| Literature DB >> 31551631 |
Selma Gicevic1, Emir Kremic2, Teresa T Fung3, Bernard Rosner4, Edin Sabanovic5, Walter C Willett1.
Abstract
National dietary surveillance systems are necessary for monitoring people's intake of foods and nutrients associated with health and disease, and for implementing national and global dietary goals. However, these systems do not exist in many low- and middle-income countries. The development of a model of dietary surveillance for Bosnia and Herzegovina, described here, provides insights into the feasibility and sustainability of dietary surveillance systems in resource-constrained settings and illustrates the challenges involved. In 2016, a year-long dietary survey was initiated in collaboration with the country's Institute for Statistics using a subsample of households that participated in the 2015 national Household Budget Survey. Interviewers collected lifestyle, anthropometric and health data and participants answered two 24-hour dietary recall questionnaires. The survey included a representative sample of 853 participants and was performed efficiently by a small team of highly motivated, well-trained staff. Conducting a high-quality dietary survey was found to be feasible despite constrained resources. In addition, the ability to link dietary intake and regular household survey data provided an effective way of associating dietary variables with socioeconomic determinants of health. This dietary survey, the first conducted by an official institution in Bosnia and Herzegovina, represents an important starting point for building a sustainable nutritional surveillance system for the country. The cost-effective, low-burden approach to dietary surveillance described here could be applied in other low- and middle-income countries, many of which already carry out regular economic surveys.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31551631 PMCID: PMC6747026 DOI: 10.2471/BLT.18.227108
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Bull World Health Organ ISSN: 0042-9686 Impact factor: 9.408
Considerations in the development of dietary surveillance, Bosnia and Herzegovina, 2016–2017
| Component | Initial challenge | Strategy | Resources | Future challenges |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Institutional base | No existing institutional base for survey data | (i) The Institute for Statistics,a a government body independent of policy-makers,b was selected as the institutional base; (ii) the government of Bosnia and Herzegovina approved the pilot survey as part of the Institute’s 2017 annual plan | (i) The Institute for Statistics provided access to detailed data in the master sampling frame used in previous surveys and to infrastructure and local connections (e.g. regional offices, telephones, printing and links to police, municipal authorities and local media); (ii) one local staff member provided by an academic partner trained to become a local contact for future dietary surveys; (iii) an academic partner provided financial resources to cover interviewer fees; (iv) clear protocols and operational procedures were developed for the survey | The government should include a dietary survey in routine data collection (e.g. four-yearly) |
| Sample | Large sample size needed for traditional dietary surveys | (i) Adopt a multiple-stage, cluster sampling approach; (ii) use the minimum sample size required for monitoring dietary intake in the population; (iii) use the minimum sample to achieve a precision of 5 to 10% for the sample means of each nutrient; (iv) employ existing local expertise, when possible | (i) Sampling frame for latest Household Budget Survey in 2015 used; (ii) sample design performed by the Household Budget Survey statistician | Strategies needed to reach young male participants |
| Staff | Large number of technical staff needed for traditional dietary surveys | Employ a small but efficient team, comprising: (i) a statistician; (ii) a supervisor; (iii) a nutritionist and dietitian; (iv) a communications officer; (v) an administrative and data clerk; and (vi) a technical support assistant | (i) Statisticianc (3 days; 0.02 FTEd) for sample design and calculating sampling weights; (ii) supervisor (0.28 FTEd) for survey design (20 days), team-leading (24 days), fieldwork oversight (12 days) and interviewer training (14 days); (iii) nutritionist and dietitian (0.36 FTEd) for assigning quantities and food codes in Diet Assess (15 minutes per 24-hour recall interview), | (i) The supervisor’s and nutritionist’s job profiles should be kept at the Institute for Statistics to achieve sustainability; (ii) alternatively, descriptive nutrient-based analyses of dietary data could be performed for the Institute for Statistics by the Diet Assess developers (as part of the service provided to all purchasers of Diet Assess software) |
| Interviewers | (i) Large number of interviewers needed; (ii) poor retention | (i) Focus on quality rather than quantity when selecting interviewers; (ii) interviewer profile: high level of motivation, computer literate, vehicle owner, resident in sample household cluster, assertive and determined personality, ability to understand the need for high data quality, and culturally sensitive and responsive to a participant’s adverse circumstances, while keeping a professional distance | (i) Four interviewers needed (230 participants each; 0.79 FTEd in total); (ii) 2–3 reserve interviewers; (iii) individuals affiliated with the Institute for Statistics (either employees or members of an interviewer pool hired externally for field surveys) were preferred; (iv) our four interviewers were highly educated, computer literate, female and aged 30–40 years; (v) three male interviewers and one female opted out for different reasons (e.g. complex methodology, poor computer skills and a lack of assertiveness) | (i) Consider employing interviewers on a full-time basis in the Institute for Statistics and train them for multiple surveys; (ii) the interviewer’s gender may be important for some survey locations |
