Paula P Schnurr1,2, Carole A Lunney1. 1. National Center for PTSD, White River Junction, Vermont. 2. Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Hanover, New Hampshire.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Despite the effectiveness of evidence-based treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), some symptoms, such as sleep disturbance, can be difficult to treat regardless of treatment type. METHODS: We examined residual PTSD symptoms in 235 female veterans and soldiers who were randomized to receive 10 weekly sessions of either Prolonged Exposure (PE) or Present-Centered Therapy (PCT). PTSD symptoms were assessed using the Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale. Analyses examined the effects of PE and the effects of clinically significant improvement (loss of diagnosis, operationalized as meaningful symptom reduction and no longer meeting diagnostic criteria). RESULTS: Both treatments resulted in reductions in PTSD symptoms. PE had lower conditional probabilities than PCT of retaining intrusive memories, avoidance of people/places, detachment/estrangement, and restricted range of affect. Loss of diagnosis had lower conditional probabilities of almost all symptoms, although hyperarousal symptoms-especially irritability/anger (60.7%) and sleep difficulties (50.9%)-were the most likely to remain. CONCLUSIONS: Results are consistent with previous findings on sleep difficulties being difficult to treat, but also show that hyperarousal symptoms overall may not be resolved even after substantial improvement. Additional strategies may be needed to treat the full range of PTSD symptoms in some patients.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Despite the effectiveness of evidence-based treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), some symptoms, such as sleep disturbance, can be difficult to treat regardless of treatment type. METHODS: We examined residual PTSD symptoms in 235 female veterans and soldiers who were randomized to receive 10 weekly sessions of either Prolonged Exposure (PE) or Present-Centered Therapy (PCT). PTSD symptoms were assessed using the Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale. Analyses examined the effects of PE and the effects of clinically significant improvement (loss of diagnosis, operationalized as meaningful symptom reduction and no longer meeting diagnostic criteria). RESULTS: Both treatments resulted in reductions in PTSD symptoms. PE had lower conditional probabilities than PCT of retaining intrusive memories, avoidance of people/places, detachment/estrangement, and restricted range of affect. Loss of diagnosis had lower conditional probabilities of almost all symptoms, although hyperarousal symptoms-especially irritability/anger (60.7%) and sleep difficulties (50.9%)-were the most likely to remain. CONCLUSIONS: Results are consistent with previous findings on sleep difficulties being difficult to treat, but also show that hyperarousal symptoms overall may not be resolved even after substantial improvement. Additional strategies may be needed to treat the full range of PTSD symptoms in some patients.
Authors: Kirsten H Dillon; Elizabeth E Van Voorhees; Paul A Dennis; Jeffrey J Glenn; Chelsey R Wilks; Leslie A Morland; Jean C Beckham; Eric B Elbogen Journal: J Affect Disord Date: 2020-03-23 Impact factor: 4.839
Authors: Elizabeth M Walters; Melissa M Jenkins; Carla M Nappi; Jacob Clark; July Lies; Sonya B Norman; Sean P A Drummond Journal: Psychol Trauma Date: 2019-06-27
Authors: Bradley E Belsher; Erin Beech; Daniel Evatt; Derek J Smolenski; M Tracie Shea; Jean Lin Otto; Craig S Rosen; Paula P Schnurr Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2019-11-18
Authors: Skye S Fitzpatrick; Antonio A Morgan-López; Tanya C Saraiya; Sudie E Back; Therese K Killeen; Sonya B Norman; Teresa López-Castro; Lesia M Ruglass; Lissette M Saavedra; Denise A Hien Journal: Psychol Addict Behav Date: 2021-06-17
Authors: Stephanie Y Wells; Carolyn L Brennan; Elizabeth E Van Voorhees; Jean C Beckham; Patrick S Calhoun; Carolina P Clancy; Michael A Hertzberg; Kirsten H Dillon Journal: J Trauma Stress Date: 2021-06-06
Authors: Kirsten H Dillon; Alyssa M Medenblik; Tiffany M Mosher; Eric B Elbogen; Leslie A Morland; Jean C Beckham Journal: J Trauma Stress Date: 2020-06-09