Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticle Circulation in an Aquatic Ecosystem.

Nanotechnology is a dynamically developing field of scientific and industrial interest across the entire world, and the commercialization of nanoparticles (NPs) is rapidly expanding. Incorporation of nanotechnologies into a range of manufactured goods results in increasing concern regarding the subsequent release of engineered NPs into the environment. One of the biggest threats of using NPs is the transfer and magnification of these particles in the trophic chain. The aim of the studies was the evaluation of the distribution of TiO2 NP contamination in the aquatic ecosystem under laboratory conditions. Bioaccumulation of TiO2 NPs by plants (Elodea canadensis) and fish (Danio rerio) in the source of contamination was investigated. The studies were focused on the consequences of short-term water contamination with TiO2 NPs and the secondary contamination of the components of the investigated model ecosystem (plants, sediments). It was found that in the fish and the plants exposed to NP contamination, the amount of Ti was higher than in the control, indicating an effective bioaccumulation of NPs or ions originating from NPs. It was clearly shown that the NPs present in the sediments are available to plants and fish. Additionally, the aquatic plants, an important trophic level in the food chain, can accumulate NPs and be a source of NPs for higher organisms. It was concluded that even an incidental contamination of water by NPs may result in long-term consequences induced by the release of NPs.

Introduction

Nanotechnology, defined as the understanding and control of matter at dimensions of roughly 1–100 nm, is a dynamically developing field of scientific and industrial interest in the entire world. Because of its exceptional potential, there has been a drastic increase in investment in nanotechnology research and development worldwide. Nanoparticles (NPs) are increasingly used in many types of consumer products. Among the most commonly used are titanium oxide NPs (titania NPs, TiO2 NPs); for example, they are present in paints, cements, sunscreen, car cosmetics, catalysts, ultraviolet protection devices, and batteries (Biswas and Wu 2005; Mann 2006).

In 2005, nanoscale TiO2 global production was 2000 tons (US EPA 2009). By 2010, the nanosize TiO2 production grew by 250% and reached 5000 t, and it is expected to continue to increase until at least 2025 (Landsiedelet et al. 2010). After use, NP-based products can enter the sewage system and subsequently enter the environment as treated effluents discharged to the surface waters or biosolids applied to the agricultural land, incinerated wastes, or landfill solids (Weir et al. 2012). Therefore, it is assumed that these NPs are getting into the aquatic environment (Guzman et al. 2006; Nowack and Bucheli 2007; Kaegi et al. 2008), and they can be bioaccumulated through the food chain.

Some work has been done on the toxicity of NPs to aquatic organisms. Hund–Rinke and Simon (2006) examined the ecotoxic effect of TiO2 NPs on algae and daphnids. The effective concentration (EC50s) of TiO2 NPs (25 nm) in Desmodesmus subspicatus is 44 mg/L. Ma et al. (2012) estimated LC50s greater than 500 mg TiO2/L and 155 mg TiO2/L for Daphnia magna and Japanese medaka, respectively. Heinlaan et al. (2008) have shown that 20 g TiO2/L induced 60% mortality of D. magna. The concentration of 20 g TiO2/L was not acutely toxic for bacteria Vibrio fischeri and crustaceans Thamnocephalus platyurus. Chen et al. (2011) showed the adverse effect of TiO2 NPs at concentrations of 1.0–7.0 mg/L on Danio rerio, resulting in the inhibition of growth and a decrease in the liver weight ratio of D. rerio. The gills displayed histopathological changes including the thickening of edema and the gill lamellae. TiO2 NPs could translocate among organs and pass through the blood–brain and the blood–heart barrier after long-term exposure. Rocco et al. (2015) proved that TiO2 NPs induce D. rerio DNA damage when the concentration was 10 μg/L for 14 and 21 days of treatment. Chronic exposure of D. rerio to 0.1 mg/L of TiO2 NPs weakened its reproduction; there was a 29.5% reduction in the number of D. rerio eggs after 13 weeks of exposure (Wang et al. 2011). Xiong et al. (2011) have found that the size distribution of NPs was similar to that of the bulk particles in suspension, and the acute toxicity of 124.5 mg/L of TiO2 NPs (96-h LC50) to D. rerio was greater than that of the bulk TiO2, which was essentially non-toxic. The bioavailability and toxicity of TiO2 NPs can be affected by environmental factors, including presence of humic acids (Yang et al. 2013; Bystrzejewska–Piotrowska et al. 2012).