| Travel cost | High travel costs for fieldwork | (i) Select interviewers who reside within sample household clusters; (ii) ensure cluster is within a 90-minute drive for each interviewer; (iii) select one male and one female from each household whenever possible to minimize travel costs | None | It may be difficult to find interviewers with the desired characteristics for some clusters |
| Collection | Slow, paper-based data collection and compilation system | Use CAPI–CATI approach for data collection, with the option to collect data offline in areas without an internet connection | (i) CAPI–CATI software: our pilot study used Qualtrics software with an offline survey application for Android mobile phones; | (i) Find a reliable offline survey application – data were occasionally lost during transfer with the application used in our pilot survey; (ii) find a simple way of automatically coding 24-hour recall questionnaire responses |
| Storage | Data stored in separate databases | (i) Integrate data from the 2015 Household Budget Survey with dietary survey data; (ii) use a subsample of respondent households from the Household Budget Survey for our dietary survey to enable data integration and analysis, such that diet can be linked to socioeconomic indicators and an individual’s dietary intake can be compared with household food consumption; (iii) this approach could reduce interviewer transport costs | None | (i) Update the sampling frame used for household budget surveys, which has become outdated due to political constraints; (ii) ensure a good response rate in urban areas; (iii) avoid overuse of the sampling frame, which may result in a high respondent burden and a high nonresponse rate; (iv) consider incentives for survey participatione |
| Analysis | (i) Complex nutrient-based analysis required; (ii) lack of a local food composition database | (i) Procure software for nutrition assessment linked to the local Balkan food composition database; (ii) train local staff to use the software | (i) Diet-assessment software and a food composition database – our dietary study used Diet Assess and the Balkan food composition database; | None |
CAPI: computer-assisted personal interviewing; CATI: computer-assisted telephone interviewing; FTE: full-time equivalent, SAS: statistical analysis system USA: United States of America.
a The Institute for Statistics of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina is one of three official statistics agencies in the country.
b The Cape Town Global Action Plan for Sustainable Development Data, launched informally at the First United Nations World Data Forum in 2017, emphasized the modernization and strengthening of national statistical offices, including expanding their domains beyond data traditionally collected, so they could act as coordinators and strategic leaders for tracking progress on Sustainable Development Goals.
c Existing skilled personnel available at national statistics agencies.
d The full-time equivalent (FTE) is the number of full-time equivalent jobs, which is derived from the total number of hours worked by the worker, divided by the average number of hours worked annually in a full-time job.
e Survey participants could be encouraged to participate in repeat surveys by receiving grocery vouchers, which could be provided free by a major supermarket chain as part of its social responsibility agenda.
Dietary survey participants’ characteristics compared with the general adult population, Bosnia and Herzegovina, 2013 and 2017
| Characteristic | Adult populationa no. (%) | Dietary survey participants,b no. (%) | Difference,% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Female | 1 463 441 (51) | 482 (57) | +6 |
| 18–40 | 1 127 597 (40) | 241 (28) | −12 |
| 41–60 | 1 033 600 (36) | 384 (45) | +9 |
| ≥ 60 | 680 597 (24) | 228 (27) | +3 |
| North and central | 2 245 017 (79) | 586 (69) | −10 |
| South | 596 777 (21) | 266 (31) | +10 |
| Urband | 1 221 971 (43) | 373 (44) | +1 |
| Total | 2 987 440e (100) | 853 (100) | NA |
| Below high school | 1 060 840 (36)f | 266 (31) | −5 |
| High school diploma | 1 525 161 (51)f | 483 (57) | +6 |
| Some further education, including a degree | 401 439 (13)f | 104 (12) | −1 |
NA: not applicable.
a The 2013 census in Bosnia and Herzegovina recorded a total population of 3 531 159. The adult population aged 18 years and over had to be estimated because the census used the age categories 15 to 19 years and 20 to 24 years.
b The dietary survey conducted in 2017 involved adults aged 18 years or older, excluding pregnant and breastfeeding women and elderly people with cognitive decline.
c These figures were based on the number of inhabitants residing in municipalities categorized as Bosnian (i.e. north and central) or Herzegovinian (i.e. south), a distinction not used in official statistics.
d Urban settlements were those awarded a city status.
e The total population aged 15 years and older.
f Percentage of the population aged 15 years and older.