Nashwa Khogali-Jakary1, John J Kanitra2, Pamela S Haan3, Cheryl I Anderson3, Alan T Davis3, David Henry4, Rama Gupta3, Caroline Moon3, Terry McLeod3, Elahé T Crockett5, Srinivas Kavuturu6. 1. , Troy, USA. 2. Department of Surgery, Ascension St. John Hospital and Medical Center, Detroit, MI, 48236, USA. 3. Department of Surgery, Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, 1200 E. Michigan Ave, Suite 655, Lansing, MI, 48912, USA. 4. , Kailua, USA. 5. Department of Medicine, Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, East Lansing, MI, 48824, USA. 6. Department of Surgery, Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, 1200 E. Michigan Ave, Suite 655, Lansing, MI, 48912, USA. Srinivas.Kavuturu@hc.msu.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The influence of visual-spatial discordance during training on laparoscopic skills is poorly understood. It has been proposed that training in visual-spatial discordant situations can improve performance in the forward alignment, which was the basis of our hypothesis. Our study's aim was to conduct a randomized control trial to explore the impact of simulated training in visual-spatial discordant situations on forward alignment performance. METHODS: The participants were 80 medical students who were randomized into four groups. Group A served as the control and performed all peg transfers in the forward alignment. Groups B, C, and D experienced varied rounds of either increasing or decreasing sensorimotor discordance. The students were trained and tested using the peg transfer task used in the Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery curriculum. Based on the group, each student performed 10 peg transfer practice rounds in their assigned alignment. After each practice session, each student was tested and scored in forward alignment performance. A baseline test, followed by three practice sessions, and three tests were done. RESULTS: Group A (control) demonstrated a statistically significant overall increase in scoring of 37.1% from baseline when compared to the final test. Groups B, C, and D showed improvements of 3.7%, 27.1%, and 19.3%, respectively, between baseline and the final test, yet none demonstrated consistent linear improvements. On multi-variate analysis, students who practiced in the side or reverse alignment positions scored 25 and 37 points lower, respectively, than students who practiced in the forward alignment. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that training in visual-spatial discordant conditions does not lead to the development of forward alignment laparoscopic skills. This could have important implications when developing future laparoscopic skills training curriculums. To our knowledge, this is the largest study to date assessing the impacts of training in visual-spatial discordance situations on performance in the forward alignment.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: The influence of visual-spatial discordance during training on laparoscopic skills is poorly understood. It has been proposed that training in visual-spatial discordant situations can improve performance in the forward alignment, which was the basis of our hypothesis. Our study's aim was to conduct a randomized control trial to explore the impact of simulated training in visual-spatial discordant situations on forward alignment performance. METHODS: The participants were 80 medical students who were randomized into four groups. Group A served as the control and performed all peg transfers in the forward alignment. Groups B, C, and D experienced varied rounds of either increasing or decreasing sensorimotor discordance. The students were trained and tested using the peg transfer task used in the Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery curriculum. Based on the group, each student performed 10 peg transfer practice rounds in their assigned alignment. After each practice session, each student was tested and scored in forward alignment performance. A baseline test, followed by three practice sessions, and three tests were done. RESULTS: Group A (control) demonstrated a statistically significant overall increase in scoring of 37.1% from baseline when compared to the final test. Groups B, C, and D showed improvements of 3.7%, 27.1%, and 19.3%, respectively, between baseline and the final test, yet none demonstrated consistent linear improvements. On multi-variate analysis, students who practiced in the side or reverse alignment positions scored 25 and 37 points lower, respectively, than students who practiced in the forward alignment. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that training in visual-spatial discordant conditions does not lead to the development of forward alignment laparoscopic skills. This could have important implications when developing future laparoscopic skills training curriculums. To our knowledge, this is the largest study to date assessing the impacts of training in visual-spatial discordance situations on performance in the forward alignment.
Entities:
Keywords:
Education; Laparoscopic skills; Laparoscopic training practice; Training; Visual motor coordination; Visual-spatial discordant
Authors: Jeffrey H Peters; Gerald M Fried; Lee L Swanstrom; Nathaniel J Soper; Lelan F Sillin; Bruce Schirmer; Kaaren Hoffman Journal: Surgery Date: 2004-01 Impact factor: 3.982
Authors: Ward J Dunnican; T Paul Singh; Ashar Ata; Emma E Bendana; Thomas D Conlee; Charles J Dolce; Rakesh Ramakrishnan Journal: Surg Innov Date: 2010-06 Impact factor: 2.058