Asymmetric Baeyer-Villiger oxidation: classical and parallel kinetic resolution of 3-substituted cyclohexanones and desymmetrization of meso-disubstituted cycloketones.

Regioselectivity is a crucial issue in Baeyer-Villiger (BV) oxidation. To date, few reports have addressed asymmetric BV oxidation of 3-substituted cycloketones due to the high difficulty of controlling regio- and stereoselectivity. Herein, we report the asymmetric BV oxidation of 3-substituted and meso-disubstituted cycloketones with chiral N,N'-dioxide/Sc(iii) catalysts performed in three ways: classical kinetic resolution, parallel kinetic resolution and desymmetrization. The methodology was applied in the total and formal synthesis of bioactive compounds and natural products. Control experiments and calculations demonstrated that flexible and adjustable catalysts played a significant role in the chiral recognition of substrates. This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019.

Introduction

Asymmetric Baeyer–Villiger oxidation provides direct, efficient access to chiral lactones from cycloketones,1–3 including kinetic resolution of racemic cycloketones and desymmetrization of mesomeric cycloketones. Classical kinetic resolution (CKR) and parallel kinetic resolution (PKR) are two main sub-categories in kinetic resolution reactions. Impressive developments have been made in the CKR of highly ring-strained 2-substituted monocyclic ketones and bicyclic cyclobutanones via BV oxidation.4 PKR enabled the generation of two regioisomers of lactones. Several examples related to bicyclic cyclobutanones were realized, yet high ee values could not be obtained for both regioisomers simultaneously.5 Previously reported desymmetrization of cycloketones via BV oxidation mainly focused on 3-substituted cyclobutanones and 4-substituted cyclohexanones.6,7 Systematic studies on mesomeric disubstituted cycloketones are scarce; only 3,5-cis-dimethyl cyclohexanone was discussed in biocatalytic cases.7d,f To sum up, despite remarkable advancements in asymmetric BV oxidation, the scope of substrates is still limited. Meanwhile, to develop an efficient catalytic system that can promote all three above-mentioned types of Baeyer–Villiger oxidation reactions is also highly meaningful.4b,6b,7e

On the other hand, regioselectivity has long been a “camphor mystery” in BV oxidation.2c,8 In comparison with 2-substituted cyclic ketones, asymmetric BV oxidation of 3-substituted cyclic ketones (cyclopentanones and cyclohexanones) was less discussed owing to the high difficulty to control regio- and stereoselectivity.9 Several biocatalyst-promoted reactions have been reported with moderate stereoselectivity9 or regioselectivity.9a,b,d In 2014, Miller's group developed the asymmetric BV oxidation of 3-substituted cycloketones with a peptide-based organocatalyst, where hydrogen bonding between the catalyst and the functional groups of the substrates resulted in moderate to good regio- and stereoselectivities (Scheme 1a).9

Scheme 1

Asymmetric Baeyer–Villiger oxidation of 3-substituted cycloketones.

The induced-fit model of BV oxidation in biocatalysis provides such a sight of view for molecular catalysts that a conformationally flexible structure can streamline the adjustment of catalysts toward cycloketones with different configurations and conformations, leading to high regio- and stereo-selectivity.4d,4f,7c,10 The privileged chiral N,N′-dioxide, bearing a catenulate alkyl linker as well as two backbones and aniline groups bound to Lewis acids, is by nature a flexible structure,11 which forms an adjustable blocker for chiral recognition. Herein, we describe novel CKR, PKR and desymmetrization of 3-substituted cycloketones (non-functional group) with a single chiral N,N′-dioxide/Sc(iii) catalytic system (Scheme 1b).

