| Literature DB >> 30320478 |
Lisa Moses1,2,3, Monica J Malowney4, Jon Wesley Boyd2,5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Concerns about ethical conflicts, moral distress, and burnout in veterinary practice are steadily increasing. Root causes of these problems have not been rigorously identified. Little research has been done to evaluate the existence of moral distress in North American veterinarians or to explore its impact on career sustainability and poor well-being. HYPOTHESIS/Entities:
Keywords: burnout: professional, negotiating, self-care, mental health, morals, surveys and questionnaires, medical futility, suicidal ideation, compassion fatigue, dissent and disputes; stress: psychological, morals, suicide, ethical theory, ethical dilemma, empathy
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30320478 PMCID: PMC6271308 DOI: 10.1111/jvim.15315
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Vet Intern Med ISSN: 0891-6640 Impact factor: 3.333
Demographics of respondents
| Percent | N | |
|---|---|---|
| Q1. How long have you been in veterinary practice? | ||
| 1–5 years | 18.79% | 167 |
| 5–10 years | 23.62% | 210 |
| Over 10 years | 57.59% | 512 |
| Answered | 889 | |
| Skipped | 4 | |
| Q3. In your veterinary training, how many hours of instruction or training did you receive about resolving differences of opinion about what is best care for patients? | ||
| None | 70.75% | 629 |
| 1–5 hours | 22.72% | 202 |
| More than 5 hours | 6.52% | 58 |
| Answered | 889 | |
| Skipped | 4 | |
| Q4. In your veterinary training, how many hours of instruction or training in self‐care did you receive? | ||
| None | 78.54% | 699 |
| 1–5 hours | 17.87% | 159 |
| More than 5 | 3.60% | 32 |
| Answered | 890 | |
| Skipped | 3 | |
| Q5. Do you have a specialty within vet medicine? | ||
| Yes | 48.76% | 434 |
| No | 51.24% | 456 |
| Answered | 890 | |
| Skipped | 3 | |
| Q7. Are you currently practicing clinical veterinary medicine or have you been in the past 3 years? | ||
| Yes, currently | 92.92% | 827 |
| Yes, in the past 3 years | 4.94% | 44 |
| No | 2.13% | 19 |
| Answered | 890 | |
| Skipped | 3 | |
| Q9. Are you a solo practitioner? | ||
| Yes | 11.15% | 98 |
| No | 88.85% | 781 |
| Answered | 879 | |
| Skipped | 14 | |
Survey responses to questions about ethical conflict and moral distress
| Percent | n | |
|---|---|---|
| Q12. How often have you had a conflict of opinion with pet owners about how they wish to proceed in the treatment of their pets? | ||
| Never | 0.34% | 3 |
| Rarely | 14.30% | 126 |
| Sometimes | 52.89% | 466 |
| Often | 31.56% | 278 |
| Always | 0.91% | 8 |
| Answered | 881 | |
| Skipped | 12 | |
| Q13. What have you done in these situations, if anything? | ||
| Nothing | 14.86% | 130 |
| Discussed with colleague | 67.89% | 594 |
| Other (please specify) | 41.60% | 364 |
| Answered | 875 | |
| Skipped | 18 | |
| Q14. How often have you been asked to do something in the course of your clinical practice that feels like the wrong thing to do? | ||
| Never | 1.83% | 16 |
| Rarely | 46.91% | 410 |
| Sometimes | 45.31% | 396 |
| Often | 5.61% | 49 |
| Always | 0.34% | 3 |
| Answered | 874 | |
| Skipped | 19 | |
| Q15. How often have you complied with these requests? | ||
| Never | 23.21% | 198 |
| Rarely | 45.96% | 392 |
| Sometimes | 23.56% | 201 |
| Often | 7.03% | 60 |
| Always | 0.23% | 2 |
| Answered | 853 | |
| Skipped | 40 | |
| Q16. Did you feel like you had the right to say no? | ||
| Yes | 71.63% | 611 |
| No | 28.37% | 242 |
| Answered | 853 | |
| Skipped | 40 | |
| Q17. How often have you had a case where you felt like you could not do the “right thing”? | ||
| Answer choices | Responses | |
