BACKGROUND: Immune checkpoint inhibitors provide significant clinical benefit to a subset of patients, but novel prognostic markers are needed to predict which patients will respond. This study was initiated to determine if features of patient T cell repertoires could provide insights into the mechanisms of immunotherapy, while also predicting outcomes. METHODS: We examined T cell receptor (TCR) repertoires in peripheral blood of 25 metastatic pancreatic cancer patients treated with ipilimumab with or without GVAX (a pancreatic cancer vaccine), as well as peripheral blood and tumor biopsies from 32 patients treated with GVAX and mesothelin-expressing Listeria monocytogenes with or without nivolumab. Statistics from these repertoires were then tested for their association with clinical response and treatment group. RESULTS: We demonstrate that, first, the majority of patients receiving these treatments experience a net diversification of their peripheral TCR repertoires. Second, patients receiving ipilimumab experienced larger changes in their repertoires, especially in combination with GVAX. Finally, both a low baseline clonality and a high number of expanded clones following treatment were associated with significantly longer survival in patients who received ipilimumab but not in patients receiving nivolumab. CONCLUSIONS: We show that these therapies have measurably different effects on the peripheral repertoire, consistent with their mechanisms of action, and demonstrate the potential for TCR repertoire profiling to serve as a biomarker of clinical response in pancreatic cancer patients receiving immunotherapy. In addition, our results suggest testing sequential administration of anti-CTLA-4 and anti-PD-1 antibodies to achieve optimal therapeutic benefit. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Samples used in this study were collected from the NCT00836407 and NCT02243371 clinical trials. FUNDING: Research supported by a Stand Up To Cancer Lustgarten Foundation Pancreatic Cancer Convergence Dream Team Translational Research grant (SU2C-AACR-DT14-14). Stand Up To Cancer is a program of the Entertainment Industry Foundation administered by the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR). Additional clinical trial funding was provided by AACR-Pancreatic Cancer Action Network Research Acceleration Network grant (14-90-25-LE), NCI SPORE in GI Cancer (CA062924), Quick-Trials for Novel Cancer Therapies: Exploratory Grants (R21CA126058-01A2), and the US Food and Drug Administration (R01FD004819). Research collaboration and financial support were provided by Adaptive Biotechnologies.
BACKGROUND: Immune checkpoint inhibitors provide significant clinical benefit to a subset of patients, but novel prognostic markers are needed to predict which patients will respond. This study was initiated to determine if features of patient T cell repertoires could provide insights into the mechanisms of immunotherapy, while also predicting outcomes. METHODS: We examined T cell receptor (TCR) repertoires in peripheral blood of 25 metastatic pancreatic cancer patients treated with ipilimumab with or without GVAX (a pancreatic cancer vaccine), as well as peripheral blood and tumor biopsies from 32 patients treated with GVAX and mesothelin-expressing Listeria monocytogenes with or without nivolumab. Statistics from these repertoires were then tested for their association with clinical response and treatment group. RESULTS: We demonstrate that, first, the majority of patients receiving these treatments experience a net diversification of their peripheral TCR repertoires. Second, patients receiving ipilimumab experienced larger changes in their repertoires, especially in combination with GVAX. Finally, both a low baseline clonality and a high number of expanded clones following treatment were associated with significantly longer survival in patients who received ipilimumab but not in patients receiving nivolumab. CONCLUSIONS: We show that these therapies have measurably different effects on the peripheral repertoire, consistent with their mechanisms of action, and demonstrate the potential for TCR repertoire profiling to serve as a biomarker of clinical response in pancreatic cancer patients receiving immunotherapy. In addition, our results suggest testing sequential administration of anti-CTLA-4 and anti-PD-1 antibodies to achieve optimal therapeutic benefit. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Samples used in this study were collected from the NCT00836407 and NCT02243371 clinical trials. FUNDING: Research supported by a Stand Up To Cancer Lustgarten Foundation Pancreatic Cancer Convergence Dream Team Translational Research grant (SU2C-AACR-DT14-14). Stand Up To Cancer is a program of the Entertainment Industry Foundation administered by the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR). Additional clinical trial funding was provided by AACR-Pancreatic Cancer Action Network Research Acceleration Network grant (14-90-25-LE), NCI SPORE in GI Cancer (CA062924), Quick-Trials for Novel Cancer Therapies: Exploratory Grants (R21CA126058-01A2), and the US Food and Drug Administration (R01FD004819). Research collaboration and financial support were provided by Adaptive Biotechnologies.
