| Campbell et al. (2007)
North Carolina, U.S.A. | Purpose: To explore the feasibility and efficacy of coping skills training (CST)Setting: North Carolina, U.S.A.Sample: 40 couplesFramework: CST | Design: Randomized trialMethods: Survivors and spouses assigned to CST or usual care. Semistructured interviews and self-reported questionnaire; analysis of covariance (ANCOVA), thematic analysis of open-ended questions | Factors/instrument(s): Self-efficacy, QoL (general and disease specific)Domains: Psychosocial, psychological | Strengths: Use of telephone-based approach to assess coping in AA PCa survivors and their intimate partnersLimitations: Small sample size, selection bias | Partners who underwent CST reported less caregiver strain, depression, and fatigue, and more vigor, suggesting that telephone-based CST is a feasible approach that can successfully enhance coping in AA PCa survivors and their intimate partners |
| Campbell et al. (2012)
North Carolina, U.S.A. | Purpose: To examine how variation in masculinity beliefs are related to important indices of psychosocial functioningSetting: North Carolina, U.S.A.Sample: 59 AAFramework: Not stated | Design: Quantitative exploratoryMethods: Correlational analyses, hierarchical multiple regressions | Factors/instrument(s): Expanded PCa Index Composite (EPIC), standard self-efficacy scale, depression and tension (i.e., anxiety) subscales of the Profile of Mood States-SF (POMS), Social/Family Well-being subscale of the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy–GeneralDomains: Psychosocial functioning (i.e., symptom distress, self-efficacy, negative mood, and functional and social well-being) | Strengths: First study to examine masculine conformity variables as predictors of psychosocial functioning in AA PCa survivorsLimitations: Cross-sectional, small sample size, low internal reliability of some subscales used | Masculinity beliefs could be important therapeutic targets for improving the efficacy of cognitive behavioral interventions for men adjusting to PCa survivorship |
| Chornokur, Dalton, Borysova, and Kumar (2011)
U.S.A. | Purpose: Critically review the literature and summarize the most prominent PCa racial disparitiesSetting: N/ASample: Not well definedFramework: Not stated | Design: Systematic reviewMethods: Included studies that focused on disparities at presentation, diagnosis, treatment, and survival in AA PCa survivors, results reported in comparison to other racial and ethnic groups | Factors/instrument(s): N/ADomains: PCa disparities at presentation, diagnosis, treatment, and survival | Strengths: In-depth look at the several types of disparities experienced by AA PCa survivors. Comparison of AA survivors to men from other racial/ethnic groupsLimitations: Cross-sectional designs, lack of demographic reporting of means and standard deviations and of number of studies reviewed, no conceptual framework | AA men persistently present with more advanced disease than Caucasian men, are administered different treatment regimens than Caucasian men, and have shorter progression-free survival following treatment. In addition, AA men report more treatment-related side effects that translate to the diminished QoL |
| Dash et al. (2008)
New York, U.S.A. | Purpose: To determine whether socioeconomic factors had a role in predicting the disease course of Black patients treated with radical prostatectomySetting: New York Veterans Administration Medical Center and Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer CenterSample: 430 Black menFramework: Not stated | Design: Cross-sectional using two cancer registriesMethods: Bivariate analyses, recurrence-free survival analysis, using time-to-biochemical recurrence | Factors/instrument(s): Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) recurrenceDomains: Biologic factors | Strengths: Large, focused sample of patient cohort using two centersLimitations: Selection bias as only Black men of lower socioeconomic status were included in the study | Data suggest that socioeconomic factors have limited impact on PSA recurrence in Black men treated with radical prostatectomy. Thus, biologic factors might have a role in the poor outcomes in this population |
| Emerson, Reece, Levine, Hull, and Husaini (2009)
Tennessee, U.S.A. | Purpose: To determine whether an intervention program that includes peer education and a culturally competent education curriculum within a church-based setting will improve PCa knowledge, perception of risk, and screening rates among AA menSetting: 206 AA churches in greater Nashville areaSample: 345 Black menFramework: Health Belief Model | Design: Quantitative, longitudinal with baseline, 3-month, and 6-month follow-ups using video messages and self-report questionnairesMethods: Difference of proportions tests, logistic multilevel regression | Factors/instrument(s): Health Belief Model, Prostate Cancer Project (PCa risks, prevention, and the benefits of screening and making informed decisions)Domains: Self-efficacy, health belief, PCa knowledge | Strengths: Large sample size and including relevant variables (such as knowledge) that have been reported to affect PCa screening participation in AA menLimitations: Selection bias as only Black men from churches were included. To generalize findings, male participants could be recruited from a variety of sites (i.e., workplaces, schools, barbershops, and other community organizations) | This study demonstrated the need for education, community involvement, and increased access to encourage minority men to obtain needed health screenings. Also, that having insurance could likely lead to a significant decrease in health disparities |
| Friedman, Corwin, Rose, and Dominick (2009)
