| Literature DB >> 30269077 |
Marie Costa1,2, Fabienne Marcellin1,2, Marion Coste1,2, Tangui Barré1,2, Sandra Nordmann1,2, Marion Mora1,2, Gwenaëlle Maradan1,2, Marc Tanti1,2,3, Christophe Cutarella4, Danielle Casanova5, Sabrina Levy-Bellaiche6, Pierre Polomeni7, Nicolas Simon1,2, Perrine Roux1,2, Maria-Patrizia Carrieri1,2.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Alcohol use disorder (AUD) is a major public health concern worldwide. In France, only 10% of people with AUD (PWAUD) receive medical care. General practitioners (GP) are one of the main entry points for AUD care. The present ongoing study, entitled ASIA (Access to Care and Indifference toward Alcohol, Accès aux Soins et Indifference à l'Alcool in French), aims to improve knowledge about factors associated with access to care for AUD by exploring related GP and PWAUD practices, experiences and perceptions. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: The ASIA project is an ongoing cross-sectional multisite study based on a complementary mixed-method approach (quantitative and qualitative) using a convergent parallel design. The double-perspective design of the study will enable us to collect and compare data regarding both PWAUD and GP points of view. For the PWAUD quantitative study, 260 PWAUD will be interviewed using a telephone-based questionnaire. For the qualitative study, 36 PWAUD have already been interviewed. The GP quantitative study will include 100 GP in a 15 min survey. Fifteen GP have already participated in semistructured interviews for the qualitative study. Logistic regression will be used to identify predictors for access to care. With respect to data analyses, qualitative interviews will be analysed using semantic analysis while quantitative logistic regression will be used for quantitative interviews. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: This study was approved by the CNIL (French National Commission on Informatics and Liberties) (approval reference number: C16-10, date of approval: 17 July 2017), the CCTIRS (Advisory Committee on Information Processing in Material Research in the Field of Health) and the CEEI (Evaluation and Ethics Committee) (approval reference number: 16-312, date of approval: 8 July 2016) of INSERM (French National Institute of Health and Medical Research). Results from ASIA will be disseminated in peer-reviewed publications, conference presentations, reports and in a PhD thesis. © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2018. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.Entities:
Keywords: access to care; alcohol use disorder; alcohol use disorder treatments; general practitioners; mixed-method study
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30269077 PMCID: PMC6169764 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-024669
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Relationship between project objectives and study components
| PWAUD | PWAUD quantitative study | GP | GP | |
| (1) Identify sociodemographic characteristics and health experiences associated with access to care (PWAUD). | X | |||
| (2) Determine sociodemographic and professional characteristics associated with AUD management and screening, acceptance of CD and pharmacological treatment prescription (GP). | X | |||
| (3) Assess whether barriers found in other studies were relevant in the current French context (PWAUD and GP). | X | X | ||
| (4) Identify other barriers and levers which could have been missed in the quantitative study (GP and PWAUD). | X | X | ||
| (5) Illustrate and examine in depth the findings of the quantitative study (GP and PWAUD). | X | X |
AUD, alcohol used isorder; CD, controlled drinking; GP, general practitioner; PWAUD, people with alcohol used isorder.
Semistructured PWAUD interview guide
| Qualitative substudy for PWAUD | |
| Standard data collected | Audit score |
| Semistructured PWAUD interview guide | |
| Opening question | You are experiencing difficulties with your alcohol consumption. I imagine it is difficult to deal with that. Could you tell me about your experience with alcohol since you started drinking, including, if applicable, your experience with health professionals for this specific problem? |
| If the interviewee does not mention these topics spontaneously, the interviewer must do so. |
How long have you been drinking, how did it start? How did you realise that you had a drinking problem? Who have you talked to about your drinking problem? Have you talked about it with your family physician or another physician? What do you think prevents you from reducing or stopping your alcohol consumption? What are your goals: to stop drinking altogether? To drink less? What steps have you taken to try to change your consumption? (treatment, consultation with specialists, alternative medicines, etc) Have you ever taken medication to stop drinking? Which medication(s) precisely? Have you looked for information concerning treatments to stop or reduce alcohol consumption? Have you heard of baclofen? Of nalmefene? Do you visit medical websites and/or online forums? Does this help you? How? |
PWAUD, people with alcohol used isorder.
