| Literature DB >> 30271394 |
Rafael Gomes Von Borowski1,2, Simone Cristina Baggio Gnoatto2, Alexandre José Macedo2, Reynald Gillet1.
Abstract
Pathogenic biofilms are a global health care concern, as they can cause extensive antibiotic resistance, morbidity, mortality, and thereby substantial economic loss. Scientific efforts have been made over the past few decades, but so far there is no effective treatment targeting the bacteria in biofilms. Antimicrobial peptidomimetics have been proposed as promising potential anti-biofilm agents. Indeed, these structurally enhanced molecules can mimic the action of peptides but are not susceptible to proteolysis or immunogenicity, the characteristic limitations of natural peptides. Here, we provide insights into antibiofilm peptidomimetic strategies and molecular targets, and discuss the design of two major peptidomimetics classes: AApeptides (N-acylated-N-aminoethyl-substituted peptides) and peptoids (N-substituted glycine units). In particular, we present details of their structural diversity and discuss the possible improvements that can be implemented in order to develop antibiofilm drug alternatives.Entities:
Keywords: AApeptides; antibiotic resistance; biofilm; peptides; peptidomimetics; peptoids
Year: 2018 PMID: 30271394 PMCID: PMC6146102 DOI: 10.3389/fmicb.2018.02157
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Microbiol ISSN: 1664-302X Impact factor: 5.640
Figure 1Structure illustration of an α-peptide and its corresponding AApeptide models, adapted from Niu et al. (2013). The α- and γ- N-acylated-N-aminoethyl amino acid amide bond replacement structures are identified by dotted circles in red. R corresponds to possible radicals.
Summary of chemical and biological information on AApeptides.
| 1 | Acyclic model and the main compound 13 | 660.4855 | 0.6–2/50–~75 | Not shown | Membrane disruption | 3.12 ( | (Hemolysis) 85; (HK-2) 86; (K562) 83 | Teng et al., | |||
| SAR: antibacterial activity was enhanced by increasing R4's hydrophobicity. Antibacterial and hemolytic activities were decreased through the introduction of cationic charges ( | |||||||||||
| 2 | The main compound | Not shown | < 5–50/40–80 (YL-36: 6.25–12.56/70–80) | < 5–50/10–70 (YL-36: < 5) | Surfactant-like (micelles) | Membrane disruption | 1- >25 (YL-36: 1–5) | (Hemolysis) 100–250 (YL-36: 100) | Padhee et al., | ||
| SAR: Cyclization reduces structure motility and facilitates bacterial membrane disruption, while lipidation encourages their interactions with membranes. Lipid tails may retard the growth of biofilms and form cationic micelles upon interaction with the matrix. | |||||||||||
Columns: compound ID for the purposes of this paper; peptidomimetic, molecule, or chemical class mimicked by the AApeptide, chemical structure, and molecular weight of the main compound in the studied model; concentration and percentage of action range tested for the antifouling and/or eradication model; antibiofilm and antimicrobial mechanisms of action; minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC); and cytotoxicity. A brief structure activity relationship (SAR) is presented below each AApeptide.
Based on antibiofilm evaluation.
Figure 2Peptide and peptoid monomer structures differ. (Left) Illustration of a classic glycine peptide unit, which has a chiral carbon linked to amino, carboxyl, and radical groups. (Right) An N-substituted R = H for glycine amino acids residues. This has a radical group linked to the amino group instead of the chiral carbon, identified by dotted circles in red.
Summary of chemical and biological information for peptoids.
| 3 | Acyclic model and the main compound | Not shown | 4–64 ~100 ( | Not shown | Membrane disruption | 1.9 ( | (Hemolysis) 780; (HEK293) 220 | Hoque et al., | |||
| SAR: Varying the nature of the lipophilic alkyl chain and spacer chain length emphasizes the role of optimum amphiphilicity in the development of non-toxic yet potent membrane-active antibacterials. | |||||||||||
| 4 | Submonomers structures of 1, 1-11mer, 1-Pro9, 1-achiral, | Not shown | < 5–100 μM/40–70 | < 5–100 μM/40–60 | eDNA, cell-cell detachment/surfactant-like (micelles) | Not shown | 12.5->100 μM | Not shown | Kapoor et al., | ||
| SAR: Peptoids can bind extracellular (eDNA) and may facilitate detachment or disruption of otherwise-stable biofilm structures. Oligomerization via interactions with aromatic side chains would increase the concentration of peptoids near the cell membrane, increasing peptoid activity and perhaps also contributing to biofilm detachment. The hydrophobic tail confers a surfactant-like nature that may aide in micelle formation, which could interact with and disrupt the hydrophobic matrix. | |||||||||||
| 5 | Lysine–norspermidine conjugates model | Not shown | 116–1000 μM/> 80 | Electrostatic and hydrogen bonding interactions with the matrix components of the biofilm | Membrane disruption | 6 | (Hemolysis) 730 | Konai and Haldar, | |||
| SAR: D-amino acids such as D-Tyr, D-Leu, D-Trp, and D-Met were also shown to be natural triggers for biofilm disassembly, although none of these possessed significant antibacterial activity. The introduction of four positive charges and hydrogen bond-forming units into a norspermidine backbone would yield greater electrostatic and hydrogen-bonding interactions with the matrix components. In addition, the lipophilic moiety should enhance interaction with the bacterial membrane. | |||||||||||
| 6 | β-peptoid–peptide hybrid oligomers (i.e., 1a−3d) and the mixed amino/guanidino subtype (i.e., 4a−4d) | 935–3734 (2b: 2815.84) | Methicillin resistant | 1–16 (2b: 4)/40–100 (2b: 100) | 8–16 (2b: 8)/~85 (2b: ~85) | Multi mechanisms | Bactericidal | 1–4 | (Hemolysis) > 500; (HeLa) 46- > 1000 (2b: > 500; 90) | Liu et al., | |
| SAR: Longer chain length was correlated with increased antimicrobial activity. This tendency was more pronounced in the lysine-containing subclasses (1 and 4) than in the homoarginine-rich ones (2 and 3). A design based on alternating oligomers with only amino or guanidino/amino functional groups in a 1:1 ratio may be a promising strategy to keep cytotoxicity at an acceptable level. Still, some guanidino side chain content is required for antibiofilm activity and chirality appears to be essential for efficient killing planktonic cells. | |||||||||||
Columns: compound ID for the purposes of this paper; peptidomimetic, molecule or chemical class mimicked by the peptoids, chemical structure and molecular weight of the main compound in the studied model; concentration and percentage of action range tested for the antifouling and/or eradication model; antibiofilm and antimicrobial mechanisms of action; minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC); and cytotoxicity. A brief structure activity relationship (SAR) is presented below each peptoid.
Based on antibiofilm evaluation.