Zhongshan Gao1,2,3, Wan-Yi Fu2, Yuemei Sun4, Biyuan Gao5, Hui-Ying Wang6, Meiling Liu7, Fang-Mei Luo8, Xiang Zhou2, Jing Jin2, Lan Zhao2, Shandong Wu1, Yi Liu1, Lingying Wu7, Xuefeng Wang7, Ning-Bo Tang4, Bao-Hua Guo8, Yan Feng9, Jian Ying Zhou10, Gabriele Gadermaier11, Fatima Ferreira11, Serge A Versteeg3, Ronald van Ree3. 1. Allergy Research Center, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. 2. College of Agriculture and Biotechnology, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. 3. Department of Experimental Immunology, Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. 4. Department of Allergy, Yu Huang Ding Hospital, Yantai, China. 5. Hangzhou Aileji Biotech Ltd, Hangzhou, China. 6. Department of Allergy, The Second Affiliated Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. 7. Department of Allergy, The Third People's Hospital of Datong, Shanxi, China. 8. Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Qujing Chinese Traditional Medicine Hospital, Yunnan, China. 9. Department of Otorhinolaryngology, The First Affiliated Hospital, Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China. 10. Department of Respiratory Disease, The First Affiliated Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. 11. Department of Biosciences, University of Salzburg, Salzburg, Austria.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Artemisia pollen allergy is a major cause of asthma in Northern China. Possible associations between IgE responses to Artemisia allergen components and clinical phenotypes have not yet been evaluated. This study was to establish sensitization patterns of four Artemisia allergens and possible associations with demographic characteristics and clinical phenotypes in three areas of China. METHODS: Two hundred and forty patients allergic to Artemisia pollen were examined, 178 from Shanxi and 30 from Shandong Provinces in Northern China, and 32 from Yunnan Province in Southwestern China. Allergic asthma, rhinitis, conjunctivitis, and eczema symptoms were diagnosed. All patients' sera were tested by ImmunoCAP with mugwort pollen extract and the natural components nArt v 1, nArt ar 2, nArt v 3, and nArt an 7. RESULTS: The frequency of sensitization and the IgE levels of the four components in Artemisia allergic patients from Southwestern China were significantly lower than in those from the North. Art v 1 and Art an 7 were the most frequently recognized allergens (84% and 87%, respectively), followed by Art v 3 (66%) and Art ar 2 (48%). Patients from Northern China were more likely to have allergic asthma (50%) than patients from Southwestern China (3%), and being sensitized to more than two allergens increased the risk of allergic asthma, in which co-sensitization to three major allergens Art v 1, Art v 3, and Art an 7 is prominent. CONCLUSIONS: Component-resolved diagnosis of Chinese Artemisia pollen-allergic patients helps assess the potential risk of mugwort-associated allergic asthma.
BACKGROUND:Artemisia pollen allergy is a major cause of asthma in Northern China. Possible associations between IgE responses to Artemisia allergen components and clinical phenotypes have not yet been evaluated. This study was to establish sensitization patterns of four Artemisia allergens and possible associations with demographic characteristics and clinical phenotypes in three areas of China. METHODS: Two hundred and forty patientsallergic to Artemisia pollen were examined, 178 from Shanxi and 30 from Shandong Provinces in Northern China, and 32 from Yunnan Province in Southwestern China. Allergic asthma, rhinitis, conjunctivitis, and eczema symptoms were diagnosed. All patients' sera were tested by ImmunoCAP with mugwort pollen extract and the natural components nArtv 1, nArt ar 2, nArt v 3, and nArt an 7. RESULTS: The frequency of sensitization and the IgE levels of the four components in Artemisia allergicpatients from Southwestern China were significantly lower than in those from the North. Artv 1 and Art an 7 were the most frequently recognized allergens (84% and 87%, respectively), followed by Art v 3 (66%) and Art ar 2 (48%). Patients from Northern China were more likely to have allergic asthma (50%) than patients from Southwestern China (3%), and being sensitized to more than two allergens increased the risk of allergic asthma, in which co-sensitization to three major allergens Artv 1, Art v 3, and Art an 7 is prominent. CONCLUSIONS: Component-resolved diagnosis of Chinese Artemisia pollen-allergicpatients helps assess the potential risk of mugwort-associated allergic asthma.