One of the biggest threats of using NPs is the transfer and magnification of these particles in the trophic chain. The studies of silver bioaccumulation by freshwater larvae of the insect Chironomus (diptera: Chironomidae) and D. rerio fish have shown that the amount of silver uptake by fish depends on the contamination source (Asztemborska et al. 2014). Larvae that have accumulated silver NPs can be a source of NPs in fish and certainly higher organisms. Only a few studies have been conducted in this area for TiO2 NPs. Zhu et al. (2010) established a simple model of a freshwater food chain including low (D. magna) and high (D. rerio) trophic-level organisms. The results proved that TiO2 NPs can transfer from D. magna to D. rerio by dietary exposure, but the biomagnification of NPs was not observed; the values of the biomagnification factors (BMFs) in this study (0.024 and 0.009) were all less than 1 (Zhu et al. 2010b). Additionally, the toxicity of TiO2 NPs was examined, showing minimal toxicity to D. magna within the traditional 48-h exposure time; however, high toxicity was observed when the exposure time was extended to 72 h (Zhu et al. 2010a).

Considering a variety of factors affecting the bioavailability and the toxicity of NPs, the evaluation of the environmental hazards and risks associated with release of NPs to the natural environment must be based on the results of ecotoxicological studies. Our knowledge of nano-TiO2 bioaccumulation in aquatic organisms in complex ecosystems is limited and must be extended.

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the distribution of TiO2 NP contamination in the model aquatic ecosystem. For this purpose, bioaccumulation of TiO2 NPs by plants (Elodea canadensis) and fish (Danio rerio) depending on the source of contamination was investigated. Different analytical techniques were performed to determine the amount of titanium in plants and fish tissues and to indentify its distribution in fish bodies. The consequences of short-term and long-term water contamination with TiO2 NPs for aquatic ecosystem were discussed.

Materials and Methods

Materials

TiO2 NPs (nanopowder, < 100 nm) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. The particle size below 100 nm and spherical morphology of nanoparticles were characterized in 1-mmol/L water suspensions using a TEM LEO 912AB transmission electron microscope (Zeiss) equipped with a Proscan high-speed slow-scan CCD camera (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1

Transmission electron micrographs of TiO2 nanoparticles (suspended in water) used in the experiment

Adult male D. rerio fish (line species ABTL) were obtained from the Zebrafish Core Facility (ZCF) at the International Institute of Molecular and Cell Biology in Warsaw, Poland. Elodea canadensis plants used in the experiment came from the Botanical Garden of the Warsaw University, Poland.

Exposure of E. canadensis and D. rerio to TiO2 NPs

Exposure of E. canadensis and D. rerio to TiO2 NPs was performed in 10-L aquariums. The water temperature was 24 °C, and the organisms were subjected to a photoperiod of 14 h of light and 10 h of darkness. Danio rerio (seven fish per aquarium) and E. canadensis (15 g of fresh fish plant per aquarium) were exposed for 2 weeks to TiO2 NPs from different sources. The experimental variants included the following: (I) control, (II) plants and fish placed in an aquarium with TiO2 NPs at a concentration of 10 mg/L, (III) doubled portion of plants placed in an aquarium with TiO2 NPs at a concentration of 10 mg/L, (IV) a portion of plants from the third experimental variant placed together with a fish in the aquarium (contaminated plants were a source of NPs), and (V) a base from the third experimental variant placed together with plants and fish in the aquarium (contaminated base was a source of NPs). Details of the research variants are presented in Fig. 2. Each variant of the experiment was performed in three replicates.