Results and discussion

Our investigation began with the CKR of racemic 3-phenyl cyclohexanone (1a) by using m-chloro peroxobenzoic acid (m-CPBA, 0.5 equiv.) as an oxidant in the presence of 5 mol% L-PrPr/Sc(OTf)3 complex in EtOAc at 30 °C (Table 1, entry 1). The corresponding mixture of lactones 2a and 3a was obtained in moderate yield with poor regio- and stereoselectivity, while racemic 1a was recovered. Next, the backbones of the chiral N,N′-dioxide ligands were evaluated and found to have an important effect on the regio- and stereoselectivity (Fig. 1). L-RaPr derived from l-ramipril was superior to l-proline-derived L-PrPr and l-pipecolic acid derived L-PiPr (Table 1, entry 3 vs. 1–2). Both regio- and stereoselectivity of the reaction were improved by introducing a bulky group into the para-position of the phenyl group in the ligand (Table 1, entries 4 and 5). For instance, the ligand L-RaPr bearing tert-butyl groups, coordinated with Sc(OTf)3, catalyzed the reaction and gave a mixture of 2a and 3a in an 83 : 17 ratio with 81% ee of 2a (Table 1, entry 5). Upon lowering the temperature to 0 °C, the ratio of 2a to 3a could be improved to 85 : 15 and the ee value of 2a was increased to 85% in 12 h (Table 1, entry 6). However, upon further decreasing the temperature to –20 °C, no better result was achieved (Table 1, entry 7). To our delight, the regio- and stereoselectivity had a significant improvement with the addition of Al(Oi-Pr)34e,6f (2a : 3a = 91 : 9, 93% ee of 2a, and 81% ee of recovered 1a), albeit with prolonged reaction time (72 h) (Table 1, entry 8). It was found that when Al(Oi-Pr)3 and 3 Å MS were both used as additives, optimal reaction results could be obtained within 48 h (Table 1, entry 9, 48% yield of the mixture of 2a and 3a, 2a:3a = 92 : 8, 93% ee of 2a, 48% yield of 1a, and 82% ee of 1a).

Table 1

Condition optimization for the CKR of racemic 3-phenyl cyclohexanones

Entry a	Ligand	T (°C)	Additives	Yield b (%)			ee c (%)
				1a	2a + 3a	2a : 3a c	1a	2a	3a
1	L-PrPr2	30	—	61	33	50 : 50	1	9	5
2	L-PiPr2	30	—	49	50	51 : 49	2	23	17
3	L-RaPr2	30	—	47	43	75 : 25	13	69	84
4	L-RaPr3	30	—	49	51	82 : 18	42	77	72
5	L-RaPr2-tBu	30	—	48	48	83 : 17	54	81	78
6 d	L-RaPr2-tBu	0	—	53	44	85 : 15	62	85	68
7 e	L-RaPr2-tBu	–20	—	73	25	89 : 11	24	73	89
8 e f	L-RaPr2-tBu	–20	Al(Oi-Pr)3	49	50	91 : 9	81	93	96
9 g	L-RaPr2-tBu	–20	3 Å MS	48	48	92 : 8	82	93	91

Unless otherwise specified, the reaction was performed with Sc(OTf)3 (5 mol%), ligand (5 mol%), 1a (0.20 mmol) and m-CPBA (0.5 equiv.) in EtOAc (0.05 M) at 30 °C for 12 h under an air atmosphere.

Yields of the isolated products.

Determined by HPLC analysis using a chiral stationary phase.

At 0 °C.

At –20 °C for 72 h.

Al(Oi-Pr)3 (50 mol%) was added.

At –20 °C for 48 h, Al(Oi-Pr)3 (50 mol%) and 3 Å MS (50 mg) were added.

Fig. 1

Chiral N,N′-dioxide ligands used in this work.

The substrate scope of CKR was then explored. A range of racemic 3-aryl cyclohexanones were transformed into the corresponding lactones smoothly under the optimized reaction conditions. Regardless of the presence of electron donating or withdrawing groups on the 3-phenyl group, excellent yields and moderate to good regioselectivities with good ee values of 2a–2g were obtained (Table 2, entries 1–7, 45–49% yields, 85–93% ee of 2, and up to 95 : 5 rr). For the condensed-ring substrate 1h (Table 2, entry 8), the desired products were obtained in 50% yield and 87% ee of 2h with 95 : 5 rr. 3-Alkyl substituted cyclohexanones 1i (Bn) and 1j (Me) were also tolerated in this catalytic system, providing the corresponding lactones in 48% yield, 82% ee of 2i with 70 : 30 rr and 44% yield, and 90% ee of 2j with 74 : 26 rr, respectively (Table 2, entries 9 and 10). The ee values of the minor isomers 3i and 3j were excellent (97% ee and 95% ee). All the unreacted 3-aryl cyclohexanones 1 were recovered in excellent yields with moderate to good ee values.

