| Literature DB >> 31289964 |
Andrew J Degnan1,2, Victor M Ho-Fung3,4, Rebecca C Ahrens-Nicklas5,6, Christian A Barrera3, Suraj D Serai3, Dah-Jyuu Wang3, Can Ficicioglu5,6.
Abstract
Gaucher disease is an inherited metabolic disorder resulting in deficiency of lysosomal enzyme β-glucocerebrosidase causing the accumulation of abnormal macrophages ("Gaucher cells") within multiple organs, most conspicuously affecting the liver, spleen, and bone marrow. As the most common glycolipid metabolism disorder, it is important for radiologists encountering these patients to be familiar with advances in imaging of organ and bone marrow involvement and understand the role of imaging in clinical decision-making. The recent advent of commercially available, reliable, and reproducible quantitative MRI acquisitions to measure fat fractions prompts revisiting the role of quantitative assessment of bone marrow involvement. This manuscript reviews the diverse imaging manifestations of Gaucher disease and discusses more optimal quantitative approaches to ascertain solid organ and bone marrow involvement with an emphasis on future applications of other quantitative methods including elastography.Entities:
Keywords: Bone marrow infiltration; Gaucher disease; Lysosomal storage disorder; Quantitative MRI; Treatment monitoring
Year: 2019 PMID: 31289964 PMCID: PMC6616606 DOI: 10.1186/s13244-019-0743-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Insights Imaging ISSN: 1869-4101
Clinical classifications of Gaucher disease
| Type | Name | Dominant clinical manifestations | Predilections | Age of onset | Life expectancy | Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chronic, non-neuronopathic | Prominent visceral involvement Anemia, bleeding predilection Osseous manifestations (avascular necrosis, fracture) Growth impairment | N370S mutations Ashkenazi Jews | Variable (childhood-early adulthood) | Normal to almost-normal | ERT or SRT for symptomatic patients |
| 2 | Acute, neuronopathic | Severe neurological involvement (supranuclear gaze palsy, strabismus, opisthonus) Lung involvement | None | Neonatal-infantile | Poor (neonatal or infantile demise) | Supportive |
| 3 | Subacute-chronic, neuronopathic | Progressive neurologic involvement and cognitive deterioration (myoclonic seizures, supranuclear gaze palsy) Variable visceral involvement | L444P, D409H mutations Arab and Japanese populations | Variable (childhood-adulthood) | Shortened, variable (childhood-early/mid-adulthood) | ERT for visceral involvement |
Laboratory investigations in Gaucher disease
| Laboratory investigation | Basis | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angiotensin-converting enzyme | Increased in the plasma of affected patients | Decreases with treatment | Nonspecific |
| Beta-glucocerebrosidase activity assay | Direct assessment of enzyme responsible for disease | Gold standard test Elevated in active disease | Expense |
| Bone marrow aspirate | Visualization of Gaucher cells in marrow | Identification of alternative or concomitant disease entities with similar presentations (e.g., hematologic malignancy) | Not routinely recommended if Gaucher diagnosis is highly suspected Nonspecific (pseudo-Gaucher cells) Discomfort Expense |
| CCL18 | Produced by Gaucher cells as macrophage chemokine | Elevated in active disease Suitable in chitotriosidase deficient individuals More closely reflects organ volumes than chitotriosidase | Expense No head-to-head comparison with chitotriosidase |
| Chitotriosidase | Released by glucocerebrosidase-laden Gaucher cells | Elevated in active disease Reduction from baseline values indicates treatment response Increasing values are consistent with active disease | Normal individuals occasionally may not produce chitotriosidase Can vary widely between patients Expense |
| DNA sequencing | Testing for genetic mutations (known and de novo) in the | Provides detailed information regarding genotype, which may be associated with specific forms of the disease Identifies carriers | Expense Variable phenotypic expression |
| Ferritin, serum iron, iron binding capacity | Iron overload occurs in patients. Uncertain etiology with possible association with | Correlates with hepatomegaly Decreases with treatment | Nonspecific with poor correlation with organ iron deposition on imaging and disease severity scoring |
| Glucosylsphingosine | Byproduct related to glucosylceramide, reflecting beta-glucocerebrosidase function | Correlates with other markers of disease activity, organomegaly, platelet levels Decreases with treatment | Expense, availability |
