Qi Zhang1, Yuan-Xin Deng1, Hong-Xi Luo2, Chen-Yu Shi1, Geoffrey M Geise2, Ben L Feringa1,3, He Tian1, Da-Hui Qu1. 1. Key Laboratory for Advanced Materials and Joint International Research Laboratory of Precision Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Feringa Nobel Prize Scientist Joint Research Center, School of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering , East China University of Science and Technology , 130 Meilong Road , Shanghai 200237 , China. 2. Department of Chemical Engineering , University of Virginia , 102 Engineers' Way , P.O. Box 400741, Charlottesville , Virginia 22904 , United States. 3. Centre for Systems Chemistry, Stratingh Institute for Chemistry and Zernike Institute for Advanced Materials, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences , University of Groningen , Nijenborgh 4 , 9747 AG Groningen , The Netherlands.
Abstract
Programming the hierarchical self-assembly of small molecules has been a fundamental topic of great significance in biological systems and artificial supramolecular systems. Precise and highly programmed self-assembly can produce supramolecular architectures with distinct structural features. However, it still remains a challenge how to precisely control the self-assembly pathway in a desirable way by introducing abundant structural information into a limited molecular backbone. Here we disclose a strategy that directs the hierarchical self-assembly of sodium thioctate, a small molecule of biological origin, into a highly ordered supramolecular layered network. By combining the unique dynamic covalent ring-opening-polymerization of sodium thioctate and an evaporation-induced interfacial confinement effect, we precisely direct the dynamic supramolecular self-assembly of this simple small molecule in a scheduled hierarchical pathway, resulting in a layered structure with long-range order at both macroscopic and molecular scales, which is revealed by small-angle and wide-angle X-ray scattering technologies. The resulting supramolecular layers are found to be able to bind water molecules as structural water, which works as an interlayer lubricant to modulate the material properties, such as mechanical performance, self-healing capability, and actuating function. Analogous to many reversibly self-assembled biological systems, the highly dynamic polymeric network can be degraded into monomers and reformed by a water-mediated route, exhibiting full recyclability in a facile, mild, and environmentally friendly way. This approach for assembling commercial small molecules into structurally complex materials paves the way for low-cost functional supramolecular materials based on synthetically simple procedures.
Programming the hierarchical self-assembly of small molecules has been a fundamental topic of great significance in biological systems and artificial supramolecular systems. Precise and highly programmed self-assembly can produce supramolecular architectures with distinct structural features. However, it still remains a challenge how to precisely control the self-assembly pathway in a desirable way by introducing abundant structural information into a limited molecular backbone. Here we disclose a strategy that directs the hierarchical self-assembly of sodium thioctate, a small molecule of biological origin, into a highly ordered supramolecular layered network. By combining the unique dynamic covalent ring-opening-polymerization of sodium thioctate and an evaporation-induced interfacial confinement effect, we precisely direct the dynamic supramolecular self-assembly of this simple small molecule in a scheduled hierarchical pathway, resulting in a layered structure with long-range order at both macroscopic and molecular scales, which is revealed by small-angle and wide-angle X-ray scattering technologies. The resulting supramolecular layers are found to be able to bind water molecules as structural water, which works as an interlayer lubricant to modulate the material properties, such as mechanical performance, self-healing capability, and actuating function. Analogous to many reversibly self-assembled biological systems, the highly dynamic polymeric network can be degraded into monomers and reformed by a water-mediated route, exhibiting full recyclability in a facile, mild, and environmentally friendly way. This approach for assembling commercial small molecules into structurally complex materials paves the way for low-cost functional supramolecular materials based on synthetically simple procedures.