Table 2

Substrate scope for the CKR of racemic 3-substituted cyclohexanones

Entry a	R	Yield b (%)			ee c (b)
		1	2 + 3	2 : 3 c	1	2	3
1	Ph (1a)	48	48	92 : 8	82	93	91
2	2-MeC6H4 (1b)	48	48	90 : 10	72	88	73
3	3-MeC6H4 (1c)	46	49	82 : 18	67	91	61
4	4-MeC6H4 (1d)	49	47	88 : 12	67	85	90
5	4-n-BuC6H4 (1e)	42	45	88 : 12	79	90	96
6	3-ClC6H4 (1f)	49	49	90 : 10	74	90	75
7	4-F3CC6H4 (1g)	43	45	95 : 5	88	91	73
8	2-Naphthyl (1h)	49	50	95 : 5	62	87	98
9	Bn (1i)	43	48	70 : 30	40	82	97
10	Me (1j)	43	44	74 : 26	55	90	95

Unless otherwise specified, the reaction was performed with Sc(OTf)3 (5 mol%), L-RaPr (5 mol%), 1a (0.20 mmol), m-CPBA (0.5 equiv.), Al(Oi-Pr)3 (50 mol%) and 3 Å MS (50 mg) in EtOAc (0.05 M) under an air atmosphere.

Yields of the isolated products.

Determined by HPLC or SFC analysis using a chiral stationary phase. For the absolute configuration of the products, see the ESI for more details.

Then, we turned our attention to the PKR of racemic 3-substituted cyclohexanones. After a slight modification of the reaction conditions (see Table S1 in the ESI for details†), by altering the ligand L-RaPr to L-RaEt as well as increasing the catalyst loading to 10 mol% and the reaction concentration to 0.10 M, 2a and 3a were obtained with 81% ee and 97% ee (Table 3, entry 1). The PKR of other 3-aryl substituted cyclohexanones proceeded well to give both lactone isomers with good to excellent enantioselectivities (Table 3, entries 2–7, 80–83% ee of 2 and 91–97% ee of 3). Substrate 1l bearing a n-butyl group was converted into the desired oxidation products in 84% mixed yield and 62 : 38 rr with 87% ee of 2l and 97% ee of 3l.

Table 3

Substrate scope for the PKR of racemic 3-substituted cyclohexanones

Entry a	R	Yield b (%)		ee c (%)
		2 + 3	2 : 3 c	2	3
1	Ph (1a)	98	55 : 45	81	97
2	2-MeC6H4 (1b)	94	56 : 44	80	93
3	3-MeC6H4 (1c)	97	53 : 47	82	91
4	4-MeC6H4 (1d)	97	55 : 45	80	96
5	4-n-BuC6H4 (1e)	98	55 : 45	83	95
6	4-MeOC6H4 (1k)	92	52 : 48	83	97
7	2-Naphthyl (1h)	94	55 : 45	81	96
8	n-Bu (1l)	84	62 : 38	87	97

Unless otherwise specified, the reaction was performed with Sc(OTf)3 (10 mol%), L-RaEt (10 mol%), 1 (0.10 mmol), m-CPBA (1.0 equiv.), Al(Oi-Pr)3 (50 mol%) and 3 Å MS (50 mg) in EtOAc (0.10 M) at –20 °C under an air atmosphere.

Yields of the isolated products.

Determined by HPLC or SFC analysis using a chiral stationary phase. For the absolute configuration of the products, see the ESI for more details.