Fig. 2

Experiment diagram. Texture indicates the objects that were contaminated with TiO2 NPs. Research variant: I—control; II—10 mg/L TiO2 in water; III—10 mg/L TiO2 in water, without fish; IV—TiO2 in plants from variant III; and V—TiO2 in the aquarium base from variant III

After the exposure, the fish and the plants were separated from the water and rinsed with distilled water. Further, tricaine (3-aminobenzoic acid ethyl ester) from Sigma was used for anesthetizing the fish. Next, the samples were frozen at − 24 °C and freeze-dried and homogenized before further analysis.

Determination of Total Ti Content

For the determination of the Ti content in D. rerio and E. canadensis, about 100 and 250 mg of a dried, homogenized material, respectively, was digested with a mixture of 5 mL HNO3, 2 mL H2O2, 1 mL HF, and 6 mL H3BO3 by using a microwave laboratory system, Multiwave 3000 (Anton Paar, Germany). After digestion, the samples were quantitatively transferred with 2% HNO3 into volumetric flasks (25 mL) and analyzed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, ICP MS (ELAN 6000 ICP mass spectrometer, PE SCIEX, Concord, Canada).

Determination of Ti Deposition in the Fish Tissues

The imaging of the NP and metal deposition in the fish tissues was carried out using an X-ray analysis, laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP MS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM).

In the X-ray analysis of the metal location in the fish body by the Carestream In Vivo MS FX PRO system, one fish from each research variant was selected. The following settings were used for obtaining the X-ray images: illumination source X-ray 20 kVp, exposure time 30 s, no excitation filter, no emission filter, no binning, f-stop 2.8, focal plane 13.1 mm, and field of view 27.80 mm. Next, the same fish was analyzed for metal deposition by using an ELAN 6000 ICP mass spectrometer (PE SCIEX, Concord, Canada). The titanium content in fish was determined in the selected 5-mm parts of the fish body (the ventral part, operculum, caudal fin, and below the dorsal fin) in the cross section of the ventral part of the fish.

More detailed studies of TiO2 NP deposition in fish cells were conducted using TEM. For this purpose, certain small parts of the gills, mussels, and the digestive system were fixed with a 2.5% glutaraldehyde/cacodylic buffer and incubated for 1 h and then washed in 0.1 M cacodylic buffer. Next, the samples were post-fixed in 1% OsO4 in ddH2O for 12 h and washed three times in ddH2O. After post-fixation, the samples were dehydrated through a graded series of EtOH (50%, 10 min; 70%, 24 h; 90%, 10 min; 96%, 10 min; anhydrous EtOH, 10 min; acetone, 10 min) and infiltrated with EPON resin in acetone (1:3, 30 min; 1:1, 30 min; 3:1, 2 h), infused twice for 24 h in pure EPON resin, and polymerized for 48 h at 60 °C. Next, 60-nm sections were prepared with ultramicrotome RMC MT-X (Tucson, USA) and were examined on a Libra 120 electron microscope (Carl Zeiss, Germany). The images were captured by the slow-scan CCD camera using WinTEM™ Graphical Use Interface.

Statistical Analysis

Results were expressed as mean ± standard deviation, n = 3. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine statistical significance of the differences between values. Statistical significance for all tests was set at P ≤ 0.05.

Results and Discussion

Bioaccumulation of Ti in D. rerio and E. canadensis

The Ti content in D. rerio and E. canadensis determined using ICP MS is presented in Table 1. In all the samples of the fish and the plants exposed to NP contamination, the amount of Ti was higher than in the control, indicating an effective bioaccumulation of NPs or ions originating from NPs.

