Jeffrey H Silber1, Lisa M Bellini1, Judy A Shea1, Sanjay V Desai1, David F Dinges1, Mathias Basner1, Orit Even-Shoshan1, Alexander S Hill1, Lauren L Hochman1, Joel T Katz1, Richard N Ross1, David M Shade1, Dylan S Small1, Alice L Sternberg1, James Tonascia1, Kevin G Volpp1, David A Asch1. 1. From the Center for Outcomes Research, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (J.H.S., O.E.-S., A.S.H., L.L.H., R.N.R.), the Departments of Pediatrics (J.H.S.), Anesthesiology and Critical Care (J.H.S.), and Medicine (L.M.B., J.A.S., K.G.V., D.A.A.), University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, the Departments of Health Care Management (J.H.S., K.G.V., D.A.A.) and Statistics (D.S.S.), the Wharton School, the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics (J.H.S., J.A.S., D.S.S., K.G.V., D.A.A.), and the Department of Psychiatry (D.F.D., M.B.), University of Pennsylvania, and the Corporal Michael J. Crescenz Veterans Affairs Medical Center (K.G.V., D.A.A.) - all in Philadelphia; the Departments of Medicine (S.V.D.), Epidemiology (D.M.S., A.L.S., J.T.), and Biostatistics (J.T.), Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore; and the Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston (J.T.K.).
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Concern persists that extended shifts in medical residency programs may adversely affect patient safety. METHODS: We conducted a cluster-randomized noninferiority trial in 63 internal-medicine residency programs during the 2015-2016 academic year. Programs underwent randomization to a group with standard duty hours, as adopted by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) in July 2011, or to a group with more flexible duty-hour rules that did not specify limits on shift length or mandatory time off between shifts. The primary outcome for each program was the change in unadjusted 30-day mortality from the pretrial year to the trial year, as ascertained from Medicare claims. We hypothesized that the change in 30-day mortality in the flexible programs would not be worse than the change in the standard programs (difference-in-difference analysis) by more than 1 percentage point (noninferiority margin). Secondary outcomes were changes in five other patient safety measures and risk-adjusted outcomes for all measures. RESULTS: The change in 30-day mortality (primary outcome) among the patients in the flexible programs (12.5% in the trial year vs. 12.6% in the pretrial year) was noninferior to that in the standard programs (12.2% in the trial year vs. 12.7% in the pretrial year). The test for noninferiority was significant (P = 0.03), with an estimate of the upper limit of the one-sided 95% confidence interval (0.93%) for a between-group difference in the change in mortality that was less than the prespecified noninferiority margin of 1 percentage point. Differences in changes between the flexible programs and the standard programs in the unadjusted rate of readmission at 7 days, patient safety indicators, and Medicare payments were also below 1 percentage point; the noninferiority criterion was not met for 30-day readmissions or prolonged length of hospital stay. Risk-adjusted measures generally showed similar findings. CONCLUSIONS: Allowing program directors flexibility in adjusting duty-hour schedules for trainees did not adversely affect 30-day mortality or several other measured outcomes of patient safety. (Funded by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education; iCOMPARE ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT02274818.).
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Concern persists that extended shifts in medical residency programs may adversely affect patient safety. METHODS: We conducted a cluster-randomized noninferiority trial in 63 internal-medicine residency programs during the 2015-2016 academic year. Programs underwent randomization to a group with standard duty hours, as adopted by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) in July 2011, or to a group with more flexible duty-hour rules that did not specify limits on shift length or mandatory time off between shifts. The primary outcome for each program was the change in unadjusted 30-day mortality from the pretrial year to the trial year, as ascertained from Medicare claims. We hypothesized that the change in 30-day mortality in the flexible programs would not be worse than the change in the standard programs (difference-in-difference analysis) by more than 1 percentage point (noninferiority margin). Secondary outcomes were changes in five other patient safety measures and risk-adjusted outcomes for all measures. RESULTS: The change in 30-day mortality (primary outcome) among the patients in the flexible programs (12.5% in the trial year vs. 12.6% in the pretrial year) was noninferior to that in the standard programs (12.2% in the trial year vs. 12.7% in the pretrial year). The test for noninferiority was significant (P = 0.03), with an estimate of the upper limit of the one-sided 95% confidence interval (0.93%) for a between-group difference in the change in mortality that was less than the prespecified noninferiority margin of 1 percentage point. Differences in changes between the flexible programs and the standard programs in the unadjusted rate of readmission at 7 days, patient safety indicators, and Medicare payments were also below 1 percentage point; the noninferiority criterion was not met for 30-day readmissions or prolonged length of hospital stay. Risk-adjusted measures generally showed similar findings. CONCLUSIONS: Allowing program directors flexibility in adjusting duty-hour schedules for trainees did not adversely affect 30-day mortality or several other measured outcomes of patient safety. (Funded by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education; iCOMPARE ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT02274818.).