Molecular self-assembly
has emerged as a topic of great significance
in general as it holds great promise toward next generations’
functional materials.[1−5] A variety of approaches followed by chemists triggered the rapid
expansion of supramolecular self-assembly as an interdisciplinary
area.[6,7] Using a “bottom-up” strategy,
complex materials can be prepared by highly programmed self-assembly
of small-molecule building blocks,[8−12] which might enable the precise tailoring and manipulation
of matter and functional control along various length scales.[13,14] Until recently, supramolecular self-assembly in artificial molecular
systems had exhibited a predominant capability to form morphology-controlled
multidimensional structures, such as amphiphilic vesicles/micelles,[15] gels,[16,17] linear polymers,[18] and the cross-linked networks.[19] The hierarchical self-assembly of these primary structures
can further result in truly unique soft matter.[20−22] The diversity,
complexity, and functionality of these materials can be especially
striking if the molecular self-assembly of the small building blocks
is precisely controlled in a programmed mode,[23−25] also signifying
the opportunity to program information via the molecular self-assembly
mode into molecular structures as information.[26] In this context, structural information in a precursor
molecule would enable the precisely controlled self-assembly of small
molecules into large-scale assemblies with desirable organized structures
and properties. However, to meet the rising need for advanced materials
with sophisticated and even multiple functions, tedious synthetic
routes are frequently required to prepare precursor molecules via
complex chemical modifications, whereas simple buildings blocks leading
to complexity would be highly desirable.Very recently, we explored
a small molecule of biological origin,
called as thioctic acid, which is a naturally tailored building block
that readily forms an amorphous supramolecular network, taking advantage
of its disulfide-containing main chain cross-linked by hydrogen bonds
and metal-carboxyl complexes,[27] which can
be easily prepared by a solvent-free mild method. Although such an
amorphous network exhibits potential applications in flexible and
wearable materials,[28−32] the disordered cross-linking of the polymer chains hardly produces
structurally ordered polymeric materials, which play a crucial role
in many other areas, such as liquid crystals,[33−35] soft actuators,[36−40] ionic transport membranes,[41] and high-strength
materials.[10,42] Herein, we focus on how this
naturally tailored small molecule can be programmed by strategic molecular
engineering to realize its precise self-assembly into long-range-order
supramolecular architectures. We hope that exploring such a dynamic
supramolecular self-assembly process toward structurally ordered assemblies
could provide a new generation of molecular tools for the design and
construction of supramolecular systems as well as natural product-based
polymer materials.[43]On the basis
of this hypothesis, we demonstrate a rational derivation
on the natural structure of thioctic acid by simple deprotonation
to form amphiphilic sodium thioctate (ST). This simple small molecule
can self-assemble into primary linear polymers at high concentrations
by dynamic covalent ring-opening-polymerization (ROP), which undergo
further self-organization into a highly ordered supramolecular network
with a large-scale layered structure using a facile evaporation process.
This is to the best of our knowledge an unprecedented example of directly
assembling simple small molecules into supramolecular materials with
high structural order, which is attributed to the naturally programmed
structural information in this unique small-molecule building block.
The dynamic covalent polymeric backbones and structural-water-cross-linked
layered network simultaneously render the polymeric materials with
good mechanical properties, humidity-actuated ability, and closed-loop
recyclability.
Results and Discussion
Design Concept and Aqueous
Self-Assembly
Structurally
ordered assemblies are generally created by highly synergetic intermolecular
interactions. The coexisting multiple species involved in molecular
self-organization should be highly hierarchical in binding affinity
as well as spatial distribution.[44] The
thermal one-pot solvent-free polymerization of thioctic acid was a
fast and homogeneous assembly process resulting in amorphous assemblies.[27] Structurally ordered self-assembly mostly involves
a slow and thermodynamically controlled process, with relatively low
growth rate kinetics to push the dynamic equilibrium toward a thermodynamically
stable state.[22] Therefore, two issues should
be addressed to realize the ordered self-assembly of thioctic acid:
(i) the self-assembly process should not be instantaneous but be programmed
with longer time scales, and (ii) multiple molecular interactions
with different binding affinities should be introduced to enable a
hierarchical self-assembly process with distinct spatial distribution.
Notably, the order (or sequence in time) of these hierarchical molecular
recognition processes should be also programmed in a precise and desirable
pathway.On the basis of these preconditions, we notice the
unique structural features of thioctic acid for potential amphiphilic
molecules. The terminal carboxylic group can be deprotonated to form
a hydrophilic carboxylate group, while the five-membered disulfide-containing
ring is hydrophobic, and the middle C4-methylene chain
links the hydrophilic and hydrophobic parts as a typical amphiphilic
structure (Figure A). This amphiphilic feature could work as structural information
for molecular recognition, driving the self-organization of these
small-molecule building blocks toward a more thermodynamically stable
situation, in which the hydrophobic five-membered rings tend to aggregate
to decrease interaction with the surrounding high-energy water molecules.
This primary amphiphilic self-assembly further triggers the secondary
dynamic covalent ROP reaction by the intermolecular dynamic covalent
exchange of disulfide bonds facilitated by the increased intermolecular
proximity. Furthermore, the subsequent self-assembly can be enabled
using the outer hydrophilic carboxylate groups which recognized each
other to form ionic bonds after the removal of solvent, forming an
ionic-bond-cross-linked polymeric network (Figure B). As a consequence, these features enable
the complex hierarchical self-assembly from small molecules to form
three-dimensional polymeric networks.