95% confidence intervalcomponent‐resolved diagnosticsodds ratioShandong province, Northern ChinaShanxi province, Northern ChinaYunnan province, Southwestern ChinaThe frequency and IgE levels of four Artemisia allergen components in patients from SX and SD were higher than that in YN China.Patients from SX and SD were more likely to have allergic asthma than patients from YN China.Patients co‐sensitization to Artv 1, Art v 3 and Art an 7 have a higher risk of developing allergic asthma.
INTRODUCTION
Over the past 30 years, there has been a significant increase in the prevalence of allergy in the Chinese population, and allergy has been found to be the major factor causing asthma.1, 2 A cross‐sectional study has shown that overall, while about 11.3% of patients in China with respiratory allergies are sensitized to Artemisia pollen, this value is much higher in Northern China (>50%). Among the major pollen species causing seasonal allergic asthma in China, Artemisia pollen has the highest association index.3, 4, 5, 6, 7 The hop (Humulus scandens), ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia), and goosefoot (Chenopodium album) pollen seasons overlap with that of Artemisia, but their IgE positive rate was significantly lower in a survey of a large number of ImmunoCAP tests in Beijing.5 In some areas in Europe, mugwort (A. vulgaris) pollen has also been associated with late summer and autumn hay fever and asthma, but its clinical importance is limited compared to birch and grass pollen.8Component‐resolved diagnosis (CRD) enables IgE sensitization profiles and potential risk to be established, and whether specific IgE is the result of primary sensitization or cross‐reactivity can also be determined.9, 10, 11, 12, 13 Such information can assist in making the right choice of immunotherapy, particularly when pollen seasons of different allergenic sources overlap.14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 Seven Artemisia pollen allergens have been identified and listed in the IUIS database (www.allergen.org), including the recently added 62 kDa putative galactose oxidase protein (Art an 7), first purified from sweet wormwood (A. annua).20, 21 In earlier studies with nine patients in Europe, using array‐based profiling of five mugwort allergens, Artv 1, Art v 3, Art v 4, and Art v 6 were recognized by 60%‐80% patients, with a co‐sensitization frequency of 60% of three of these four allergens.22 Until now, only two mugwort major component allergens (Artv 1 and Art v 3) have been commercially available for component‐resolved diagnosis, with the prevalence of Artv 1 around 80% and Art v 3 around 60% in mugwort‐allergicpatients from Beijing and Shanxi provinces.21, 23 Previous CRD analyses have revealed Artv 1 as a specific marker of mugwort pollen sensitization, and it is on the list of the 100 important allergen molecules,19 although significant differences were found in different geographic areas.24Currently, conventional diagnosis of Artemisia pollen allergy in China largely relies on skin prick tests, immunoblot kits using European mugwort or Chinese Artemisia spp. pollen extracts, or ImmunoCAP (w6, A. vulgaris extract); CRD has rarely been applied to establish sensitization profiles or to direct allergen immunotherapy in Chinese mugwort‐allergicpatients. In addition, the relation between IgE responses to different components and clinical phenotypes has barely been explored.7 Here, we used ImmunoCAP to evaluate the importance of IgE to four Artemisia pollen components: Artv 1 (defensin‐like protein), Art ar 2 (pathogenesis‐related protein 1), Art v 3 (lipid transfer protein), and Art an 7 (putative galactose oxidase) in a group of 240 Chinese Artemisia pollen‐allergicpatients from three different Chinese provinces (Shanxi, Shandong, and Yunnan, respectively) with characteristic seasonal Artemisia pollen counts, and describe possible associations with demographics and clinical phenotypes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patients and symptoms
