Weilong Li1, Dongfeng Zhang2, Weijing Wang2, Yili Wu2, Afsaneh Mohammadnejad1, Jesper Lund1, Jan Baumbach3,4, Lene Christiansen1,5, Qihua Tan6,7. 1. Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Department of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark. 2. Division of Epidemiology and Health Statistics, Qingdao University Medical College, Qingdao, China. 3. Chair of Experimental Bioinformatics, TUM School of Life Sciences, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany. 4. Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark. 5. Department of Clinical Immunology, Copenhagen University Hospital, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark. 6. Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Department of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark. qtan@health.sdu.dk. 7. Unit of Human Genetics, Department of Clinical Research, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark. qtan@health.sdu.dk.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Body mass index (BMI) serves as an important measurement of obesity and adiposity, which are highly correlated with cardiometabolic diseases. Although high heritability has been estimated, the identified genetic variants by genetic association studies only explain a small proportion of BMI variation. As an active effort for further exploring the molecular basis of BMI variation, large-scale epigenome-wide association studies have been conducted but with limited number of loci reported, perhaps due to poorly controlled confounding factors, including genetic factors. Being genetically identical, monozygotic twins discordant for BMI are ideal subjects for analyzing the epigenetic association between DNA methylation and BMI, providing perfect control on their genetic makeups largely responsible for BMI variation. SUBJECTS: We performed an epigenome-wide association study on BMI using 30 identical twin pairs (15 male and 15 female pairs) with age ranging from 39 to 72 years and degree of BMI discordance ranging from 3-7.5 kg/m2. Methylation data from whole blood samples were collected using the reduced representation bisulfite sequencing technique. RESULTS: After adjusting for blood cell composition and clinical variables, we identified 136 CpGs with p-value < 1e-4, 30 CpGs with p < 1e-05 but no CpGs reached genome-wide significance. Genomic region-based analysis found 11 differentially methylated regions harboring coding and non-coding genes some of which were validated by gene expression analysis on independent samples. CONCLUSIONS: Our DNA methylation sequencing analysis on identical twins provides new references for the epigenetic regulation on BMI and obesity.