Figure 1
Self-assembly process of sodium thioctate
in water. (A and B) Molecular
structures (A) and schematic representation (B) of the ST monomers,
ST polymers, and their networks. (C) Photographs of the ST crystalline
powder, viscous ST polymer solution, and the resulting free-standing
flexible solid film. (D) Schematic mechanism of the evaporation-induced
interfacial supramolecular self-assembly from disordered polymers
in aqueous solution to dry-ordered film network.
Self-assembly process of sodium thioctate
in water. (A and B) Molecular
structures (A) and schematic representation (B) of the ST monomers,
STpolymers, and their networks. (C) Photographs of the ST crystalline
powder, viscous STpolymer solution, and the resulting free-standing
flexible solid film. (D) Schematic mechanism of the evaporation-induced
interfacial supramolecular self-assembly from disorderedpolymers
in aqueous solution to dry-ordered film network.Gram-scale ST monomers can easily be obtained by the quantitative
deprotonation reaction of thioctic acid with sodium hydroxide in ethanol
and subsequent filtration, yielding a light-yellow crystalline powder
with high water-solubility (over 400 g/L at 298 K). Dissolving ST
powder in water resulted in a homogeneous yellow solution, and the
concentrated solution (over 200 g/L) exhibited remarkably increased
viscosity (Figure C), suggesting polymerization. The formation of ring-opened linear
poly(ST) polymer was confirmed by distinctive proton shifts[27] and broadening in the 1H NMR spectrum
(Figure S1). Meanwhile, the disulfide-containing
five-membered ring can be considered a chromophore because of its
characteristic absorption maximum at 330 nm (Figure
S2A), which originates from the red-shifted absorption of the
disulfide group as a result of five-membered-ring tension.[45] Therefore, the absorbance of this chromophore
can be used to detect the dynamic covalent ROP process in aqueous
solution.[46] At concentrations lower than
150 g/L, the absorbance versus concentration plot of ST strictly follows
Lambert–Beer’s law, while the absorbance of the 200
g/L sample exhibited a remarkable decrease in slope (Figure S2B), confirming the ROP process. It should be noted
that the polymers and monomers coexisted in a concentrated state due
to the presence of absorption at 330 nm. The coexistence is attributed
to the dynamic nature of the dynamic covalent self-assembly process.[47] The viscous polymer solution exhibited excellent
stability at room temperature, without phase separation or viscosity
decrease after three months of observation (Figure
S3). At an extremely high concentration (400 g/L), the high
viscosity can even support the formation of a transparent hydrogel
network at relatively low temperature (10 °C) (Figure S4), which can be rationalized on the basis of the
formation of high-molecular-weight polymers and ionic-bond cross-links.
The hydrogel is labile to concentration decrease and temperature increase,
which would transform the material into a viscous polymer solution
upon heating or dilution by water, revealing the dynamic reversible
nature of this supramolecular polymer.
Evaporation-Induced Interfacial
Self-Assembly
As demonstrated
previously, the key to forming a structurally ordered network includes
a long-time growth process and temporal distribution of the hierarchical
self-assembly steps programmed in a precise and desirable pathway.
The equilibrium states of the hierarchical dynamic self-assembly processes
of poly(ST) are strongly dependent on concentration, indicating that
a concentration increase can be a key factor to drive the proposed
dynamic self-assembly equilibrium. On the basis of this notion, we
employ a solvent-evaporation strategy to direct the hierarchical self-assembly
process in a thermodynamically controlled manner. The evaporation-directed
method has been used in controlling uniform assembled morphology of
nanostructures.[48] Here we demonstrate that
the evaporation process enables a dynamic covalent ROP templated by
interfacial self-assembly (Figure D), i.e., the edge of the ellipsoidal droplet bears
the fastest evaporation kinetic, thus undergoing nucleation at the
edge region when the localized solution is oversaturated. Upon further
solvent evaporation, the air/liquid/solid interface moves slowly along
the evaporation direction, where the linear polymers assemble and
grow at the three-phase interface, eventually producing a structurally
ordered layered network. We propose that the interfacial confinement
effect could well organize these unique small-molecule building blocks
by producing a localized concentration gradient at the interface.
Therefore, this whole process from small molecules (ST) to polymeric
network poly(ST) can be identified as an evaporation-induced interfacial
self-assembly (EIISA) route.The EIISA process can be performed
readily by dispensing the ST aqueous solution on a glass or polyethylene
substrate followed by slow evaporation at ambient conditions, resulting
in a free-standing dry solid polymeric film, which can be easily separated
from the substrate (Figures C and S5 and S6). Polarized optical
microscopy was employed to detect the self-assembly process with evaporation-induced
interface movement in real time (Figures a and S7). Initially,
the aqueous solution of ST is homogeneous and isotropic, hence exhibiting
an invisible birefringence property. With the evaporation of the solution,
a bright pattern of cyan color appeared to form an interface, suggesting
the formation of structurally ordered assemblies. Then the interface
moved along the evaporation direction, leaving the progressing route
with expanded cyan patterns. The bright cyan regions changed into
yellow patterns with further evaporation, which can be attributed
to the shrinking of the assembled layers induced by water release.
