Young Chandler1, Jinani C Jayasekera1, Clyde B Schechter2, Claudine Isaacs3, Christopher J Cadham1, Jeanne S Mandelblatt1. 1. Department of Oncology, Georgetown University Medical Center, Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, Cancer Prevention and Control Program, Washington, DC. 2. Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Montefiore Medical Center, Bronx, NY. 3. Department of Medicine, Georgetown University Medical Center, Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, Breast Cancer Program, Washington, DC.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Tumor genomic expression profile data are used to guide chemotherapy choice, but there are gaps in evidence for women aged 65 years and older. We estimate chemotherapy effects by age and comorbidity level among women with early-stage, hormone receptor-positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)-negative breast cancers and Oncotype DX scores of 26 or higher. METHODS: A discrete-time stochastic state transition simulation model synthesized data from population studies and clinical trials to estimate outcomes over a 25-year horizon for subgroups based on age (65-69, 70-74, 75-79, and 80-89 years) and comorbidity levels (no or low, moderate, severe). Outcomes were discounted at 3%, and included quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), life-years, and breast cancer and other-cause mortality with chemoendocrine vs endocrine therapy. Sensitivity analysis tested the effect of varying uncertain parameters. RESULTS: Women aged 65-69 years with no or low comorbidity gained 0.16 QALYs with chemo-endocrine and reduced breast cancer mortality from 34.8% to 29.7%, for an absolute difference of 5.1%; this benefit was associated with a 12.8% rate of grade 3-4 toxicity. Women aged 65-69 years with no or low or moderate comorbidity levels, and women aged 70-74 years with no or low comorbidity had small chemotherapy benefits. All women aged 75 years and older experienced net losses in QALYs with chemo-endocrine therapy. The results were robust in sensitivity analyses. Chemotherapy had greater benefits as treatment effectiveness increased, but toxicity reduced the QALYs gained. CONCLUSION: Among women aged 65-89 years whose tumors indicate a high recurrence risk, only those aged 65-74 years with no or low or moderate comorbidity have small benefits from adding chemotherapy to endocrine therapy. Genomic expression profile testing (and chemotherapy use) should be reserved for women aged younger than 75 years without severe comorbidity.
BACKGROUND: Tumor genomic expression profile data are used to guide chemotherapy choice, but there are gaps in evidence for women aged 65 years and older. We estimate chemotherapy effects by age and comorbidity level among women with early-stage, hormone receptor-positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)-negative breast cancers and Oncotype DX scores of 26 or higher. METHODS: A discrete-time stochastic state transition simulation model synthesized data from population studies and clinical trials to estimate outcomes over a 25-year horizon for subgroups based on age (65-69, 70-74, 75-79, and 80-89 years) and comorbidity levels (no or low, moderate, severe). Outcomes were discounted at 3%, and included quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), life-years, and breast cancer and other-cause mortality with chemoendocrine vs endocrine therapy. Sensitivity analysis tested the effect of varying uncertain parameters. RESULTS:Women aged 65-69 years with no or low comorbidity gained 0.16 QALYs with chemo-endocrine and reduced breast cancer mortality from 34.8% to 29.7%, for an absolute difference of 5.1%; this benefit was associated with a 12.8% rate of grade 3-4 toxicity. Women aged 65-69 years with no or low or moderate comorbidity levels, and women aged 70-74 years with no or low comorbidity had small chemotherapy benefits. All women aged 75 years and older experienced net losses in QALYs with chemo-endocrine therapy. The results were robust in sensitivity analyses. Chemotherapy had greater benefits as treatment effectiveness increased, but toxicity reduced the QALYs gained. CONCLUSION: Among women aged 65-89 years whose tumors indicate a high recurrence risk, only those aged 65-74 years with no or low or moderate comorbidity have small benefits from adding chemotherapy to endocrine therapy. Genomic expression profile testing (and chemotherapy use) should be reserved for women aged younger than 75 years without severe comorbidity.