| Never | 4.28% | 37 |
| Rarely | 33.06% | 286 |
| Sometimes | 49.25% | 426 |
| Often | 13.29% | 115 |
| Always | 0.12% | 1 |
| Answered | 865 | |
| Skipped | 28 | |
| Q18. What prevented you from doing the right thing? | ||
| Answered via free text | 761 | |
| Skipped | 132 | |
| Q19. When you have had cases like this, how much distress has it caused your staff, at its worst? | ||
| None | 2.98% | 24 |
| Mild distress | 24.07% | 194 |
| Moderate distress | 54.34% | 438 |
| Severe distress | 18.61% | 150 |
| Answered | 806 | |
| Skipped | 87 | |
| Q20. When you have had cases like this, how much distress has it caused you, at its worst? | ||
| None | 1.00% | 8 |
| Mild distress | 21.02% | 169 |
| Moderate distress | 49.88% | 401 |
| Severe distress | 28.11% | 226 |
| Answered | 804 | |
| Skipped | 89 | |
| Q21. What, if anything, have you done to cope in these situations? | ||
| Done nothing | 17.15% | 136 |
| Talked with partner or friend | 72.51% | 575 |
| Discussed with colleague | 72.51% | 575 |
| Sought professional help | 11.73% | 93 |
| Other | 15.89% | 126 |
| Answered | 793 | |
| Skipped | 100 | |
| Q22. How often have you received what you consider to be inappropriate requests for euthanasia? | ||
| Never | 6.95% | 58 |
| Rarely | 63.67% | 531 |
| Sometimes | 26.86% | 224 |
| Often | 2.40% | 20 |
| Always | 0.12% | 1 |
| Answered | 834 | |
| Skipped | 59 | |
| Q23. How often have you complied with these requests? | ||
| Never | 39.74% | 308 |
| Rarely | 37.68% | 292 |
| Sometimes | 11.48% | 89 |
| Often | 7.35% | 57 |
| Always | 3.74% | 29 |
| Answered | 775 | |
| Skipped | 118 | |
| Q24. When you have had requests like this, how much distress has it caused you or your staff, at its worst? | ||
| None | 3.89% | 30 |
| Mild distress | 32.81% | 253 |
| Moderate distress | 44.62% | 344 |
| Severe distress | 18.68% | 144 |
| Answered | 771 | |
| Skipped | 122 | |
| Q25. How often have you managed cases where you feel that a pet owner is requesting treatment when you consider those efforts to be futile? | ||
| Answer choices | Responses | |
| Never | 0.96% | 8 |
| Rarely | 20.38% | 170 |
| Sometimes | 56.95% | 475 |
| Often | 21.58% | 180 |
| Always | 0.12% | 1 |
| Answered | 834 | |
| Skipped | 59 | |
| Q26. What strategies did you use to manage this situation? | ||
| Done nothing | 16.93% | 138 |
| Discussed with colleague | 70.92% | 578 |
| Other, if so what? | 43.19% | 352 |
| Answered | 815 | |
| Skipped | 78 | |
| Q27. Have you ever refused to provide a treatment that you feel is futile? | ||
| Yes | 50.73% | 416 |
| No | 49.27% | 404 |
| Answered | 820 | |
| Skipped | 73 | |
| Q28. How often do you feel conflicted or upset because a pet owner refuses to do what you think is in the best interest of your patient? | ||
| Never | 1.33% | 11 |
| Rarely | 18.89% | 156 |
| Sometimes | 54.96% | 454 |
| Often | 23.49% | 194 |
| Always | 1.33% | 11 |
| Answered | 826 | |
| Skipped | 67 | |
| Q29. How have you opted to cope with these feelings? | ||
| Done nothing | 21.99% | 179 |
| Talked with partner or friend | 72.48% | 590 |
| Discussed with colleague | 76.29% | 621 |
| Sought professional help | 9.58% | 78 |
| Other | 15.36% | 125 |
| Answered | 814 | |
| Skipped | 79 | |
| Q30. How often do you recommend euthanasia to pet owners if they have not brought up the topic? | ||
| Never | 2.68% | 22 |
| Rarely | 12.18% | 100 |
| Sometimes | 57.13% | 469 |
| Often | 28.01% | 230 |
| Answered | 821 | |
| Skipped | 72 | |
| Q31. Do you recommend euthanasia to pet owners when they have already said they will not consider it? | ||
| Answer choices | Responses | |
| Yes | 85.00% | 680 |
| No | 15.00% | 120 |
| Answered | 800 | |
| Skipped | 93 | |
