Spin-induced multiferroicity in the binary perovskite manganite Mn2O3.

The ABO3 perovskite oxides exhibit a wide range of interesting physical phenomena remaining in the focus of extensive scientific investigations and various industrial applications. In order to form a perovskite structure, the cations occupying the A and B positions in the lattice, as a rule, should be different. Nevertheless, the unique binary perovskite manganite Mn2O3 containing the same element in both A and B positions can be synthesized under high-pressure high-temperature conditions. Here, we show that this material exhibits magnetically driven ferroelectricity and a pronounced magnetoelectric effect at low temperatures. Neutron powder diffraction revealed two intricate antiferromagnetic structures below 100 K, driven by a strong interplay between spin, charge, and orbital degrees of freedom. The peculiar multiferroicity in the Mn2O3 perovskite is ascribed to a combined effect involving several mechanisms. Our work demonstrates the potential of binary perovskite oxides for creating materials with highly promising electric and magnetic properties.

Introduction

Perovskite structures of transition-metal oxides provide an unprecedented playground for condensed-matter physics and materials science. They exhibit numerous exciting phenomena and functional properties, such as exotic magnetism, ferroelectricity, high-Tc superconductivity, colossal magnetoresistance, charge/orbital ordering, significant thermoelectricity, giant negative thermal expansion, photoelectricity, multiferroicity, etc[1-5]. There are two different cation sites in the ABO3 perovskite structure, namely, B-sites that are octahedrally coordinated by oxygen and A-sites that are cuboctahedrally coordinated and often heavily distorted[6]. Small and highly charged transition-metal cations normally occupy the B-sites, but they are hardly suitable to occupy the large 12-coordinated A-sites. A partial filling of the A-positions with transition metals is possible in a unique class of A-site-ordered perovskites, e.g., in such manganites as (AMn3)Mn4O12 (A = Na, Ca, La, Bi)[7-10]. The full occupation of the A-sites with transition metals would yield a B2O3 binary perovskite, but until recently this remained a formidable challenge.

Recently, the first binary perovskite oxide, Mn2O3, was synthesized under high-pressure and high-temperature (HP-HT) conditions[11,12]. It is worth mentioning that it was found by a single-crystal X-ray diffraction technique that Fe2O3 also adopts a perovskite structure at HP-HT conditions being, however, not quenchable to ambient pressure[13]. The Mn cations show variable charge states (e.g., Mn2+, Mn3+, and Mn4+) with ionic radii, and, in particular, the Mn2+ cation is sufficiently large to be accommodated in the A-position of the perovskite structure. Using synchrotron X-ray diffraction (SXRD), electron diffraction, annular bright-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (ABF-STEM), and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS)[11,12], we demonstrated that the perovskite-type Mn2O3 can be represented as (Mn2+Mn3+3)Mn3.25+4O12, given different oxidation states of Mn depending on the crystallographic position.

As shown in Fig. 1, the crystal structure of perovskite-type Mn2O3 is determined within the a = 4ap supercell[11]. It is a distorted variant of the AA′3B4O12 quadruple perovskites with an in-phase a+b+c+ octahedral tilt according to the Glazer notation[14]. As all the A-sites are occupied by the Mn ions, the octahedral tilt is significant, reaching about 15–18° (Fig. 1a). The MnB–O interatomic distances are in the range of 1.82–2.20 Å so that the MnBO6 octahedra are significantly deformed. A distorted square-planar first coordination sphere for the MnA′ cations with the MnA′-O distance in the range of 1.81–2.09 Å is created due to the cooperative tilt of the MnBO6 octahedra. The second coordination sphere of the MnA′ cations includes one to two oxygen atoms positioned at much larger distances of 2.33–2.37 Å. Consequently, the complete coordination environment is a distorted tetragonal pyramid or octahedron. Due to the rotation and distortion of the MnBO6 octahedra, a distorted octahedral environment for the MnA cations with the MnA–O distances in the range of 2.24–2.69 Å is created.

