Literature DB >> 31197729

Communicating Uncertainty: a Narrative Review and Framework for Future Research.

Arabella L Simpkin1,2,3, Katrina A Armstrong4,5.   

Abstract

Discussing the uncertainty associated with a clinical decision is thought to be a critical element of shared decision-making. Yet, empirical evidence suggests that clinicians rarely communicate clinical uncertainty to patients, and indeed the culture within healthcare environments is often to equate uncertainty with ignorance or failure. Understanding the rationale for discussion of uncertainty along with the current evidence about approaches to communicating and managing uncertainty can advance shared decision-making as well as highlight gaps in evidence. With an increasing focus on personalized healthcare, and advances in genomics and new disease biomarkers, a more sophisticated understanding of how to communicate the limitations and errors that come from applying population-based, epidemiologic findings to predict individuals' futures is going to be essential. This article provides a narrative review of studies relating to the communication of uncertainty, highlighting current strategies together with challenges and barriers, and outlining a framework for future research.

Entities:  

Keywords:  communication; decision-making; doctor-patient relationships; medical education; patient-centered care

Mesh:

Year:  2019        PMID: 31197729      PMCID: PMC6848305          DOI: 10.1007/s11606-019-04860-8

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Gen Intern Med        ISSN: 0884-8734            Impact factor:   5.128


  60 in total

1.  Conflict Aversion: Preference for Ambiguity vs Conflict in Sources and Evidence.

Authors: 
Journal:  Organ Behav Hum Decis Process       Date:  1999-09

2.  Diagnostic error in internal medicine.

Authors:  Mark L Graber; Nancy Franklin; Ruthanna Gordon
Journal:  Arch Intern Med       Date:  2005-07-11

3.  Less is more in presenting quality information to consumers.

Authors:  Ellen Peters; Nathan Dieckmann; Anna Dixon; Judith H Hibbard; C K Mertz
Journal:  Med Care Res Rev       Date:  2007-04       Impact factor: 3.929

Review 4.  Patient experiences of uncertainty - a synthesis to guide nursing practice and research.

Authors:  Britt S Hansen; Kristine Rørtveit; Ingrid Leiknes; Ingvild Morken; Ingelin Testad; Inge Joa; Elisabeth Severinsson
Journal:  J Nurs Manag       Date:  2012-01-23       Impact factor: 3.325

5.  On medical uncertainty.

Authors:  J T Lynn
Journal:  Am J Med       Date:  1994-02       Impact factor: 4.965

6.  Stress From Uncertainty and Resilience Among Depressed and Burned Out Residents: A Cross-Sectional Study.

Authors:  Arabella L Simpkin; Alisa Khan; Daniel C West; Briana M Garcia; Theodore C Sectish; Nancy D Spector; Christopher P Landrigan
Journal:  Acad Pediatr       Date:  2018-03-07       Impact factor: 3.107

7.  The role of numeracy on client knowledge in BRCA genetic counseling.

Authors:  David B Portnoy; Debra Roter; Lori H Erby
Journal:  Patient Educ Couns       Date:  2009-10-23

8.  Does Introducing Imprecision around Probabilities for Benefit and Harm Influence the Way People Value Treatments?

Authors:  Nick Bansback; Mark Harrison; Carlo Marra
Journal:  Med Decis Making       Date:  2015-08-24       Impact factor: 2.583

9.  Surrogate decision-makers' perspectives on discussing prognosis in the face of uncertainty.

Authors:  Leah R Evans; Elizabeth A Boyd; Grace Malvar; Latifat Apatira; John M Luce; Bernard Lo; Douglas B White
Journal:  Am J Respir Crit Care Med       Date:  2008-10-17       Impact factor: 21.405

10.  Laypersons' responses to the communication of uncertainty regarding cancer risk estimates.

Authors:  Paul K J Han; William M P Klein; Thomas C Lehman; Holly Massett; Simon C Lee; Andrew N Freedman
Journal:  Med Decis Making       Date:  2009-05-21       Impact factor: 2.583

View more
  19 in total

1.  The Writing on the Wall: An Exercise in Clinical Reasoning.

Authors:  Patrick Rendon; Justin Roesch; Gurpreet Dhaliwal
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2020-05-29       Impact factor: 5.128

2.  Experts' Views on FDA Regulatory Standards for Drug and High-Risk Medical Devices: Implications for Patient Care.

Authors:  Sanket S Dhruva; Jonathan J Darrow; Aaron S Kesselheim; Rita F Redberg
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2022-02-09       Impact factor: 5.128

Review 3.  Prognostication, Ethical Issues, and Palliative Care in Disorders of Consciousness.

Authors:  Adeline L Goss; Claire J Creutzfeldt
Journal:  Neurol Clin       Date:  2022-02       Impact factor: 3.806

4.  Communication of Diagnostic Uncertainty in Primary Care and Its Impact on Patient Experience: an Integrative Systematic Review.

Authors:  Maria R Dahm; William Cattanach; Maureen Williams; Jocelyne M Basseal; Kelly Gleason; Carmel Crock
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2022-09-20       Impact factor: 6.473

5.  Anatomy of diagnosis in a clinical encounter: how clinicians discuss uncertainty with patients.

Authors:  Maram Khazen; Erin E Sullivan; Jason Ramos; Maria Mirica; Mark Linzer; Gordon D Schiff; Andrew P J Olson
Journal:  BMC Prim Care       Date:  2022-06-17

6.  Bridging the Gap Between Competencies and Uncertainties in Postgraduate Training in Family Medicine: Results and Psychometric Properties of a Self-Assessment Questionnaire.

Authors:  Kristina Flägel; Marie-Therese Müller; Katja Goetz; Elisabeth Flum; Simon Schwill; Jost Steinhäuser
Journal:  Adv Med Educ Pract       Date:  2022-07-04

7.  The Bearable Lightness of Uncertainty.

Authors:  Denise L F Davis; Calvin L Chou
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2019-11       Impact factor: 5.128

8.  Improve Communicating Uncertainty in Intensive Care Unit With Patient and Family (ICU-PF).

Authors:  Anhar Alhussaini
Journal:  Cureus       Date:  2021-12-30

9.  Effective provider-patient communication of a rare disease diagnosis: A qualitative study of people diagnosed with schwannomatosis.

Authors:  Vanessa L Merker; Scott R Plotkin; Martin P Charns; Mark Meterko; Justin T Jordan; A Rani Elwy
Journal:  Patient Educ Couns       Date:  2020-09-28

10.  Communication about Prognosis during Patient-Initiated Second Opinion Consultations in Advanced Cancer Care: An Observational Qualitative Analysis.

Authors:  N C A van der Velden; M B A van der Kleij; V Lehmann; E M A Smets; J M L Stouthard; I Henselmans; M A Hillen
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2021-05-26       Impact factor: 3.390

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.