| Literature DB >> 31294906 |
Flora Peyvandi1,2, Fatemeh Tavakkoli3, Diana Frame4, Jennifer Quinn3, Benjamin Kim3, Adebayo Lawal3, Mimi C Lee3, Wing Y Wong3.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Although the clinical manifestations of severe haemophilia A (HA) are well studied, the challenges, if any, of living with mild HA are not clearly delineated to date. AIM: To assess available evidence of clinical risks and societal/economic impacts of disease in adult patients with mild HA using a systematic literature review.Entities:
Keywords: acute bleeding; disease burden; haemophilia; quality of life
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31294906 PMCID: PMC6852304 DOI: 10.1111/hae.13777
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Haemophilia ISSN: 1351-8216 Impact factor: 4.287
Figure 1Study attrition
Characteristics of included studies
| Number of studies | Number of mild HA adults | |
|---|---|---|
| Total | 17 | 3213 |
| Country/sites | ||
| Europe | 10 | 1045 |
| North America | 6 | 2049 |
| Japan | 1 | 119 |
| Patient population of entire study | ||
| Mild HA adults and age‐matched healthy controls | 1 | 47 |
| Mild/moderate HA, mild HA/HB | 3 | 217 |
| HA, any severity | 5 | 122 |
| HA or HB | 5 | 2044 |
| Various coagulopathies | 3 | 783 |
| Year of publication | ||
| 1996‐2007 | 2 | 56 |
| 2008‐2017 | 15 | 3157 |
| Level of evidence/study design | ||
| IB (Prospective cohort or registry) | 6 | 1517 |
| IIB (Retrospective cohort) | 6 | 316 |
| IIC (Outcomes research, survey data) | 5 | 1380 |
Data were extracted for the subset of patients of interest (mild HA adults) in this review.
Search dates extended back to 1966 (the initiation of MEDLINE database), but the earliest study meeting eligibility criteria was published in 1996.
Bleeding episodes reported in mild HA patients
| Study | Population (FVIII level/age) | Follow‐up period | Bleeding events | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| % (n/N) of patients with bleeding | episodes/pt year (SD) | |||
| Prospective cohort (US, Canada) |
6%‐40% (median NR) Age NR | 5 y (2002‐2006) | 36% (4/11) had bleeding score | NR |
| Cross‐sectional survey (Finland) |
5%‐40% (median NR) Age ≥16 | 1 y (years NR; publication 1996) | 40% (8/20) had at least one episode of moderate bleeding | NR |
| Retrospective cohort (Italy) |
0.6‐0.33 IU/mL (median 0.15 IU/mL) Median age 35 (range 3‐88) | 10 y (range 1‐39; 1985‐2010) | 91% (68/75) had at least one bleed during follow‐up |
0.56 (0.67) Includes all bleeds regardless of treatment |
| Retrospective cohort (Slovenia) |
5%‐40% (mean 8.5%) Age 13‐54 | 6 y (2007‐2014) |
57% (8/14) Includes surgery, trauma, dental procedures |
0.44 Includes all bleeds regardless of treatment |
| Retrospective cohort (Canada) |
5%‐40% (mean 0.15 IU/mL) Adults ≥18 (mean age 46) | 5 y (year NR; publication 2008) | 17% (8/46) with 2 or more bleeds requiring medical assessment or therapy in past 5 y | NR |
| Prospective cohort (Italy) |
NR (median NR) Adults ≥18 | Duration NR (2011‐2013) | 5.5% (1/18) had evidence of cerebral microbleed | NR |
| Prospective cohort (US) |
6%‐30% (median NR) Adults ≥18 | 2 y (2005‐2007) | NR (23 patients with data) |
4.5 (10.0) Definition of bleeding episodes not available |
Abbreviation: NR, not reported.
Bleeding score calculated from 5 y mean scores of haemarthrosis and soft tissue haematoma.
Bleeding histories were divided into severity based on symptom clustering across the whole cohort of coagulation disorders (n = 224); most episodes were joint and soft tissue bleeds.
Outcomes may include some patients under 13 y; study was retained due to long follow‐up duration and detailed reporting. Three patients had FVIII inhibitors.
Eleven soft tissue bleeds occurred in one patient who developed FVIII inhibitors.
Subjects are from large kindred with specific mutation (VAL2016ala).
Patients without prior symptomatic brain bleeding were assessed for evidence of asymptomatic bleeding using cerebral MRI.
This analysis of HUGS‐Va included only participants with complete follow‐up data.