OBJECTIVE: Body mass index (BMI) serves as an important measurement of obesity and adiposity, which are highly correlated with cardiometabolic diseases. Although high heritability has been estimated, the identified genetic variants by genetic association studies only explain a small proportion of BMI variation. As an active effort for further exploring the molecular basis of BMI variation, large-scale epigenome-wide association studies have been conducted but with limited number of loci reported, perhaps due to poorly controlled confounding factors, including genetic factors. Being genetically identical, monozygotic twins discordant for BMI are ideal subjects for analyzing the epigenetic association between DNA methylation and BMI, providing perfect control on their genetic makeups largely responsible for BMI variation. SUBJECTS: We performed an epigenome-wide association study on BMI using 30 identical twin pairs (15 male and 15 female pairs) with age ranging from 39 to 72 years and degree of BMI discordance ranging from 3-7.5 kg/m2. Methylation data from whole blood samples were collected using the reduced representation bisulfite sequencing technique. RESULTS: After adjusting for blood cell composition and clinical variables, we identified 136 CpGs with p-value < 1e-4, 30 CpGs with p < 1e-05 but no CpGs reached genome-wide significance. Genomic region-based analysis found 11 differentially methylated regions harboring coding and non-coding genes some of which were validated by gene expression analysis on independent samples. CONCLUSIONS: Our DNA methylation sequencing analysis on identical twins provides new references for the epigenetic regulation on BMI and obesity.
Authors: Amy Berrington de Gonzalez; Patricia Hartge; James R Cerhan; Alan J Flint; Lindsay Hannan; Robert J MacInnis; Steven C Moore; Geoffrey S Tobias; Hoda Anton-Culver; Laura Beane Freeman; W Lawrence Beeson; Sandra L Clipp; Dallas R English; Aaron R Folsom; D Michal Freedman; Graham Giles; Niclas Hakansson; Katherine D Henderson; Judith Hoffman-Bolton; Jane A Hoppin; Karen L Koenig; I-Min Lee; Martha S Linet; Yikyung Park; Gaia Pocobelli; Arthur Schatzkin; Howard D Sesso; Elisabete Weiderpass; Bradley J Willcox; Alicja Wolk; Anne Zeleniuch-Jacquotte; Walter C Willett; Michael J Thun Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2010-12-02 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Peter M Visscher; Naomi R Wray; Qian Zhang; Pamela Sklar; Mark I McCarthy; Matthew A Brown; Jian Yang Journal: Am J Hum Genet Date: 2017-07-06 Impact factor: 11.025
Authors: Adam E Locke; Bratati Kahali; Sonja I Berndt; Anne E Justice; Tune H Pers; Felix R Day; Corey Powell; Sailaja Vedantam; Martin L Buchkovich; Jian Yang; Damien C Croteau-Chonka; Tonu Esko; Tove Fall; Teresa Ferreira; Stefan Gustafsson; Zoltán Kutalik; Jian'an Luan; Reedik Mägi; Joshua C Randall; Thomas W Winkler; Andrew R Wood; Tsegaselassie Workalemahu; Jessica D Faul; Jennifer A Smith; Jing Hua Zhao; Wei Zhao; Jin Chen; Rudolf Fehrmann; Åsa K Hedman; Juha Karjalainen; Ellen M Schmidt; Devin Absher; Najaf Amin; Denise Anderson; Marian Beekman; Jennifer L Bolton; Jennifer L Bragg-Gresham; Steven Buyske; Ayse Demirkan; Guohong Deng; Georg B Ehret; Bjarke Feenstra; Mary F Feitosa; Krista Fischer; Anuj Goel; Jian Gong; Anne U Jackson; Stavroula Kanoni; Marcus E Kleber; Kati Kristiansson; Unhee Lim; Vaneet Lotay; Massimo Mangino; Irene Mateo Leach; Carolina Medina-Gomez; Sarah E Medland; Michael A Nalls; Cameron D Palmer; Dorota Pasko; Sonali Pechlivanis; Marjolein J Peters; Inga Prokopenko; Dmitry Shungin; Alena Stančáková; Rona J Strawbridge; Yun Ju Sung; Toshiko