Table 1

Titanium contents in fish and plants exposed for 2 weeks to TiO2 NPs

Research variant	Ti content (g kg−1 d.w.)
	Danio rerio	Elodea canadensis
I	0.06 ± 0.01	0.03 ± 0.01
II	0.21 ± 0.01	3.50 ± 0.53
III	n/a	1.85 ± 0.20
IV	0.09 ± 0.01	0.72 ± 0.12
V	0.13 ± 0.01	2.02 ± 0.09

Research variant: I—control; II—10 mg/L TiO2 in water; III—10 mg/L TiO2 in water, without fish; IV—TiO2 in plants from variant III; and V—TiO2 in the aquarium base from variant III

The highest content of Ti (3.5 g/kg of dry weight (d.w.)) was found in plants cultivated in water contaminated with TiO2 NPs (variant I). This can be an effect of the bioaccumulation of NPs or their deposition on the plant surface. In the E. canadensis from experimental variant III, the amount of Ti was ca. 50% lower because of the doubled number of plants in the container. After transferring the plants to the non-contaminated water (experimental variant IV), the amount of Ti was reduced of ca. 60%. This suggests that NPs were weakly bounded or adsorbed at the plant surface, and after a transfer to the uncontaminated environment, they moved into the water. A relatively high content of Ti (ca. 2 g/kg d.w.) was determined in the samples of plants cultivated in the aquarium with the base contaminated with TiO2 NPs. This clearly shows that the NPs present in the sediments were available to plants. Irrespective of the source of the TiO2 NP contamination, E. canadensis had elevated content of Ti as compared to the control samples. This indicated that the aquatic plants, an important trophic level in the food chain, can accumulate NPs and be a source of NPs for higher organisms.

These results were in agreement with the results of Ti bioaccumulation in D. rerio. The highest content of Ti was determined in fish exposed to TiO2 NPs in water, while the lowest concentration was found in organisms staying together with the contaminated plants (variant IV). The increase in the Ti concentration in different organs of D. rerio as an effect of water contamination with TiO2 NPs was previously documented by Chen et al. (2011). In fish exposed to NPs at a concentration of 7 mg/L, after 6 months of exposure, the Ti content was in the range of 45–60 μg/kg in the brain, liver, and heart, and the highest value was determined in gills, ca. 100 μg/kg. In the present study, the Ti content determined in D. rerio was considerably higher; however, the entire fish body was analyzed in the experiments.

Fish can accumulate NPs in their gills and/or body shell or by feeding on contaminated plants. We can also expect that some adsorption or TiO2 NPs on the fish body take place. In the variant with contaminated water, the TiO2 NP concentration available for organisms was obviously the highest, resulting in the highest bioaccumulation by both organisms. We expect the bioaccumulation by the gills and body shell and the adsorption of TiO2 NPs on the fish body to be the dominant processes responsible for the observed effect. In experimental variant IV, the only source of Ti for fish was plants. The Ti content in plants was lower than in the case of water contamination. Here, we concluded that feeding on the contaminated plants was the main process of Ti bioaccumulation by fish. A significant amount of Ti was also accumulated by fish in experimental variant V with the aquarium base contaminated with TiO2 NPs. Therefore, it was obvious that in water, TiO2 NPs tend to sediment at the bottom of the container. A relatively high content of Ti in fish bodies as compared to that in the case of water contamination (ca. 40% lower) implied that Ti was still available for organisms. These results clearly show that the bioaccumulation of Ti by D. rerio depends on the source of the NP contamination, which is in agreement with the results of previous studies on the bioaccumulation of silver NPs by the same fish (Asztemborska et al. 2014). We found that the silver content in D. rerio living in water and containing NPs was 110-fold lower than that in organisms fed with contaminated Chironomid larvae, but remained in the digestive system (Asztemborska et al. 2014).