Joint score and pain reported in mild HA patients
| Study | Population (FVIII level/age) | Follow‐up period | Number of mild HA patients | Mean (SD) or Median (range) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joint score (name of scale) | Pain or overall severity score (name of scale) | ||||
| Prospective cohort (US) |
6%‐30% (median NR) Age ≥18 | 2 y (2005‐2007) | 23 | Joint range of motion limitation (AAOS): 5.4 ± 4.5 | NR |
| Cross‐sectional survey (Finland) |
5%‐40% (median NR) Age ≥16 | 1 y (years NR, publication 1996) | 20 | NR | Pain in previous year: 5% (1/20) severe, 15% (3/20) moderate |
| Retrospective cohort (Italy) |
0.06‐0.33 IU/mL (median 0.15 IU/mL) Median age 35 (range 3‐88) | 10 y (range 1‐39) (1985‐2010) | 75 | Mean physical joint score 0.88 ± 1.78 (scale NR) | NR |
| Retrospective cohort (Canada) |
5%‐40% (mean 0.15 IU/mL) Age ≥18 (mean age 46) | 5 y (year NR, publication 2008) | 47 | Max joint score by Colorado PE0.5: 5.3 mild haemophilia vs 2.8 control ( | HAQ pain score: 0.51 haemophilia vs 0.61 controls (no significant difference) |
Abbreviations: AAOS, American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons; Colorado PE0.5: Scale based on modified World Federation of Haemophilia (WFH) Physical Joint Examination instrument.19; NR, not reported.
This analysis of HUGS‐Va included only participants with complete follow‐up data.
Pain and disability increased with age.
Outcomes may include some patients under 13 y; study was retained due to long follow‐up duration and detailed outcome reporting.
Subjects are from large kindred with specific mutation (VAL2016ala). Normative data are from age‐matched healthy controls (n = 32).
Figure 2Quality of life scores in mild HA (as % of maximum score). § Physical component summary (PCS) and mental component summary (MCS) for SF‐36 and SF‐12 use norm‐referenced scoring (not available as transformed/scaled scores) and are shown as % of the closest available age and country norms. For HUGS‐Va, normative data were not reported within the study, so SF‐12 norms for Utah, age >18 were used.21 * P < 0.05 vs comparison
Healthcare cost and indirect cost/societal impact for mild HA patients
| Study | Population (FVIII level/age) | Follow‐up period | Number of mild HA patients | Cost outcomes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Annual direct cost (mean or median, with currency and year) | Indirect cost/productivity | ||||
| Retrospective cohort (US) |
6%‐50% (median NR) Adults | 12 mo | 36 |
22 182 USD (1995; mean) total cost 18 017 USD factor cost | NR |
| Retrospective cohort (Portugal) |
5%‐40% (median NR) Age ≥18 | 12 mo | 16 |
€793 (year of currency NR; mean or median not specified) €506 hospital costs €+ 287 clotting factor | NR |
| Cost model (Belgium) |
6%‐40% Adults | Lifetime (simulated 2011 birth cohort, projected to future) | N/A (simulated cohort) | NR |
Disability weight vs norms: 0.054 Lifetime DALYs per mild haemophilia case: 5 (95% CrI 2‐10) SF‐36D data used for disability weights |
| Prospective cohort (US) |
6%‐30% (median NR) Age ≥18 | 2 y (2005‐2007) | 23 | NR |
6.2 d lost from work per year (total) 4.7 per year due to HA |
| Retrospective cohort (Italy) |
0.06‐0.33 IU/mL (median 0.15 IU/mL) Median age 35 (range 3‐88) | 10 y (range 1‐39) (1985‐2010) | 75 | NR | 64% employed/in training (mild HA adults) |
| Prospective cohort (Italy) |
>5% (median NR) Age NR (assumed 17‐65, based on reporting of employment status) | 12 mo (2005) | 109 | NR | 3.4 d lost from work per year |
| Retrospective cohort (Canada) |
5%‐40% (mean 0.15 IU/mL) Age ≥18 (mean age 46) | 5 y (years NR, publication 2008) | 47 | NR |
60% (27/45) employed mild HA vs 68% (21/31) controls. HAQ standard disability score: 0.24 vs 0.12 controls |
Abbreviations: 95% CrI, 95% credible interval; DALY, disability‐adjusted life year; NR, not reported; SD, standard deviation.
Costing by CPT code using Medicare fee schedule. A substantial portion of the study population was HIV+.
Data on outpatient visits, hospital admissions and surgeries are not available by severity.
Costs are not reported separately for adults and children; authors stated no statistical difference.
Sensitivity analyses under different discounting assumptions: 1‐2 lifetime DALYs after discounting. No excess mortality was assumed for mild or moderate haemophilia patients.
No normative/ healthy control data available.
Subjects are from large kindred with specific mutation (VAL2016ala). No significant difference between mild HA and age‐matched healthy controls.