 18 (35.4 ± 12.7) | 33 | NR | 3 |
(Abbreviations: HIV human immunodeficiency virus, RC retrospective cohort, PC prospective cohort, RCT randomized controlled trial, H isoniazid, R rifampicin, Z pyrazinamide, E ethambutol, S streptomycin, Mfx moxifloxacin, NR not reported)
Fig. 2The Egger’s funnel plot of publication bias
Fig. 3Frequency of death among tuberculous meningitis in adults
Fig. 4Frequency of neurological sequelae among survivors
Subgroup analyses of deaths
| Number of studies | Number of deaths | Number of patients assessed | Proportion of death (95%CI) | Heterogeneity (95%CI) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Study type | |||||
| Prospective cohort | 9 | 322 | 1141 | 22.4%(14.1–33.8) | 3.4(2.7–4.4) |
| Retrospective cohort | 11 | 205 | 983 | 22.0%(14.5–31.8) | 3.1(2.5–4.0) |
| BMRC stage | |||||
| Stage I | 7 | 60 | 356 | 17.5%(8.9–31.7) | 1.8(1.2–2.7) |
| Stage II | 7 | 157 | 513 | 28.5%(20.6–37.9) | 1.7(1.2–2.6) |
| Stage III | 7 | 207 | 318 | 64.8%(51.5–76.1) | 1.9(1.3–2.8) |
| HIV infection | |||||
| HIV positive | 7 | 301 | 547 | 53.4%(42.4–64.1) | 2.1(1.4–3.0) |
| HIV negative | 11 | 257 | 1264 | 17.5%(12.1–24.7) | 2.7(2.1–3.5) |
| Treatment duration | |||||
| At least 6 months | 9 | 256 | 853 | 27.9%(19.7–38.8) | 3.1(2.4–4.0) |
| At least 9 months | 13 | 498 | 1584 | 22.4%(14.5–32.8) | 4.0(3.4–4.8) |
| Treatment with streptomycin | |||||
| Yes | 5 | 102 | 558 | 17.1(8.5–31.6) | 3.5(2.5–4.9) |
| No | 11 | 181 | 783 | 20.3%(13.6–29.2) | 2.6(2.0–3.3) |
(Abbreviations: BMRC the British Medical Research Council, HIV human immunodeficiency virus)
Frequency of symptoms and diagnostic findings at admission
| Number of studies | Number of patients with characteristics | Number of patients assessed | Proportion (95%CI) | Heterogeneity (95%CI) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Characteristics | |||||
| Females | 21 | 925 | 2384 | 39.9%(34.0–46.0) | 2.8(2.3–3.3) |
| Previous BCG vaccination | 4 | 117 | 286 | 44.8%(22.4–69.5) | 3.7(2.6–5.4) |
| Known tuberculosis contact | 4 | 98 | 298 | 21.6%(3.8–65.5) | 5.5(4.1–7.4) |
| Lost-to-follow-up | 9 | 79 | 1196 | 7.3%(5.3–10.0) | 1.3(1.0–1.9) |
| HIV positive | 16 | 530 | 1864 | 10.6%(4.2–24.6) | 4.3(3.7–5.0) |
| BMRC stage | |||||
| Stage I | 17 | 534 | 2041 | 24.9% (21.1–29.1) | 1.9 (1.5–2.5) |
| Stage II | 17 | 927 | 2041 | 46.9%(41.4–52.4) | 2.3(1.9–2.9) |
| Stage III | 17 | 562 | 2041 | 26.4%(20.7–32.9) | 2.9(2.4–3.5) |
| Diagnostic | |||||
| Possible | 11 | 363 | 1399 | 29.0%(21.0–38.5) | 3.2(2.6–4.1) |
| Probable | 13 | 583 | 1565 | 34.7%(27.8–42.3) | 2.8(2.2–3.5) |
| Definite | 14 | 611 | 1643 | 38.9%(32.1–46.1) | 2.6(2.0–3.2) |
| Symptoms | |||||
| Fever | 14 | 1013 | 1126 | 89.5%(84.2–93.2) | 2.1(1.6–2.7) |
| Headache | 16 | 1089 | 1306 | 85.9%(77.9–91.4) | 3.1(2.5–3.7) |
| Seisures | 15 | 260 | 1369 | 18.5%(14.2–23.7) | 2.2(1.8–2.8) |
| Vomiting | 11 | 511 | 932 | 54%(40.3–67.1) | 3.8(3.1–4.7) |
| Weight loss | 8 | 319 | 611 | 47.9%(24.5–72.2) | 3.9(3.1–5.0) |
| Radiological findings | |||||
| Abnormal chest radiogragh | 9 | 465 | 781 | 54.5%(42.2–66.3) | 3.1(2.4–4.0) |
| Basilar enhancement | 14 | 565 | 1100 | 49.5%(28.8–70.5) | 5.3(4.5–6.1) |
| Hydrocephalus | 18 | 511 | 1461 | 35.2%(27.9–43.2) | 2.8(2.4–3.4) |
| Infarction | 13 | 273 | 1221 | 23.2%(18.3–29.0) | 2.2(1.7–2.8) |
| Tuberculoma | 16 | 359 | 1326 | 22.4%(16.9–29.0) | 2.6(2.1–3.2) |
| Diagnostic testing | |||||
| Positive culture for | 18 | 588 | 1514 | 23.8%(15.2–35.3) | 3.9(3.3–4.6) |
| Positive smear for acid-fast bacilli in CSF | 14 | 166 | 1177 | 10.0%(5.5–17.6) | 3.0(2.5–3.7) |
| Positive polymerase chain reaction for Mycobacterium tuberculosis in CSF | 10 | 187 | 978 | 22.3%(17.8–27.5) | 1.7(1.2–2.4) |
| Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolated from site other than CSF | 4 | 70 | 404 | 14.7%(7.0–28.1) | 2.7(1.8–4.3) |
(Abbreviations: BMRC the British Medical Research Council, CSF cerebrospinal fluid)