Chidambar Kulkarni1, Stefan C J Meskers1, Anja R A Palmans1, E W Meijer1. 1. Laboratory of Macromolecular and Organic Chemistry and Institute for Complex Molecular Systems, Eindhoven University of Technology, P.O. Box 513, Eindhoven 5600 MB, The Netherlands.
Abstract
Chiral conjugated polymers bearing enantiopure side chains offer the possibility to harness the effect of chirality in organic electronic devices. However, its use is hampered by the low degree of circular polarization in absorption (gabs) in most of the conjugated polymer thin-films studied. Here we demonstrate a versatile method to significantly increase the gabs by using a few weight percentages of a commercially available achiral long-chain alcohol as an additive. This additive enhances the chiroptical properties in both absorption and emission by ca. 5-10 times in the thin-films. We envisage that the alcohol additive acts as a plasticizer which enhances the long-range chiral liquid crystalline ordering of the polymer chains, thereby amplifying the chiroptical properties in the thin-film. The application of this methodology to various conjugated polymers has been demonstrated.
Chiral conjugated polymers bearing enantiopure side chains offer the possibility to harness the effect of chirality in organic electronic devices. However, its use is hampered by the low degree of circular polarization in absorption (gabs) in most of the conjugated polymer thin-films studied. Here we demonstrate a versatile method to significantly increase the gabs by using a few weight percentages of a commercially available achiral long-chain alcohol as an additive. This additive enhances the chiroptical properties in both absorption and emission by ca. 5-10 times in the thin-films. We envisage that the alcohol additive acts as a plasticizer which enhances the long-range chiral liquid crystalline ordering of the polymer chains, thereby amplifying the chiroptical properties in the thin-film. The application of this methodology to various conjugated polymers has been demonstrated.
Conjugated semiconducting
polymers form the active component of
organic electronic devices such as solar cells, light-emitting diodes,
and field-effect transistors.[1−3] Most of the conjugated polymers
studied bear achiral or branched, but racemic, side chains to provide
better solubility in common organic solvents used for processing.[4] On the other hand, conjugated polymers bearing
enantiopure chiral side chains display new functionalities.[5,6] Circularly polarized photo- and electroluminescent devices based
on chiral conjugated oligomers and polymers have been studied for
application in advanced display technology.[7−10] Furthermore, chirality of the
molecular semiconductor has been utilized to construct chiral sensors[11] and to detect circularly polarized light.[12] The enantiopure molecular materials can show
chiral-induced spin-selectivity,[13] and
thus chiral molecular semiconductors can be applied as spin-filters.[14] The impact of the chirality of a semiconductor
was further demonstrated by Fuchter and co-workers, where they observed
over 80-fold difference in the hole mobility of 1-aza[6]-helicene
in the thin-film state between enantiopure and racemic mixture.[15] Thus, it is clear that chirality of a system
or chiral supramolecular organization attained through enantiomerically
pure side chains can directly impact the desired functionality.[5,6] In order to exploit the manifestation of chirality in semiconductor
devices, it is paramount to achieve and control high degree of circular
polarization (defined as g = 2 × [(IL – IR)/(IL + IR)], where IL and IR are the intensities
of left and right circularly polarized light absorbed (gabs) or emitted (gPL), respectively)
of chiral conjugated polymer thin-films.Various approaches
to achieve high g-values (gabs, gPL, and gEL) in molecular systems can be broadly classified
into two main categories, namely, based (i) on molecular or local
origin, and (ii) on long-range ordering or a nonlocal mechanism. The
local origin of photo- and electroluminescence (gEL > 1) is observed for lanthanide[16−18] and platinium[19] complexes with chiral ligands. Since the emission
originates at a molecular level, the observed g-values
are independent of the long-range ordering in the system. Although
this approach yields high g-values, it has a few
shortcomings, namely, a low photoluminescence quantum yield, an electronically
forbidden transitions in metal complexes leading to narrow emission
band, and finally the structurally unique chiral ligands such as helicenes
further limiting the scope of this approach.On the other hand,
Chen and co-workers have shown that chiral oligo(fluorenes)[8,20] exhibit highly ordered chiral liquid crystalline phases such as
cholesterics in annealed films with g-values >0.1.