A total of 240 patients were recruited based on a convincing history of Artemisia pollen allergy in late summer and autumn, positive results in specific mugwortIgE tests but negative or very weak to hop pollen (w22) by ImmunoCAPs or by quick immunoblot kit assay (EUROIMMUN Beijing, China or Xinhualian, Beijing, China). These 240 patients were from three areas: 178 from Datong and Taiyuan, Shanxi Province (SX), 30 from Yantai, Shandong Province (SD), and 32 from Qujing, Yunnan Province (YN). CRD for some of the patients from SX (110/178) has previously been reported,21 so for these, here, only the Art ar 2 component was tested. Patients were also divided into three age groups—children (2‐12 years old), teenagers (13‐18 years), and adults (19‐66 years). The three areas in China showed different seasonal Artemisia pollen counts: Taiyuan (Shanxi province), inland next to the Inner Mongolia grasslands, has the highest Artemisia pollen concentration which reaches a peak in August and September; in the coastal city of Yantai (Shandong province), east of Shanxi, the pollen peak is in September; and the Yunnan province, with a subtropical and tropical monsoon climate, has a very low Artemisia pollen concentration, limited to October and November. Geographic areas and Artemisia pollen count records (microscopic observation of pollen collected on a slide by a simple device) were taken from a survey report25 and are given in Figure S1.Clinical presentations of Artemisia pollen allergy were established by experienced clinicians through questionnaires and clinical observations and tests. Seasonal allergic asthma was defined by a history of dyspnea, wheezing and/or coughing episodes and diagnosed by spirometry (MasterScreen or Powercube‐Body, Germany). For some patients (33/104) from SX and SD, asthma was confirmed by testing for positive airway reversibility, that is, by FEV1 increasing ≥12% after inhalation of 400 μg of salbutamol sulphate. Conjunctivitis was defined based on symptoms such as ocular itching and tearing. The diagnosis of atopic eczema was based on the presence of skin rash with red, raised itchy bumps, and of allergic rhinitis on itching, sneezing, runny nose, and congestion. For all clinical presentations, a clear association of symptoms with the Artemisia pollen season was necessary for a diagnosis of Artemisia pollen allergy.Written informed consent was obtained from all participants, and the study was approved by the local ethics committee of Second Affiliated Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University (authorization No. 2011‐R‐1 and 2013‐67‐087) in collaboration with the Third People's Hospital of Datong, Shanxi (authorization No. 2015‐001), Yu Huang Ding Hospital, Yantai, Shandong (authorization No. 2015‐164), and Qujing Chinese Traditional Medicine Hospital, Yunnan, China.
ImmunoCAP tests
All 240 subjects were tested for their specific IgE to mugwort pollen extract (code w6) and two commercial components (nArtv 1, nArt v 3, with code w231 and w233, respectively) by ImmunoCAP (ThermoFisher Scientific, Uppsala, Sweden). The two additional natural allergens Art ar 2 (GenBank MF326217) and Art an 7 (GenBank KY428925) recently included in IUIS (http://allergen.org/) were biotinylated and coupled to streptavidin‐conjugated ImmunoCAPs (o212) as described previously.26 Natural Art ar 2 was purified by a monoclonal antibody affinity chromatography (C9‐C1: obtained by immunization from a pollen extract of Chinese mugwort A. argyi), and its primary sequence is identical to Art v 2 as demonstrated upon cloning (GenBank MF326222). Natural Art an 7 was purified from A. annua extract as described previously.21 Sera with an IgE value > 100 kUA/L were diluted and retested, with 0.35 kUA/L considered as positive cutoff.
Statistical analyses
Data were analyzed by SPSS 21.0, with a value of P < 0.05 considered as significantly different. Frequencies of positive IgE were analyzed by chi‐square test or Fisher's exact test and differences in IgE levels between groups calculated by the Mann‐Whitney U test. The Spearman correlation coefficient analysis was used to determine correlations of IgE levels between groups, and quantitative variables in the three areas were compared by Kruskal‐Wallis test, with Bonferoni correction applied in pair‐wise comparison.
RESULTS
Symptoms and sensitization profiles of Chinese mugwort‐allergic patients
Of the 240 patients, the vast majority (95%) were diagnosed with Artemisia pollen‐associated allergic rhinitis. In addition, 53% had conjunctivitis, 43% allergic asthma, and 19% atopic eczema, with quite significant geographic variation of these three symptoms (Table 1). For IgE reactivity against the four components, Artv 1 was the most frequently recognized allergen (81%, range 53%‐93%), ahead of Art an 7 (80%, range 38%‐87%), Art v 3 (53%, range 9%‐66%) and Art v 2 (42%, range 9%‐48%). Median IgE levels were highest against Artv 1 (9.6 kUA/L), followed by Art an 7 (2.1 kUA/L) and Art v 3 (1.1 kUA/L), whereas the median IgE to Art ar 2 was below the cutoff (Table 1).
