| Literature DB >> 30485287 |
Anna Shevchenko1, Andrea Schuhmann1, Henrik Thomas1, Günter Wetzel2.
Abstract
The role of aquatic resources in ancient economies and paleodiet is important for understanding the evolution of prehistorical societies. Charred food remains from ancient pottery are valuable molecular evidence of dietary habits in antiquity. However, conventional archaeometric approaches applied in their analysis lack organismal specificity, are affected by abundant environmental contaminants, do not elucidate food processing recipes and are limited in the inland regions where diverse dietary resources are available. We performed proteomics analysis of charred organic deposits adhered on early ceramics from Mesolithic-Neolithic inland site Friesack 4 (Brandenburg, Germany). One of pots-a small coarse bowl radiocarbon dated to the end of the 5th millennium BC-was attributed to Endmesolithic pottery. Proteomics of foodcrust from this vessel identified fine carp roe meal and revealed details of a prehistorical culinary recipe. Ancient proteins were unequivocally distinguished from contemporary contaminants by computing deamidation ratios of glutamine residues. These data paint a broader picture of the site-specific exploitation of aquatic resources and contribute to better understanding of the dietary context of Neolithic transition in European inland.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30485287 PMCID: PMC6261446 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0206483
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Fig 1Archaeological site Friesack 4.
Panel A: Location in Havelland administrative district, Brandenburg, Germany. Panel B: Layout of archaeological excavations undertaken at the Friesack 4 site: shaded area–leaded by M. Schneider (1916–1928); filled grey areas—H. Reinerth (R 1-5/1940); designated with “W”—S. Wenzel (2000–2001); designated with 1–4, 7, A-D, X-Z—B. Gramsch (1977–1989; 1998). The position of the test trench 1979 is designated with asterisk; quadrats A and D are pointed with arrows (graphic rendering the original map from Bodo Hildebrand (†) and Dieter Becker). Panel C. South profile of the test trench 1979: A—peat; B, D–yellowish grey light sand; C, E–organic silt; F–Pleistocene sand (graphic rendering the original drawing from B. Gramsch).
Fig 2Fragment of Endmesolithic pottery #1977:7/3258 T from Friesack 4.
Panel A: side view; Panel B: inner view, secondary conical puncture is seen at the upper right corner. Panel on the right shows basal fragment of the dish with foodcrust. Panel C: Graphical reconstruction of the profile of the bowl #1977:7/3258 T.
Overview of Friesack 4 foodcrusts.
| N | Sample name | Archaeological inventory N | 14C dating | Ceramics typology | Proteomics analysis result (number of identified proteins) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BP | calBC | Contemporary proteins | Ancient proteins | |||||
| Common background | Environmental contaminants | |||||||
| 1 | 1977:7/3258 T | 5350±30 | 4300–4050 | Friesack-Boberger | Human proteins (32); Hen egg ovalbumin; Bovine milk proteins (1) | Bacteria: | Fish vitellogenins and parvalbumins | |
| 2 | 1977:7/3251.1 | 5042±25 | 3946–3776 | Brzesc Kujawski (?) [ | Human proteins and multispecies hits (90); Bovine milk proteins (4); Bovine collagen (2) | Bacteria: | [Collagen, | |
| 3 | 1977:7/3157.1 | 5419±27 | 4336–4241 | Friesack-Boberger [ | Human proteins (34); Bovine milk proteins (2) | Bacteria: | ||
| 4 | 1977:7/3078 | 4705±22 | 3628–3376 | Funnelbeaker [ | Human proteins (42) | Insect proteins (5) Plants: | ||
1 –full list of identified proteins is shown in the S1 File.
2 –based on deamidation rate of glutamine residues in detected peptides.
3 –small number of detected glutamine-containing peptides and overlapping pig and bovine sequences did not allow more specific conclusions.
Glutamine deamidation rates in fish proteins detected in #3258 and modern reference samples.
| Proteins | Number of proteins | Number of peptides containing one glutamine residue | Averaged glutamine deamidation rate, % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keratins in all samples | 5 | 34 | <1 |
| Sample #3258 | |||
| Vitellogenin | 1 | 3 | 96 |
| Parvalbumin | 1 | 1 | 80 |
| Fresh carp roe | |||
| Vitellogenin | 1 | 3 | <1 |
| Parvalbumin | 1 | 1 | <1 |
| Proteins in fish broth | 12 | 65 | 5 |
1 –Raw data are in S1 File
2 –Includes all peptides containing one glutamine residue that were detected in Sample #3258; in keratins and fish broth proteins only peptides detected in both native and deamidated forms were considered. Note that for the vast majority of glutamine containing peptides in modern proteins we observed no deamidation.