The cholesteric ordering has been mainly observed for poly(fluorene)
homopolymers,[21,22] copolymer,[23−26] and poly(p-phenyleneethynylene)s[27] which exhibited g-values ranging
from 0.1 to 1 in annealed thin-films. Unlike the metal complexes discussed
previously, the chiral poly(fluorene)s[28,23] and poly(thiophene)s[29] show a strong film-thickness dependence of gabs, indicating that the long-range cholesteric
ordering dictates the g-value in such systems. Chiral
poly(fluorene-alt-benzothiadiazole) (c-PFBT) has
been shown to form a multidomain cholesteric organization with high g-values,[23,30] and this has been utilized to
achieve highly circularly polarized OLEDs.[9] To enhance the chiral organization of c-PFBT through cholesteric
ordering and plasmonic effect, Prasad and co-workers have used gold
nanoparticles (diameter 4–10 nm) as additive to c-PFBTpolymer,
and annealing the nanocomposite films resulted in enhanced circular
dichroism effect.[31] Further, an alternative
route to induce cholesteric organization and high g-values to conjugated polymers was successfully demonstrated by the
addition of a chiral dopant with high helical twisting power to an
achiral conjugated polymer such as poly(9,9′-dioctylfluorene-alt-benzothiadiazole) (F8BT).[32,33] In spite of
the above-mentioned efforts, a vast number of enantiopure chiral conjugated
polymers exhibit no apparent cholesteric organization, thus impeding
their applications.Here we have developed a generally applicable
and facile method
to significantly enhance the chiroptical properties of conjugated
polymer thin-films. Our approach uses a cheap, commercially available,
and achiral additive to improve the chiral liquid crystalline ordering
of enantiopure conjugated polymer thin-films, thus leading to significantly
enhanced chiroptical properties. To study the effect of the additive,
we have chosen the chiral analogues of a known archetypical red-emitting
diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP) alternating fluorene copolymer.[34] First, we show the effect of the additive on
the chiroptical and photophysical properties of the polymer. Then,
we shed light on the influence of the additive on the mesoscopic organization
of the polymer, and finally we conclude by showing the general applicability
of the approach to other conjugated polymers.
Results and Discussion
All the three fluorene-alt-DPPpolymers (Figure a) were synthesized
by Suzuki-polycondensation and characterized using 1H-, 13C NMR, and GPC (See Supporting Information Figures S1–S18). All polymers showed good thermal stability
without any degradation until 300 °C (Figure S19). Further thermal analysis by differential scanning calorimetry
(DSC) showed that all polymers exhibit only a weak endothermic transition
at high temperatures, without any discernible glass-transition temperature
(Figure S20). Polarized optical microscopy
(POM) images of F8*- polymer
recorded under cross-polarizer showed that around the weak endothermic
transition observed in DSC, the polymer becomes more fluidic, and
the birefringence increases and moreover the birefringence is retained
on further cooling the sample to room temperature (Figure S21). Thus, based on DSC and POM results, we designate
the temperature at which polymer transitions from a less ordered amorphous
to ordered, birefringent phase as Ttrans. Due to the rather weak and broad Ttrans transition, all the polymers thin-films were annealed at higher
temperature (280 °C) to ensure the complete transition. The thermal
and molecular weight distribution of the polymers are presented in Table S1. Most of the studies here will be focused
on F8*- polymer, where the asterisk
sign indicates the position of the chiral unit.
Figure 1
Enhancing chiroptical
properties with an additive. (a) Structure
of the fluorene copolymers investigated in this study. Asterisk sign
indicates the position of the chiral side chains. (b) Structure and
important physical properties of the achiral polyethylene monoalcohol
(PEM-OH) used as a processing additive. (c) CD spectra
of F8*- films embedded with different
weight percentage of PEM-OH at 20 °C. The films
were annealed at 280 °C for 15 min and cooled down to room temperature
before measuring CD spectra. Arrow indicates spectral changes with
increasing weight percentage of PEM-OH. (d) |gabs| at CD maximum as a function of weight percentage
of PEM-OH based on CD spectra shown in (c). The solid
black line is a guide to the eye to indicate the trend in |gabs|. The gray bar indicates the percentage
around which maximum enhancement is observed. Typical film thickness
= 120 ± 20 nm.
