| Literature DB >> 30737262 |
Adam Sutherland1,2,3, Darren M Ashcroft1,3, Denham L Phipps1,3.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To explore the factors contributing to prescribing error in paediatric intensive care units (PICUs) using a human factors approach based on Reason's theory of error causation to support planning of interventions to mitigate slips and lapses, rules-based mistakes and knowledge-based mistakes.Entities:
Keywords: human factors; medication errors; paediatric intensive care; prescribing errors
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2019 PMID: 30737262 PMCID: PMC6557218 DOI: 10.1136/archdischild-2018-315981
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Arch Dis Child ISSN: 0003-9888 Impact factor: 3.791
Description of participants
| Participant reference | Profession |
| Site 1 | |
| A1 | Consultant intensivist (also joined the SHERPA session) |
| A2 | Paediatric trainee |
| A3 | Anaesthetic trainee |
| A4 | PICU trainee |
| A5 | Anaesthetic trainee |
| Site 2 | |
| R1 | Advanced nurse practitioner |
| R2 | PICU trainee |
| R3 | Consultant intensivist |
| R4 | Advanced nurse practitioner |
| R5 | Consultant intensivist |
| R6 | Paediatric trainee |
| SHERPA session | |
| E1 | PICU research nurse |
| E2 | Consultant intensivist |
| E3 | PICU pharmacist |
PICU, paediatric intensive care unit; SHERPA, Systematic Human Error reduction and Prediction Approach.
Characteristics of participating sites
| PICU1 | PICU2 | |
| Admissions/year | 850 | 750 |
| Full time equivalents consultants | 12 | 10 |
| Cardiac surgery | Yes | No |
| Prescribing system | Paper based | Paper based |
PICU, paediatric intensive care unit.
Figure 1PICU, paediatric intensive care unit.
Themes and categories identified from the interviews
| Theme | Categories | Examples |
| Individual factors | Inexperience. | Inexperienced in paediatric prescribing (eg, an adult anaesthetist on a short rotation). |
| Organisational factors | Divergent practice and systems. | Different protocols between patients receiving non-intensive care unit (ICU) care (postoperative recovery) and those receiving ICU care. |
| Task-related factors | Ambiguous or inaccessible information. | Inability to locate guidelines and procedures on the intranet because of a lack of computer facilities. |
| Team-related factors | Flat hierarchy. | Lack of handover related to medicines that the patient is receiving on admission. |
| Work-related factors | Distraction and interruption. | Rewriting a complex medication chart and being asked to review blood gases, or answer the telephone. |
Relationships between failure models and identified contributory factors
| Failure point | Example of active failure | Type of task step | Likely contributing factors | Recovery step | Potential mitigation strategies | |
| Slips and lapses | 3.2–3.4 | Failure to document prescription details appropriately. | Information entry and communication. | Cognitive burden; memory processing; workload and prioritisation; and support. | Nursing staff will not administer medication without a complete prescription. | Computerised physician order entry and |
| 3.7 and 3.8 | Failure to document times for administration. | |||||
| 3.10 | Failure to sign the prescription. | Information entry. | ||||
| Rules-based mistakes | 3.5.1–3.5.4 | Failure to undertake pre-prescription checks (physiology, organ status, other meds and route). | Planning; information retrieval; and information interpretation. | Skills and knowledge; | Pharmacist review of medication. | Computerised Decision Support Systems (CDSS). |
| 3.7 | Select incorrect dosing frequency/times. | Selection; information retrieval; and information entry. | Skills and knowledge; complexity; verbal communication; and ambiguous information. | Nursing staff will not administer medication if frequency is incorrect. | Standardised order sets. | |
| 3.5.4.2–3.5.4.4 | Incorrect calculation; wrong final infusion volume/concentration; and wrong infusion rate. | Information retrieval; information entry; and calculation. | Cognitive burden; skills and knowledge; inexperience; verbal communication; ambiguous information; and divergent practice. | Nursing staff will not administer medication if infusion prescription is incorrect. | Organisationally standardised infusion concentrations and prescriptions. | |
| Knowledge-based mistakes | 3.1 | Incorrect action taken based on faulty analysis of different drug dosing references. | Information retrieval; communication; and information interpretation. | Verbal communication; ambiguous information; skills and knowledge; and divergent practice. | Nursing staff will not administer medication if dosing reference is ambiguous. | Standardised formularies. |
| 3.5.1 | Failure to take account of interactions (drug/disease), effects of fluid restriction, impact of route of administration and age/weight. | Information retrieval and information interpretation. | Verbal communication; ambiguous information; and skills and knowledge. | None. | CDSS. | |
| 3.5.4.3 | Wrong final infusion volume/concentration. | Information retrieval; information entry; and calculation. | Cognitive burden; ambiguous information; skills and knowledge; inexperience; and divergent practice. | Nursing staff will not administer medication if infusion prescription is incorrect. | Organisationally standardised infusion concentrations and prescriptions. | |
| 3.9.2 | Failure to identify monitoring conditions. | Planning; communication; and information entry. | Ambiguous information; skills and knowledge; and inexperience. | Nursing staff will challenge monitoring requirements. | CDSS. |