Figure 2
(A) Real-time
detection of the formation of a crystalline-phase
structure, upon water evaporation, by polarized optical microscopy.
The colored bright spots indicated the presence of ordered crystallites
in the corresponding region. (B) Photographs of a poly(ST) polymer
film with natural light showing good transparency. (C) Photographs
of a poly(ST) polymer film under polarized light suggesting the extensive
presence of ordered crystalline regions. (D) SEM images of poly(ST)
polymer film.
(A) Real-time
detection of the formation of a crystalline-phase
structure, upon water evaporation, by polarized optical microscopy.
The colored bright spots indicated the presence of ordered crystallites
in the corresponding region. (B) Photographs of a poly(ST) polymer
film with natural light showing good transparency. (C) Photographs
of a poly(ST) polymer film under polarized light suggesting the extensive
presence of ordered crystalline regions. (D) SEM images of poly(ST)polymer film.The resulting polymer film exhibited
good optical transparency
(Figure B) and showed
a remarkable birefringence feature (Figure C), indicating long-range-ordered self-assembly
in bulk phase. The identical peak signals from the ST monomer powder
and polymer film in the Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectrum
(Figure S8) and Raman spectra (Figure S9) indicated similar chemical structures
both before and after the EIISA process, confirming the absence of
other side reactions. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images (Figures D and S10) showed the compact surface morphology of
the resulting films. Wrinkled nanostructures were observed, which
might be the result of surface folding induced by solvent evaporation.
Structural Characterization of the Resulting Polymers
The
polymeric nature of the resulting poly(ST) film can be confirmed
by its optical properties. The diluted aqueous solution of monomer
ST (1 g/L) containing a five-membered ring exhibited a characteristic
absorption at 330 nm (Figure A) and photochemical excitation induced the ring-opening process
to produce disulfide radicals, which were rebonded intramolecularly
due to the uninitiated primary amphiphilic self-assembly at 1 g/L.
The UV–vis reflection spectrum of the resulting poly(ST) film
showed a peak at 312 nm, while no distinctive absorption was visible
at 330 nm, indicating the absence of ST monomers. Differential scanning
calorimetry (DSC) on the ST powder also showed a distinctive dehydration
peak at 81.1 °C (Figure B), and no dehydration peak was observed at this region in
the poly(ST) film, indicating a higher binding energy of bound water
in the poly(ST) film compared to the powder. This result also suggests
complete polymerization in the poly(ST)film because of the lack of
a dehydration peak in the ST monomer thermogram.
Figure 3
(A) UV–vis absorption
spectra of ST aqueous solution (1
g/L) and dry poly(ST) film. (B) DSC curves of the ST powder and poly(ST)
polymer film. (C) Hydration number (λ) measurements under varying
relative humidity. (D) FT-IR spectra of the poly(ST) polymer film
before (red line) and after (black line) release of adsorbed D2O.
(A) UV–vis absorption
spectra of ST aqueous solution (1
g/L) and dry poly(ST) film. (B) DSC curves of the ST powder and poly(ST)polymer film. (C) Hydration number (λ) measurements under varying
relative humidity. (D) FT-IR spectra of the poly(ST) polymer film
before (red line) and after (black line) release of adsorbed D2O.The water-sensitive ionic bonds
in the network create the poly(ST)
film’s humidity-responsive capability. The dry robust polymer
film can adsorb water molecules from the air, leading to an increase
in hydration that scales with the relative humidity (RH) of the air
(Figure C). To quantitatively
evaluate the hydration number (λ, defined as the number of water
molecules per carboxylate group) of the humidity-responsive poly(ST)
film, humidity-varying thermogravimetry was performed on the ST powder
and poly(ST) film (Figure S11–S13). The ST powder exhibited a low λ value from 0.03 (RH = 0%)
to 0.65 (RH = 98%) at 25 °C. However, the poly(ST) film bear
a much higher λ which increased from 0.12 (RH = 0%) to 1.64
(RH = 98%) at 25 °C, and an increased temperature (40 °C)
led to a slight difference of this range from 0.04 (RH = 0%) to 1.98
(RH = 98%). The higher λ number of poly(ST) film is attributed
to its ordered layered structure, wherein the hydrophilic carboxylate
groups associate to form interlayer water channels by ionic bonding.