Enhancing chiroptical
properties with an additive. (a) Structure
of the fluorene copolymers investigated in this study. Asterisk sign
indicates the position of the chiral side chains. (b) Structure and
important physical properties of the achiral polyethylene monoalcohol
(PEM-OH) used as a processing additive. (c) CD spectra
of F8*- films embedded with different
weight percentage of PEM-OH at 20 °C. The films
were annealed at 280 °C for 15 min and cooled down to room temperature
before measuring CD spectra. Arrow indicates spectral changes with
increasing weight percentage of PEM-OH. (d) |gabs| at CD maximum as a function of weight percentage
of PEM-OH based on CD spectra shown in (c). The solid
black line is a guide to the eye to indicate the trend in |gabs|. The gray bar indicates the percentage
around which maximum enhancement is observed. Typical film thickness
= 120 ± 20 nm.
Enhancing Chiroptical Properties
of F8*- Thin-Films with an Additive
The pristine films
(∼120 ± 20 nm) of F8*- spin-coated from a chloroform solution on glass substrate did not
exhibit any Cotton effect (Figure S22a).
Upon annealing, a clear Cotton effect was observed, and the maximum
effect was seen when annealed at 280 °C (Figure S22a), beyond the Ttrans of the polymer (∼240 °C). The gabs was found to be −5 × 10–3 (at 540 nm), which is in similar range as observed for most of the
conjugated polymers in thin-films. The low magnitude of the gabs can be explained by the local chiral ordering
of the polymer chains.In order to enhance the chiroptical properties
of F8*- in the thin-film, here
we have chosen the commercially available alcohol, namely, polyethylene
monoalcohol (PEM-OH) with an average 48 methylene units
and a Tm of 108–110 °C as
an additive (Figure b). First we look at the effect of the additive on the Cotton effect
at a constant film thickness (∼120 ± 20 nm). The PEM-OH and F8*- were
mixed in a good solvent and spin-coated on glass substrates and annealed
beyond the Ttrans and Tm of both F8*- and PEM-OH, respectively, and finally the CD spectra of thin-films
were recorded at 20 °C (see the Methods section for detailed procedure). The CD spectra show a pronounced enhancement
in Cotton effect with addition of small amount (2–6 wt %) of PEM-OH. The sign of the Cotton effect is unaffected, and only
the magnitude increases with addition of PEM-OH. The
enhancement in magnitude of the Cotton effect saturates around 6–8
wt %, and with further increase in the amount of PEM-OH, a small decrease in the magnitude of the Cotton effect was observed
(Figure c). We noticed
a 15–20 nm red-shift of the CD maximum going from 0 to 40 wt
% of PEM-OH. To quantify the enhancement in chiroptical
properties, we study the evolution of gabs with addition of PEM-OH. The gabs changes from −5 × 10–3 for
pristine polymer film to −6 × 10–2 for
8 wt % of PEM-OH blended films (Figure d). The gabs remained
−5 ± 1 × 10–2 with addition of
higher weight percentage of PEM-OH. Linear dichroism
spectra on films with different weight percentage of PEM-OH showed negligible anisotropy in the films (Figure S23), indicating that such artifacts do not contribute significantly
to the observed CD signals. For all the different weight percentages
of PEM-OH, the UV–vis absorption spectra of the
polymer remain unaltered in the thin-film (Figure S24). Similarly, both the steady-state and time-resolved photoluminescence
spectra of F8*- are unaltered
by the addition of PEM-OH (Figure S25), suggesting no electronic perturbation of the F8*- on addition of PEM-OH.As it has been previously shown that gabs strongly depends on the film thickness for fluorene-based polymers,[28] we have looked into the film-thickness dependence
of gabs for F8*- both without and with PEM-OH. Annealed thin-films
of F8*- (without PEM-OH) show an increase in gabs from −0.002
(80 nm) to −0.034 (200 ± 10 nm) with an increase in film
thickness (Figure a). Further, by combining the effect of PEM-OH (8 wt
%) with the film-thickness dependence we could observe significant
enhancement in gabs, and a maximum gabs of −0.13 could be achieved for a
film thickness of 240 ± 20 nm (Figure a). This indicates that both the effect of PEM-OH and film-thickness dependence operate synergistically
to achieve high |gabs| (>0.1) in annealed
films.
