| Literature DB >> 30834116 |
Lauren R Sastre1, Stephanie Matson2, Kenneth J Gruber3, Lauren Haldeman4.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To examine medical provider (n = 16) perceptions in addressing and managing pediatric obesity with a diverse, low-income patient population.Entities:
Keywords: Pediatric; counseling; diet; food; nutrition; obesity
Year: 2019 PMID: 30834116 PMCID: PMC6396046 DOI: 10.1177/2050312119834117
Source DB: PubMed Journal: SAGE Open Med ISSN: 2050-3121
Medical providers interview guide.
| 1. How long have you been at TAPM? |
Initiating weight discussions.
| Themes | Quotations | MD/NP (n = 16) | RD (n = 2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initiated ⩽2 years of age | MP12: Usually around two because that’s when they start charting the BMI charts. | n = 12 | n/a |
| Initiated 4–5 years | MP2: I typically start getting into it around age four or five … I would be less likely to dive into talking about a kid’s BMI if they’re kind of on the borderline at that age, as I would be say a fourteen year old. | n = 2 | n/a |
| Comfortable initiating weight discussions | D MP6: Very [comfortable]. I think that I have gotten over the fear of using the word obesity, because I feel like, you know I explain I’m not trying to be offensive, this is a medical term and that it has nothing to do with how your child looks it’s all about your child’s health. | n = 12 | n = 2 |
| Somewhat comfortable initiating weight discussions | MP1: A little uncomfortable with it, and that’s before I started working a lot more with the nutrition department, as a result it has become something I am more comfortable with. | n = 3 | |
| Utilizes a growth chart | MP4: I generally show them the growth chart first and kinda show them where their height is and where their weight is and I explain how the BMI works, and the categories related to that, so if their fallen in overweight vs. obese. | n = 5 | n = 2 |
| Uses family history/risk factors | MP10: I usually ask them if they have any concerns about the child’s weight or if they want to discuss it or if they think it’s a problem … it’s surprising, some kids are way above the 97th percentile and the parents never even mention weight as a concern. They feel it’s normal or it’s fine and their healthy. | n = 7 | |
| Open-ended question about weight | MP8: I normally ask if the family sees an issue, does your child seem overweight to you? Is it something that you’re worried about? Is it something you’d like help with? | n = 6 | n = 2 |
| Physical appearance | MP5: Kinda lay it on the line, going look you know most girls don’t like heavy guys. I did have one guy say no, some girls like heavy guys, ah you’re defeating the point here. | n = 1 |
MP: Medical Providers; RD: registered dietitian.
MP includes medical doctors/physicians (MDs) and nurse practitioners (NPs).
Weight counseling advice, observed changes, and influencing patients.
| Themes | Quotations | MD/NP (n = 16) | RD (n = 2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advice includes physical activity | MP3: I give them ideas about getting a jump rope … I tell them they don’t have to do their whole hour all at once … very few come back for the follow up and the ones that come back are not exercising. | n = 12 | n = 2 |
| Advice includes nutrition | MP5: I just try to be caring and compassionate and realize this isn’t a quick fix, this did not occur overnight, it’s not any one person’s fault. It’s that there’s a lot of different things that need to go on, small changes every day need to happen, like eating slower is probably the most important … not eating in front of the TV, but if you do you know you get your portion, you don’t get the whole bag of chips. | n = 7 | n = 2 |
| Nutrition perceived as difficult | MP2: When I’m talking about weight I talk about both aspects, again I would say that they’re more receptive to the physical activity part because that’s something that is hard to disagree with, … the nutrition stuff I feel like there is a lot more gray area in | n = 2 | |
| Some, or half of patients show changes post counseling | MP9: Some have done really well. I have children, I’ve got teenagers, and have lost weight, I have kids that the BMI just slows down. And we talk to them, I say you know look over the last two years we’ve gone from being, you know, high 90th percentile to being 85th. | n = 7 | n = 2 |
| Rare to observe changes post counseling efforts | MP8: Getting a parent to report that they’ve made changes in un-common. Just a real treat for us to have that positive effect. I mean, you know, I do see kids who lose weight. It just doesn’t happen very often. | n = 3 | |
| More visits needed, or patient compliance to follow-up visits for success post counseling | MP3: I always see them back a month later and very few of them, very few of them come back for the follow up and the ones that come back are not exercising. | n = 5 | n = 1 |
| Family/parents/home environment believed to be the greatest influence on behavior change in pediatric patients | MP1: The parents of the kids. Honestly we give them the tools, if they’re going to end up being successful, it’s because they’ve made the changes. | n = 11 | |
| Perceptions of RD in weight management | MP2: I would say that the dietitian does, I think I do to some extent but I think that the dietician has better success than I do in that area, if that makes sense. | n = 3 | n/a |
MP: medical providers; RD: registered dietitian.
MP includes medical doctors/physicians (MDs) and nurse practitioners (NPs).
Barriers to weight counseling.
| Themes | Quotations | MD/NP (n = 16) | RD (n = 2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lack of time | MP4: Um, time. You know we get ten fifteen minutes with most patients and they’re not usually here for their weight they’re here for something else. So time is always a factor, and two and just the | n = 5 | |
| Language/culture | MP9: Some of the foreign populations, chubby babies are healthy babies, and ah I think there are the barriers, sometimes you don’t wanna offend anybody, and you don’t want to make people feel bad. | n = 4 | n = 2 |
| Parents (parental weight, lack of awareness of weight, belief weight is normal/healthy, etc.) | MP10: Parents who have been battling with weight tend to be a little more defensive, and they kinda get upset thinking we’re talking about their parenting. | n = 14 |
MP: medical providers; RD: registered dietitian.
MP includes medical doctors/physicians (MDs) and nurse practitioners (NPs).