Table 1
Demographics and characterization of the study population in the three provinces in China
Demographics and characterization of the study population in the three provinces in ChinaSD, Shandong province; SX, Shanxi province; YN, Yunnan province.The correlation of mugwortIgE levels to the sum of the four components was very high (Spearman r = 0.92, P < .001), fitting a linear regression (R
2 = 0.74, Figure S2). The 11 outliers in the bottom right corner are mainly from YN Province. For these patients, other allergens such as Art v 4 and/or Art v 6 may play a role.
CRD and age
IgE levels against mugwort extract, Art ar 2, and Art an 7 were significantly different (P < 0.05) among children, teenagers and adults (Figure 1A), with the adult group having a significantly lower IgE to mugwort and Art an 7 than the child and teenager group. The frequency of sensitization to Art ar 2 was higher in the child group than in the teenager and adult groups (Figure 1B). The number of components recognized per patient was not significantly different between age groups (Figure 1C).
Figure 1
Mugwort extract and four components tested in different age groups. IgE levels (A), frequency (B) and number of sensitized allergens, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Art v 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (C). Significant differences are shown: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Mugwort extract and four components tested in different age groups. IgE levels (A), frequency (B) and number of sensitized allergens, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Artv 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (C). Significant differences are shown: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
CRD and geographic background
The IgE levels against mugwort extract and four allergen components in Shanxi (SX) and Shandong (SD) in Northern China were significantly higher than in patients from Yunnan (YN) in Southwestern China (P ≤ 0.001). SX patients had higher IgE levels against the two components Art v 3 and Art an 7 than patients from SD, but not against Artv 1 and Art ar 2 (Figure 2A). The frequency of sensitization to Artv 1, Art ar 2, and Art an 7 was similar in SX and SD, and significantly higher than in YN. The number of SX patients sensitized to Art v 3 was significantly higher and with higher IgE level (Figure 2A,B). Most patients from SX and SD were sensitized to 2‐4 components, while for YNpatients this was less than 2 components (Figure 2C). Multiple allergen sensitization (3‐4 components) resulted in an elevated occurrence of allergic asthma (P < 0.001, OR, 3.65; 95%CI, 2.11‐6.33). Patients from SX and SD in N China were more likely to have allergic asthma (48%‐64%) than patients from YN (3%, in SW China). Rates of conjunctivitis were very high in YNpatients, followed by SX patients, with the lowest rate found in SD (P < 0.01) (Figure 2D).
Figure 2
IgE reactivity of patients from three areas. IgE levels to mugwort extract and four allergen components (A), frequency of sensitized components (B), recognized component numbers, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Art v 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (C) and allergic symptoms among patients from three areas (D). SX, Shanxi province; SD, Shandong province; YN, Yunnan province. The median is shown as a red solid line, and cutoff (0.35 kUA/L) as a dashed line. Significant differences between groups are shown: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
IgE reactivity of patients from three areas. IgE levels to mugwort extract and four allergen components (A), frequency of sensitized components (B), recognized component numbers, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Artv 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (C) and allergic symptoms among patients from three areas (D). SX, Shanxi province; SD, Shandong province; YN, Yunnan province. The median is shown as a red solid line, and cutoff (0.35 kUA/L) as a dashed line. Significant differences between groups are shown: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
CRD and clinical phenotypes
For all tested patients, mugwort extract IgE values in the allergic asthma group were higher than the non asthmatic group but not significantly, while three components Artv 1, Art v 3, and Art an 7 showed a statistically significant difference (Figure 3A). With increasing numbers of allergens recognized, the frequency of allergic asthma increased, but this was not observed for the other three allergic symptoms (Figure 3B). Furthermore, the frequency of sensitization to Artv 1, Art v 3, and Art an 7 was also significantly higher in patients with allergic asthma (Figure 3C), resulting in an approximately 3‐fold higher risk of allergic asthma in patients sensitized to Artv 1 (OR, 3.26; 95% CI, 1.53‐6.94; P = 0.002), Art v 3 (OR, 2.77; 95% CI, 1.63‐4.72; P = 0.001), and Art an 7 (OR, 3.28; 95% CI, 1.58‐6.78; P = 0.001).
