Concise asymmetric synthesis of (-)-bilobalide.

The Ginkgo biloba metabolite bilobalide is widely ingested by humans but its effect on the mammalian central nervous system is not fully understood1-4. Antagonism of γ-aminobutyric acid A receptors (GABAARs) by bilobalide has been linked to the rescue of cognitive deficits in mouse models of Down syndrome5. A lack of convulsant activity coupled with neuroprotective effects have led some to postulate an alternative, unidentified target4; however, steric congestion and the instability of bilobalide1,2,6 have prevented pull-down of biological targets other than the GABAΑRs. A concise and flexible synthesis of bilobalide would facilitate the development of probes for the identification of potential new targets, analogues with differential selectivity between insect and human GABAΑRs, and stabilized analogues with an enhanced serum half-life7. Here we exploit the unusual reactivity of bilobalide to enable a late-stage deep oxidation that symmetrizes the molecular core and enables oxidation states to be embedded in the starting materials. The same overall strategy may be applicable to G. biloba congeners, including the ginkgolides-some of which are glycine-receptor-selective antagonists8. A chemical synthesis of bilobalide should facilitate the investigation of its biological effects and its therapeutic potential.

The Ginkgo biloba metabolite bilobalide is widely ingested by humans but its effect on the mammalian central nervous system is not fully understood[1,2,3,4]. Antagonism of gamma-aminobutyric acid A receptors (GABAARs) by bilobalide has been tied to rescue of cognitive deficits in mouse models of Down syndrome[5]. A lack of convulsant activity coupled with these neuroprotective effects have led some to postulate an alternative, unidentified target.[4] However, steric congestion and the instability of 1[1,2,6] have prevented pulldown of biological targets other than the GABAARs. A concise and flexible synthesis of 1 would provide a platform to generate probes for identification of potential new targets; analogs with differential selectivity between insect and human GABAARs; and stabilized analogs with enhanced serum half-life[7]. Here we exploit the unusual reactivity of bilobalide to affect a late-stage oxidation that symmetrizes the molecular core and allows oxidation states to be embedded in the starting material. The same overall strategy disclosed here may be applicable to G. biloba congeners including the ginkgolides, some of which are glycine receptor (GlyR)-selective antagonists[8]. The therapeutic potential of bilobalide and its incompletely understood effects can now be interrogated through chemical synthesis.

The leaves of Ginkgo biloba have been used historically as insecticides and helminthicides[9,10], activity attributed to its constituent terpene trilactones, including bilobalide (1, Fig. 1)[11,12]. Ginkgo extracts have seen use in traditional Chinese medicine to treat senility, a practice that has penetrated the Western world, albeit controversially, due to opposing claims of efficacy[1] and serious adverse effects associated with Ginkgo toxin (4-O-methylpyridoxine)[2] or inhibition of platelet aggregating factor (PAF)[13] by ginkgolides. Animal models demonstrate some credible effects on impaired cognition: Down syndrome model mice (Ts65DN), which show deficits in declarative learning and memory, exhibit normalized novel object recognition after treatment by pure bilobalide[5]. Rescue of learning and memory is proposed to arise through neuronal excitation by antagonism of GABAARs. Unlike the plant metabolite picrotoxinin (2, Figure 1), bilobalide is not acutely toxic, and unlike the gingkolides, bilobalide does not affect PAF. Despite their disparate toxicity, bilobalide and picrotoxinin exhibit similar inhibitory potencies at recombinant GABAARs (IC50 = 4.6 μM vs. 2.0 μM, respectively; α1β2γ2L, Xenopus laevis oocytes), but differentially inhibit the actions of GABAAR positive modulators[14].

Figure 1.

Congeners and design considerations.

a. Plant metabolites active in the human nervous system; b. late-stage excision of a buried C-H bond in bilobalide (bilobalide) allows oxygens to be placed in a symmetric starting material; c. prior work iteratively changed oxidation states.

In addition to incomplete approaches[15–16, 17], two prior syntheses of bilobalide have been completed [24 steps enantioselective;[18,19]17 steps racemic[20]], both of which established the cyclopentane core with efficiency but required 8–11 subsequent redox steps to reach the target. Guided by these challenges, we realized that a single oxidation transform might reduce synthetic complexity by unmasking a pseudosymmetric fused dilactone, ultimately leading to a symmetric starting material (see Figure 1). However, late-stage installation of the deep C10 hydroxyl (Figure 1, highlighted in red) presented a problem. Neither hydrogen of its precursor inner-lactone (shown in green) seemed accessible, whereas a hydrogen of the outer-lactone (shown in blue) resided at the surface of bilobalide’s bowl-like scaffold. Here, we utilize unexpected properties of the bilobalide scaffold in a concise synthesis of (–)-des-hydroxybilobalide (>99% ee, 5, Figure 1), which relies on stereocontrol transmitted from an unusual oxetane acetal. A late-stage oxidation is rendered regioselective using skeletal rearrangement and acidification, completing the synthesis of (–)-bilobalide in a single additional step.

