Eric Vallabh Minikel1,2,3, Eric Kuhn4, Alexandra R Cocco4, Sonia M Vallabh5,2,3, Christina R Hartigan4, Andrew G Reidenbach5, Jiri G Safar6, Gregory J Raymond7, Michael D McCarthy8, Rhonda O'Keefe8, Franc Llorens9,10, Inga Zerr9, Sabina Capellari11,12, Piero Parchi11,13, Stuart L Schreiber5,14, Steven A Carr15. 1. Chemical Biology and Therapeutics Science Program, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02142 minikel@broadinstitute.org. 2. Program in Biological and Biomedical Sciences, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115. 3. Prion Alliance, Cambridge, MA 02139. 4. Proteomics Platform, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02142. 5. Chemical Biology and Therapeutics Science Program, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02142. 6. Departments of Pathology and Neurology Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106. 7. Laboratory of Persistent Viral Diseases, NIAID Rocky Mountain Labs, Hamilton, MT 59840. 8. Environmental Health and Safety, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02142. 9. National Reference Center for TSE, Georg-August University, Göttingen, 37073, Germany. 10. Biomedical Research Networking Center on Neurodegenerative Diseases (CIBERNED), L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, 08908, Barcelona, Spain. 11. IRCCS Istituto delle Scienze Neurologiche di Bologna, Bologna, 40139, Italy. 12. Department of Biomedical and Neuromotor Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, 40123, Italy. 13. Department of Experimental, Diagnostic and Specialty Medicine, University of Bologna, Bologna, 40138, Italy. 14. Department of Chemistry & Chemical Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138. 15. Proteomics Platform, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02142 scarr@broad.mit.edu.
Abstract
Therapies currently in preclinical development for prion disease seek to lower prion protein (PrP) expression in the brain. Trials of such therapies are likely to rely on quantification of PrP in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) as a pharmacodynamic biomarker and possibly as a trial endpoint. Studies using PrP ELISA kits have shown that CSF PrP is lowered in the symptomatic phase of disease, a potential confounder for reading out the effect of PrP-lowering drugs in symptomatic patients. Because misfolding or proteolytic cleavage could potentially render PrP invisible to ELISA even if its concentration were constant or increasing in disease, we sought to establish an orthogonal method for CSF PrP quantification. We developed a multi-species targeted mass spectrometry method based on multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) of nine PrP tryptic peptides quantified relative to an isotopically labeled recombinant protein standard for human samples, or isotopically labeled synthetic peptides for nonhuman species. Analytical validation experiments showed process replicate coefficients of variation below 15%, good dilution linearity and recovery, and suitable performance for both CSF and brain homogenate and across humans as well as preclinical species of interest. In n = 55 CSF samples from individuals referred to prion surveillance centers with rapidly progressive dementia, all six human PrP peptides, spanning the N- and C-terminal domains of PrP, were uniformly reduced in prion disease cases compared with individuals with nonprion diagnoses. Thus, lowered CSF PrP concentration in prion disease is a genuine result of the disease process and not an artifact of ELISA-based measurement. As a result, dose-finding studies for PrP lowering drugs may need to be conducted in presymptomatic at-risk individuals rather than in symptomatic patients. We provide a targeted mass spectrometry-based method suitable for preclinical quantification of CSF PrP as a tool for drug development.
Therapies currently in preclinical development for prion disease seek to lower n class="Species">prion protein (PrP) expression in the brain. Trials of such therapies are likely to rely on quantification of PrP in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) as a pharmacodynamic biomarker and possibly as a trial endpoint. Studies using PrP ELISA kits have shown that CSF PrP is lowered in the symptomatic phase of disease, a potential confounder for reading out the effect of PrP-lowering drugs in symptomatic patients. Because misfolding or proteolytic cleavage could potentially render PrP invisible to ELISA even if its concentration were constant or increasing in disease, we sought to establish an orthogonal method for CSF PrP quantification. We developed a multi-species targeted mass spectrometry method based on multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) of nine PrP tryptic peptides quantified relative to an isotopically labeled recombinant protein standard for human samples, or isotopically labeled synthetic peptides for nonhuman species. Analytical validation experiments showed process replicate coefficients of variation below 15%, good dilution linearity and recovery, and suitable performance for both CSF and brain homogenate and across humans as well as preclinical species of interest. In n = 55 CSF samples from individuals referred to prion surveillance centers with rapidly progressive dementia, all six humanPrPpeptides, spanning the N- and C-terminal domains of PrP, were uniformly reduced in prion disease cases compared with individuals with nonprion diagnoses. Thus, lowered CSF PrP concentration in prion disease is a genuine result of the disease process and not an artifact of ELISA-based measurement. As a result, dose-finding studies for PrP lowering drugs may need to be conducted in presymptomatic at-risk individuals rather than in symptomatic patients. We provide a targeted mass spectrometry-based method suitable for preclinical quantification of CSF PrP as a tool for drug development.