| Q33. How often have pet owners' attitudes or beliefs about treatment made it difficult to provide the care you think is appropriate? | ||
| Never | 0.49% | 4 |
| Rarely | 25.67% | 210 |
| Sometimes | 59.17% | 484 |
| Often | 14.30% | 117 |
| Always | 0.37% | 3 |
| Answered | 818 | |
| Skipped | 75 | |
| Q35. How much distress has this caused you, at its worst? | ||
| None | 3.29% | 26 |
| Mild distress | 27.56% | 218 |
| Moderate distress | 50.57% | 400 |
| Severe distress | 18.58% | 147 |
| Answered | 791 | |
| Skipped | 102 | |
| Q36. How often have you felt distressed or anxious about your work? | ||
| Never | 1.00% | 8 |
| Rarely | 12.23% | 98 |
| Sometimes | 34.46% | 276 |
| Often | 43.32% | 347 |
| Always | 8.99% | 72 |
| Answered | 801 | |
| Skipped | 92 | |
| Q37. How often have you been asked to do things that are outside of your skill set for financial or other reasons? | ||
| Never | 6.37% | 51 |
| Rarely | 36.08% | 289 |
| Sometimes | 44.07% | 353 |
| Often | 12.11% | 97 |
| Always | 1.37% | 11 |
| Answered | 801 | |
| Skipped | 92 | |
| Q38. How often do these requests cause conflict? | ||
| Never | 4.03% | 30 |
| Rarely | 40.94% | 305 |
| Sometimes | 41.07% | 306 |
| Often | 10.74% | 80 |
| Always | 3.22% | 24 |
| Answered | 745 | |
| Skipped | 148 | |
| Q39. How often have you had disagreements with other veterinarians about how best to manage a case you share? | ||
| Never | 4.64% | 37 |
| Rarely | 46.80% | 373 |
| Sometimes | 42.79% | 341 |
| Often | 5.40% | 43 |
| Always | 0.38% | 3 |
| Answered | 797 | |
| Skipped | 96 | |
| Q40. How have you resolved such situations? | ||
| Done nothing | 18.47% | 140 |
| Discussed with colleague | 87.20% | 661 |
| Other | 20.84% | 158 |
| Answered | 758 | |
| Skipped | 135 | |
| Q41. How much distress have these disagreements caused you, at its worst? | ||
| None | 5.28% | 40 |
| Mild distress | 47.10% | 357 |
| Moderate distress | 34.04% | 258 |
| Severe distress | 13.59% | 103 |
| Answered | 758 | |
| Skipped | 135 | |
| Q42. Are disagreements with other veterinarians more or less distressing than when you disagree with a pet owner? | ||
| More distressing | 38.63% | 277 |
| Less distressing | 35.43% | 254 |
| About the same | 25.94% | 186 |
| Answered | 717 | |
| Skipped | 176 | |
| Q43. How often have you had disagreements with other members of your staff (ie, non‐veterinarians) about how best to proceed with a clinical case? | ||
| Never | 14.12% | 111 |
| Rarely | 50.64% | 398 |
| Sometimes | 32.32% | 254 |
| Often | 2.80% | 22 |
| Always | 0.13% | 1 |
| Answered | 786 | |
| Skipped | 107 | |
| Q44. Do you feel that your compassion or ability to empathize toward your patients has waned over the course of your practice? | ||
| Yes | 26.14% | 206 |
| Sometimes | 32.49% | 256 |
| No | 41.37% | 326 |
| Answered | 788 | |
| Skipped | 105 | |
| Q45. Do you feel like you have lost compassion for pet owners over the course of your practice? | ||
| Yes | 31.35% | 247 |
| Sometimes | 43.15% | 340 |
| No | 25.51% | 201 |
| Answered | 788 | |
| Skipped | 105 | |
| Q46. How often do you feel like you are just going through the motions? | ||
| Never | 8.52% | 67 |
| Rarely | 30.53% | 240 |
| Sometimes | 41.48% | 326 |
| Often | 17.68% | 139 |
| Always | 1.78% | 14 |
| Answered | 786 | |
| Skipped | 107 | |
| Q47. Do you ever feel like you prioritize the needs of animal owners over your patients? | ||
| Yes | 60.00% | 471 |
| No | 40.00% | 314 |
| Answered | 785 | |
| Skipped | 108 | |
| Q49. Do you feel conflicted about this? | ||
| Never | 2.60% | 12 |
| Rarely | 19.09% | 88 |
| Sometimes | 47.72% | 220 |
| Often | 25.38% | 117 |
| Always | 5.21% | 24 |
| Answered | 461 | |
| Skipped | 432 | |