This enables the abundant spatial sites and carboxylate interlayers
as the water diffusion channels. However, for the ST powder samples,
the poor structural order resulted in the limited diffusion and hydration
in the inner cores. On the contrary, notably slower hydration kinetics
of poly(ST) film were observed compared with that of ST powder (Figure S14), which is attributed to the ordered
layered structure of periodically alternating hydrophobic/hydrophilic
layers. The sandwich-like layers confined the hydrophilic water channels
in two-dimension between the hydrophobic polymer mainchain phase,
thus slowing the hydration kinetics in the low humidity regions (Figure S15). The observed differences in hydration
thermodynamics and kinetics between the ST powders and poly(ST) films
further supports the proposed long-range-order layered structure with
water channels in the poly(ST) films formed by EIISA method.The water adsorption mechanism was confirmed by analysis of the
FT-IR spectra (Figure S16). A slight IR
shift for the carboxylate groups was observed from 1562 to 1552 cm–1 after adsorbing water, which was attributed to the
hydration of the carboxylate groups. The disappearance of a shoulder
peak at 1432 cm–1 after water adsorption also suggested
the hydration of the carboxylate groups while the increased peak around
3400 cm–1 indicated bound water in the network.
The release process was further confirmed by D2O because
of its characteristic feature signal at around 2500 cm–1 (Figure D). The
D2O molecules adsorbed in the poly(ST) network were found
to be totally released by placing the film into dry air condition
at room temperature, indicating that the bound water in the network
can be fully exchanged in an ambient atmosphere.X-ray diffraction
and scattering tests (Figure ) were performed to characterize the structural
order of the resulting poly(ST) film. X-ray diffraction (XRD) of the
dry poly(ST) film showed sharp and high-intensity diffraction peaks
in the small angle regime (less than 20°), indicating a typical,
highly ordered structure at the nanoscale (Figure A). The peak at 4.38° was attributed
to a layer distance of 2.02 nm (calculated by the Bragg equation).
The periodic signals also suggested a highly ordered layered structure.
Meanwhile, the broad and low peak at around 23° suggested an
amorphous hydrophobic disulfide-containing polymer main chain phase.[27] As a reference, ST powder was also measured,
which showed a largely amorphous structure with poor structural order,
indicating the significance of the EIISA method for the formation
of structurally ordered poly(ST) film. Small-angle X-ray scattering
(SAXS) showed a sharp scattering signal at 0.297 Å–1 (Figure B), indicating
the high structural order with 2.11 nm spacing grazing-incidence wide-angle
X-ray scattering (GIWAXS) further revealing the highly ordered layered
structure of the resulting poly(ST) film (Figure C,D). The periodic one-dimensional scattering
sharp peaks and two-dimensional high-intensity scattering rings confirmed
the highly ordered layered structure in the poly(ST) network.[41] The observed scattering vector q = 0.302 Å–1 can be attributed to the layer
distance of 2.08 nm of the resulting poly(ST) film, which was consistent
with the XRD and SAXS results, confirming the interlayer distance
as 2.1 nm of the layered poly(ST) film.
Figure 4
(A) XRD patterns of the
ST monomer powders and the resulting poly(ST)
film. (B) Synchrotron radiation SAXS pattern of the poly(ST) film.
Inset image shows the distinctive scattering ring of the sample. (C)
One-dimensional GIWAXS plot of the poly(ST) film. Scattering intensity
is plotted versus q.
(D) Two-dimensional GIWAXS pattern of the poly(ST) film.
(A) XRD patterns of the
ST monomer powders and the resulting poly(ST)
film. (B) Synchrotron radiation SAXS pattern of the poly(ST) film.
Inset image shows the distinctive scattering ring of the sample. (C)
One-dimensional GIWAXS plot of the poly(ST) film. Scattering intensity
is plotted versus q.
(D) Two-dimensional GIWAXS pattern of the poly(ST) film.