PWAUD questionnaire
| Section number | Main theme | Specific themes |
| 1 | General information | Age, gender, family situation, educational status, income, employment status, quality of housing, receiving ordinary healthcare, access to transportation, internet access. |
| 2 | Alcohol consumption | Craving level, health issues related to alcohol consumption, withdrawal symptoms, alcohol consumption perceptions |
| 3 | Substances use other than alcohol | Tobacco, opioids, benzodiazepines, cocaine, synthetic drugs |
| 4 | Experiences and perceptions related to alcohol consumption | Feelings, discrimination, drinking environment (place, peers) |
| 5 | AUD aims concerning personal alcohol consumption | (eg, abstinence, reduction, etc) |
| 6 | Care received | Having a regular GP, quality of relationship with regular GP, receiving/having received care (in the 3 years prior to enrolment), having already sought AUD care through regular GP or in general, and, if applicable, reasons for not having sought AUD care. |
| 7 | Methods used to stop or reduce alcohol consumption | Medical methods, alternative therapies, association support. For each method, participants are asked if it was/is helpful and if it is ongoing. |
| 8/9 | Pharmacological treatments | Pharmacological treatments: Question 8 is designed for PWAUD who have already had at least one experience with pharmacological treatment, while question 9 is for people who have never taken any pharmacological treatment. For each of the five prescribed pharmacological treatments for maintaining abstinence or reducing alcohol consumption, participants are asked (1) if they have heard of it (if applicable where/from whom), (2) if they have taken the treatment (if applicable, who prescribed it to them), (3) reasons for deciding to take or not to take this treatment, (4) the treatment’s efficacy and (5) (if appropriate) their personal opinion about the causes for failure using this treatment. |
AUD, alcohol used isorder; GP, general practitioner; PWAUD, people with alcohol use d isorder.
Semistructured GP interview guide
| Qualitative substudy among GP | |
| Standard data collected | Year of birth |
| Semistructured GP interview guide | |
| Opening question | Can you tell me about your experience with patients with alcohol use disorder, especially how you handle them? |
| If the interviewee does not mention these topics spontaneously, the interviewer must do so: |
Are you currently following patients with alcohol use disorder? How do you screen for alcohol use disorder? Do you use a specific scale or test? Do you treat patients by yourself for substance abuse or do you refer them to a colleague or a specialised centre? Do you prescribe pharmacological treatments to help with the suppression/reduction of alcohol consumption? Which ones? What motivates this choice of treatment? Do you think it is possible to stop drinking without treatment? Do you think that abstinence is the only possible answer for people who have a drinking problem? Do you consider that reducing consumption is an acceptable therapeutic objective (with respect to abstinence)? What do you think about baclofen and nalmefene? |
GP, general practitioner.
GP questionnaire
| GP questionnaire | ||
| Section number | Main theme | Specific themes |
| 1 | General information about GP and their practice | Gender, age, practice duration (years), number of regular patients, consultation duration, addictology training, participation in an addictology network, opioid maintenance treatment prescription, interest in addictology, tobacco cessation management. |
| 2 | Alcohol consumption screening: alcohol cessation/reduction management | Performs screening (yes or no, alone or with another healthcare professional and, if applicable, which category of professional), reason for not managing patient alcohol cessation, number of patients with AUD, prescribes blood analysis to screen for AUD (yes or no), AUD spontaneous assessment (if applicable, with which tool/scale), uses a brief intervention (yes or no), knowledge of specialised alcoholism network structures (for nine different structures, GP are asked if they know the structure and if they collaborate with it). |
| 3 | AUD management (if applicable) | AUD management motivations, treatment/orientation/advice provided, pharmacological treatment prescription (yes or no and, if applicable, the reason for not prescribing pharmacological treatment to stop or reduce alcohol consumption), prescription of one of the five pharmacological treatments indicated to stop or reduce alcohol consumption (for each treatment: treatment prescription intention, prescription motivation, treatment risk–benefit opinion, opinion about causes for treatment failure, opinion about causes for poor adherence and treatment cessation). |
| 4 | Opinion question | ‘Do you think that abstinence is the only acceptable therapeutic goal for PWAUD? (Yes, no, I don’t know)’, and ‘Do you think that CD is a realistic therapeutic goal for PWAUD? (Yes, no, I don’t know)’. |