Authors: E P McCarthy; L I Iezzoni; R B Davis; R H Palmer; M Cahalane; M B Hamel; K Mukamal; R S Phillips; D T Davies Journal: Med Care Date: 2000-08 Impact factor: 2.983
Authors: Elizabeth E Drye; Sharon-Lise T Normand; Yun Wang; Joseph S Ross; Geoffrey C Schreiner; Lein Han; Michael Rapp; Harlan M Krumholz Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2012-01-03 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Jeffrey H Silber; Paul R Rosenbaum; Amy K Rosen; Patrick S Romano; Kamal M F Itani; Liyi Cen; Lanyu Mi; Michael J Halenar; Orit Even-Shoshan; Kevin G Volpp Journal: Med Care Date: 2009-12 Impact factor: 2.983
Authors: Amy K Rosen; Susan A Loveland; Patrick S Romano; Kamal M F Itani; Jeffrey H Silber; Orit O Even-Shoshan; Michael J Halenar; Yun Teng; Jingsan Zhu; Kevin G Volpp Journal: Med Care Date: 2009-07 Impact factor: 2.983
Authors: Kevin G Volpp; Amy K Rosen; Paul R Rosenbaum; Patrick S Romano; Kamal M F Itani; Lisa Bellini; Orit Even-Shoshan; Liyi Cen; Yanli Wang; Michael J Halenar; Jeffrey H Silber Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2009-05-20 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Kevin G Volpp; Amy K Rosen; Paul R Rosenbaum; Patrick S Romano; Orit Even-Shoshan; Yanli Wang; Lisa Bellini; Tiffany Behringer; Jeffrey H Silber Journal: JAMA Date: 2007-09-05 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Kevin G Volpp; Amy K Rosen; Paul R Rosenbaum; Patrick S Romano; Orit Even-Shoshan; Anne Canamucio; Lisa Bellini; Tiffany Behringer; Jeffrey H Silber Journal: JAMA Date: 2007-09-05 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Jeffrey H Silber; Paul R Rosenbaum; Orit Even-Shoshan; Mayadah Shabbout; Xuemei Zhang; Eric T Bradlow; Roger R Marsh Journal: Health Serv Res Date: 2003-06 Impact factor: 3.402
Authors: Jeffrey H Silber; Paul R Rosenbaum; Rachel R Kelz; Caroline E Reinke; Mark D Neuman; Richard N Ross; Orit Even-Shoshan; Guy David; Philip A Saynisch; Fabienne A Kyle; Dale W Bratzler; Lee A Fleisher Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2012-07 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Terri Blackwell; Dana R Kriesel; Eric Vittinghoff; Conor S O'Brien; Jason P Sullivan; Natalie C Viyaran; Shadab A Rahman; Steven W Lockley; Laura K Barger; Ann C Halbower; Sue E Poynter; Kenneth P Wright; Pearl L Yu; Phyllis C Zee; Christopher P Landrigan; Charles A Czeisler; Katie L Stone Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2019-03-15 Impact factor: 2.226
Authors: Christopher P Landrigan; Shadab A Rahman; Jason P Sullivan; Eric Vittinghoff; Laura K Barger; Amy L Sanderson; Kenneth P Wright; Conor S O'Brien; Salim Qadri; Melissa A St Hilaire; Ann C Halbower; Jeffrey L Segar; John K McGuire; Michael V Vitiello; Horacio O de la Iglesia; Sue E Poynter; Pearl L Yu; Phyllis C Zee; Steven W Lockley; Katie L Stone; Charles A Czeisler Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2020-06-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Matthew D Weaver; Christopher P Landrigan; Jason P Sullivan; Conor S O'Brien; Salim Qadri; Natalie Viyaran; Wei Wang; Céline Vetter; Charles A Czeisler; Laura K Barger Journal: Am J Med Date: 2020-02-13 Impact factor: 4.965
Authors: Makayla Cordoza; Mathias Basner; David A Asch; Judy A Shea; Lisa M Bellini; Michele Carlin; Adrian J Ecker; Susan K Malone; Sanjay V Desai; Joel T Katz; David W Bates; Dylan S Small; Kevin G Volpp; Christopher G Mott; Sara Coats; Daniel J Mollicone; David F Dinges Journal: J Grad Med Educ Date: 2021-10-15
Authors: Mathias Basner; David A Asch; Judy A Shea; Lisa M Bellini; Michele Carlin; Adrian J Ecker; Susan K Malone; Sanjay V Desai; Alice L Sternberg; James Tonascia; David M Shade; Joel T Katz; David W Bates; Orit Even-Shoshan; Jeffrey H Silber; Dylan S Small; Kevin G Volpp; Christopher G Mott; Sara Coats; Daniel J Mollicone; David F Dinges Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2019-03-07 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Shadab A Rahman; Jason P Sullivan; Laura K Barger; Melissa A St Hilaire; Conor S O'Brien; Katie L Stone; Andrew J K Phillips; Elizabeth B Klerman; Salim Qadri; Kenneth P Wright; Ann C Halbower; Jeffrey L Segar; John K McGuire; Michael V Vitiello; Horacio O de la Iglesia; Sue E Poynter; Pearl L Yu; Amy L Sanderson; Phyllis C Zee; Christopher P Landrigan; Charles A Czeisler; Steven W Lockley Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2021-02-22 Impact factor: 7.124