Figure 2
(a) Thickness dependence of |gabs|
for F8*- annealed thin-films
without and with (8 wt %) PEM-OH. The solid lines is
a guide to the eye to indicate the trend. Error bars in the film thickness
indicate the thickness distribution on different parts of the film.
(b) Degree of circular polarization in photoluminescence (gPL) without and with (8 wt %) of PEM-OH when excited at 356 nm. The weight percentage of the PEM-OH and film thickness are mentioned in (b). All the films were annealed
at 280 °C for 15 min, and the spectra are recorded at 20 °C.
(a) Thickness dependence of |gabs|
for F8*- annealed thin-films
without and with (8 wt %) PEM-OH. The solid lines is
a guide to the eye to indicate the trend. Error bars in the film thickness
indicate the thickness distribution on different parts of the film.
(b) Degree of circular polarization in photoluminescence (gPL) without and with (8 wt %) of PEM-OH when excited at 356 nm. The weight percentage of the PEM-OH and film thickness are mentioned in (b). All the films were annealed
at 280 °C for 15 min, and the spectra are recorded at 20 °C.We have further investigated the
influence of the PEM-OH additive and film thickness on
the degree of circular polarization
in photoluminescence (gPL) for F8*-. Pristine annealed F8*- film (thickness of 120 nm) shows a gPL of −0.0019 (at 573 nm). For a film of similar
thickness with 8 wt % of PEM-OH, a gPL of −0.048 (at 583 nm) was observed, showing
>25 times increase in gPL on addition
of PEM-OH. Combining both the effects of adding PEM-OH (8 wt %) and film thickness (240 ± 20 nm), gPL of −0.11 (at 583 nm) was observed
with an enhancement in gPL of >50 times
compared to the pristine annealed films of F8*-. Thus, the PEM-OH additive can lead to significant
enhancement in chiroptical properties (gabs and gPL).To understand the origin
of the enhancement on addition of PEM-OH, we first studied
if the alcohol group of PEM-OH is really necessary for
amplification of chiroptical properties
in the thin-film. In place of PEM-OH, a linear chain
alkane with 42 methylene units (C44H90, tetratetracontane),
similar to the number of methylene units in PEM-OH, was
used as an additive. The CD spectra of the pristine annealed film
and with 7 wt % of tetratetracontane were identical (Figure S26a), indicating no enhancement in gabs on addition of tetratetracontane. It is to be noted
that with PEM-OH at similar weight percentage (6–8
wt %), the maximum enhancement was already observed. However, with
20 wt % of tetratetracontane the gabs increased to −0.02, an enhancement of <2 times
compared to the pristine films (Figure S26c). This suggests that alcohol group on the long-chain alkane is important
in achieving high enhancement factor. Further, we have also looked
into the role of polymer self-assembly in alcohol as solvent and its
relation to the enhancement in chiroptical properties in thin-film.
First we studied F8*-, which
showed significantly high gabs (∼
−0.02) when self-assembled in dilute n-butanol
as solvent (Figure S27), and it was also
observed that addition of PEM-OH resulted in improved gabs in annealed thin-film (Figure c). However, F8-, a structural isomer of F8*- with chiral side chains on the DPP unit,
did not show any Cotton effect (helical organization) in n-decanol (Figure S28a), and also the annealed
thin-films of F8- with PEM-OH additive showed low gabs of 10–3 (Figure S28b, c). Where the solution experiments give evidence for the presence
of a chiral packing in nanosized aggregates, the thin-film experiments
show the presence of macroscopic chiral liquid crystalline ordering.
Apparently, the need for a nanoscopic local arrangement is amplified
macroscopically.