Inspired by the CKR and PKR of 3-substituted cyclohexanones, we then focused on the desymmetrization of cis-3,5-diphenyl cyclohexanones. Upon further survey of the reaction parameters, the optimal conditions were found to be 4 (0.10 mmol), m-CPBA (0.10 mmol), L-RaPr/Sc(OTf)3 complex (1 : 1, 10 mol%) and 3 Å MS (50 mg) in EtOAc at 0 °C for 48 h (see Table S4 in the ESI for details†). The substituents on the phenyl group of the cyclohexanones were proven to have little effect on this reaction, and a series of desymmetrization products 5a–5g were obtained in excellent yields and enantioselectivities (Table 4, entries 1–7, 96–99% yields, and 93–97% ee). The absolute configuration of 5a was determined to be (4R,6R) by X-ray crystallographic analysis.12 Dimethyl substituted 4h could undergo transformation as well and gave the target lactone 5h in 99% yield with 91% ee (Table 4, entry 8). In addition, 3,4-di-phenyl cyclopentanone 4i was also tolerated in this desymmetrization reaction (Table 4, entry 9, 99% yield, 96% ee).

Table 4

Substrate scope for the desymmetrization of meso-disubstituted cycloketones

Entry a	R	Yield b (%)	ee c (%)
1	Ph (4a)	97	96
2	3-MeC6H4 (4b)	98	97
3	4-OMeC6H4 (4c)	96	93
4	4-FC6H4 (4d)	98	94
5	3-ClC6H4 (4e)	99	93
6	4-ClC6H4 (4f)	98	94
7	4-BrC6H4 (4g)	99	94
8	Me (4h)	99	91
9 d	Ph (4i)	99	96

Unless otherwise specified, the reaction was performed with Sc(OTf)3 (10 mol%), L-RaPr (10 mol%), 4 (0.10 mmol), m-CPBA (1.0 equiv.), and 4 Å MS (50 mg) in EtOAc (0.05 M) at –20 °C for 48 h under an air atmosphere.

Yields of the isolated products.

Determined by HPLC or SFC analysis using a chiral stationary phase. For the absolute configuration of the products, see the ESI for more details.

For 4i, n = 0; L-PiEt was used instead of L-RaPr at 0 °C for 24 h.

(S)-C4-benzyl suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA) exhibits high selectivity for histone deacetylases (HDAC) 6 and 8, which can regulate gene expression via deacetylation of nucleosomal histones. Recently, Pflum's group realized the synthesis of the (S)-C4-benzyl SAHA analog in 9 steps (6.3% overall yield) from (R)-4-benzyloxazolidin-2-one.13 In contrast, as shown in Scheme 2a, the (S)-C4-benzyl SAHA analog could be obtained in 31% overall yield with 94% ee in 6 steps from racemic 1i, involving the key step of asymmetric BV oxidation of 1i to a mixture of 2i and 3i. The Syn-1,3-dimethyl moiety served as a core chiral skeleton in various natural products,14 such as mycolipenic acid, mycolipanolic acid and (–)-rasfonin. Manipulating the desymmetrization product 5h with a two-step transformation, syn-1,3-dimethyl thioester 10 was obtained, which could be easily transformed into the aforementioned natural products (Scheme 2b, see the ESI for details†).

Scheme 2

The synthesis of the (S)-C4-benzyl SAHA analog and the derivatization of 5h. (1) m-CPBA (1.0 equiv.), L-RaPr/Sc(OTf)3 (1 : 1, 10 mol%), Al(Oi-Pr)3 (50 mol%), 3 Å MS (50 mg), EtOAc (0.05 M), –20 °C for 48 h. (2) PhNH2 (2.0 equiv.), AlMe3 (2.0 equiv.), THF, 0 °C to rt. (3) PCC (2.0 equiv.), celite, N2, DCM. (4) (OMe)2(O)PCH2COOMe (1.4 equiv.), NaH (1.5 equiv.), THF. (5) Pd/C, H2, MeOH. (6) H2NOH·HCl, KOH, MeOH, 0 °C. (7) EtSH, AlMe3, THF, 0 °C to rt. (8) TBDPSCl, NaH, EtOAc.