| Liver function tests (AST, ALT, bilirubin, albumin, total protein) | Hepatic dysfunction related to liver infiltration is common | Provides assessment of active hepatic involvement | May be insensitive to early hepatic involvement |
| Routine hematological tests (hemoglobin, platelet count, coagulation parameters) | Anemia and thrombocytopenia hallmark features of this disease | Provides information regarding hematologic involvement that may prompt other treatment | Nonspecific for overall disease severity |
| Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase | Marker of osteoclasts and Gaucher cells | Decreases with treatment | Nonspecific |
Historic and available therapies for Gaucher disease
| Medication name | Therapy type | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alglucerase (Ceredase, Genzyme corporation) | Enzyme replacement | Earliest therapy with demonstrated improvements in organ involvement, biomarkers, bone pain. Satisfactory safety profile | No longer available Derived from human placenta Intravenous route Cost Does not cross blood-brain barrier Allergic reactions |
| Imiglucerase (Cerezyme, Genzyme corporation) | Enzyme replacement | Replaced alglucerase with comparable therapeutic response Satisfactory safety profile | Intravenous route Cost Does not cross blood-brain barrier Allergic reactions |
| Velaglucerase alfa (VPRIV, Shire Human Genetics Therapies) | Enzyme replacement | Fewer allergic reactions Comparable therapeutic response with imiglucerase | Intravenous route Cost Does not cross blood-brain barrier |
| Taliglucerase alfa (Elelyso, Pfizer Inc.) | Enzyme replacement | Easier manufacturing, lower cost | Intravenous route Does not cross blood-brain barrier Less therapeutic response data |
| Miglustat (Zavesca, Actelion) | Substrate reduction | Oral route Potential to cross blood-brain barrier | Failed to achieve neurological treatment response High prevalence of side effects Cost |
| Eliglustat (Genzyme corporation) | Substrate reduction | Oral route Early clinical evidence of treatment response | Drug-drug interactions CYP2D6 and CYP3A metabolism considerations Cardiotoxicity Does not cross blood-brain barrier Cost |
Imaging modalities relevant to Gaucher disease
| Imaging modality | Gaucher disease manifestations | Advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magnetic resonance imaging without intravenous contrast | Abdominal: organ enlargement, heterogeneous parenchymal signal, hepatic and splenic lesions, decreased ADC in affected organs Musculoskeletal: abnormal marrow signal, avascular necrosis, fracture, vertebral height loss | Offers both qualitative and quantitative multisystem assessment including treatment response Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation Reproducible | Expense Contraindications in selected individuals Sedation requirement for certain patients |
| Quantitative chemical-shift imaging (QCSI), lumbar spine and proximal femurs | Abdominal and skeletal: decreased fat-fractions | Accurate, reproducible Validated in several studies to correlate with biomarkers and respond to treatment | Availability, technical expertise Expense Cannot be measured in areas of osteonecrosis or vertebral collapse |
| Magnetic resonance spectroscopy | Abdominal and skeletal: decreased fat-fractions | Accurate, reproducible More reliable at lower fat-fractions than chemical-shift imaging | Limited validation Availability, technical expertise Expense Acquisition time |
| Magnetic resonance elastography | Abdominal: increased liver and spleen stiffness values | Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation May be obtained in conjunction with other MRI evaluations | Availability Expense Less well-validated |
| Magnetic resonance imaging with hepatocyte-specific intravenous contrast | Abdominal: organ enlargement, heterogeneous parenchymal signal, hepatic and splenic lesions | Gold-standard for liver lesion characterization Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation Reproducible | Expense Contrast administration-related issues Low-yield in the absence of previously identified suspicious or indeterminate lesion May not avoid need for confirmatory biopsy in Gaucher disease to overlap between liver involvement and suspicious imaging features |