Morphological Characterization of Pristine
and PEM-OH Blended Films
Having established
the importance of polymer
self-assembly in alcohols as solvent and the role of alcohol group
of PEM-OH in enhancement of chiroptical properties, we
further investigated the interaction of PEM-OH with F8*- polymer chains. The FT-IR spectra
of F8*- thin-films (∼120
nm) without and with 5–20 wt % of PEM-OH showed
no clear shifts in both the C=O stretching of the DPP units
and the C–H stretching of the alkyl chains (Figure S29), suggesting no chemical interactions between F8*- and PEM-OH. The
effect of the PEM-OH on mesoscopic organization of F8*- was further investigated by polarized
optical microscopy (POM). POM images of pristine annealed films (∼165
± 10 nm) show birefringence without a clear texture. However,
on closer examination we see small features (3–6 μm)
reminiscent of nematic ordering (Figure a). On the other hand, the 10 wt % PEM-OH blended films shows clear birefringence with large
domains (10–20 μm) present through most part of the film
(Figure b). This suggests
that, on addition of PEM-OH, the chiral liquid crystalline
ordering in the sample gets enhanced. The effect of PEM-OH on surface topography was studied through tapping-mode atomic force
microscopy (AFM). The AFM height images of pristine annealed F8*- films shows a network of fibers
with a very smooth surface (±14 nm, Figure c). However, the 10 wt % blended films show
platelet like topography with an increased surface roughness of 80–100
nm (Figure d). The
lack of fibrillary morphology indicates marked difference between
the pristine and PEM-OH blended films. Further differential
scanning calorimetric (DSC) studies were carried out to study the
bulk phase behavior of polymer on addition of PEM-OH.
Pristine polymer shows weak transition (Ttrans) around 230–240 °C (Figure S30). With 12.5 wt % of PEM-OH embedded into the polymers,
first the melting of PEM-OH was observed at 108–112
°C, and with further heating near the Ttrans of F8*- a clear
exothermic transition was observed (Figure S30). This exothermic peak (cold crystallization) on the heating run
indicates ordering of polymer and PEM-OH mixture near
the Ttrans of F8*-.
Figure 3
Morphological characterization of the effect of PEM-OH on F8*- annealed
thin-films.
(a) and (b) Polarized optical microscopy image of F8*- annealed films without and with 10 wt % of PEM-OH, respectively, under crossed polarizers. The white
circles indicate regions in which a nematic like texture is observed.
Note that the size of regions is much larger in (b) compared to (a).
The thickness of film for POM images was 165 ± 10 nm. (c) and
(d) Tapping mode atomic force microscopy height images of F8*- annealed films without and with 10 wt % PEM-OH, respectively. Note that the scale bar for both (c)
and (d) is the same (1 μm). The film thickness for AFM studies
was ∼120 nm.
Morphological characterization of the effect of PEM-OH on F8*- annealed
thin-films.
(a) and (b) Polarized optical microscopy image of F8*- annealed films without and with 10 wt % of PEM-OH, respectively, under crossed polarizers. The white
circles indicate regions in which a nematic like texture is observed.
Note that the size of regions is much larger in (b) compared to (a).
The thickness of film for POM images was 165 ± 10 nm. (c) and
(d) Tapping mode atomic force microscopy height images of F8*- annealed films without and with 10 wt % PEM-OH, respectively. Note that the scale bar for both (c)
and (d) is the same (1 μm). The film thickness for AFM studies
was ∼120 nm.In order to study this
ordering, bulk wide-angle X-ray scattering
(WAXS) experiments were performed. The WAXS profile of annealed F8*- shows a principal peak at 0.35
Å–1 corresponding to a distance of 17.5 Å
which matches well with the distance between the fully elongated chiral
chains on the fluorene (Figure S31a, b).
In addition to the principal peak, other weak peaks at 0.68 and 1.21
Å–1 and a broad halo centered at 1.38 Å–1 were observed. These features suggests that F8*- exhibits a semicrystalline organization,
and this is also consistent with the disordered fibrillary morphology
observed in AFM (Figure c). On addition of PEM-OH, only minor changes were observed
in the WAXS profile, suggesting that the semicrystalline nature of F8*- is maintained (Figure S31c). It is worth noting that the liquid crystalline
ordering observed in POM on addition of PEM-OH is at
a much larger length scale (few micrometers) compared to local ordering
(nanometer scale) probed using WAXS measurements.Based on DSC,
POM, and AFM studies, the structural evolution of
the F8*- on addition of PEM-OH can be visualized as shown in Figure . At room temperature (either in thin-film
or bulk), both PEM-OH and the semicrystalline F8*- exist as physical mixture (Figure a). On heating beyond the melting
point of PEM-OH, it melts and blends into the matrix
of F8*- (Figure b). On further heating near the Ttrans of the polymer, the polymer softens or in other
words the semicrystalline regions in the polymer melt (Figure c), and it now interacts with
the molten PEM-OH leading to cold crystallization or
ordering into a nematic-like phase (Figure d). Thus, the PEM-OH enhances
the chiroptical properties in the thin-film by improving the chiral
liquid crystalline ordering of the polymer chains without a direct
chemical interaction with the polymer chains.