Fig. 1

Crystal structure of the perovskite-type Mn2O3. a A highly distorted and tilted perovskite unit cell. b The crystal structure of the binary perovskite Mn2O3 determined within the a = 4a supercell. The oxygen atoms at the corners of the MnBO6 octahedra are omitted for clarity. It is a distorted variant of the AA′3B4O12 perovskite with an in-phase cooperative a+b+c+ octahedral tilt. c Relative thermal expansion of the perovskite Mn2O3 (V is the unit cell volume at ambient conditions). One can see the weak volumetric changes upon the magnetic transitions

One unique feature of this binary perovskite Mn2O3 is that all the A- and B-site cations can be magnetically and electrically active, thus leading to an interplay of multiple structural and electronic instabilities[15,16]. Besides the conventional MnB–O–MnB interaction path, the binary perovskite has additional paths through the A-cations along the chains of MnA′–O–MnB, MnA–O–MnB, MnA–O–MnA′, and MnA′–O–MnA′. The highly distorted and tilted structure along with the competing multiple interactions could induce unexpected interplay of different properties in the binary perovskite Mn2O3, compared to those known in conventional perovskite oxides. More details of the crystal structure of the perovskite-type Mn2O3 may be found in earlier publication[11].

In this work, we report the observation of a spin-induced multiferroicity in this unique Mn2O3 perovskite. The coexistence of magnetism and ferroelectricity in perovskites, such as BiFeO3 (ref. [17]) and TbMnO3 (ref. [18]), renders such compounds an interesting field of research and creates potential for industrial applications[19-21]. In the last decade, a large number of multiferroic materials with different mechanisms of magnetoelectric (ME) coupling were discovered. However, binary oxides showing multiferroicity are rare. CuO (refs. [22-24]), Fe3O4 (ref. [25]), and Fe2O3 (ref. [26]) are the few known examples reported so far. Mn2O3 represents the first example of multiferroic binary oxide with the unusual perovskite structure.

Results

Multiple magnetic transitions in the binary perovskite Mn2O3

The magnetic susceptibility (χ) of the Mn2O3 perovskite measured in a low magnetic field (H = 500 Oe) is presented in Fig. 2a. At temperatures above ~ 180 K, it follows the Curie–Weiss law χ = C/(T-θ) with the Curie–Weiss temperature θ = –327 K. The negative θ value suggests predominantly antiferromagnetic (AFM) interactions between the Mn ions. At low temperatures, the Mn2O3 perovskite undergoes two magnetic transitions at T1 = 101 K and T2 = 49 K, as further confirmed by heat capacity measurements. Since the magnetic ordering occurs at temperatures much lower than ∣θ∣, strong magnetic frustration is present in the system. The drops of χ with decreasing temperature reflect the AFM nature of both transitions (Fig. 2). However, the magnitudes of these dips are small, and the magnetic susceptibility χ starts increasing again only a few Kelvin below T1 (T2). These features suggest that only a partial magnetic ordering occurs at both transitions. A group of the magnetic Mn cations may remain disordered because of the frustration and become randomly frozen at low temperatures, as indicated by a divergence between the ZFC and FC susceptibility curves below ~ 5 K. Furthermore, the low-temperature transition at T2 is clearly suppressed in a high magnetic field (Fig. 2b). In contrast, the high-temperature transition at T1 is not affected even by a strong magnetic field of 7 T (Fig. 2c). The AC magnetic susceptibility exhibits a frequency-dependent peak around 5 K (Fig. 2d) and the magnetization at 2 K is far from saturation up to 12 T (Fig. 2e). These features further suggest a short-ranged ordered magnetic state at low temperatures.