Rheology and Mechanical Properties
The storage moduli
(G′) was higher than the loss moduli (G″) over the entire range of frequencies (Figure S17A) and also exhibited a single plateau
region in the dynamic moduli. It should be noted that the moduli can
be commensurate with that of the previously reported covalent-/iron(III)-co-cross-linked network,[27] even
in the absence of a covalent cross-linker or iron(III) ions in the
poly(ST) film. In a temperature-varied experiment (Figure S17B), moduli and viscosity slightly decreased with
rising temperatures, which might be attributed to the thermo-labile
disulfide bonds in the polymer main chain.The dry polymer film
exhibited robust mechanical properties with a Young’s tensile
modulus of 168.8 MPa (Figure A), which was attributed to the ordered layered structure
and high-affinity ionic bonds in the dry network. Interestingly, an
increased hydrated degree led to a remarkable decrease in the tensile
strength but also an increasing flexibility and stretchability (Figure A). This observation
was attributed to the hydration of high-affinity ionic groups by bound
water molecules, which worked as a lubricant-like structural water[49−51] by forming weak but dynamic hydrogen bonds in the interlayers of
the network. The hydrated poly(ST) film exhibited a fast relaxation-recovery
ability (Figure B
and Movie S1) and an elasticity in a cyclic
experiment (Figure S18). In the highly hydrated
state (RH > 95%), the hydrated poly(ST) polymer turned very soft
and
viscous, showing a lower birefraction degree (Figure
S19) and amorphous diffraction peaks (Figure
S20), which is attributed to the formation of the hydrogen-bond-cross-linked
network.
Figure 5
(A) Tensile stress curves of the poly(ST) film under different
RH (5%, 50%, and 80%, respectively). Inset photographs show the stretched
poly(ST) film (RH = 80%). (B) Photographs show the rapid relaxation
behavior of a stretched poly(ST) film (RH = 80%). (C) Schematic representation
of the tension-induced alignment of the elastic poly(ST) film. (D)
Optical microscope images of the polymer filaments made by stretching
the hydrated poly(ST) films (RH = 80%). Bright field (top) and polarized
light field (bottom) show the ordered fibers paralleled with the tension
direction. (E) Schematic representation and optical images of the
helical filaments which are formed by mechanical tension followed
by relaxation.
(A) Tensile stress curves of the poly(ST) film under different
RH (5%, 50%, and 80%, respectively). Inset photographs show the stretched
poly(ST) film (RH = 80%). (B) Photographs show the rapid relaxation
behavior of a stretched poly(ST) film (RH = 80%). (C) Schematic representation
of the tension-induced alignment of the elastic poly(ST) film. (D)
Optical microscope images of the polymer filaments made by stretching
the hydrated poly(ST) films (RH = 80%). Bright field (top) and polarized
light field (bottom) show the ordered fibers paralleled with the tension
direction. (E) Schematic representation and optical images of the
helical filaments which are formed by mechanical tension followed
by relaxation.A notable decrease in optical
transparency was observed upon stretching
the elastic poly(ST) film (Figure A inset), which is the result of tension-induced order
of the stretched polymer chain (Figure C). The alignment of microfibers along the tension
direction can be observed in brightfield and polarized- light-field
by optical microscopy (Figure D). Interestingly, an instant loosening of the stretched filaments
resulted in a rapid formation of helical filaments, in which the aligned
order was maintained. This transformation might be the result of an
energy dissipation pathway originating from imposed potential energy
within the stretched filaments. The helical structure was stable in
dry conditions (RH < 50%) for several weeks, while they lost their
shape and inner order upon exposure to highly humid conditions due
to the decreased structural order by adsorbed water. Hence, the structural
order of the layered network is necessary for this relaxation-induced
spiraling behavior.
Applications as Dynamic Materials
The resulting structurally
ordered layered supramolecular film simultaneously integrates dynamic
covalent mainchains and supramolecular interaction in a single network,
including noncovalent ionic bonds, hydrogen bonds of bound water,
the van der Waals interaction of folded and packed polymer chains,
and dynamic covalent disulfide bonds. These distinct features result
from the dynamic nature of the polymer main chains with a high-proportion
of disulfide groups, which might give this material unique dynamic
properties and applications. The self-healing ability of the resulting
poly(ST) films was confirmed by scratching experiments (Figure S21A). The film samples with varied degrees
of hydration exhibited different self-healing capability, which was
activated at the RH regions over 50%, while the dry samples showed
no self-healing. In a typical healing experiment, a scratch can be
healed almost completely in 12 h. Considering the switchable mechanical
properties depending on reversible water adsorption/release, a water-mediated
self-healing capability of mechanically robust materials is realized.
Self-healing robust materials are very rare because of the limited
interface mobility.[52] In our case, the
damaged dry robust poly(ST) film can be “lubricated”
by adsorbing water to enhance the interface mobility and dynamic properties.