Figure 3
The interrelation of asthma and non asthma symptoms with IgE levels (A), number of sensitized allergens, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Art v 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (B) and component positive frequency between asthma and non asthma groups (C). Significant differences are shown *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
The interrelation of asthma and non asthma symptoms with IgE levels (A), number of sensitized allergens, 0 indicates none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual allergens Artv 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7 (B) and component positive frequency between asthma and non asthma groups (C). Significant differences are shown *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]To exclude the influence of geographic background on association of sensitization profiles and age with allergic asthma, analyses were performed for the 178 patients from SX alone. There were no significant differences between asthmatic and non asthmatic groups for IgE values of mugwort extracts and four individual components (Figure 4A). There was a weak but significant correlation between patients’ age and asthma symptoms (Spearman r = 0.284, P < 0.001), with adults suffering more often from asthma than children (Table 2, Figure 4B). Asthmatic patients had a higher frequency of IgE reactivity to three or four allergens than the non asthmatic patients (0‐2 components) (P = 0.001, OR, 2.86, 95% CI, 1.49‐5.50) (Figure 4C). The sensitization frequency to Artv 1 (P = 0.027) and Art v 3 (P = 0.01) was significantly higher than in the non asthma group (Table 2), and more than a 2‐fold risk of allergic asthma was found in Artemisia pollen‐allergicpatients with IgE reactivity to Artv 1 (OR, 2.64; 95% CI, 1.09‐6.36) and Art v 3 (OR, 2.30; 95% CI, 1.21‐4.37). No significant differences were observed for the other two allergens (Table 2). The interrelation of symptoms and sensitized allergens in asthmatic and non asthmatic groups is shown in Figure 4D,E, with the number of patients reacting to both Artv 1 and Art v 3 being significantly higher (P < 0.03) in asthmatic (72.6%) than non‐asthmatic allergypatients (48.9%).
Figure 4
IgE reactivity of asthmatic and non‐asthmatic patients from Shanxi province. A, specific IgE levels to mugwort extract and four component allergens (Art v 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3 and Art an 7); B, distribution of asthmatic and non asthmatic patients among different age groups; C, multiple allergens sensitizations in asthma and non asthma groups, 0‐none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual Art v 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7; and D, Venn diagrams of the interrelation of sensitized allergens in asthma and non asthma groups; the median is shown as a red solid line, significant differences: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001
Table 2
Characterization of asthmatic and non asthmatic patients from Shanxi
Patients, no. (%)
Non asthmatic
Asthmatic
Total
P value
Patients, no. (%)
93 (52)
85 (48)
178 (100)
Age median (range)
16 (6‐59)
28 (4‐61)
22 (4‐61)
<0.001
Allergen positive no. (%)
Art v 1
73 (79)
77 (91)
150 (84)
0.027
Art ar 2
44 (47)
42 (49)
86 (48)
0.779
Art v 3
53 (57)
64 (75)
117 (66)
0.01
Art an 7
77 (83)
78 (92)
155 (87)
0.075
IgE reactivity of asthmatic and non‐asthmatic patients from Shanxi province. A, specific IgE levels to mugwort extract and four component allergens (Artv 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3 and Art an 7); B, distribution of asthmatic and non asthmatic patients among different age groups; C, multiple allergens sensitizations in asthma and non asthma groups, 0‐none of the four tested components were positive, and 1, 2, 3, and 4 represent the number of positive individual Artv 1, Art ar 2, Art v 3, and Art an 7; and D, Venn diagrams of the interrelation of sensitized allergens in asthma and non asthma groups; the median is shown as a red solid line, significant differences: *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001Characterization of asthmatic and non asthmatic patients from Shanxi
DISCUSSION