Fig. 2

Magnetic properties of the perovskite-type Mn2O3. a Temperature dependence of DC magnetic susceptibility measured in the field of 500 Oe with both the zero-field-cooling (ZFC) and field-cooling (FC) modes. This curve distinctly demonstrates two magnetic transitions at T1 = 101 K and T2 = 49 K. The inset shows a Curie–Weiss fit of the paramagnetic susceptibility. b, and c shows an effect of applied magnetic field on the above-mentioned magnetic transitions. While the transition at T2 is apparently suppressed by application of a 7 T field, the transition at T1 is very weakly affected by 7 T field. d AC magnetic susceptibility as a function of temperature. The frequency dependent peak around 5 K suggests a short-range ordered magnetic state. e The M–H curve at 2 K showing no saturation of magnetization up to 13 T

In order to examine structural changes upon the low-temperature magnetic transitions, we carried out high-resolution powder X-ray diffraction studies at the ID22 beamline of the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (Grenoble, France) at temperatures below 150 K. Rietveld refinements of these XRD patterns showed the persistence of the original room-temperature structure across the transitions. At the lowest temperature of 5 K we reached in these experiments, we found the same face-centered triclinic structure with the unit cell parameters a = 14.6505(5) Å, b = 14.6300(5) Å, c = 14.6394(7) Å, α = 89.306(4)°, β = 89.288(4)°, γ = 89.293(7)°, V = 3137.1(1) Å3, and Z = 64. Temperature evolution of the unit cell volume of perovskite Mn2O3 demonstrates the anomalies at the magnetic transitions (Fig. 1c). One can see that the magnetic ordering leads to minor volumetric effects, indicating the presence of magnetoelastic coupling.

Neutron powder diffraction data

Further insights into the nature of the magnetically ordered states of perovskite-type Mn2O3 are gained from neutron powder diffraction (NPD) data shown in Fig. 3a, b. Due to a complex character of the triclinic crystal structure with 20 symmetry independent magnetic sites per unit cell, solution of the magnetic structures is an extremely challenging problem. To impose some symmetry restrictions, we adapted an approach, which uses the higher-symmetry approximation for the crystal structure and is based on the knowledge of the magnetic structures in closely related A2+Mn7O12 (A2+ = Ca, Sr, Pb and Cd) quadruple manganites[27-29]. This approach is well justified, owing to the fact that the triclinic distortion is very small[11] and could not be resolved in our high-resolution neutron powder diffraction data. The trigonal space group with a large unit cell and is an isotropy subgroup, associated with the kS = (0,0,3/4) propagation vector[30,31] of the group, having a smaller unit cell size and . The latter structural model was used as the parent structure for the magnetic structure solutions and Landau free-energy decomposition in the A2+Mn7O12 manganites[27-29]. We also used the (, ) symmetry in our analysis, which allowed us to drastically reduce the number of symmetry unrelated sites and resulted in successful determination of the spin structures in both magnetic phases of Mn2O3 (Fig. 4).

Fig. 3

Neutron diffraction data of the perovskite-type Mn2O3. a, b Rietveld refinement of the WISH neutron diffraction patterns collected at 60 K and 1.5 K, respectively. The black cross symbols and red solid lines represent the experimental and calculated intensities, respectively. The blue lines at the bottom of both plots are the difference between the experimental and calculated intensities. There are three sets of tick marks: the upper one indicates the positions of Bragg peaks for the nuclear, the middle one shows a few reflections of the vanadium can for the sample, and the lower one indicates the positions of Bragg peaks for magnetic scattering. The inset in a shows temperature dependence of the k-component of the magnetic propagation vector k0. The inset in b shows magnified portion of the diffraction pattern where a satellite of the k2± propagation vector is observed

Fig. 4

Magnetic structures of the perovskite-type Mn2O3. a Schematic representations of the magnetic structure in the commensurate high-temperature phase (49 K < T < 101 K). This structure is a longitudinal spin density wave with the unit cell eight times bigger than the cell of the parent () structure. It combines two types of the B-site and three types of the A-site Mn-layers stacked along the c-axis. b Schematic representations of the magnetic structure in the incommensurate low-temperature phase (T < 49 K). This structure combines both cycloidal and helical components. P refers to the induced electric polarization