Figure 4
Schematic illustration
of the influence of PEM-OH on
the morphology of the conjugated polymer. The glass substrate is depicted
in gray, the black lines represent polymer chains, the yellow lines
indicate PEM-OH, and the cyan regions illustrate the
semiordered regions in the sample. (a) Shows the physical mixture
of crystalline PEM-OH and semicrystalline polymer at
room temperature. (b) Around the melting point of PEM-OH, the crystallites of PEM-OH break down, and the polymer
does not undergo any changes. On furthering heating until Ttrans or Tm of polymer,
both polymer and PEM-OH mix (c) and instantaneously undergo
cold-crystallization (d) leading to ordered regions containing PEM-OH (the cyan regions in (d)).
Schematic illustration
of the influence of PEM-OH on
the morphology of the conjugated polymer. The glass substrate is depicted
in gray, the black lines represent polymer chains, the yellow lines
indicate PEM-OH, and the cyan regions illustrate the
semiordered regions in the sample. (a) Shows the physical mixture
of crystallinePEM-OH and semicrystalline polymer at
room temperature. (b) Around the melting point of PEM-OH, the crystallites of PEM-OH break down, and the polymer
does not undergo any changes. On furthering heating until Ttrans or Tm of polymer,
both polymer and PEM-OH mix (c) and instantaneously undergo
cold-crystallization (d) leading to ordered regions containing PEM-OH (the cyan regions in (d)).
Generality of the PEM-OH Methodology
Finally,
we have looked into the general applicability of the PEM-OH methodology to enhance chiroptical properties in other π-conjugated
polymers. The polymers we have chosen are the fully chiral F8*-, c-PFBT, and chiral poly(thiophene)
(PBMBT) (Figure a and 5a). F8*- and c-PFBTpolymers self-assemble in n-decanol with gabs of 0.008
and −0.07, respectively (Figure S32). Chiral poly(thiophene) (PBMBT) has also been observed
to show significantly high gabs (∼0.08)
in n-decanol as solvent at low concentration.[35,36] Further, the PEM-OH embedded films indeed show an enhancement
of 10 and 5 times for F8*- and c-PFBT, respectively (see Figure S33, Figure S34, Figure b, and Table ). Annealed PBMBT films blended with different
weight percentage of PEM-OH also showed improved chiroptical
properties (Figure S35, Figure b), but the maximum gabs was observed around 30 wt % of the additive
(Table ).
Figure 5
Application
of PEM-OH addition strategy to other π-conjugated
polymers. (a) Chemical structure of c-PFBT and PBMBT. (b) Evolution of |gabs|
at the maximum of CD effect in annealed thin-films as a function of
different weight percentage of PEM-OH. The black solid
is a guide to the eye. c-PFBT, PBMBT, and F8*- films were annealed at 150,
170, and 280 °C, respectively, for 15 min and cooled down. Thicknesses
of c-PFBT, PBMBT, and F8*- films were 90 ± 10, 80 ± 20, and
120 ± 10 nm, respectively. All the CD spectra were recorded at
20 °C.
Table 1
Comparison
of Chiroptical Properties
of Different Polymers with and without PEM-OH
polymer
gabs for pristine filmsa (gabs,prist)
max. gabs for PEM–OH blended filmsa (gabs, PEM-OH) (wt % of PEM-OH)b
enhancement
factor (gabs,PEM–OH/gabs,prist)
gPL for pristine
filmsa
max. gPL for PEM-OH blended filmsa
F8*-alt-DPP
–5 × 10–3
–6 × 10–2 (8 wt %)
12
–9 × 10–3
5 × 10–2
F8*-alt-DPP*
–8 × 10–2
–1 × 10–1 (10 wt %)
12.5
N.D.
N.D.
c-PFBT
–4 × 10–2
–2 × 10–1 (10 wt %)
5
–3 × 10–2
2.4 × 10–1
PBMBT
–1 × 10–3
–9 × 10–2 (30 wt %)
6–8
N.D.