Tanaka; Alexander Teumer; Stella Trompet; Sander W van der Laan; Jessica van Setten; Jana V Van Vliet-Ostaptchouk; Zhaoming Wang; Loïc Yengo; Weihua Zhang; Aaron Isaacs; Eva Albrecht; Johan Ärnlöv; Gillian M Arscott; Antony P Attwood; Stefania Bandinelli; Amy Barrett; Isabelita N Bas; Claire Bellis; Amanda J Bennett; Christian Berne; Roza Blagieva; Matthias Blüher; Stefan Böhringer; Lori L Bonnycastle; Yvonne Böttcher; Heather A Boyd; Marcel Bruinenberg; Ida H Caspersen; Yii-Der Ida Chen; Robert Clarke; E Warwick Daw; Anton J M de Craen; Graciela Delgado; Maria Dimitriou; Alex S F Doney; Niina Eklund; Karol Estrada; Elodie Eury; Lasse Folkersen; Ross M Fraser; Melissa E Garcia; Frank Geller; Vilmantas Giedraitis; Bruna Gigante; Alan S Go; Alain Golay; Alison H Goodall; Scott D Gordon; Mathias Gorski; Hans-Jörgen Grabe; Harald Grallert; Tanja B Grammer; Jürgen Gräßler; Henrik Grönberg; Christopher J Groves; Gaëlle Gusto; Jeffrey Haessler; Per Hall; Toomas Haller; Goran Hallmans; Catharina A Hartman; Maija Hassinen; Caroline Hayward; Nancy L Heard-Costa; Quinta Helmer; Christian Hengstenberg; Oddgeir Holmen; Jouke-Jan Hottenga; Alan L James; Janina M Jeff; Åsa Johansson; Jennifer Jolley; Thorhildur Juliusdottir; Leena Kinnunen; Wolfgang Koenig; Markku Koskenvuo; Wolfgang Kratzer; Jaana Laitinen; Claudia Lamina; Karin Leander; Nanette R Lee; Peter Lichtner; Lars Lind; Jaana Lindström; Ken Sin Lo; Stéphane Lobbens; Roberto Lorbeer; Yingchang Lu; François Mach; Patrik K E Magnusson; Anubha Mahajan; Wendy L McArdle; Stela McLachlan; Cristina Menni; Sigrun Merger; Evelin Mihailov; Lili Milani; Alireza Moayyeri; Keri L Monda; Mario A Morken; Antonella Mulas; Gabriele Müller; Martina Müller-Nurasyid; Arthur W Musk; Ramaiah Nagaraja; Markus M Nöthen; Ilja M Nolte; Stefan Pilz; Nigel W Rayner; Frida Renstrom; Rainer Rettig; Janina S Ried; Stephan Ripke; Neil R Robertson; Lynda M Rose; Serena Sanna; Hubert Scharnagl; Salome Scholtens; Fredrick R Schumacher; William R Scott; Thomas Seufferlein; Jianxin Shi; Albert Vernon Smith; Joanna Smolonska; Alice V Stanton; Valgerdur Steinthorsdottir; Kathleen Stirrups; Heather M Stringham; Johan Sundström; Morris A Swertz; Amy J Swift; Ann-Christine Syvänen; Sian-Tsung Tan; Bamidele O Tayo; Barbara Thorand; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Jonathan P Tyrer; Hae-Won Uh; Liesbeth Vandenput; Frank C Verhulst; Sita H Vermeulen; Niek Verweij; Judith M Vonk; Lindsay L Waite; Helen R Warren; Dawn Waterworth; Michael N Weedon; Lynne R Wilkens; Christina Willenborg; Tom Wilsgaard; Mary K Wojczynski; Andrew Wong; Alan F Wright; Qunyuan Zhang; Eoin P Brennan; Murim Choi; Zari Dastani; Alexander W Drong; Per Eriksson; Anders Franco-Cereceda; Jesper R Gådin; Ali G Gharavi; Michael E Goddard; Robert E Handsaker; Jinyan Huang; Fredrik Karpe; Sekar Kathiresan; Sarah Keildson; Krzysztof Kiryluk; Michiaki Kubo; Jong-Young Lee; Liming Liang; Richard P Lifton; Baoshan Ma; Steven A McCarroll; Amy J McKnight; Josine L Min; Miriam F Moffatt; Grant W Montgomery; Joanne M Murabito; George Nicholson; Dale R Nyholt; Yukinori Okada; John R B Perry; Rajkumar Dorajoo; Eva Reinmaa; Rany M Salem; Niina Sandholm; Robert A