PURPOSE: To examine the validity of ultrasound (via cloud-based software that measures pixilation intensity according to a scale of 0-100) to noninvasively assess muscle glycogen in human skeletal muscle. METHODS: In study 1, 14 professional male rugby league players competed in an 80-min competitive rugby league game. In study 2 (in a randomized repeated measures design), 16 recreationally active males completed anexhaustive cycling protocol to deplete muscle glycogen followed by 36 h of HIGH or LOW carbohydrate intake (8 g·kg vs 3 g·kg body mass). In both studies, muscle biopsies and ultrasound scans were obtained from the vastus lateralis (at 50% of the muscle length) before and after match play in study 1 and at 36 h after glycogen depletion in study 2. RESULTS: Despite match play reducing (P < 0.01) muscle glycogen concentration (pregame: 443 ± 65; postgame: 271 ± 94 mmol·kg dw, respectively) in study 1, there were no significant changes (P = 0.4) in ultrasound scores (pregame: 47 ± 6, postgame: 49 ± 7). In study 2, muscle glycogen concentration was significantly different (P < 0.01) between HIGH (531 ±129 mmol·kg dw) and LOW (252 ± 64 mmol·kg dw) yet there was no difference (P = 0.9) in corresponding ultrasound scores (HIGH: 56 ± 7, LOW: 54 ± 6). In both studies, no significant correlations (P > 0.05) were present between changes in muscle glycogen concentration and changes in ultrasound scores. CONCLUSIONS: Data demonstrate that ultrasound (as based on measures of pixilation intensity) is not valid to measure muscle glycogen status within the physiological range (i.e., 200-500 mmol·kg dw) that is applicable to exercise-induced muscle glycogen utilization and postexercise muscle glycogen resynthesis.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To examine the validity of ultrasound (via cloud-based software that measures pixilation intensity according to a scale of 0-100) to noninvasively assess muscle glycogen in human skeletal muscle. METHODS: In study 1, 14 professional male rugby league players competed in an 80-min competitive rugby league game. In study 2 (in a randomized repeated measures design), 16 recreationally active males completed an exhaustive cycling protocol to deplete muscle glycogen followed by 36 h of HIGH or LOW carbohydrate intake (8 g·kg vs 3 g·kg body mass). In both studies, muscle biopsies and ultrasound scans were obtained from the vastus lateralis (at 50% of the muscle length) before and after match play in study 1 and at 36 h after glycogen depletion in study 2. RESULTS: Despite match play reducing (P < 0.01) muscle glycogen concentration (pregame: 443 ± 65; postgame: 271 ± 94 mmol·kg dw, respectively) in study 1, there were no significant changes (P = 0.4) in ultrasound scores (pregame: 47 ± 6, postgame: 49 ± 7). In study 2, muscle glycogen concentration was significantly different (P < 0.01) between HIGH (531 ±129 mmol·kg dw) and LOW (252 ± 64 mmol·kg dw) yet there was no difference (P = 0.9) in corresponding ultrasound scores (HIGH: 56 ± 7, LOW: 54 ± 6). In both studies, no significant correlations (P > 0.05) were present between changes in muscle glycogen concentration and changes in ultrasound scores. CONCLUSIONS: Data demonstrate that ultrasound (as based on measures of pixilation intensity) is not valid to measure muscle glycogen status within the physiological range (i.e., 200-500 mmol·kg dw) that is applicable to exercise-induced muscle glycogen utilization and postexercise muscle glycogen resynthesis.
Authors: Niels Ørtenblad; Joachim Nielsen; Kasper D Gejl; Harry E Routledge; James P Morton; Graeme L Close; David C Niemann; Julia L Bone; Louise M Burke Journal: Nutrients Date: 2020-07-13 Impact factor: 5.717