N.D.
Annealed films.
The values in the parentheses indicate
the percentage were maximum gabs was observed,
N.D.: not determined.
Application
of PEM-OH addition strategy to other π-conjugated
polymers. (a) Chemical structure of c-PFBT and PBMBT. (b) Evolution of |gabs|
at the maximum of CD effect in annealed thin-films as a function of
different weight percentage of PEM-OH. The black solid
is a guide to the eye. c-PFBT, PBMBT, and F8*- films were annealed at 150,
170, and 280 °C, respectively, for 15 min and cooled down. Thicknesses
of c-PFBT, PBMBT, and F8*- films were 90 ± 10, 80 ± 20, and
120 ± 10 nm, respectively. All the CD spectra were recorded at
20 °C.Annealed films.The values in the parentheses indicate
the percentage were maximum gabs was observed,
N.D.: not determined.Further
the PBMBT films annealed at 120 °C (below
the Tm ∼ 160 °C of polymer)
did not show any enhancement in Cotton effect (Figure S36). However, when the films were annealed at 170
°C, that is, beyond the Tm of both
the PEM-OH (108–110 °C) and PBMBT (∼160 °C), the gabs was
significantly enhanced (Figure b and Figure S35). This indicates
that annealing beyond the Tm of both PEM-OH and the polymer is necessary for them to undergo intermixing
and leading to more ordered organization. DSC thermogram of PBMBT with 4 wt % of PEM-OH showed improved crystallization
compared to the pristine polymer (Figure S37). Similarly, F8*- also showed
a strong cold crystallization with 27 wt % of PEM-OH at
∼230 °C (Ttrans of the polymer, Figure S38). These observations are similar to
that seen for F8*-, indicating
that a similar mechanism of enhancement is operative for these polymers
as well.Furthermore, the PEM-OH blended films
of c-PFBT show gPL reaching
−0.2 to −0.3
at higher weight percentage of PEM-OH (Figure S39). It is noteworthy that c-PFBT was
previously shown to exhibit high gabs (∼0.15)
at an optimum of molecular weight.[23] However,
in the present study we have utilized the as synthesized polydisperse
sample without fractionation and could still achieve higher gabs (>0.2) than those observed for the optimum
molecular weight at a given film thickness (∼80 nm). Moreover,
Fuchter and co-workers[33] used 53% of 1-aza[6]helicene
to achieve a gabs of 0.2 for achiral F8BT,
whereas we could reach similar gabs values
at only 8–10 wt % of PEM-OH for c-PFBT. It was also observed that at low loading of PEM-OH (<10 wt %) the films were macroscopically uniform without affecting
any of the photophysical properties of the pristine polymers.
Outlook
and Conclusion
Here we have developed a method to improve
the chiroptical properties
in the thin-films of enantiopure conjugated polymers using a commercially
available achiral long-chain alcohol (PEM-OH) as an additive.
The enhancement in chiroptical properties is ca. 5–10 times
in the annealed thin-films and is applicable to a broad range of enantiopure
conjugated polymers. Based on microscopic studies, we attribute the
enhancement in chiroptical properties to improved chiral liquid crystalline
ordering of polymer chains on addition of PEM-OH. We
envisage that the PEM-OH acts as a supramolecular plasticizer
which aids in providing increased mobility to the polymer chains beyond Ttrans or Tm, thereby
improving their chiral liquid crystalline organization. PEM-OH can be viewed as a processing agent to enhance chiroptical properties,
analogues to the alkane di(thiol/iodide) which are widely used additives
to enhance the efficiency of organic solar cells.[37,38]We have identified the following criteria to be crucial for
the PEM-OH methodology to work: (i) the chiral self-assembly
of
the enantiopure conjugated polymers in alcohols as solvent is a prerequisite
to using the PEM-OH method in the thin-film, and (ii)
in principle this methodology could work with other long-chain alcohols
with appropriate thermal behavior (Tm, alcohol < Ttrans, polymer/Tm, polymer and that the alcohol additive remains
in the molten state at the Ttrans or Tm of the polymer). Since PEM-OH is a disperse polymer, it would be interesting to investigate the
effect of the dispersity of the long-chain alcohol additive on the
chiroptical enhancement. We anticipate that this new class of UV–vis–NIR
transparent long-chain alcohol additives which does not affect the
photophysical properties of the conjugated polymers will pave the
way for harnessing the chirality of enantiopure conjugated polymers
for various applications.