Then the damage can be healed, taking advantage of the reversible
polymeric main chains and dynamic supramolecular interactions (Figure S21B), followed by releasing the water
molecule upon drying to afford repaired and robust films.Considering
the three-dimensional multilayer polymer film, the humidity-induced
expansion motion can be expected to be used as a humidity-induced
actuator based on the supramolecular network. Placing a flat poly(ST)polymer film above a moisture generator would generate an asymmetric
humidity gradient environment, with the film region near the water
adsorbing more water molecules than the region away from the water,
thus producing an asymmetric volume expansion degree (Figure A,B). In a typical experiment,
a polymer film can transform from a flat shape into a bent one, while
the inverse process can be driven by drying (Figure
S22) or triggering the other less-hydrated side of the film
(Figure C). The humidity-induced
layer expansion can be confirmed by XRD patterns (Figure D), in which the diffraction
angle of the film decreased with the increased RH, indicating the
increase of layer distances after adsorbing water molecules. The kinetic
curve showed a linear correlation with time and a responding rate
of 2.9 deg/s (Figure E). Although several polymer actuators have been reported,[53,54] the actuator presented here based on the poly(ST) network, is totally
cross-linked by dynamic covalent and supramolecular interactions instead
of covalent cross-linkers, with an extremely simple preparation method
initiated from natural small molecules.
Figure 6
(A) Schematic representation
of the humidity-induced actuation
behavior of poly(ST) polymer film. The blue arrows mean the humidity
gradient direction. (B) Schematic representation of the expansion
mechanism of the interlayers. (C) Photographs show the capability
of poly(ST) polymer film acting as a humidity-responsive actuator.
(D) XRD patterns of the poly(ST) film under varied RH. (E) Actuating
kinetic curve of the bending polymer film to water vapor.
(A) Schematic representation
of the humidity-induced actuation
behavior of poly(ST) polymer film. The blue arrows mean the humidity
gradient direction. (B) Schematic representation of the expansion
mechanism of the interlayers. (C) Photographs show the capability
of poly(ST) polymer film acting as a humidity-responsive actuator.
(D) XRD patterns of the poly(ST) film under varied RH. (E) Actuating
kinetic curve of the bending polymer film to water vapor.The realization of recyclability in synthetic polymers is
a key
topic toward environment and energy issues. Though many polymer materials
can be degraded or reprocessed, it has been highly challenging to
realize fully recyclable polymers which can be transformed into monomer
feedstocks in a mild and facile condition.[55−60] Here we propose a polymer-recycling strategy by dynamic covalent
ROP. Interestingly, dissolving the poly(ST) polymer film in water
resulted in a monomer/oligomer solution (Figures A and S23), which
was confirmed by 1H NMR spectroscopy (Figure S24). This result revealed that the cross-linked polymer
network can be efficiently depolymerized into ring-closed ST monomers
and oligomers by the addition of excess water. The high degradation
efficiency can be also confirmed by the remarkably decreased moduli
(below 5 Pa) and viscosity (below 10 Pas) of a degraded aqueous solution
(100 g/L) (Figure S25). Then the recycled
monomer/oligomers solution can be used to produce recycled polymer
film by a similar EIISA process. Therefore, the closed-loop polymer-recycling
process simply requires the mediation by water (Figure A) while the depolymerization process can
be completed in 20 min (Figure B). The recycled polymer film exhibited
consistent mechanical properties (Figure C), indicating the high recycling efficiency
of this water-mediated route. Therefore, this polymer exhibits an
unprecedented recyclability that bears no organic solvent, no heat,
no high pressure, and no special technique, showing a promising potential
toward environmentally friendly and energy-saving polymer materials.
Figure 7
(A) Schematic
representation of the water-mediated recycling process
of the poly(ST) films. (B) Photographs show the recycling process
of the polymer film fragments into a new polymer film. (C) Tensile
stress curve of the original and recycled poly(ST) films. The tested
samples are dried at room temperature (RH < 10%).
(A) Schematic
representation of the water-mediated recycling process
of the poly(ST) films. (B) Photographs show the recycling process
of the polymer film fragments into a new polymer film. (C) Tensile
stress curve of the original and recycled poly(ST) films. The tested
samples are dried at room temperature (RH < 10%).
Conclusions
By controlling the dynamic self-assembly
of sodium thioctate (ST)
in water based on hydrophilic/hydrophobic effects, dynamic covalent
ROP, and ionic interactions with evaporation-induced interfacial ordering,
we achieved hierarchical self-assembly of a small molecule into a
layered supramolecular network with a long-range order. The resulting
layered dry network bears alternating layers with hydrophilic ionic
stacking and hydrophobic polymer mainchains, with the former being
able to bind water molecules to form interlayer water channels. Distinct
structural features provide this material with dynamic and adaptive
mechanical properties, self-healing capability, and actuation functions.