This study provides new insights in mugwort component sensitization and clinical significance in China. From both sensitization frequencies and IgE titers, we can draw a general conclusion that three allergens qualify as major allergens in China: Artv 1, Art v 3, and Art an 7. These results are in line with those from Europe27 and our immunoblots of three widely recognized allergens in Northern China.21 Artv 1 and Art an 7 were consistently the most prevalent (more than 80%) in the three areas, indicating that these two allergens are biomarkers of Artemisia pollens inducing allergic reactions. From the observations obtained from Shanxi and Shandong, we estimate the prevalence of Artv 1 at 84%‐93% in Northern China, which is quite similar to that of the mugwort‐allergicpatients in Europe but higher than in North America.24, 27 Median Artv 1IgE value was also similar to those in Northern Europe. Art an 7 was assumed to be in the same allergen group as Art v 60 kDa, which was reported about 20 years ago and has recently been identified as a putative galactose oxidase with a very high rate of sensitization (around 90%).21 In the present study, the frequency of Art an 7 sensitization was quite similar, at 87% in SX and slightly lower in SD. The prevalence and degree of sensitization to Art v 3 were quite different in these two areas, with 66% in SX and 25% in SD. Very significant differences with respect to recognition of Art v 3 amongst mugwort‐allergicpatients have also been reported in Europe.20 Although the prevalence of 66% in SX is quite similar to that reported in central Europe,10, 28 IgE levels are much higher. The striking difference between SX and SD is most likely explained by a higher pollen load in SX and possibly by different Artemisia species dominating in the regions.7, 28 Art ar 2 had the least prevalence (42%‐48%) and IgE levels, being close to the 58% for Art v 2 reported in Europe.29This is the first study to explore a possible relationship between Artemisia pollen molecular sensitization profiles and seasonal allergic asthma. Mugwort‐allergicpatients sensitized to three or four allergens had a higher risk of asthma (56.4%, OR is 2.86‐3.65) than patients sensitized to two or less (31.1%). In line with this, in YN, with very low Artemisia pollen exposure (ratio of the total pollen count in peak month in SX, SD, and YN is 10:6:1, Figure S1) and the majority of patients being sensitized to ≤2 allergens, only one in 30 patients had allergic asthma (Figure 2D). Sensitization to a higher number of allergens is usually accompanied by a higher IgE level and potential broader cross‐reactivity to allergens of pollens from not only Artemisa, but also from other genera in the Asteraceae family, such as Dendranthema, Helianthus, Xanthium, and Ambrosia. Artv 1 was ranked highest in inducing asthma because of its higher prevalence and OR values related to asthma. Art v 3 is the second major allergen, although its prevalence was lower than Artv 1; sensitized patients can have very high IgE levels in Northern China, and allergic reactions due to cross‐reactivity to various fruits, peanut, soybean, wheat, sunflower seed have been reported in this study and previously.16, 30, 31The four components used are natural proteins, so potential CCD involvement in the IgE binding cannot be excluded for those allergens known to be glycoproteins, that is, Artv 1, Art ar 2, and Art an 7. Art v 3 is a lipid transfer protein and is not glycosylated. Of the three glycoproteins, the Art ar 2 and Art an 7 carry typical CCD‐like N‐linked glycans,21, 29 whereas Artv 1 has O‐linked glycans that have also been described to be recognized by IgE of some patients.32 It can therefore not be excluded that both types of glycan‐specific IgE antibodies play a role in recognition of the three allergens. However, we think the role of CCD‐specific IgE is quite limited in Chinese patients, as in our recent paper on Art an 7,21 we tested CCD in 21 patients, and found a low frequency of positivity (4/21) with low IgE levels. Moreover, our ongoing research indicates that recombinant of Artv 1 has similar IgE binding potency in mugwort‐allergicpatients, suggesting a minor role for IgE binding to Artv 1's O‐linked glycans.A small number of sera demonstrated significantly higher IgE binding to mugwort extract than to the sum of IgE responses against the four components tested in the present study (Figure S2). This suggests that for these patients other components are probably relevant. Similar to what was reported earlier,22 Art v 5 seems to be of minor importance, and ten of these sera were negative for IgE reactivity to rArt an 5. We speculate Art v 4 and Art v 6 are most likely to be the missing components because of their broad cross‐reactivity.33Because of the geographic difference associated with different Artemisia species distribution and pollen load in China, the pattern of Artemisia pollen allergen sensitization between the north and south China is dramatically different. Here, we selected two commercially available components from European (A. vulgaris) and