| DXA | Osteopenia consistent with worsening marrow infiltration | Osteopenia indicates worsening skeletal involvement and may predict pathologic fracture risk Nominal ionizing radiation exposure | Unreliable in sites of osteonecrosis and compression deformity Normative values unreliable below 6 years of age Low-yield in younger children at lower risk of fracture Predictive value of BMD to predict fracture risk in children is undefined |
| Computed tomography with intravenous contrast | Abdominal: organ enlargement, heterogeneous parenchymal attenuation, hepatic and splenic lesions | Availability Satisfactory identification of lesions | Incomplete characterization of focal lesions Ionizing radiation exposure (may be optimized for dose reduction) |
| Ultrasound, abdomen | Abdominal: organ enlargement, heterogeneous hepatic echotexture, hepatic and splenic lesions | Accessible, affordable Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation equivalent to CT for screening for liver complications | Operator dependent, protocols sometimes rely on single operator Overlap of benign and malignant focal lesion characteristics requiring additional workup Less sensitive than MRI for comprehensive assessment of organ involvement Disagreement with volumes obtained on other modalities |
| Chest CT | Interstitial and bronchial wall thickening, groundglass and centrilobular nodular opacities | Accurately depicts pulmonary involvement in patients with symptoms | Pulmonary involvement is rare Findings often nonspecific Ionizing radiation exposure |
| 99 m-Tc-Sestamibi scintigraphy | Increased uptake at distal femoral and proximal tibial epiphyses | Semi-quantitative method May correspond with treatment response Availability | Ionizing radiation exposure Poor spatial resolution Limited validation data Low specificity |
| 99 m-Tc-MDP scintigraphy | Decreased uptake at sites of bone crises | May potentially differentiate between bone crises and osteomyelitis | Not well-validated Ionizing radiation exposure Availability Expense Poor spatial resolution Not specific |
| Echocardiography and cardiac MRI | Pulmonary hypertension (mostly adults on treatment) Valvular calcifications (D409H homozygous mutation) | Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation Definitive investigations for cardiac involvement | Low-yield in pediatric population Expense Limited data to support widespread use, particularly for cardiac MRI |
| Acoustic radiation force impulse/shear wave elastography (US) | Increased liver and spleen stiffness values | Similar or higher performance compared with transient elastography Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation May be combined with conventional US evaluation of organ involvement No sedation | Availability Measurement variability |
| Transient elastography | Increased liver and spleen stiffness values | Non-invasive, no ionizing radiation Expense | No imaging guidance to assess most affected regions of organs No imaging component for further characterization of organ parenchyma quality or lesions |
Fig. 1Three-dimensional reconstructions of liver and spleen volumes from MRI in Gaucher disease. Volume-rendered organ volume reconstructions generated from non-contrast MRI data were used to track treatment response in a 9-year-old male with Gaucher disease. Organ volumes for the liver (1241 mL, 1.03 MN) and spleen (526 mL, 5.44 MN) are decreased from a prior examination at 6 years of age (1.35 MN and 6.43 MN, respectively)
Fig. 2Liver cirrhosis in pediatric Gaucher disease. Sagittal grayscale ultrasound demonstrates an enlarged liver with nodular cirrhotic morphology and perihepatic ascites in a 12-year-old male with Gaucher disease
Fig. 3Focal Gaucher cell accumulation in the liver. Axial non-contrast abdominal CT (a) demonstrates a focal hypoattenuating hepatic lesion (arrow) in the posterior right hepatic lobe in 10-year-old male with type 1 Gaucher disease. At follow-up at 16 years of age with unenhanced MRI, lesion (arrow) was unchanged in size with T1-weighted hypointense (b) and mixed T2-weighted signal intensity (c). Findings are most consistent with focal Gaucher cell deposition (“Gaucheroma”)
Fig. 4Spleen fibrosis in pediatric Gaucher disease. Axial MR elastography of a 13-year-old patient with newly diagnosed, untreated type 1 Gaucher disease demonstrates elevated spleen stiffness values (6.27 kPa, abnormal defined greater than 3.6 kPa), but no significant hepatic fibrosis identified (2.19 kPa, abnormal defined greater than 2.9 kPa)