Entities:
Keywords:
Cancer immunotherapy; Immunology; Oncology; T-cell receptor
Authors: Dung T Le; Andrea Wang-Gillam; Vincent Picozzi; Tim F Greten; Todd Crocenzi; Gregory Springett; Michael Morse; Herbert Zeh; Deirdre Cohen; Robert L Fine; Beth Onners; Jennifer N Uram; Daniel A Laheru; Eric R Lutz; Sara Solt; Aimee Luck Murphy; Justin Skoble; Ed Lemmens; John Grous; Thomas Dubensky; Dirk G Brockstedt; Elizabeth M Jaffee Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2015-01-12 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Caroline Robert; Jacob Schachter; Georgina V Long; Ana Arance; Jean Jacques Grob; Laurent Mortier; Adil Daud; Matteo S Carlino; Catriona McNeil; Michal Lotem; James Larkin; Paul Lorigan; Bart Neyns; Christian U Blank; Omid Hamid; Christine Mateus; Ronnie Shapira-Frommer; Michele Kosh; Honghong Zhou; Nageatte Ibrahim; Scot Ebbinghaus; Antoni Ribas Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-04-19 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Naiyer A Rizvi; Julien Mazières; David Planchard; Thomas E Stinchcombe; Grace K Dy; Scott J Antonia; Leora Horn; Hervé Lena; Elisa Minenza; Bertrand Mennecier; Gregory A Otterson; Luis T Campos; David R Gandara; Benjamin P Levy; Suresh G Nair; Gérard Zalcman; Jürgen Wolf; Pierre-Jean Souquet; Editta Baldini; Federico Cappuzzo; Christos Chouaid; Afshin Dowlati; Rachel Sanborn; Ariel Lopez-Chavez; Christian Grohe; Rudolf M Huber; Christopher T Harbison; Christine Baudelet; Brian J Lestini; Suresh S Ramalingam Journal: Lancet Oncol Date: 2015-02-20 Impact factor: 41.316
Authors: William S DeWitt; Ryan O Emerson; Paul Lindau; Marissa Vignali; Thomas M Snyder; Cindy Desmarais; Catherine Sanders; Heidi Utsugi; Edus H Warren; Juliana McElrath; Karen W Makar; Anna Wald; Harlan S Robins Journal: J Virol Date: 2015-02-04 Impact factor: 5.103
Authors: Edward Cha; Mark Klinger; Yafei Hou; Craig Cummings; Antoni Ribas; Malek Faham; Lawrence Fong Journal: Sci Transl Med Date: 2014-05-28 Impact factor: 17.956
Authors: Dung T Le; Eric Lutz; Jennifer N Uram; Elizabeth A Sugar; Beth Onners; Sara Solt; Lei Zheng; Luis A Diaz; Ross C Donehower; Elizabeth M Jaffee; Daniel A Laheru Journal: J Immunother Date: 2013-09 Impact factor: 4.456
Authors: Siân Jones; Xiaosong Zhang; D Williams Parsons; Jimmy Cheng-Ho Lin; Rebecca J Leary; Philipp Angenendt; Parminder Mankoo; Hannah Carter; Hirohiko Kamiyama; Antonio Jimeno; Seung-Mo Hong; Baojin Fu; Ming-Tseh Lin; Eric S Calhoun; Mihoko Kamiyama; Kimberly Walter; Tatiana Nikolskaya; Yuri Nikolsky; James Hartigan; Douglas R Smith; Manuel Hidalgo; Steven D Leach; Alison P Klein; Elizabeth M Jaffee; Michael Goggins; Anirban Maitra; Christine Iacobuzio-Donahue; James R Eshleman; Scott E Kern; Ralph H Hruban; Rachel Karchin; Nickolas Papadopoulos; Giovanni Parmigiani; Bert Vogelstein; Victor E Velculescu; Kenneth W Kinzler Journal: Science Date: 2008-09-04 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Paul C Tumeh; Christina L Harview; Jennifer H Yearley; I Peter