Methods
Sample Preparation
for PEM-OH Blended Films
A stock solution of PEM-OH at a concentration of 1 mg/mL
was prepared by dissolving the required amount of freshly powdered PEM-OH (as obtained from Sigma-Aldrich) in chloroform as the
solvent in a vial with PTFE seal cap (Note 1). The sealed vial containing PEM-OH and chloroform was heated at 70 °C (oil bath temp)
for 2 h to ensure complete dissolution of PEM-OH in chloroform.
The vial was further sonicated for 5 min and heated with a heat gun.
Separate vials (1.5 mL) containing ∼1.5–1.7 mg of the
polymer were charged with different amounts of the semihot PEM-OH stock solution (Note 2). The chloroform from each of the sample
vials was evaporated by gently blowing N2 gas and finally
heating with heat gun to ensure complete removal of the solvent. To
each of the sample vials, fresh chloroform was added such that the
concentration of the sample with respect to the polymer was 15 mg/mL
(Note 3). These vials were further heated on an oil bath at 70 °C
for 2 h to ensure the homogeneous mixing of the polymer and PEM-OH. The samples once cooled down to room temperature were
spin-coated (2000 rpm, 60 s, maximum acceleration) on clean glass
slides. The slides were further annealed beyond the Ttrans or Tm of the polymers
in a glovebox for 15 min. All the spectra are recorded at room temperature
(20 °C).Note 1: It is important to freshly powder the
commercially available PEM-OH pallets instead of using
powdered and stored PEM-OH. The extent of chirality enhancement
was found to be low with stored powder. Also it was observed that
powdered and stored PEM-OH was difficult to dissolve
in chloroform using the above-described procedure. We think it is
mostly due to the hygroscopic nature of the PEM-OH, which
might result in powdered sample adsorbing water and making it difficult
to dissolve in chloroform and consequently affecting the enhancement
factor.Note 2: By semihot we mean at a temperature of around
30–40
°C. By allowing the PEM-OH stock solution to cool
down to room temperature, we saw a white precipitate. Thus, PEM-OH may not be completely soluble in chloroform at room
temperature.Note 3: The concentration was with respect to the
amount of polymer
taken and not with respect to the total amount of the material (polymer
+ PEM-OH). This is because, by considering the concentration
with respect to the total material (polymer + PEM-OH),
the magnitude of Cotton effect decreases at higher weight percentage
of PEM-OH due to lowering of polymer concentration.
Authors: Heong Sub Oh; Sha Liu; HongSub Jee; Alexander Baev; Mark T Swihart; Paras N Prasad Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2010-11-19 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Luisa Torsi; Gianluca M Farinola; Francesco Marinelli; M Cristina Tanese; Omar Hassan Omar; Ludovico Valli; Francesco Babudri; Francesco Palmisano; P Giorgio Zambonin; Francesco Naso Journal: Nat Mater Date: 2008-04-20 Impact factor: 43.841
Authors: Daniele Di Nuzzo; Chidambar Kulkarni; Baodan Zhao; Eilam Smolinsky; Francesco Tassinari; Stefan C J Meskers; Ron Naaman; E W Meijer; Richard H Friend Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2017-12-01 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: James N Wilson; Winfried Steffen; Trent G McKenzie; Günter Lieser; Masao Oda; Dieter Neher; Uwe H F Bunz Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2002-06-19 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Yanhou Geng; Anita Trajkovska; Sean W Culligan; Jane J Ou; H M Philip Chen; Dimitris Katsis; Shaw H Chen Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2003-11-19 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Jessica Wade; James N Hilfiker; Jochen R Brandt; Letizia Liirò-Peluso; Li Wan; Xingyuan Shi; Francesco Salerno; Seán T J Ryan; Stefan Schöche; Oriol Arteaga; Tamás Jávorfi; Giuliano Siligardi; Cheng Wang; David B Amabilino; Peter H Beton; Alasdair J Campbell; Matthew J Fuchter Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2020-12-01 Impact factor: 14.919