| Literature DB >> 31489933 |
Mia J Biondi1,2,3, Marjolein van Tilborg4,5, David Smookler6,7, Gregory Heymann8, Analiza Aquino9, Stephen Perusini10, Erin Mandel11,12, Robert A Kozak13, Vera Cherepanov14, Matthew Kowgier15, Bettina Hansen16,17, Lee W Goneau18, Harry L A Janssen19,20, Tony Mazzulli21,22, Gavin Cloherty23, Robert J de Knegt24, Jordan J Feld25,26,27.
Abstract
In order to expand hepatitis C virus (HCV) screening, a change in the diagnostic paradigm is warranted to improve accessibility and decrease costs, such as utilizing dried blood spot (DBS) collection. In our study, blood from 68 patients with chronic HCV infection was spotted onto DBS cards and stored at the following temperatures for one week: -80 °C, 4 °C, 21 °C, 37 °C, and alternating 37 °C and 4 °C; to assess whether temperature change during transportation would affect sensitivity. Sample was eluted from the DBS cards and tested for HCV antibodies (HCV-Ab) and HCV core antigen (core-Ag). HCV-Abs were detected from 68/68 DBS samples at -80 °C, 4 °C, 21 °C, and 67/68 at 37 °C and alternating 37 °C and 4 °C. Sensitivity of core-Ag was as follows: 94% (-80 °C), 94% (4 °C), 91% (21 °C), 93% (37 °C), and 93% (37 °C/4 °C). Not only did temperature not greatly affect sensitivity, but sensitivities are higher than previously reported, and support the use of this assay as an alternative to HCV RNA. We then completed a head-to-head comparison (n = 49) of venous versus capillary samples, and one versus two DBS. No difference in core-Ag sensitivity was observed by sample type, but there was an improvement when using two spots. We conclude that HCV-Abs and core-Ag testing from DBS cards has high diagnostic accuracy and could be considered as an alternative to HCV RNA in certain settings.Entities:
Keywords: Chronic hepatitis C; core-antigen; diagnosis; dried blood spot; widespread screening
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31489933 PMCID: PMC6784259 DOI: 10.3390/v11090830
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Viruses ISSN: 1999-4915 Impact factor: 5.048
Sensitivity and specificity of hepatitis C Virus (HCV) antibody and antigen on dried blood spots (DBS) by storage condition.
| Storage Condition | HCV Antibody | HCV Core Antigen | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sensitivity (95% CI) | Sensitivity >3 fmol/L (95% CI) | Sensitivity >10 fmol/L (95% CI) | |
|
| 100% (100–100) (68/68) | 94.1% (88.5–99.7) (64/68) | 85.3% (76.4–94.2) (58/68) |
|
| 100% (100–100) (68/68) | 94.1% (88.5–99.7) (64/68) | 85.3% (76.4–94.2) (58/68) |
|
| 100% (100–100) (68/68) | 91.2% (84.3–98.1) (62/68) | 80.9% (70.8–91.0) (55/68) |
|
| 98.6% (96.6–100) (67/68) | 92.7% (86.4–98.9) (63/68) | 80.9% (70.8–91.0) (55/68) |
|
| 98.6% (96.6–100) (67/68) | 92.7% (86.4–98.9) (63/68) | 85.3% (76.4–94.2) (58/68) |
Figure 1Distribution of core-Ag concentration by dried blood spots (DBS) storage condition as compared to serum. Bars represent mean and standard deviation. Environmental conditions with an astrix (*) have a mean statistically significant difference from −80 °C (p < 0.05).
Figure 2Correlation between core-antigen (Ag) titre from dried blood spots (DBS) and serum per condition. Pearson correlation: (A) Samples stored at −80 °C. Samples excluded if core-Ag concentration was less than 3 fmol/L stored at (B) −80 °C, (C) 4 °C, (D) 21 °C, (E) 37 °C, (F) 37 °C/4 °C.
Figure 3Correlation between core-antigen (Ag) titre from dried blood spots (DBS) from venous and capillary samples and one vs. two spots. Pearson correlation: (A) Core-Ag measurement from one DBS from venous whole blood to one DBS from capillary whole blood finger-prick, (B) Core-Ag measurement from two DBS from venous whole blood to two DBS from capillary whole blood finger-prick, (C) Core-Ag measurement from two DBS from capillary whole blood finger-prick as compared to RNA viral load measurement in serum.
Summary of sensitivity and specificity of hepatitis C virus (HCV) diagnostic options.
| Test | Biondi et al. | Mohamed et al. [ | Lamoury et al. [ | Soulier et al. [ | WHO Meta-Analysis [ | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sensitivity † | Specificity | Sensitivity † | Specificity † | Sensitivity † | Specificity † | Sensitivity † | Specificity † | Sensitivity † | Specificity † | |
| HCV-Ab | 98.0% | 100% | ||||||||
| HCV RNA | 100% | 99.9% | ||||||||
| HCV-Ab DBS | 100% | 99.1% | 98.2% | 98.0% | 99.0% | |||||
| HCV RNA DBS ‡ | 98.1% | 100% | 96.0% | 97.7% | ||||||
| Core-Ag DBS | 94.1% | 15/15 | 76.7% | 97.3% | 82.9% | 96.1% | 64.1% | 100% | ||
| HCV-Core-Ag DBS | 91.2% | 5/5 | 64.1% | 100% | ||||||
† 95% CI. ‡ Combined analysis of venous and capillary blood.
Figure 4Potential diagnostic algorithms for hepatitis C virus (HCV) testing. (A) HCV antibody testing from DBS with subsequent RNA testing, (B) HCV antibody testing from dried blood spots (DBS) with subsequent core-Ag testing. If core-antigen (Ag) negative, subsequent RNA testing, (C) HCV antibody testing from DBS with subsequent core-Ag testing, (D) HCV core-Ag testing from DBS card. † Retest as clinically indicated if suspected seroconversion or ongoing exposure. ‡ Testing ends as a result of positive HCV core antigen. Ab = antibody, Core = core antigen, GT = genotype.