two noncommercially available from Chinese mugwort (A. argyi and A. annua). This choice was made to combine convenience (commercial availability) with local relevance (dominant Chinese mugwort species). It is however unlikely that the different species display much difference in IgE binding potencies because IgE responses are expected to be highly cross‐reactive between species within a genus. This assumption is based on ongoing investigations into sequence identity and variation of seven homologous allergen groups in seven Artemisia species. The results so far indicate that sequence identity is very high, perhaps with the exception of group 3, that is, the LTPs that show some more heterogeneity. Therefore, it is safe to assume that the total Artemisia pollen load (exposure) has the largest impact on the degree of mugwort pollen allergy prevalence and its clinical phenotypes, not the possible geographic variation in mugwort species. Also a recent study provides support for this in showing that regional differences in pollen induced allergic rhinitis are associated with pollen load due to environmental and climate conditions in Inner Mongolia, China.34 Inner Mongolia is north of Shanxi Province, where we enrolled 66% of patients in this research.Most mugwortallergypatients have previously been found to first suffer mild allergic rhinitis symptoms at median age of 27.9 years, with a transition to asthma usually taking about 5 years (median age of 32.6 years),7 and becoming more common after middle age. In this study, the median age was found to be 23 years for allergic rhinitis, and 28 years for allergic asthma, 5 years earlier than previous reports. This difference in the process toward allergic asthma in teenagers may be related to higher IgE values of extract and components (Figure 1A). The main reason is perhaps the significantly higher exposure to Artemisia pollen due to the warmer climate (annual average temperature +1.5°C) and uncontrolled growth and spread of several dominant Artemisia plants in waste and marginal lands or roadsides in the suburbs and countryside in North China over the last 30 years. A comparison over 30 years in Taiyuan, Shanxi Province, showed the total Artemisia spp. pollen count had increased 36%, with the peak lasting 2 weeks longer.35 This indicates a need to control the growth and spread of Artemisia plants in the wild.In conclusion, different sensitization patterns and symptoms were observed in mugwort‐allergicpatients from Northern and Southern China. Sensitization to three or more mugwort allergens resulted in a higher risk of allergic asthma.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This study was supported by a grant from Hangzhou Aileji Biotech Ltd, China (2016‐R1) and by the Natural Science Foundation of China (31772271). We thank Dr. Hongshan Ma for his administrative support and Ms Hong‐li Chen, Jing Yang, Wen‐jun Wang, Xiao‐jing Du from Datong 3rd People's Hospital for their contribution in sera collection. We thank Dr. Luud Gilissen for critical comments on the draft and Dr. Shirley Burgess for correcting the English. University of Amsterdam covers the open access charge.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
ZS Gao and WY Fu received a grant from Hangzhou Aileji BioTech Ltd (2016‐R1), China. ZS Gao received a grant from Natural Science Foundation of China (31772271). A patent to predict the potential Artemisia pollen allergic asthma has been applied in China (201810913872.5 pending) by ZS Gao, WY Fu, and BY Gao. The remaining authors declare that they have no relevant conflict of interests.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION
ZSG, RVR, FF, GG, and HYW conceived and designed the study. WYF, JJ, LZ, SAV, and BYG purified and characterized new allergen components. YMS, MLL, FML, LYW, XFW, BHG, YF, NBT, JYZ, and HYW were involved in the clinical study of patients. WYF, SDW, YMS, XZ, YL, JJ, LZ, and BYG conducted ImmunoCAP test and data analysis. ZSG, WYF, YMS, RvR, GG, and JYZ drafted the manuscript in collaboration with all co‐authors.Click here for additional data file.Click here for additional data file.
Authors: M Smith; S Jäger; U Berger; B Sikoparija; M Hallsdottir; I Sauliene; K-C Bergmann; C H Pashley; L de Weger; B Majkowska-Wojciechowska; O Rybníček; M Thibaudon; R Gehrig; M Bonini; R Yankova; A Damialis; D Vokou; A M Gutiérrez Bustillo; K Hoffmann-Sommergruber; R van Ree Journal: Allergy Date: 2014-05-10 Impact factor: 13.146
Authors: Andrea Wangorsch; Stephan Scheurer; Miguel Blanca; Natalia Blanca-Lopez; María Luisa Somoza; Laura Martín-Pedraza Journal: Front Allergy Date: 2022-02-08