In the temperature range of 49 K < T < 101 K, the magnetic structure is a longitudinal spin-density wave (Fig. 4a) with the propagation vector k0 = (0,0,9/8) locked to the structural modulation through the relation kS + 2k0 = 3. It is remarkable that, apart from the fundamental k0 component, a presence of a sizable third harmonic 3k0 ≡ (0,0,3/8) is clearly visible (Fig. 3a), revealing essentially anharmonic character of the modulated magnetic structure. The magnetic space group of this anharmonic spin-density wave is , which implies a non-polar nature of the lock-in magnetic phase. The corresponding Fourier coefficients for the four symmetry independent Mn sites in the parent structure, refined from the data collected at T = 60 K, are given in Supplementary Table 1. In addition, the magnetic structure details of this high-temperature phase are presented in Supplementary Figure 1.

Below T2, the magnetic propagation vector k0 de-locks from the structural modulation giving rise to an incommensurate ground state (Fig. 4b). Apart from k0, a set of additional magnetic reflections is observed, which can be indexed using propagation vectors from the series k = k0 ± nkS (n = 0, 1, 2…), similar to the multi-k ground state of A2+Mn7O12 manganites[28,29]. This observation strongly supports the presence of 3:1 (Mn3+:Mn4+) charge order and orbital density wave in the system and reveals a crucial role of the magneto-orbital coupling[28,29,32]. The diffraction patterns provide evidence for the four distinct magnetic components, with k0 = (0,0,1.2439(3)), k1 = (0,0,1.0060(3)), k1− = (0,0,0.4940(3)) and k2+ = k2− (0,0,0.2560(3)) at T = 1.5 K, which were combined to get a constant-moment phase-modulated cycloid (Fig. 4b). This remarkable magnetic structure results in a good refinement quality (Fig. 3) and naturally explains the multiferroic properties below T2 (as described in the next section). The magnetic point group is triclinic 1′ and sets no restrictions on the polarization direction. In addition, the symmetry allows an admixture of a helical component similar to the ground state of A2+Mn7O12 manganites[28,29]. A tilting of the plane of the spin rotation by 20(2) degrees from the c-axis further improves the refinement quality, implying that the magnetic structure is very general and combines both the major cycloidal and the minor helical components (see Supplementary Table 2 for details). The above propagation vectors characterizing magnetic orders in the perovskite Mn2O3 are completely different from those found earlier in the cubic bixbyite α-Mn2O3[33]. The magnetic structure details of this low-temperature phase are presented in Supplementary Figure 2.

Factors that stabilize the complex magnetic structures in the binary perovskite Mn2O3 are probably common for the whole series of A2+Mn7O12 manganites[28,29,32]. A competing exchange interactions of the Mn ions occupying both the A-site and B-site positions in the perovskite structure and modulated by the orbital density wave, play a central role in the stabilization of these magnetic structures. The main distinctive feature of the perovskite Mn2O3 are the direction of the magnetic moments in the high-temperature spin density wave, and the presence of the cycloidal component in the ground state. They both imply a different type of magnetic anisotropy, of which origin requires further experimental and theoretical studies.