To elucidate the regioselectivity in both CKR and PKR, several control experiments were conducted. First, when Sc(OTf)3 was used to promote the CKR of 1a without a ligand, only 21% mixed yield of 2a and 3a with 50 : 50 rr was obtained (Scheme 3a). Furthermore, when the enantiopure substrate (S)-1a was tested under the standard conditions of CKR type of BV oxidation with the ligand ent-L-RaPr derived from D-ramipril, a mixture of 2a and 3a was obtained in quantitative yield. However, when L-RaPr was used, the reactivity was diminished and lower regioselectivity was obtained (Scheme 3b). These results suggest that (S)-1a matched with ent-L-RaPr and gave the major product (S)-2a; however, (S)-1a mismatched with L-RaPr and revealed poorer reactivity to give (R)-3a. A similar phenomenon was also observed in the PKR type of BV oxidation with L-RaEt and ent-L-RaEt as the ligands (Scheme 3c).

Scheme 3

Control experiments.

As discussed above, the migratory aptitude of 1a contributed little to the regioselectivity in the formation of lactones (Scheme 3a). We proposed that the stereoelectronic effect in the Criegee intermediate, a notion that the migrating group needs to be antiperiplanar to the leaving group in peroxide acids before the migration of the alkyl group in the Criegee intermediate, could be essential for the recognition of 1a (Fig. 2a).3d,e Since different aniline groups in L-RaPr12 and L-RaEt resulted in different steric hindrances between 1a and catalysts, the energy difference in the alkyl migration step in the formation of 2a and 3a with different configurations would result in the difference of regioselectivity. To provide further evidence for the above conjecture, ONIOM (M06/6-31G*: HF/STO-3G) calculations were performed (see the ESI for details†). Based on previous theoretical studies of BV oxidation with chiral N,N′-dioxide/Sc(iii) catalysts,15 the transition states in the alkyl group migration step in CKR and PKR were optimized and their Gibbs free energies were calculated (Fig. 2b, c). In L-RaPr-TS-(R)-2a and L-RaEt-TS-(R)-2a, 1a was placed away from the aniline groups, while in L-RaPr-TS-(R)-3a and L-RaEt-TS-(R)-3a, 1a was placed between the aniline group and the bicyclic ring backbone of the ligand. For L-RaPr with bulky iso-propyl and tert-butyl groups on the aniline group, the larger steric hindrance between the ligand and 1a resulted in a larger energy difference between L-RaPr-TS-(R)-3a and L-RaPr-TS-(R)-2a (Fig. 2b, ΔG = 4.2 kcal mol–1), and so the former is the favored transition state while the latter is the disfavored one. Meanwhile, owing to a less bulky aniline group and the flexible catalyst structure, the energy difference between L-RaEt-TS-(R)-3a and L-RaEt-TS-(R)-2a was significantly smaller (Fig. 2c, ΔG = 0.7 kcal mol–1), and both transition states are favored. Such a revelation is consistent with the control experiments in Scheme 3. The theoretical study shows that the adjustable aniline groups and flexible catalyst structure proved to be powerful for the regioselectivity and enantioselectivity in the BV oxidation of 1a with N,N′-dioxide/Sc(iii) catalysts through the recognition of the 3-position of the cyclohexanones in BV oxidation.

Fig. 2

Gibbs free energy diagram of the optimized transition states of (±)-1a and m-CPBA catalyzed by N,N′-dioxide/Sc(iii) complexes.

Conclusions

We realized the catalytic asymmetric CKR and PKR of 3-substituted cyclohexanones and desymmetrization of meso-disubstituted cycloketones through BV oxidation with a single catalytic system. The pending problem of regio- and stereoselectivity in BV oxidation was solved by the modulation of the structure of chiral N,N′-dioxide/Sc(iii) complexes. The experimental studies and theoretical calculations showed that flexible and adjustable catalysts can influence the migratory aptitude of the substrate via stereoelectronic control and chiral recognition. Besides, this methodology has been proven to be efficient in synthesizing useful bioactive compounds and natural products.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Click here for additional data file.

Click here for additional data file.