Authors: Sylvia K Plevritis; Diego Munoz; Allison W Kurian; Natasha K Stout; Oguzhan Alagoz; Aimee M Near; Sandra J Lee; Jeroen J van den Broek; Xuelin Huang; Clyde B Schechter; Brian L Sprague; Juhee Song; Harry J de Koning; Amy Trentham-Dietz; Nicolien T van Ravesteyn; Ronald Gangnon; Young Chandler; Yisheng Li; Cong Xu; Mehmet Ali Ergun; Hui Huang; Donald A Berry; Jeanne S Mandelblatt Journal: JAMA Date: 2018-01-09 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Young Chandler; Clyde B Schechter; Jinani Jayasekera; Aimee Near; Suzanne C O'Neill; Claudine Isaacs; Charles E Phelps; G Thomas Ray; Tracy A Lieu; Scott Ramsey; Jeanne S Mandelblatt Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2018-01-08 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Iris Lansdorp-Vogelaar; Roman Gulati; Angela B Mariotto; Clyde B Schechter; Tiago M de Carvalho; Amy B Knudsen; Nicolien T van Ravesteyn; Eveline A M Heijnsdijk; Chester Pabiniak; Marjolein van Ballegooijen; Carolyn M Rutter; Karen M Kuntz; Eric J Feuer; Ruth Etzioni; Harry J de Koning; Ann G Zauber; Jeanne S Mandelblatt Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2014-07-15 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Rafael Caparica; Marco Bruzzone; Francesca Poggio; Marcello Ceppi; Evandro de Azambuja; Matteo Lambertini Journal: Breast Cancer Res Treat Date: 2018-11-21 Impact factor: 4.872
Authors: Jennifer L Patnaik; Tim Byers; Carolyn Diguiseppi; Thomas D Denberg; Dana Dabelea Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst Date: 2011-06-30 Impact factor: 13.506
Authors: Hyman B Muss; Donald A Berry; Constance T Cirrincione; Maria Theodoulou; Ann M Mauer; Alice B Kornblith; Ann H Partridge; Lynn G Dressler; Harvey J Cohen; Heather P Becker; Patricia A Kartcheske; Judith D Wheeler; Edith A Perez; Antonio C Wolff; Julie R Gralow; Harold J Burstein; Ahmad A Mahmood; Gustav Magrinat; Gutav Magrinat; Barbara A Parker; Ronald D Hart; Debjani Grenier; Larry Norton; Clifford A Hudis; Eric P Winer Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2009-05-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Valentina I Petkov; Dave P Miller; Nadia Howlader; Nathan Gliner; Will Howe; Nicola Schussler; Kathleen Cronin; Frederick L Baehner; Rosemary Cress; Dennis Deapen; Sally L Glaser; Brenda Y Hernandez; Charles F Lynch; Lloyd Mueller; Ann G Schwartz; Stephen M Schwartz; Antoinette Stroup; Carol Sweeney; Thomas C Tucker; Kevin C Ward; Charles Wiggins; Xiao-Cheng Wu; Lynne Penberthy; Steven Shak Journal: NPJ Breast Cancer Date: 2016-06-08
Authors: Ton Wang; Alison Baskin; Jacquelyn Miller; Allan Metz; Niki Matusko; Tasha Hughes; Michael Sabel; Jacqueline S Jeruss; Lesly A Dossett Journal: Ann Surg Oncol Date: 2020-07-10 Impact factor: 5.344
Authors: Amy Trentham-Dietz; Oguzhan Alagoz; Christina Chapman; Xuelin Huang; Jinani Jayasekera; Nicolien T van Ravesteyn; Sandra J Lee; Clyde B Schechter; Jennifer M Yeh; Sylvia K Plevritis; Jeanne S Mandelblatt Journal: PLoS Comput Biol Date: 2021-06-17 Impact factor: 4.475
Authors: Ton Wang; Nicole Mott; Jacquelyn Miller; Nicholas L Berlin; Sarah Hawley; Reshma Jagsi; Lesly A Dossett Journal: JAMA Netw Open Date: 2020-09-01