Metal Location in D. rerio

X-Ray Analysis

The next step of the studies was the analysis of the Ti location in the fish bodies. X-ray images showed that the metal was accumulated in the ventral part of the fish body in each research variant (Fig. 3). Irrespective of the lowest total Ti bioaccumulation, the highest concentration was observed in the D. rerio originating from experimental variant with contaminated plant as TiO2 NP source. This confirms the conclusion that feeding on contaminated plants is one of the main processes resulting in Ti bioaccumulation by fish under the considered conditions. However, a significant concentration was determined in the D rerio from the variants with TiO2 NPs containing water or from the aquarium base. This indicates that contaminated food is an important source of NPs for fish.

Fig. 3

Metal location in fish body obtained by X-ray. Research variant: I—control; II—10 mg/L TiO2 in water; III—10 mg/L TiO2 in water, without fish; IV—TiO2 in plants from variant III; and V—TiO2 in the aquarium base from variant III

LA-ICP MS

On the basis of the results obtained from the X-ray images, the measuring points for LA-ICP MS were determined. The Ti concentration in the ventral part of the fish from each research variant is presented in Fig. 4. The Ti level in the fish bodies from all the experimental variants was significantly higher than that in the control. The results obtained by the X-ray analysis have been confirmed: the highest Ti concentration was found in D. rerio originating from the experimental variant with contaminated plants as the source of the TiO2 NPs. To confirm the presence of Ti in the digestive system, an analysis of the cross section of the ventral part of the fish was done (Fig. 5). The results revealed a very high Ti content in the D. rerio in the aquarium with the TiO2 NP-contaminated plants. In the rest of the examined samples, the Ti content was lower; however, it was still significantly higher than that in the control fish. This confirms that plants contaminated with NPs can be a very efficient source of contamination for higher organisms.

Fig. 4

Intensity signal of titanium in the ventral part of the fish (LA-ICP MS)

Fig. 5

Intensity signal of titanium in deeper ventral part of the fish (LA-ICP MS)

TEM

The highest content of Ti in the ventral part of the fish body was determined in D. rerio from experimental variant III (contaminated food); however, the highest total bioaccumulation of Ti was found in variant II (water contamination). This is an effect of the high concentration of Ti in a limited part of the digestive system of the D. rerio feeding on contaminated plants and a more evenly distributed Ti content in the body of the fish in the rest of the variants. Imaging of the Ti content in the operculum, caudal fin, and below the dorsal fin by LA-ICP MS was then performed. The results were inconclusive but seemed to confirm the above conclusion. The analysis of gills, mussels, and the intestine by TEM revealed TiO2 NPs in fish cells (Fig. 6). In the D. rerio exposed to NPs in water, some TiO2 NPs were found in the mussels and gills (Fig. 6a, d, respectively). TiO2 NPs were also found in the intestine of D. rerio exposed to NPs in the form of contaminated plants (Fig. 6c); however, some aggregates of TiO2 NPs could be seen on micrographs of fish from the variants with contaminated water.

Fig. 6

Transmission electron micrographs of TiO2 nanoparticles in selected tissues of Danio rerio. a Mussels, variant II. b Intestine, variant II. c Intestine, variant III. d Gills, variant II

Conclusion

The aim of this study was to evaluate the distribution of TiO2 NP contamination in an aquatic ecosystem. It was found that (i) plants E. canadensis and fish Danio rerio exposed to TiO2 nanoparticle contamination effectively accumulate NPs or ions originating from NPs; (ii) aquatic plants, an important trophic level in the food chain, can be a source of NPs for higher organisms; and (III) NPs stored in the sediment can still interact with organisms and be available for plants and fish.

It was concluded that even an incidental contamination of water by NPs may result in long-term consequences induced by the release of NPs. The interpretation of Amara’s law in the view of the growth of nanotechnologies made by Bystrzejewska-Piotrowska et al. (2009) can be applied for the estimation of short- and long-term consequences of water system contamination by NPs (Fig. 7). A further investigation of such parameters as the level and the intensity of release of NPs from the sediments to the water and the organisms living in aquatic ecosystems is required.

Fig. 7

Short- and long-term contamination of an aquatic environment with nanoparticles—an interpretation of Amara’s law