| Literature DB >> 29932158 |
Donna Angelina Rade1, Gemma Crawford2, Roanna Lobo3, Corie Gray4, Graham Brown5,6.
Abstract
The number of migrants has increased globally. This phenomenon has contributed to increasing health problems amongst migrants in high-income countries, including vulnerability for HIV acquisition and other sexual health issues. Adaptation processes in destination countries can present difficulties for migrants to seek help from and gain access to health services. This study examined migrants’ from sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) and South East Asia (SEA) sexual health help-seeking behavior in high-income countries with universal health coverage. The systematic review followed PRISMA guidelines and was registered with PROSPERO. Several databases were searched from 2000 to 2017. Of 2824 studies, 15 met the inclusion criteria. These consisted of 12 qualitative and three quantitative studies conducted in Australia, Spain, the United Kingdom, Belgium, Scotland, Ireland, and Sweden. Migrants experienced a range of difficulties accessing health services, specifically those related to sexual health, in high-income countries. Few studies described sources of sexual health help-seeking or facilitators to help-seeking. Barriers to access were numerous, including: stigma, direct and indirect costs, difficulty navigating health systems in destination countries and lack of cultural competency within health services. More culturally secure health services, increased health service literacy and policy support to mitigate costs, will improve health service access for migrants from SSA and SEA. Addressing the structural drivers for stigma and discrimination remains an ongoing and critical challenge.Entities:
Keywords: help-seeking behavior; migrants; sexual health; systematic review
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29932158 PMCID: PMC6069090 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph15071311
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Search terms and databases used in the systematic review.
| Databases | PsycINFO, MEDLINE, ProQuest, PubMed, Scopus, Global Health and Web of Science. |
|---|---|
| Concept 1: Migrants | “Ethnic group*” OR “Culturally and Linguistically Diverse” OR “Non-English speaking” OR “Ethnic minority*” OR “Transient*” OR “migra*” OR “Immigra*” OR “International student*” OR “Migrant worker*” OR “Labour migra*” OR “Minority group*” OR “Asylum seeker” OR “Displaced people” |
| Concept 2: Sexual health | “Sexual behavio*” OR “Sexual risk behavio*” OR “Sexual practice*” OR “HIV infection*” OR “Sexually transmitted disease*” OR “Genital disease*” OR “Sexually transmitted infection*” OR “Unsafe sex” OR “Sex education” OR “sexual literacy” OR “sexual health” OR “reproductive health” OR STI OR STD OR HIV |
| Concept 4: Help-seeking | “Health seeking behavio?r” OR “Help-seeking behavio?r” OR “Health system” OR “Health care” OR “Health service accessibility” OR “Health service” OR “Health information” OR “Health education” OR “Social support” OR “Primary health care” OR “HIV testing” |
Figure 1Flow diagram of review process.
General study characteristics, quality appraisal, and findings of fourteen studies addressing migrant sexual health help-seeking behavior in high income countries.
| Title | Research Objective | Study Design | Conclusions/Recommendations |
|---|---|---|---|
| To identify barriers for African migrants to access voluntary HIV testing, and to assess possible solutions to increase rates of HIV testing among this population. |
|
Barriers to HIV testing in African migrants in Ireland were found, including fear of consequences of an HIV diagnosis (residency status and social relations) and test affordability. Involve stakeholders (immigrant group leaders, policy makers, health providers and religious leaders) in interventions to increase HIV testing to ensure cultural acceptability. | |
| To explore barriers and enablers to sexual health help-seeking behaviors, and experiences of stigma and discrimination among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia living in Perth, Western Australia. |
|
Barriers and enablers to sexual help-seeking behaviors included sociocultural and religious influence, financial constraints and knowledge dissemination to reduce stigma. Common experiences of stigma and discrimination (including in health care settings) and the social and self-isolation of people living with HIV. Address stigma and discrimination in health care settings. Provide culturally-appropriate sexual health knowledge that is group specific rather than targeted at migrants universally. | |
| To explore sexual health help-seeking behaviors and views of HIV among Thai women living in Sweden. |
|
Low sexual and reproductive health care use and low uptake of HIV testing. Women expressed low perception of risk to HIV. Barriers to healthcare included: language difficulties and low knowledge about the healthcare system. This resulted in a dependence on partners to access health services, or a preference to seek medical help in Thailand. Offer HIV testing as part of cervical cancer screening. Offer free health examinations to Thai migrants. | |
| To examine barriers in accessing and utilizing health services of West African women refugees compared to Australian women. |