3 –the same peptides as in sample #3258
List of peptides matched to collagens in foodcrusts #3078 and #3251.1.
| Peptide sequence | Precursor ion, m/z | Best Mascot peptide ion score(N of matched spectra) | ID of the best scored spectrum | Present in collagens of animal groups | Deamidation state of Q and N | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #3078 | #3251.1 | #3078 | #3251.1 | Control sample (pottery glue) | ||||
| Collagen-alpha1(I) chain | ||||||||
| 449.759 | Ww11_01.02342.02342.2 W15_05.09390.09390.2 glue_06.01952.01952.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5,6 | ● (-) | ● (+/-) | ● (-) | |||
| 553.292 | 33(4) | 46(4) | Ww11_01.01812.01812.2 W15_05.06740.06740.2 glue_05.01420.01420.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5,6 | ● (-) | ● (+/-) | ● (-) | |
| 730.351 | 55(4) | 77(3) | Ww11_03.02882.02882.2 W15_05.11204.11204.2 glue_06.02345.02345.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5 | ● | ● | ● | |
| 589.288 | 48(1) | Ww11_03.02751.02751.2 W15_05.10708.10708.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5,6 | ● (-) | ● (-) | |||
| 718.345 | 52(2) | W15_05.11435.11435.2 | b,s,h,2,5 | ● | ||||
| 780.912 | 34(6) | Ww11_03.05551.05551.2 | b,2 | ● | ||||
| 773.900 | W15_05.14431.14431.2 | s,h | ● | |||||
| 666.831 | 37(1) | Ww11_03.01617.01617.2 | b,s,2,5,6 | ● (-) | ||||
| 916.935 | 31(6) | Ww11_03.04710.04710.2 | b,s,h,1,2,4,5 | ● | ||||
| 641.313 | 41(1) | Ww11_03.01481.01481.2 | b,4 | ● | ||||
| 664.827 | 33(2) | W15_05.17242.17242.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5,6 | ● | ||||
| 793.883 | 52(4) | W15_05.17008.17008.2 | b,s,h,1,2,3,4,5 | ● (+/-) | ||||
| 596.820 | 32(1) | W15_05.08507.08507.2 | b,s,h,1,3,5,6 | ● | ||||
| Collagen-alpha2(I) chain | ||||||||
| 596.84 | Glue_06.03455.03455.2 | b | ● (-) | |||||
| 790.887 | 59(3) | Ww11_01.02629.02629.2 | b,h,1,2 | ● | ||||
| 775.884 | 34(1) | W15_09.09529.09529.2 | s,3 | ● | ||||
| 644.322 | 30(1) | Ww1_03.02841.02841.2 | b,1,2,3 | ● (-) | ||||
| 737.341 | 52(2) | Ww11_03.02904.02904.2 | b,s,1,2,4 | ● | ||||
| 766.895 | 37(3) | Ww11_03.04284.04284.2 | b,2 | ● | ||||
| 1066.058 | 45(2) | Ww11_01.10429.10429.2 | b,s,1,2,4 | ● | ||||
| 620.326 | 61(2) | W15_05.09594.09594.2 | s,3 | ● | ||||
| 634.340 | 34(1) | W15_05.11721.11721.2 | b,h,1,2,4,5,6 | ● | ||||
| 727.380 | 39(1) | W15_05.21986.21986.2 | s,6,4 | ● | ||||
| 714.368 | 37(1) | W15_05.21102.21102.2 | b,1,2,3,5 | ● | ||||
| 739.843 | 50(1) | W15_05.09791.09791.2 | s | ● | ||||
1—only peptides longer than seven amino acids and with Mascot ion score >30 are included. Species-specific amino acids in homologues peptides sequences are marked in bold. Oxidized proline and methionine residues are underlined.
2 –Bold–accepted after manual inspection. includes spectra matched with ion score >15.
3—sequences of detected peptide were compared with collagens of animal species (as in NCBI database, Oct. 2017) which inhabited Friesack region in Late Mesolithic and Early Neolith: families Bovidae (b), Suidae (s); Caprinae (1), Cervidae (2), Equidae (3); order Carnivora (4); C. canadensis (5), O.cuniculus (6) and human (h).
4—detected peptides are indicated with “●”; “-”stays if glutamine or asparagine residue was detected unmodified; “+/-”if both forms, deamidated and unmodified, are detected.
