| Literature DB >> 31496146 |
Aditya Srinivasan1, Run Wang2.
Abstract
Benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), a common cause of lower urinary tract symptoms in the elderly male population, has conventionally treated by transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP). During recent years, newer minimally invasive therapies (MITs) have entered the playing field and challenged TURP with their convenience, lack of sexual side effects, and overall safety. The present paper provides an update on the more heavily studied and most recent MITs, analyzing their mechanism of action, tolerability, and efficacy in clinical practice. Particularly, robust clinical data have propelled UroLift and Rezuum to the forefront in the armamentarium of minimally invasive BPH treatment. Newer mechanical therapies such as the temporary implantable nitinol device, ClearRing, ZenFlow Spring, and Butterfly are appealing options as they forego cutting, ablation, heating, or removing prostatic tissue. It is obvious that there is wide variation in the degree of clinical readiness of each modality and only time and long-term, multicenter studies will decide which of these therapies are accepted by the patient and urologist.Entities:
Keywords: Benign prostatic hyperplasia; Prostate; Surgery; Urination
Year: 2019 PMID: 31496146 PMCID: PMC7502324 DOI: 10.5534/wjmh.190076
Source DB: PubMed Journal: World J Mens Health ISSN: 2287-4208 Impact factor: 5.400
Inclusion and exclusion criteria for the UroLift technique
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| • Age>50 y | • Obstructive median lobe |
| • Prostate volume 20–70 mL (on ultrasound) | • Active urinary tract infection |
| • IPSS>12 | • PSA>10 ng/mL (unless negative biopsy) |
| • Qmax<15 mL/s | • Prostatitis within past 1 year |
| • PVR<350 mL | • History of urinary retention |
| • Previous BPH surgery |
IPSS: international prostate symptom score, Qmax: maximum urinary flow rate, PVR: postvoid residual, PSA: prostate specific antigen, BPH: benign prostatic hyperplasia.
Adopted from Jones et al (Ther Adv Urol 2016;8:372–6) [8].
Inclusion and exclusion criteria for temporary implantable nitinol device
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| • Age>50 y | • Previous prostate surgery |
| • IPSS≥10 | • Prostate cancer |
| • Qmax≤12 mL/s | • Urethral stricture |
| • Prostate volume assessed by TRUS of <60 mL | • Bladder stones |
| • Obstructing median lobe |
IPSS: international prostate symptom score, Qmax: maximum urinary flow rate, TRUS: transrectal ultrasonography.
Fig. 1ClearRing (with permission from ProArc Medical).
Fig. 2ZenFlow Spring (with permission from ZenFlow).
Fig. 3Butterfly device (with permission from Butterfly Medical).
Inclusion and exclusion criteria for prostatic artery embolization
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| • Age>40 y | • Malignancy |
| • Prostate volume≥30 mL | • Bladder anomalies |
| • IPSS≥18 and/or QoL≥3 | • Chronic renal failure |
| • Acute urinary retention | • Acute urinary infection |
| • BPH refractory to medical therapy | • Renal insufficiency (eGFR<60 mL/min) |
| • Qmax≤15 mL/s at micturition volume of minimum 150 mL | • Advanced atherosclerosis of the iliac or prostatic arteries |
| • Urethral strictures |
IPSS: international prostate symptom score, QoL: quality of life, BPH: benign prostatic hyperplasia, Qmax: maximum urinary flow rate, eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria for Rezum
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| • Age≥45 y with symptomatic BPH | • PVR>300 mL |
| • Prostate volume<120 mL | • PSA>2.5 ng/mL |
| • IPSS≥13 | • Recurrent or active UTI |
| • PVR<250 mL | • Prior prostate intervention/surgery |
| • 5≤Qmax≤15 mL/s |
BPH: benign prostatic hyperplasia, IPSS: international prostate symptom score, PVR: postvoid residual, Qmax: maximum urinary flow rate, PSA: prostate specific antigen, UTI: urinary tract infection.
Adopted from Westwood et al (Ther Adv Urol 2018;10:327–33) [37].
Inclusion and exclusion criteria for Aquablation
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| Age≥50 y | Active UTI |
| IPSS>12 | Large prostate size>100 mL |
| LUTS refractory to medical therapy | PVR>400 mL |
| Qmax≤12 mL/s | Abnormal renal function |
| Prostate size 25–80 mL |
IPSS: international prostate symptom score, LUTS: lower urinary tract symptoms, Qmax: maximum urinary flow rate, UTI: urinary tract infection, PVR: postvoid residual.
Adopted from Taktak et al (Ther Adv Urol 2018;10:183–8) [43].
Types of MIST and factors specific to each type
| Type of MIST | Mechanism of action | Prostate size | Anesthetic | Relative contraindication | Major advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UroLift | Transprostatic perma- nent implant widens prostatic urethra | <100 mL | Local anesthesia and sedation | Previous prostate surgery, obstructive median lobe, renal insufficiency | No known cases of sexual dysfunction; can be done in clinic |
| Intraprostatic stents | Endoscopic stents open up the bladder outlet | <100 mL | Local or regional anesthesia | Penile or artificial urinary sphincters; acute UTI | Can be placed fairly quickly |
| TIND | Local ischemic necrosis remodels bladder neck and prostatic urethra | <60 mL | Local anesthesia | Previous prostate surgery, prostate cancer, urethral stricture, obstructing median lobe | Placed quickly and in the outpatient setting, no sexual side effects |
| BoNT-A intraprostatic inejctions | AcH inhibition decreases growth of prostatic tissue | N/A | Local anesthesia and sedation | Urethral stricture, neurogenic bladder | Short-term symptomatic relief in patients who cannot undergo invasive procedures |
| PAE | Injection of microspheres impede prostatic arteries | >30 mL | Local anesthesia and sedation | Prostate malignancy, urethral strictures, coagulation disorders, chronic renal failure | Useful in patients who cannot undergo more invasive procedures |
| Aquablation | High pressure saline dissects prostatic tissue | 25–80 mL | General anesthesia | Urinary retention, large prostate size (>100 mL) | Can be performed in under 10 minutes; preservation of urinary and ejaculatory function |
| Rezum | Thermal energy generated by water vapor causes prostatic cell necrosis | <120 mL | Local anesthesia and sedation | PSA>2.5 ng/mL, active UTI, urinary retention, prior prostate surgery | Day procedure; no effects on sexual function |
MIST: minimally invasive surgical therapies, TIND: temporary implantable nitinol device, BoNT-A: botulinum neurotoxin-A, PAE: prostatic artery embolization, N/A: not available, UTI: urinary tract infection, PSA: prostate specific antigen.