Scott; Lisette Stolk; Atsushi Takahashi; Toshihiro Tanaka; Ferdinand M van 't Hooft; Anna A E Vinkhuyzen; Harm-Jan Westra; Wei Zheng; Krina T Zondervan; Andrew C Heath; Dominique Arveiler; Stephan J L Bakker; John Beilby; Richard N Bergman; John Blangero; Pascal Bovet; Harry Campbell; Mark J Caulfield; Giancarlo Cesana; Aravinda Chakravarti; Daniel I Chasman; Peter S Chines; Francis S Collins; Dana C Crawford; L Adrienne Cupples; Daniele Cusi; John Danesh; Ulf de Faire; Hester M den Ruijter; Anna F Dominiczak; Raimund Erbel; Jeanette Erdmann; Johan G Eriksson; Martin Farrall; Stephan B Felix; Ele Ferrannini; Jean Ferrières; Ian Ford; Nita G Forouhi; Terrence Forrester; Oscar H Franco; Ron T Gansevoort; Pablo V Gejman; Christian Gieger; Omri Gottesman; Vilmundur Gudnason; Ulf Gyllensten; Alistair S Hall; Tamara B Harris; Andrew T Hattersley; Andrew A Hicks; Lucia A Hindorff; Aroon D Hingorani; Albert Hofman; Georg Homuth; G Kees Hovingh; Steve E Humphries; Steven C Hunt; Elina Hyppönen; Thomas Illig; Kevin B Jacobs; Marjo-Riitta Jarvelin; Karl-Heinz Jöckel; Berit Johansen; Pekka Jousilahti; J Wouter Jukema; Antti M Jula; Jaakko Kaprio; John J P Kastelein; Sirkka M Keinanen-Kiukaanniemi; Lambertus A Kiemeney; Paul Knekt; Jaspal S Kooner; Charles Kooperberg; Peter Kovacs; Aldi T Kraja; Meena Kumari; Johanna Kuusisto; Timo A Lakka; Claudia Langenberg; Loic Le Marchand; Terho Lehtimäki; Valeriya Lyssenko; Satu Männistö; André Marette; Tara C Matise; Colin A McKenzie; Barbara McKnight; Frans L Moll; Andrew D Morris; Andrew P Morris; Jeffrey C Murray; Mari Nelis; Claes Ohlsson; Albertine J Oldehinkel; Ken K Ong; Pamela A F Madden; Gerard Pasterkamp; John F Peden; Annette Peters; Dirkje S Postma; Peter P Pramstaller; Jackie F Price; Lu Qi; Olli T Raitakari; Tuomo Rankinen; D C Rao; Treva K Rice; Paul M Ridker; John D Rioux; Marylyn D Ritchie; Igor Rudan; Veikko Salomaa; Nilesh J Samani; Jouko Saramies; Mark A Sarzynski; Heribert Schunkert; Peter E H Schwarz; Peter Sever; Alan R Shuldiner; Juha Sinisalo; Ronald P Stolk; Konstantin Strauch; Anke Tönjes; David-Alexandre Trégouët; Angelo Tremblay; Elena Tremoli; Jarmo Virtamo; Marie-Claude Vohl; Uwe Völker; Gérard Waeber; Gonneke Willemsen; Jacqueline C Witteman; M Carola Zillikens; Linda S Adair; Philippe Amouyel; Folkert W Asselbergs; Themistocles L Assimes; Murielle Bochud; Bernhard O Boehm; Eric Boerwinkle; Stefan R Bornstein; Erwin P Bottinger; Claude Bouchard; Stéphane Cauchi; John C Chambers; Stephen J Chanock; Richard S Cooper; Paul I W de Bakker; George Dedoussis; Luigi Ferrucci; Paul W Franks; Philippe Froguel; Leif C Groop; Christopher A Haiman; Anders Hamsten; Jennie Hui; David J Hunter; Kristian Hveem; Robert C Kaplan; Mika Kivimaki; Diana Kuh; Markku Laakso; Yongmei Liu; Nicholas G Martin; Winfried März; Mads Melbye; Andres Metspalu; Susanne Moebus; Patricia B Munroe; Inger Njølstad; Ben A Oostra; Colin N A Palmer; Nancy L Pedersen; Markus Perola; Louis Pérusse; Ulrike Peters; Chris Power; Thomas Quertermous; Rainer Rauramaa; Fernando Rivadeneira; Timo E Saaristo; Danish Saleheen; Naveed Sattar; Eric E Schadt; David Schlessinger; P Eline Slagboom; Harold Snieder; Tim D