Authors: Sonia M Vallabh; Chloe K Nobuhara; Franc Llorens; Inga Zerr; Piero Parchi; Sabina Capellari; Eric Kuhn; Jacob Klickstein; Jiri G Safar; Flavia C Nery; Kathryn J Swoboda; Michael D Geschwind; Henrik Zetterberg; Steven E Arnold; Eric Vallabh Minikel; Stuart L Schreiber Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2019-04-01 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Daniel Broudy; Trevor Killeen; Meena Choi; Nicholas Shulman; Deepak R Mani; Susan E Abbatiello; Deepak Mani; Rushdy Ahmad; Alexandria K Sahu; Birgit Schilling; Kaipo Tamura; Yuval Boss; Vagisha Sharma; Bradford W Gibson; Steven A Carr; Olga Vitek; Michael J MacCoss; Brendan MacLean Journal: Bioinformatics Date: 2014-05-09 Impact factor: 6.937
Authors: Andrew N Hoofnagle; Jeffrey R Whiteaker; Steven A Carr; Eric Kuhn; Tao Liu; Sam A Massoni; Stefani N Thomas; R Reid Townsend; Lisa J Zimmerman; Emily Boja; Jing Chen; Daniel L Crimmins; Sherri R Davies; Yuqian Gao; Tara R Hiltke; Karen A Ketchum; Christopher R Kinsinger; Mehdi Mesri; Matthew R Meyer; Wei-Jun Qian; Regine M Schoenherr; Mitchell G Scott; Tujin Shi; Gordon R Whiteley; John A Wrobel; Chaochao Wu; Brad L Ackermann; Ruedi Aebersold; David R Barnidge; David M Bunk; Nigel Clarke; Jordan B Fishman; Russ P Grant; Ulrike Kusebauch; Mark M Kushnir; Mark S Lowenthal; Robert L Moritz; Hendrik Neubert; Scott D Patterson; Alan L Rockwood; John Rogers; Ravinder J Singh; Jennifer E Van Eyk; Steven H Wong; Shucha Zhang; Daniel W Chan; Xian Chen; Matthew J Ellis; Daniel C Liebler; Karin D Rodland; Henry Rodriguez; Richard D Smith; Zhen Zhang; Hui Zhang; Amanda G Paulovich Journal: Clin Chem Date: 2016-01 Impact factor: 8.327
Authors: Jason M Wilham; Christina D Orrú; Richard A Bessen; Ryuichiro Atarashi; Kazunori Sano; Brent Race; Kimberly D Meade-White; Lara M Taubner; Andrew Timmes; Byron Caughey Journal: PLoS Pathog Date: 2010-12-02 Impact factor: 6.823
Authors: Hermann C Altmeppen; Johannes Prox; Berta Puig; Mark A Kluth; Christian Bernreuther; Dana Thurm; Ellen Jorissen; Bettina Petrowitz; Udo Bartsch; Bart De Strooper; Paul Saftig; Markus Glatzel Journal: Mol Neurodegener Date: 2011-05-27 Impact factor: 14.195
Authors: Andrew G Reidenbach; Michael F Mesleh; Dominick Casalena; Sonia M Vallabh; Jayme L Dahlin; Alison J Leed; Alix I Chan; Dmitry L Usanov; Jenna B Yehl; Christopher T Lemke; Arthur J Campbell; Rishi N Shah; Om K Shrestha; Joshua R Sacher; Victor L Rangel; Jamie A Moroco; Murugappan Sathappa; Maria Cristina Nonato; Kong T Nguyen; S Kirk Wright; David R Liu; Florence F Wagner; Virendar K Kaushik; Douglas S Auld; Stuart L Schreiber; Eric Vallabh Minikel Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2020-07-28 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Peter Hermann; Brian Appleby; Jean-Philippe Brandel; Byron Caughey; Steven Collins; Michael D Geschwind; Alison Green; Stephane Haïk; Gabor G Kovacs; Anna Ladogana; Franc Llorens; Simon Mead; Noriyuki Nishida; Suvankar Pal; Piero Parchi; Maurizio Pocchiari; Katsuya Satoh; Gianluigi Zanusso; Inga Zerr Journal: Lancet Neurol Date: 2021-03 Impact factor: 44.182
Authors: Sonia M Vallabh; Eric Vallabh Minikel; Victoria J Williams; Becky C Carlyle; Alison J McManus; Chase D Wennick; Anna Bolling; Bianca A Trombetta; David Urick; Chloe K Nobuhara; Jessica Gerber; Holly Duddy; Ingolf Lachmann; Christiane Stehmann; Steven J Collins; Kaj Blennow; Henrik Zetterberg; Steven E Arnold Journal: BMC Med Date: 2020-06-18 Impact factor: 8.775
Authors: Meredith A Mortberg; Hien T Zhao; Andrew G Reidenbach; Juliana E Gentile; Eric Kuhn; Jill O'Moore; Patrick M Dooley; Theresa R Connors; Curt Mazur; Shona W Allen; Bianca A Trombetta; Alison McManus; Matthew R Moore; Jiewu Liu; Deborah E Cabin; Holly B Kordasiewicz; Joel Mathews; Steven E Arnold; Sonia M Vallabh; Eric Vallabh Minikel Journal: JCI Insight Date: 2022-03-22
Authors: Andrew G Reidenbach; Eric Vallabh Minikel; Hien T Zhao; Stacy G Guzman; Alison J Leed; Michael F Mesleh; Holly B Kordasiewicz; Stuart L Schreiber; Sonia M Vallabh Journal: Biomolecules Date: 2019-12-18
Authors: Lucas M Ascari; Stephanie C Rocha; Priscila B Gonçalves; Tuane C R G Vieira; Yraima Cordeiro Journal: Front Bioeng Biotechnol Date: 2020-10-20
Authors: Eric Vallabh Minikel; Hien T Zhao; Jason Le; Jill O'Moore; Rose Pitstick; Samantha Graffam; George A Carlson; Michael P Kavanaugh; Jasna Kriz; Jae Beom Kim; Jiyan Ma; Holger Wille; Judd Aiken; Deborah McKenzie; Katsumi Doh-Ura; Matthew Beck; Rhonda O'Keefe; Jacquelyn Stathopoulos; Tyler Caron; Stuart L Schreiber; Jeffrey B Carroll; Holly B Kordasiewicz; Deborah E Cabin; Sonia M Vallabh Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2020-11-04 Impact factor: 16.971