Spin-induced ferroelectricity in the binary perovskite Mn2O3

The dielectric constant (εr) of the binary perovskite Mn2O3 as a function of temperature is shown in Fig. 5a. There is a clear dielectric peak with a thermal hysteresis at T2~49 K. The position of the dielectric peak does not shift with frequency. These features indicate a first-order ferroelectric phase transition induced by the onset of the magnetic ordering at T2. However, no apparent dielectric anomaly is detected around the magnetic transition at T1 = 101 K. To confirm the ferroelectricity, the pyroelectric current measurements are performed from 2 K to 120 K with both positive and negative E-field poling (see Supplementary Figure 3). Two pyroelectric peaks are observed in the temperature range investigated. The pyroelectric peak around 49 K is consistent with the magnetic transition at T2. When the poling electric field is reversed, the sign of pyroelectric peak is also reversed (Fig. 5b). Moreover, the position of this pyroelectric peak at T2 does not shift with the heating rate (see Supplementary Figure 4). These features strongly suggest an intrinsic ferroelectricity below T2. There is another pronounced peak around 80 K which does not coincide with any magnetic or structural phase transition and is independent of external magnetic fields (see Supplementary Figure 5). It could be due to extrinsic factors such as space trapped charges at grain boundaries. We note that a broad and high pyroelectric peak was often reported in the quadruple perovskite manganites such as CaMn7O12, and its origin is quite controversial[27,34-44].

Fig. 5

Spin-induced ferroelectricity in the binary perovskite Mn2O3. a The dielectric constant as a function of temperature. A dielectric peak with a hysteresis is seen at T2 = 49 K, indicating a first-order ferroelectric transition. No apparent dielectric anomaly at T1 = 101 K is detected. The inset shows an enlarged view around T2. b The electric polarization as a function of temperature measured with a poling electric field of 0.4 MV m−1. The polarization is reversed by a negative poling field. The inset presents the pyroelectric current as a function of temperature after subtracting the background. The peak around T2 confirms spin-induced ferroelectricity. c The electric polarization measured with different poling electric field. d The electric polarization as a function of poling electric field

To further clarify whether the pyroelectric peak at elevated temperatures corresponds to intrinsic ferroelectricity or not, we employ polarized second harmonic generation (SHG) technique with the 90° reflection geometry (see Supplementary Figure 7). The SHG signals obtained at high temperatures (120 and 70 K) are almost zero. In contrast, a non-zero SHG signal is visible at 40 K, which corroborates the emergence of the electric polarization at low temperatures. The SHG results further confirm that the broad peak of the pyroelectric current at high temperature (80 K) is due to extrinsic factors, whereas the spin-induced ferroelectricity below T2 = 49 K is the intrinsic feature of our material. More importantly, these results for the perovskite Mn2O3 cast doubts concerning large polarization values which are often reported for quadruple perovskites of this family. For example, the giant ferroelectricity in CaMn7O12 reported previously could be delusive, whereas, intrinsic ferroelectricity below T1 may be, in fact, rather weak.

The electric polarization (P) as a function of temperature is obtained by integrating the pyroelectric current with time after subtracting the background current (see Supplementary Figure 6 for more details). Figure 5c, d shows the poling electric field dependence of P. The value of the polarization increases steadily with increasing poling electric field, and reaches ~30 μC m−2 at E = 0.55 MV m−1.

In the low-temperature ferroelectric phase stabilizing below T2 = 49 K, a pronounced ME effect is clearly observed. As shown in Fig. 6a, the pyroelectric peak around T2 is gradually suppressed by increasing external magnetic field. This behavior is consistent with the magnetic susceptibility around T2 (Fig. 2b), at which the magnetic transition is smeared out in high magnetic fields. Consequently, the electric polarization P below T2 decreases with increasing magnetic field (Fig. 6b), yielding a strong ME effect.

Fig. 6

Magnetic field control of polarization in the binary perovskite Mn2O3. a The influence of magnetic field on the pyroelectric current. b The effect of magnetic field on the electric polarization. The polarization is greatly reduced by applying external magnetic fields