Spector; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Michael Stumvoll; Jaakko Tuomilehto; André G Uitterlinden; Matti Uusitupa; Pim van der Harst; Mark Walker; Henri Wallaschofski; Nicholas J Wareham; Hugh Watkins; David R Weir; H-Erich Wichmann; James F Wilson; Pieter Zanen; Ingrid B Borecki; Panos Deloukas; Caroline S Fox; Iris M Heid; Jeffrey R O'Connell; David P Strachan; Kari Stefansson; Cornelia M van Duijn; Gonçalo R Abecasis; Lude Franke; Timothy M Frayling; Mark I McCarthy; Peter M Visscher; André Scherag; Cristen J Willer; Michael Boehnke; Karen L Mohlke; Cecilia M Lindgren; Jacques S Beckmann; Inês Barroso; Kari E North; Erik Ingelsson; Joel N Hirschhorn; Ruth J F Loos; Elizabeth K Speliotes Journal: Nature Date: 2015-02-12 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Katherine J Dick; Christopher P Nelson; Loukia Tsaprouni; Johanna K Sandling; Dylan Aïssi; Simone Wahl; Eshwar Meduri; Pierre-Emmanuel Morange; France Gagnon; Harald Grallert; Melanie Waldenberger; Annette Peters; Jeanette Erdmann; Christian Hengstenberg; Francois Cambien; Alison H Goodall; Willem H Ouwehand; Heribert Schunkert; John R Thompson; Tim D Spector; Christian Gieger; David-Alexandre Trégouët; Panos Deloukas; Nilesh J Samani Journal: Lancet Date: 2014-03-13 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Simone Wahl; Alexander Drong; Benjamin Lehne; Marie Loh; William R Scott; Sonja Kunze; Pei-Chien Tsai; Janina S Ried; Weihua Zhang; Youwen Yang; Sili Tan; Giovanni Fiorito; Lude Franke; Simonetta Guarrera; Silva Kasela; Jennifer Kriebel; Rebecca C Richmond; Marco Adamo; Uzma Afzal; Mika Ala-Korpela; Benedetta Albetti; Ole Ammerpohl; Jane F Apperley; Marian Beekman; Pier Alberto Bertazzi; S Lucas Black; Christine Blancher; Marc-Jan Bonder; Mario Brosch; Maren Carstensen-Kirberg; Anton J M de Craen; Simon de Lusignan; Abbas Dehghan; Mohamed Elkalaawy; Krista Fischer; Oscar H Franco; Tom R Gaunt; Jochen Hampe; Majid Hashemi; Aaron Isaacs; Andrew Jenkinson; Sujeet Jha; Norihiro Kato; Vittorio Krogh; Michael Laffan; Christa Meisinger; Thomas Meitinger; Zuan Yu Mok; Valeria Motta; Hong Kiat Ng; Zacharoula Nikolakopoulou; Georgios Nteliopoulos; Salvatore Panico; Natalia Pervjakova; Holger Prokisch; Wolfgang Rathmann; Michael Roden; Federica Rota; Michelle Ann Rozario; Johanna K Sandling; Clemens Schafmayer; Katharina Schramm; Reiner Siebert; P Eline Slagboom; Pasi Soininen; Lisette Stolk; Konstantin Strauch; E-Shyong Tai; Letizia Tarantini; Barbara Thorand; Ettje F Tigchelaar; Rosario Tumino; Andre G Uitterlinden; Cornelia van Duijn; Joyce B J van Meurs; Paolo Vineis; Ananda Rajitha Wickremasinghe; Cisca Wijmenga; Tsun-Po Yang; Wei Yuan; Alexandra Zhernakova; Rachel L Batterham; George Davey Smith; Panos Deloukas; Bastiaan T Heijmans; Christian Herder; Albert Hofman; Cecilia M Lindgren; Lili Milani; Pim van der Harst; Annette Peters; Thomas Illig; Caroline L Relton; Melanie Waldenberger; Marjo-Riitta Järvelin; Valentina Bollati; Richie Soong; Tim D Spector; James Scott; Mark I McCarthy; Paul Elliott; Jordana T Bell; Giuseppe Matullo; Christian Gieger; Jaspal S Kooner; Harald Grallert; John C Chambers Journal: Nature Date: 2016-12-21 Impact factor: 49.962