Ericka L Fink1, Robert C Tasker2. 1. Departments of Critical Care Medicine & Pediatrics, UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 2. Departments of Anesthesiology, Critical Care and Pain Medicine & Neurology, Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Randomized controlled trials leading to innovations that improve outcomes in acute life-threatening illnesses in children are scarce. A key issue is how we refocus research on outcomes that matter and are more relevant to those making emergency decisions, and those involved with managing and living with the late-outcome. We have used information from recent trials in critically ill children - in particular those illnesses without any primary neurologic involvement - to develop an approach to brain-related outcomes that will maximize child and family benefit from research. RECENT FINDINGS: Fifteen recent pediatric critical care trials illustrate four types of brain-related outcomes assessment: death or organ-system-failures - as illustrated by studies in systemic illness; neurological and neuropsychological outcomes - as illustrated by the glycemic control studies; cognitive outcomes - as illustrated by a sedative trial; and composite outcomes - as illustrated by the therapeutic hypothermia studies. SUMMARY: The 15 research trials point to five areas that will need to be addressed and incorporated into future trial design, including use of: neurologic monitoring during intensive care unit admission; postdischarge outcomes assessments; strategies to improve retention in long-term follow-up; child and family-centered outcomes; and core outcomes datasets.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Randomized controlled trials leading to innovations that improve outcomes in acute life-threatening illnesses in children are scarce. A key issue is how we refocus research on outcomes that matter and are more relevant to those making emergency decisions, and those involved with managing and living with the late-outcome. We have used information from recent trials in critically illchildren - in particular those illnesses without any primary neurologic involvement - to develop an approach to brain-related outcomes that will maximize child and family benefit from research. RECENT FINDINGS: Fifteen recent pediatric critical care trials illustrate four types of brain-related outcomes assessment: death or organ-system-failures - as illustrated by studies in systemic illness; neurological and neuropsychological outcomes - as illustrated by the glycemic control studies; cognitive outcomes - as illustrated by a sedative trial; and composite outcomes - as illustrated by the therapeutic hypothermia studies. SUMMARY: The 15 research trials point to five areas that will need to be addressed and incorporated into future trial design, including use of: neurologic monitoring during intensive care unit admission; postdischarge outcomes assessments; strategies to improve retention in long-term follow-up; child and family-centered outcomes; and core outcomes datasets.
Authors: Paula R Williamson; Douglas G Altman; Heather Bagley; Karen L Barnes; Jane M Blazeby; Sara T Brookes; Mike Clarke; Elizabeth Gargon; Sarah Gorst; Nicola Harman; Jamie J Kirkham; Angus McNair; Cecilia A C Prinsen; Jochen Schmitt; Caroline B Terwee; Bridget Young Journal: Trials Date: 2017-06-20 Impact factor: 2.279
Authors: Michael O Harhay; Jason Wagner; Sarah J Ratcliffe; Rachel S Bronheim; Anand Gopal; Sydney Green; Elizabeth Cooney; Mark E Mikkelsen; Meeta Prasad Kerlin; Dylan S Small; Scott D Halpern Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2014-06-15 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: Martha A Q Curley; David Wypij; R Scott Watson; Mary Jo C Grant; Lisa A Asaro; Ira M Cheifetz; Brenda L Dodson; Linda S Franck; Rainer G Gedeit; Derek C Angus; Michael A Matthay Journal: JAMA Date: 2015-01-27 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Richard Holubkov; Amy E Clark; Frank W Moler; Beth S Slomine; James R Christensen; Faye S Silverstein; Kathleen L Meert; Murray M Pollack; J Michael Dean Journal: Pediatr Crit Care Med Date: 2015-01 Impact factor: 3.624
Authors: Andréa M C Ventura; Huei Hsin Shieh; Albert Bousso; Patrícia F Góes; Iracema de Cássia F O Fernandes; Daniela C de Souza; Rodrigo Locatelli Pedro Paulo; Fabiana Chagas; Alfredo E Gilio Journal: Crit Care Med Date: 2015-11 Impact factor: 7.598
Authors: Christopher S Parshuram; Karen Dryden-Palmer; Catherine Farrell; Ronald Gottesman; Martin Gray; James S Hutchison; Mark Helfaer; Elizabeth A Hunt; Ari R Joffe; Jacques Lacroix; Michael Alice Moga; Vinay Nadkarni; Nelly Ninis; Patricia C Parkin; David Wensley; Andrew R Willan; George A Tomlinson Journal: JAMA Date: 2018-03-13 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Jeffrey P Burns; Deborah E Sellers; Elaine C Meyer; Mithya Lewis-Newby; Robert D Truog Journal: Crit Care Med Date: 2014-09 Impact factor: 7.598
Authors: Danielle C Lavallee; Kate E Chenok; Rebecca M Love; Carolyn Petersen; Erin Holve; Courtney D Segal; Patricia D Franklin Journal: Health Aff (Millwood) Date: 2016-04 Impact factor: 6.301
Authors: Frank W Moler; Faye S Silverstein; Richard Holubkov; Beth S Slomine; James R Christensen; Vinay M Nadkarni; Kathleen L Meert; Amy E Clark; Brittan Browning; Victoria L Pemberton; Kent Page; Seetha Shankaran; Jamie S Hutchison; Christopher J L Newth; Kimberly S Bennett; John T Berger; Alexis Topjian; Jose A Pineda; Joshua D Koch; Charles L Schleien; Heidi J Dalton; George Ofori-Amanfo; Denise M Goodman; Ericka L Fink; Patrick McQuillen; Jerry J Zimmerman; Neal J Thomas; Elise W van der Jagt; Melissa B Porter; Michael T Meyer; Rick Harrison; Nga Pham; Adam J Schwarz; Jeffrey E Nowak; Jeffrey Alten; Derek S Wheeler; Utpal S Bhalala; Karen Lidsky; Eric Lloyd; Mudit Mathur; Samir Shah; Theodore Wu; Andreas A Theodorou; Ronald C Sanders; J Michael Dean Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-04-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Mathias Lühr Hansen; Simon Hyttel-Sørensen; Janus Christian Jakobsen; Christian Gluud; Elisabeth M W Kooi; Jonathan Mintzer; Willem P de Boode; Monica Fumagalli; Ana Alarcon; Thomas Alderliesten; Gorm Greisen Journal: Syst Rev Date: 2021-04-16
Authors: Ericka L Fink; Aline B Maddux; Neethi Pinto; Samuel Sorenson; Daniel Notterman; J Michael Dean; Joseph A Carcillo; Robert A Berg; Athena Zuppa; Murray M Pollack; Kathleen L Meert; Mark W Hall; Anil Sapru; Patrick S McQuillen; Peter M Mourani; David Wessel; Deborah Amey; Andrew Argent; Werther Brunow de Carvalho; Warwick Butt; Karen Choong; Martha A Q Curley; Maria Del Pilar Arias Lopez; Demet Demirkol; Ruth Grosskreuz; Amy J Houtrow; Hennie Knoester; Jan Hau Lee; Debbie Long; Joseph C Manning; Brenda Morrow; Jhuma Sankar; Beth S Slomine; McKenna Smith; Lenora M Olson; R Scott Watson Journal: Crit Care Med Date: 2020-12 Impact factor: 9.296