Fig. 5Splenic necrosis in pediatric Gaucher disease. Transverse grayscale abdominal ultrasound (a) of a 2-year-old male Gaucher disease patient with marked splenomegaly shows replacement of normal splenic parenchyma with fluid and hyperechoic regions corresponding to dystrophic calcification. Contrast-enhanced abdominal CT (b) of this patient demonstrates enlarged spleen replaced with liquefying necrosis and peripheral dystrophic calcifications
Fig. 6Spectrum of musculoskeletal involvement in Gaucher disease. Nearly all type 1 Gaucher disease patients experience musculoskeletal manifestations ranging from marrow infiltration and osteopenia to pathologic fractures and compression deformities of the spine
Fig. 7Erlenmeyer flask deformity. Frontal radiograph of the right knee in a 12-year-old-male Gaucher disease patient with widening of the distal femoral diaphysis and metaphysis resulting in Erlenmeyer flask deformity
Fig. 8Marrow infiltration in Gaucher disease. A 30-year-old female with type 1 Gaucher disease with shoulder pain. Coronal T1-weighted imaging demonstrates diffuse hypointense infiltration of the humerus including the proximal epiphysis compared to subcutaneous fat
Semi-quantitative Gaucher disease bone marrow involvement scoring systems
| Classification | Bone marrow burden (BMB) | Spanish MRI (S-MRI) | Terk | Rosenthal staging | Duseldorf bone marrow disease score | Vertebra-disc ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sites | Femurs Lumbar spine | Femurs Lumbar spine Pelvis | Femurs | Lower extremities | Lower extremities | Lumbar spine |
| Considerations | Most validated method Correlates with quantitative Modified method allows use of STIR acquisition Confusion with red marrow in younger patients | Less validated Relevance of pelvis imaging is questioned Confusion with red marrow in younger patients | Does not appreciate more reversible changes seen within the axial skeleton Confusion with red marrow in younger patients | Less sensitive than methods including lumbar involvement Confusion with red marrow in younger patients | Correlates with severe disease Less sensitive than methods including lumbar spine | Quantitative region-of-interest based measurement Limited clinical validation data |
Bone marrow burden (BMB) classification
| Femurs | Lumbar spine | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Involvement | Site | Score | Site | Score |
| Diaphysis | 1 | Patchy | 1 | |
| Proximal epiphysis/apophysis | 2 | Diffuse | 2 | |
| Distal epiphysis | 3 | Absence of fat in basiverteral region | 1 | |
| Sequence | Signal intensitya | Score | Signal intensityb | Score |
| T2-weighted, (or, STIR)c | Hyperintense | 2 (2) | Hyperintense | 2 (2) |
| Slightly hyperintense | 1 (1) | Slightly hyperintense | 1 (1) | |
| Isointense | 0 (0) | Isointense | 0 (0) | |
| Slightly hypointense | 1 (N/A) | Slightly hypointense | 1 (N/A) | |
| Hypointense | 2 (N/A) | Hypointense | 2 (N/A) | |
| Mixed type | 3 (3) | |||
| T1-weighted | Slightly hyperintense or isointense | 0 | Slightly hyperintense | 0 |
| Slightly hypointense | 1 | Isointense | 1 | |
| Hypointense | 2 | Slightly hypointense | 2 | |
| Hypointense | 3 | |||
| Sum | Sum | |||
aRelative to subcutaneous fat
bRelative to normal intervertebral disc
cModified BMB scoring with STIR instead of T2-weighted imaging, adjusted scoring indicated in parentheses
Fig. 9Magnetic resonance spectroscopy assessment of marrow response to treatment. Gaucher disease patient with first imaging at 15 years of age subsequently treated with ERT. Magnetic resonance spectroscopy spectra (left) show increasing fat-fraction on follow-up examinations. Conventional T1-weighted coronal images (right) of the right femur demonstrate diffuse marrow infiltration with subtle fat infiltration with time
Fig. 10Bone infarct and subperiosteal hemorrhage mimicking osteomyelitis in Gaucher disease. A 13-year-old male presented with atraumatic knee pain and swelling. Initial lateral knee radiograph (a) showed subtle periosteal reaction along the posterior metadiaphysis of the distal femur and ill-defined intramedullary sclerosis within the femoral shaft. Follow-up MRI demonstrated intramedullary marrow edema and focal subperiosteal fluid with surrounding inflammatory changes in the popliteal fossa thought to be related to subperiosteal hemorrhage on axial T2-weighted image (b). Coronal post-contrast T1 fat-saturated image (c) demonstrated peripheral serpentine enhancement of areas of bone infarction within the distal femur. The patient was subsequently diagnosed with Gaucher disease after initial workup for hematopoietic malignancy