Discussion

Below, we discuss a possible mechanism of spin-induced multiferroicity in the perovskite-type Mn2O3. The appearance of the ferroelectric polarization in spin-induced improper multiferroics can be generally understood in terms of either the spin current model[45] or inverse Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya (DM) interaction[46]. The extremely complex magnetic structure of the Mn2O3 perovskite combines both cycloidal and helical components, which generate polarization through different mechanisms. A spin cycloid is a naturally polar object whose polarization is proportional to a double vector product k×(Si×Sj), where the spins Si and Sj rotate, propagating along k[47]. In the case of the Mn2O3 perovskite, the phase-modulated cycloid combines four distinct sub-components with k = k0, k1+, k1− and k2+ ≡ k2− generating their own polarizations in the plane perpendicular to the c-axis (considering the trigonal approximation for the crystal structure). To the contrary, spin helix is non-polar, unless the crystal structure, on top of which the spin ordering takes place, belongs to a ferroaxial crystal class[27,48]. The trigonal (triclinic) crystal structure of perovskite-type Mn2O3 indeed satisfies this criterion, implying that the ferroaxial mechanism is relevant as well, and generates polarization along the c-axis.

Apparently, the very general character of the magnetic structure is the key ingredient of the great tunability of the electric polarization by applied magnetic field. Significant modifications of the structure, like tilting of the spin plane, do not require symmetry breaking and can gradually occur under external perturbations. This, in turn, changes the relative contributions of the different mechanisms to the polarization, resulting in its strong field dependence.

Thus, the perovskite-type Mn2O3 represents a unique example of a binary multiferroic oxide that adopts a complex distorted perovskite structure and demonstrates spin-induced ferroelectricity with a strong ME effect. In this material, the A-position is fully occupied by the transition-metal cations and, therefore, the role of the A-sites is greatly amplified, leading to more fascinating properties that would not be expected in the conventional ABO3 perovskites. The combination of octahedral tilting and deformation, Jahn–Teller distortion, charge/orbital ordering, and multiple magnetic interactions opens up a valuable playground both for designing and engineering of new materials and for investigation of challenging fundamental physical phenomena. Although, bulk samples of the perovskite-type Mn2O3 were synthesized at HP-HT conditions, the high-pressure perovskite phase can also be stabilized through epitaxial strain in thin films. Fabrication of such binary perovskites at ambient pressure will be an attractive topic in the future.

Methods

Sample preparation and characterization

Fine polycrystalline samples of the perovskite-type Mn2O3 were synthesized under HP-HT conditions (~20 GPa and 1200–1400 K) using multi-tonne multi-anvil presses at BGI (Universität Bayreuth, Germany)[49]. Details of the synthesis procedures were the same as in previous work[11]. The chemical composition of the samples was examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) at a LEO-1530 instrument, microprobe analysis at a JEOL JXA-8200 electron microprobe, and by ICP-MS bulk chemical analysis. The crystal structure of the samples was studied at ambient conditions by means of powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) at high brilliance Rigaku diffractometer. The XRD studies of the sample at different temperatures were carried at a high resolution powder diffraction beamline ID22 (former ID31) at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (Grenoble, France) with the wavelength of λ = 0.39993 Å.

Magnetic and electric measurements

DC and AC magnetic susceptibility were measured on a Quantum Design magnetic properties measurement system (MPMS). The temperature and magnetic field dependence of dielectric constant and pyroelectric currents were measured by using a homemade probe on a Cryogen-free Superconducting Magnet System (TeslatronPT, Oxford Instruments). The dielectric constant was measured by using a LCR meter (Aglient 4980A). After poling the sample in an electric field with the cooling process, the pyroelectric current was measured by an electrometer (Keithley 6517B) during the warming process with a constant rate.

Neutron diffraction measurements

Two sets of neutron powder diffraction data were collected; one at the ISIS pulsed neutron and muon facility of the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (UK) on the WISH diffractometer and another at the IBR-2 high-flux pulsed reactor (FNLP Dubna, Russia) on the DN-12 diffractometer. In both cases, samples (∼40 mg) were loaded into a cylindrical vanadium cans and measured in the temperature range of 1.5–120 K using an Oxford Instrument Cryostat and 10–200 K using a He-close cycle refrigerator, respectively. Rietveld refinements of the crystal and magnetic structures were performed using the Fullprof program against the data measured in detector banks at average 2θ values of 58°, 90°, 122°, and 154° (WISH) and 45.5° and 90° (DN-12).

Data availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request.