The synthesis commenced with a methodological challenge: an asymmetric Reformatsky reaction between 6a and 6b (available in two and one steps respectively, see SI section 3). Reformatsky conditions proved necessary due to the tendency of 7 to undergo retro-aldol cleavage under basic conditions, whereas zinc, chromium and samarium alkoxides were stable at −78 °C. There have been no examples of catalytic enantio- and diastereoselective zinc Reformatsky reactions[21], nor use of simple, chiral L-type bisoxazoline (BOX) ligands. Wolf has demonstrated the use of related, electron-rich hemiaminals to control single stereocenters[22], and the simplicity of these conditions provided a foundation to explore. After a ligand screen, we found that a combination of diethylzinc and indabox (10 mol% A) were effective to provide secondary alcohol 7 in 97:3 er in favor of syn-diastereomer 7 (2.3:1). The combined yield of both diastereomers was determined to be 64% by NMR (purification by chromatography on silica led to material loss via retro-aldol), and the crude reaction mixture could be carried forward efficiently. The doubly-activated bromide 6a may uniquely enable the use of simple BOX ligands, which have eluded use for enantioselective Reformatsky reactions[21].

A Giese-type 5-exo-trig cyclization of 7 occurred with high regio- and diastereoselectivity (20:1 dr; 6-endo-trig n.d.) to form the quaternary carbon of cyclopentene 8. Recrystallization purified the material to >99% enantiomeric excess and provided the product in 21% yield over two steps; the relative and absolute stereochemistry were confirmed by x-ray crystallography (see SI section 5).

Prior syntheses of 1 installed the extremely hindered tert-alkyl, bis-neo-pentyl C8 hydroxyl either by late-stage dihydroxylation with stoichiometric osmium tetroxide (23 °C, 12 hr)[18]; or by early-stage nitrile anion addition to a tert-butyl ketone, which rendered the synthesis racemic[20]. More recently, the Drago-Mukaiyama hydration has emerged as an effective method to chemoselectively hydrate hindered alkenes through an outer-sphere, metal-hydride hydrogen atom transfer (MHAT) mechanism[23]. In this case, application of standard conditions delivered a low-yield of 9 with no diastereoselectivity (Figure 2b, entry 4). We recently discovered that the kinetically-relevant reductant in many Mukaiyama reactions is an alkoxysilane (e.g. Ph(i-PrO)SiH2) formed in situ by silane alcoholysis[24]. This custom, commercially available silane allowed us to screen a diverse range of solvents, and we identified a correlation between solvent polarity and diastereoselectivity, possibly due to internal hydrogen bonding (see Figure 2b). Ligands on the metal catalyst had no effect on dr. Tert-butylmethyl ether favored the wrong (S)-C8 diastereomer of the alcohol (which cyclized to a lactone), whereas methylcyclohexane reversed this stereoselectivity to favor (R)-C8 diastereomer 9 in a 3:1 ratio.

Figure 2.

Synthesis of (–)-bilobalide.

a. Reagents and conditions: (1) 6a, 6b (1.2 equiv.), A (10 mol%), Et2Zn (3.0 equiv.), THF, −78 °C; (2) Bu3nH (1.5 equiv.), AIBN (0.1 equiv.), PhMe, 85 °C (3) Mn(dpm)3 (10 mol%), Ph(i-PrO)SiH2 (3.0 equiv.), PPh3 (1.5 equiv.), methylcyclohexane, O2 (1 atm), 50 °C; (4) (–)-B4 (10 mol%), THF/H2O (2:1), 23 °C; (5) IBX (3.0 equiv.), DMSO, 23 °C; (6) TMS-EBX (3.0 equiv.), TBAF (3.0 equiv.), THF, −78 °C to −20 °C; (7) SmI2 (8.4 equiv.), THF/H2O (5:1), 0 °C; (8) LiHMDS (3.0 equiv.), THF, −78 °C; B(OMe)3 (5.0 equiv.), 23 °C; mCPBA (5.0 equiv.), 0 °C; (9) H2, Pd/C (10 wt%), MeOH, 23 °C; 3M HCl (aq.), 80 °C; (10) Bz2O (1.5 equiv.), DMAP (1.5 equiv.), THF, 23 °C; KHMDS (3.0 equiv.), −78 °C, (±)-C (3 equiv.), −78 °C; 3M HCl (aq.), 80 °C; b. Solvent screen (enabled by Ph(iPrOSiH2); C7H14 = methylcyclohexane; c. Acid-catalyzed oxetane acetal formation; a10: 39:61 er, 11: 69:31 er.

Formation of the fourth contiguous, fully-substituted carbon atom by alkylation was frustrated by dehydration of 9 under basic conditions or preference for the wrong C5 stereoisomer. Surprisingly, treatment of 9 with strong acid led to unexpectedly stable oxetane acetals 10 (endo-OMe) and 11 (exo-OMe), possibly driven by a ‘corset effect’ that increases the barrier to ring-opening of strained molecules like tetrahedranes[25]. Only the minor endo-isomer 10 could be carried forward: the major exo-OMe diastereomer 11 dehydrated under basic conditions and its epimerization to 10 was unsuccessful. However, analysis by chiral chromatography indicated that a moderate parallel kinetic resolution of (rac)-9 had occurred: each diastereomer possessed opposite enantiomeric excess [39:61 er versus 69:31 er]. Accordingly, a single enantiomer of 9, if matched with the correct enantiomer of chiral acid, would favor formation of the desired endo-10. Indeed, whereas (–)-9 reacted with (–)-B to favor (1.4:1) exo-acetal 11, (+)-9 reacted to favor (4.5:1) endo-acetal 10, isolated in 71% yield as a single enantiomer. Endo-acetal 10 proved crucial to control formation of the final quaternary carbon.