The unique dynamic covalent polymer mainchains can be disassembled
into monomers and quantitively reused by a facile room-temperature
water-mediated route, providing a conceptually new strategy to design
recyclable polymeric materials.In summary, this supramolecular
material based on the self-assembly
of deprotonated thioctic acid exhibits simplicity in preparation as
well as order and complexity in structure and properties, pushing
the versatile supramolecular materials based on thioctic acid from
previously disordered elastomers to structurally ordered layers. This
work paves the way for what we believe to be one of the fundamental
issues in supramolecular chemistry; programming the precisely hierarchical
self-assembly of small molecules toward structurally complex architectures,
opening new avenues for dynamic polymeric materials in optics, electronics,
sensors, coatings, and biomedical systems.
Materials
and Methods
Materials Preparation
Sodium thioctate (ST) was prepared
as bright yellow solid powder by a one-step reaction of equivalent
amounts of thioctic acid and NaOH in ethanol/water solution heated
under reflux. The ST powder is highly water-soluble and viscous aqueous
solution can be obtained with a high concentration up to 300 g/L.
In a typical preparation of poly(ST) film, a small volume of poly(ST)
solution (300 g/L) was deposited on the substrate by simply drop-coating
(the formed area is about 10 cm2 per 1 mL). The substrate
can be glass, plastic dish, or Teflon. Then the polymer solution on
the substrate was left in air to allow slow evaporation of the solvent.
The evaporation process normally takes 2–6 h depending on the
air humidity and the temperature. No remarkable difference was observed
in the resulting polymer film obtained in different time within this
time regime. The resulting dry polymer can be easily separated from
the substrate as a transparent, free-standing, and robust polymer
film.
Mechanical Tension Experiments
The stress–strain
curves were recorded with an HY-0580 tension machine (HENGYI Company,
Shanghai). The tested polymer films were preplaced for at least 2
h at the given RH to reach the adsorption/desorption equilibrium with
water. Then the film was quickly fixed onto the tension machine and
tested. The whole tension process was completed in 10 min. Considering
the low water adsorption/desorption kinetic of the poly(ST) films,
the hydration number of the polymer film in mechanical tension experiments
can be considered as almost constant. The RH of the testing environment
was fluctuated in a limited region (40% ∼ 60%). The film was
shaped as a rectangle sample (20 × 10 × 0.5 mm). The initial
length was 10 mm. Unless otherwise noted, the tensile stress was measured
at a constant speed of 10 mm/min. The data were recorded in real time.
Hydration Number Measurement
The hydration thermodynamics
and kinetics of poly(ST) film were measurement by a Relative Humidity
Thermogravimetric Analyzer (RH-TGA, TA-Q5000 SA). In a typical experiment,
a small piece of dry poly(ST) film (∼7 mg) was loaded into
a metal-coated quartz pan, and the pan was transferred into the humidity
chamber of the analyzer. The total gas flow rate (water vapor and
N2) was chosen as 20 mL/min, and different relative humidity
values, namely 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 98%, were achieved by changing
the relative flow rates of water vapor saturated N2 and
dry N2 gas. The film was first dried at 60 °C at 0%
RH for 4 h (8 h for powder) to remove residual moisture, and the film
weight was recorded as the dry weight (WD). After the initial drying step, the chamber temperature was reduced
to a designated value (i.e., 25 or 40 °C) and the RH value was
increased stepwise to 98% (hydration) and then reduced stepwise to
0% (dehydration). The film was allowed to equilibrate at each RH value
for 12 h (4 h for powder), and the film weight was recorded at the
end of each 12 h equilibration step. The hydrated film weight (WH) at each RH value was taken as the average
of the weight recorded during hydration and dehydration ramps. The
film hydration number λ [eq(H2O)/eq(−COOH)]
was defined aswhere the EWST is the equivalent weight
of ST and is taken as 228 g/mol.
Authors: Richard van Hameren; Peter Schön; Arend M van Buul; Johan Hoogboom; Sergiy V Lazarenko; Jan W Gerritsen; Hans Engelkamp; Peter C M Christianen; Hans A Heus; Jan C Maan; Theo Rasing; Sylvia Speller; Alan E Rowan; Johannes A A W Elemans; Roeland J M Nolte Journal: Science Date: 2006-12-01 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Rienk Eelkema; Michael M Pollard; Javier Vicario; Nathalie Katsonis; Blanca Serrano Ramon; Cees W M Bastiaansen; Dirk J Broer; Ben L Feringa Journal: Nature Date: 2006-03-09 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Laurens T de Haan; Julien M N Verjans; Dirk J Broer; Cees W M Bastiaansen; Albertus P H J Schenning Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2014-07-17 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Georg M Scheutz; Jonathan L Rowell; Fu-Sheng Wang; Khalil A Abboud; Chi-How Peng; Brent S Sumerlin Journal: Org Biomol Chem Date: 2020-08-26 Impact factor: 3.890