List of peptides matched to fish vitellogenin and parvalbumin in foodcrust #3258*.
| Peptide sequence | Precursor ion, m/z | Best Mascot peptide ion score (N of matched spectra | ID of the best scored spectrum | Gene Identifier of sequences matched by MSBLAST | Organismal order | Relative deamidation of glutamine (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #3258 | Reference sample (fresh carp roe) | ||||||
| 549.830 | 54(8) | W2_01.19607.19607.2 ro-03.15419.15419.2 | 399761434, 4572552, 15778562, 156713467, 124518427, 556825564, 157419156, 284097898, 332712555, 662036448, 831290949 | ● (100%) | ● (<1%) | ||
| 570.817 | 38(5) | W2_01.11233.11233.2 ro-02.12343.12434.2 | 399761434, 4572552, 15778562, 742165772, 108863148, 556825564, 157419156, 284097898, 332712555 | ● (88%) | ● (<1%) | ||
| 794.939 | 72(7) | W2_01.13204.13204.2 ro-02.29364.29364.2 | 399761434, 4572552, 15778562, 124518427, 15778562, 157419156, 284097898, 662036448 | ● | ● | ||
| 664.339 | 36(1) | W2_01.07052.07052.2 ro-01.13019.13019.2 | 399761434, 4572552, 15778562, 156713467, 108863148, 556825564, 284097898, 63100501, 662036448 | ● | ● | ||
| 759.380 | 50(9) | W2_01.07946.07946.2 ro-02.20727.20727.2 | 742165772, 1024933123, 662036450, 4572552, 157419156, 399761434, 124518427, 160333705, 1025281290 | ● | |||
| 613.870 | 36(3) | W2_01.15246.15246.2 ro-03.22789.22789.2 | 15778562, 742165772, 5725516, 499021581, 554825686, 86143840, 156530049 | ● (100%) | |||
| 559.85 | 37(2) | W2_01.12404.12404.2 ro-07.09971.09971.2 | 156713467, 691424740, 1020581238 | ● | |||
| 458.214 | 36(2) | W2_0_02576.02576.2 | 966641035 | ● | |||
| 583.783 | 33(3) | W2_0_08991.08991.2 ro-10.06024.06024.2 | 966641035 | ● | ● | ||
| 613.31 | 35(2) | W2_01.09714.09714.2 ro-10.08132.08132.2 | 966641035 | ● (80%) | LFLQNFSAGAR (0%) | ||
*—data are combined from two analyses
1—only peptides longer than seven amino acids and Mascot ion score above 30 are included. Underlined amino acids were detected modified
2 –includes spectra matched with ion score >15.
c–statistically significant hits matching identical peptide sequence or its homologues resulted from single nucleotide substitution (as for example valine to isoleucine replacement).
4 –“●”–stays for peptides detected in the sample; “n/d.”–no peptide detected
5 –matches to several overlapping fragmentation spectra acquired from precursors with different mass
6 –matched to homologue sequence
7 –accession number of the best MS BLAST protein hit matching all detected peptides
8 –peptide GIINLLQLNVK was detected in three forms in #3258 (15% Q, 69% QN and 16% QNN-deamidated) and two forms in fresh roe (Q and QN-deamidated, both <1%). Peptide LFLQNFSAGAR was detected in #3258 as N- and QN-deamidated (20% and 80% respectively) and unmodified in fresh roe.
Fig 3Parvalbumin peptides detected in #3258 basal crust are matched to C. carpio sequence by MS BLAST.
“Query” includes sequences of peptides identified in the sample; “Sbjct”—sequences of corresponding peptides matched to C.carpio protein (acc no KTF75949.1).
Fig 4Pronounced deamidation of the glutamine residue (Q) in fish vitellogenin from foodcrust #3258.
Upper panel: Fragmentation spectrum of vitellogenin peptide LELEV (m/z 570.32, z +2) identified in fresh carp roe. In foodcrust #3258, 88% of glutamine residue in this peptide was converted into glutamic acid (E); mirrored image of fragmentation spectrum of peptide LELEV detected in #3258 is shown at the lower panel. Masses of fragment ions including Q or E at the position six are shown in bold.
Fig 5Electron microscopy of rim and basal foodcrusts from #3258 vessel.
Panels A-E: Images of complex rim crust with fungal micelles (My), incrusted bisaccate conifer pollen (panel B) and Streptomyces-type bacterial spores (panel E) on the surface. Damaged microstructures of plant phloem and xylem, leaves surface cuticle, frazzles of thin membranes and fluffy bulk material are designated with arrows on panels C and D, and also well recognizable on panel E. Panel F: A piece of basal crust consisting of dense homogeneous material.