Due to steric hindrance in substrate 10, the final C–C bond could only be established using an alkyne electrophile. A 3-step sequence was run in quick succession due to intermediate instability; only alkyne 12 could be purified. First, 2-iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX) oxidation delivered an unstable β-keto ester that could undergo α-alkylation. Second, this mixture of keto-enol tautomers was treated with Waser’s reagent (TMS-EBX) and tetra-n-butylammonium fluoride (TBAF)[26]. The endo-methoxy oxetane effectively shielded one trajectory of electrophile approach and provided the product as a single diastereomer. In contrast, the exo-methoxy oxetane, if carried forward to this step, eliminated the tert-alkyl ether and did not undergo alkynylation. Alkynylation prior to oxetane formation delivered exclusively the incorrect diastereomer. The unstable alkynylation product was reduced with high stereoselectivity using SmI2 in a mixture of tetrahydrofuran/water to provide the stable alcohol 12 in 60% yield over 3 steps.[27] Traditional hydride reductants produced the opposite diastereomer. Anti-Markovnikov hydration of the alkyne to directly incorporate the northern lactone motif could not be accomplished under a variety of standard conditions including oxidation by lithium tert-butylperoxide[28], so an alternative procedure was developed. Deprotonation of the terminal alkyne with lithium bis(trimethylsilyl)amide (LHMDS) followed by treatment with trimethylborate led to the formation of an alkynylborate intermediate. Addition of meta-chloroperbenzoic acid (mCPBA) to the reaction mixture likely formed an intermediate ketene and/or mixed anhydride that was captured by the adjacent alcohol. To the best of our knowledge, this procedure for alkyne oxidation has not been reported. Hydrogenolysis of the benzyl esters followed by in situ acidic hydrolysis caused skeletal rearrangement to (–)-5 in excellent yield.

Introduction of the final, deep C10 oxygen proved challenging. The steric hindrance and ‘bowl’ shape of 5, in addition to its base-lability, derailed many potential solutions. 5 contains three acidic sites—the hydroxyl, the inner-lactone and the outer-lactone—but addition of 3 equivalents of strong base, followed by acidic quench at −78 °C caused significant decomposition and poor mass recovery. We found that treatment with one equivalent of potassium bis(trimethylsilyl)amide (KHMDS) followed by addition of aqueous 1M HCl caused full mass recovery, but cleanly delivered the iso-bilobalide scaffold (e.g. 16a, Figure 3), a result of intramolecular translactonization[29]. Similarly, we found translactonization to occur at room temperature with 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene (DBU) (bilobalide to iso-bilobalide, see SI section 3). This facile rearrangement is probably driven both by the proximity of the C8 hydroxyl to C4 at the Bürgi-Dunitz angle, as well as delocalization of the lactone π-system into the adjacent C-O σ* orbital. Molecular models revealed that the iso-bilobalide rearrangement partially folds the skeletal cavity ‘inside-out’ (see Figure 3) to render the inner lactone protons more accessible to reagents. However, neither the alkoxide of 1 nor its tert-butyldimethylsilyl (TBS) ether (16b) provided substantial bilobalide upon treatment with oxidant (Davis’ oxaziridine, (±)-17). Despite the unfolding of the bilobalide cavity and C10-proton exposure (highlighted in green), base still favored deprotonation of the outer lactone and therefore oxidation provided the isomeric neo-bilobalide 15. We wondered if inner lactone deprotonation required both increased exposure (rearrangement) and increased acidification. Induction through sigma bonds or delocalization of the lactone π-system into an adjacent, withdrawn C-O σ* orbital might acidify the α-protons, i.e. stabilize the corresponding enolate[30]. Conversion of 5 to the isomeric benzoate followed by deprotonation and oxidation at low temperature yielded (–)-1 with only a trace of 15. Combination of benzoylation and oxidation into one step proved successful, scalable and selective; neo-bilobalide (11) could not be detected.

Figure 3.

Late-stage, regio and stereo-selective oxidation of C10 over C1.

Reagents and conditions for entry 3: 1. EDCI (3 equiv.), BzOH (3 equiv.), DMAP (0.1 equiv.), THF; 2. KHMDS (1.5 equiv), (±)-C (1.5 equiv); 2M HCl, 60 °C Based on conversion.

The sequence in Figure 2 has been completed in seven days by one person to produce 0.35 g of (–)-5. The same overall strategy disclosed here may be applicable to G. biloba congeners including the ginkgolides, some of which are glycine receptor (GlyR)-selective antagonists[31]. These studies have laid a foundation for new, enabling chemistry and a platform for functional modification of bilobalide.