Shintaku; Emma J M Taylor; Lidia Robert; Bartosz Chmielowski; Marko Spasic; Gina Henry; Voicu Ciobanu; Alisha N West; Manuel Carmona; Christine Kivork; Elizabeth Seja; Grace Cherry; Antonio J Gutierrez; Tristan R Grogan; Christine Mateus; Gorana Tomasic; John A Glaspy; Ryan O Emerson; Harlan Robins; Robert H Pierce; David A Elashoff; Caroline Robert; Antoni Ribas Journal: Nature Date: 2014-11-27 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Devalingam Mahalingam; Grey A Wilkinson; Kevin H Eng; Paul Fields; Patrick Raber; Jennifer L Moseley; Karol Cheetham; Matt Coffey; Gerard Nuovo; Pawel Kalinski; Bin Zhang; Sukeshi Patel Arora; Christos Fountzilas Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2019-11-06 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Emily F Davis-Marcisak; Thomas D Sherman; Pranay Orugunta; Genevieve L Stein-O'Brien; Sidharth V Puram; Evanthia T Roussos Torres; Alexander C Hopkins; Elizabeth M Jaffee; Alexander V Favorov; Bahman Afsari; Loyal A Goff; Elana J Fertig Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2019-07-23 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Yun Min Chang; Andreas Wieland; Zheng-Rong Li; Se Jin Im; Donald J McGuire; Haydn T Kissick; Rustom Antia; Rafi Ahmed Journal: J Virol Date: 2020-09-29 Impact factor: 5.103
Authors: Kroopa Joshi; Marc Robert de Massy; Mazlina Ismail; James L Reading; Imran Uddin; Annemarie Woolston; Emine Hatipoglu; Theres Oakes; Rachel Rosenthal; Thomas Peacock; Tahel Ronel; Mahdad Noursadeghi; Virginia Turati; Andrew J S Furness; Andrew Georgiou; Yien Ning Sophia Wong; Assma Ben Aissa; Mariana Werner Sunderland; Mariam Jamal-Hanjani; Selvaraju Veeriah; Nicolai J Birkbak; Gareth A Wilson; Crispin T Hiley; Ehsan Ghorani; José Afonso Guerra-Assunção; Javier Herrero; Tariq Enver; Sine R Hadrup; Allan Hackshaw; Karl S Peggs; Nicholas McGranahan; Charles Swanton; Sergio A Quezada; Benny Chain Journal: Nat Med Date: 2019-10-07 Impact factor: 53.440
Authors: Takahiro Tsujikawa; Todd Crocenzi; Jennifer N Durham; Elizabeth A Sugar; Annie A Wu; Beth Onners; Julie M Nauroth; Robert A Anders; Elana J Fertig; Daniel A Laheru; Kim Reiss; Robert H Vonderheide; Andrew H Ko; Margaret A Tempero; George A Fisher; Michael Considine; Ludmila Danilova; Dirk G Brockstedt; Lisa M Coussens; Elizabeth M Jaffee; Dung T Le Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2020-04-09 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Katelyn T Byrne; Courtney B Betts; Rosemarie Mick; Shamilene Sivagnanam; David L Bajor; Daniel A Laheru; E Gabriela Chiorean; Mark H O'Hara; Shannon M Liudahl; Craig Newcomb; Cécile Alanio; Ana P Ferreira; Byung S Park; Takuya Ohtani; Austin P Huffman; Sara A Väyrynen; Andressa Dias Costa; Judith C Kaiser; Andreanne M Lacroix; Colleen Redlinger; Martin Stern; Jonathan A Nowak; E John Wherry; Martin A Cheever; Brian M Wolpin; Emma E Furth; Elizabeth M Jaffee; Lisa M Coussens; Robert H Vonderheide Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2021-06-10 Impact factor: 12.531