Charles Dupras1, Stanislav Birko2, Aliya Affdal2, Hazar Haidar2, Marie-Eve Lemoine2, Vardit Ravitsky2. 1. Center of Genomics and Policy (Dupras) and Institute for Health and Social Policy (Haidar) McGill University; École de santé publique, Université de Montréal (Birko, Affdal, Haidar, Lemoine, Ravitsky), Montréal, Que. charles.dupras2@mcgill.ca. 2. Center of Genomics and Policy (Dupras) and Institute for Health and Social Policy (Haidar) McGill University; École de santé publique, Université de Montréal (Birko, Affdal, Haidar, Lemoine, Ravitsky), Montréal, Que.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Noninvasive prenatal testing is a recent technology that provides some genetic information about the fetus through the analysis of cell-free fetal DNA circulating in maternal blood. We aimed to identify the benefits, challenges and guiding ethical principles most relevant to the clinical integration of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada, according to experts throughout the country. METHODS: We conducted a 3-round Delphi study involving Canadian experts of contemporary discussions about the ethical and societal implications of prenatal testing and genomic technologies. In round 1, we asked participants to identify clinical benefits and challenges related to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada, and the ethical principles they think should guide it. In round 2, we asked participants to select the most important elements stated by their peers. In round 3, participants were informed of the aggregated results from round 2, and invited to revise or confirm their selection. RESULTS: Round 1 had a participation rate of 20.2%, and involved 61 participants. Subsequent rounds 2 and 3 had retention rates of 95.1% (n = 58) and 84.5% (n = 49), respectively. Through these discussions, we identified 3 lists of benefits (n = 10), challenges (n = 27), and ethical principles (n = 16) prioritized by Canadian experts as being most relevant to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. INTERPRETATION: Although multiple and diverse potential issues were identified, Canadian experts agreed on 2 sets of requirements for the responsible implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. Interdisciplinary appraisals may be instrumental to responsible policy-making related to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. Copyright 2018, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
BACKGROUND: Noninvasive prenatal testing is a recent technology that provides some genetic information about the fetus through the analysis of cell-free fetal DNA circulating in maternal blood. We aimed to identify the benefits, challenges and guiding ethical principles most relevant to the clinical integration of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada, according to experts throughout the country. METHODS: We conducted a 3-round Delphi study involving Canadian experts of contemporary discussions about the ethical and societal implications of prenatal testing and genomic technologies. In round 1, we asked participants to identify clinical benefits and challenges related to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada, and the ethical principles they think should guide it. In round 2, we asked participants to select the most important elements stated by their peers. In round 3, participants were informed of the aggregated results from round 2, and invited to revise or confirm their selection. RESULTS: Round 1 had a participation rate of 20.2%, and involved 61 participants. Subsequent rounds 2 and 3 had retention rates of 95.1% (n = 58) and 84.5% (n = 49), respectively. Through these discussions, we identified 3 lists of benefits (n = 10), challenges (n = 27), and ethical principles (n = 16) prioritized by Canadian experts as being most relevant to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. INTERPRETATION: Although multiple and diverse potential issues were identified, Canadian experts agreed on 2 sets of requirements for the responsible implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. Interdisciplinary appraisals may be instrumental to responsible policy-making related to the implementation of noninvasive prenatal testing in Canada. Copyright 2018, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
Authors: Antina de Jong; Wybo J Dondorp; Suzanna G M Frints; Christine E M de Die-Smulders; Guido M W R de Wert Journal: Nat Rev Genet Date: 2011-08-18 Impact factor: 53.242
Authors: An Chen; Henni Tenhunen; Paulus Torkki; Seppo Heinonen; Paul Lillrank; Vedran Stefanovic Journal: PLoS One Date: 2017-03-29 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Rachèl V van Schendel; Carla G van El; Eva Pajkrt; Lidewij Henneman; Martina C Cornel Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2017-09-19 Impact factor: 2.655