|
Barriers to accessing health care were negatively correlated with longer residence and higher education Emotional factors and service provider perceptions were major barriers to access healthcare services. Implement intensive health promotion campaigns through social networks and ethnic media. | |
| To investigate the role of culture in constructions of sexual and reproductive health and health care seeking behavior from the perspective of 1.5 generation migrants |
|
Some migrants’ constructs of sexual and reproductive health changed when in a new culture; others had difficulty integrating new cultural values. Culture may be more easily adapted as many aspects of home (e.g., political, economically, etc.) do not exist in new country. Religion is portable, and may be the reason for an experience of ‘culture clash’ for some migrants. | |
| To examine the facilitators and barriers to medical follow-up among immigrant women living in Spain |
|
Barriers for immigrant women living with HIV in continuing treatment included cultural, social, and gender roles, relationship with the healthcare system, and self-perception. Health professionals to work to identify and overcome barriers faced by patients in adhering to treatment | |
| To describe the interrelationships between migration and resettlement, the Australian immigration system and living with HIV. |
|
Main issue faced by migrants living with HIV was migration Uncertain immigration status can be a barrier to treatment, health care and support. Reduce barriers to accessing health services, including reviewing the practice of rejecting permanent residency applications of people living with HIV Address HIV-related stigma in migrant communities | |
| To identify barriers faced by Eritrean and Ethiopian migrants in Stockholm, Sweden for HIV testing. |
|
Main barrier was ‘fogging the issue of HIV’—categorised as hiding the truth, living in denial and seeking help outside the healthcare system. This was due to distrust of the healthcare system and fearing the consequences of living with HIV. Provide culturally appropriate information on HIV-related issues, in combination with offers of HIV testing early on arrival to Sweden. | |
| To examine the barriers, needs, and perceptions of HIV voluntary counselling and testing (VCT) among sub-Saharan African migrants in Belgium |
|
Multiple barriers to VCT identified including: fear of dying of AIDS, fear of stigma or discrimination and low perceived risk of acquisition. Implement VCT with pre- and post-test counselling, including via health services and via community outreach testing. | |
| To explore young refugees’ accessibility to health information |
|
Similar barriers were found to health service access as other young people Experiences of forced migration, displacement, and resettlement brings additional challenges. Improve accessibility of sexual health services to reduce poor sexual health outcomes and increase sexual health literacy. | |
| To assess knowledge and access to contraception and reproductive health of mothers and daughters from Sudanese and Eritrean backgrounds living in Brisbane |
|
A range of barriers found to health service access and contraceptive use included: lack of cultural competency and ineffective communication by health care workers; poor knowledge of health care system and intergenerational culture clash in relation to sexual health education in the home. Provide sexual health information for new migrants during process of resettling Develop partnerships between health care professionals and CaLD communities Provide translated health information and access to interpreters Design culturally sensitive strategies for parents to communicate with their children about sexual health and enable parent-daughter transfer of health information. | |
| To examine barriers faced by Black African communities to accessing HIV healthcare services. |
|
A range of barriers found including language, limited knowledge of HIV, preference for traditional medicines and lack of cultural diversity among health service workers. Plan health services considering cultural diversity, including use of traditional medicine Ensure HIV workforce undertakes cultural competency training, and is culturally diverse. | |
| To examine the influence of England’s government health policy on migrants’ health seeking and HIV testing. |
|
Changes in policy resulted in difficulties in accessing healthcare services due to cost and difficultly registering. Reverse the policy changes made Provide clear information and guidelines to both migrants and health workers in regards to accessing free health services. | |
| To identify sources of sexual health information sought by African women in Scotland. |
|
Poor knowledge of STIs and HIV and low uptake of sexual health services and regular screening. Develop collaboration between African communities in Scotland with the sexual health services to develop better HIV prevention program. | |
| To assess experiences of Karen and Assyrian woman refugees in utilizing SRH services in Australia |
|
Constructions and experiences of sexual health were closely tied to cultural, religious and gendered family views. Further research to explore interaction of gender, culture and migration process in the construction of sexual health. |