U.S.A. | Purpose: To explore AA men’s PCa information-seeking behaviors in depth, their capacity to use this information, and their recommendations for development of PCa prevention and screening messages and communication strategies for reaching other AA men with these messagesSetting: Not statedSample: 25 AA menFramework: Not stated | Design: Mixed methods descriptiveMethods: Qualitative, exploratory; semistructured interviews and focus groups. Descriptives of demographic data and thematic analyses of open-ended questions | Factors/instrument(s): PCa information-seeking behaviors, capacity to use PCa information, recommended PCa messages, and suggested strategies for delivering PCa messagesDomains: PCa decision-making | Strengths: Qualitative description of communication strategies, mixed methods approachLimitations: Cross-sectional, no comparison group, no conceptual framework | Barriers to information seeking were fear, poor resources, and limited family communication. Participants requested messages stressing men’s “ownership” of PCa delivered “word-of-mouth” by clergymen, AA women, and AA PCa survivors |
| Gray, Fergus, and Fitch (2005)
Tennessee, U.S.A. | Purpose: To reveal how PCa affects the lives of individual Black men and to show how a narrative approach can contribute to health psychologySetting: N/ASample: Two Black menFramework: Not stated | Design: Qualitative, exploratory; method: open-ended interview-based studyMethods: Each participant was interviewed four times | Factors/instrument(s): The impact of PCa on Black menDomains: PCa experiences | Strengths: Detailed narrative approach used to elicit the impact of PCa in Black menLimitations: Small sample size, no conceptual framework | Black men, like all men with PCa, have diverse experiences and are influenced by a wide array of personal and societal factors. While the high risk of PCa among Black men makes proactive interventions advisable, such interventions will be most effective if the heterogeneity of men’s experiences are taken into account |
| Hanson et al. (2013)
Maryland and Washington, D.C., U.S.A. | Purpose: To test the hypothesis that despite ADT, ST would increase muscle power and mass, thereby improving body composition, physical function, fatigue levels, and QoL in an understudied subset of Black PCa patients on ADTSetting: Veteran Affairs Medical Centers in Washington, D.C., and MarylandSample: 17 AA menFramework: Not stated | Design: Quantitative, descriptiveMethods: Within-group differences were determined using t-tests and regression models. Participants were examined on ADT at baseline and after 12 weeks of ST | Factors/instrument(s): Muscle mass, power, strength, endurance, physical function, fatigue perception, and QoLDomains: Physical and physiological | Strengths: Examined improvement in muscle function and functional performance in Black menLimitations: No comparison group, no randomization, small sample size, no conceptual framework | ST significantly increased total body muscle mass (2.7%), thigh muscle volume (6.4%), power (17%), and strength (28%). There were significant increases in functional performance (20%), muscle endurance (110%), and QoL scores (7%) and decreases in fatigue perception (38%). Improved muscle function was associated with higher functional performance (R2 = 0.54) and lower fatigue perception (R2 = 0.37), and both were associated with improved QoL (R2 = 0.45), whereas fatigue perception tended to be associated with muscle endurance (R2 = 0.37) |
| Jones, Taylor, et al. (2007)
Central Virginia, U.S.A. | Purpose: To examine the cultural beliefs and attitudes of AA PCa survivors regarding the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) modalitiesSetting: In-person interviews in participants’ homes and rural community facilitiesSample: 17 AA menFramework: Not stated | Design: Qualitative descriptives; personal interviews using a semistructured interview guideMethods: Inductive thematic analysis | Factors/instrument(s): PCa, CAM, AA men’s health, culture, herbs, prayer, spirituality, and trustDomains: Spiritual | Strengths: Explored spirituality and CAM use in AA PCa survivorsLimitations: Small sample size, conceptual framework | All participants used prayer often; two men used meditation and herbal preparations. All men reported holding certain beliefs about different categories of CAM. Several men were skeptical of CAM modalities other than prayer. Four themes were revealed: importance of spiritual needs as a CAM modality to health, the value of education in relation to CAM, importance of trust in selected health-care providers, and how men decide on what to believe about CAM modalities |
| Maliski, Connor, Williams, and Litwin (2010)
California, U.S.A. | Purpose: To describe the use of faith by low-income, uninsured AA/Black men in coping with PCa and its treatment and adverse effectsSetting: Participants chose to interview in person at UCLA in a private room, in their home, or by telephoneSample: 18 AA male participants, between 53 and 81 yearsFramework: Grounded theory techniques to develop a descriptive model regarding spirituality and faith in the context of PCa treatment–related incontinence and/or erectile dysfunction | Design: QualitativeMethods: Ethnicity-concordant, trained male interviewed using a semistructured interview guide for all interviews. Interviews lasted 1–2 hr. Men contacted for second interviews 3–6 months following the initial interview to clarify or expand on concepts identified in their baseline interviews or to confirm emerging themes | Factors/instrument(s): FaithDomains: Spirituality, psychosocial, psychological | Strengths: Use of in-depth qualitative interviews, in addition to follow-up interviews to expand on conversations from original interview. Use of grounded theory as a theoretical frameworkLimitations: Findings are specific to the situation of participants and cannot be generalized to all AA/Black men. Findings may not represent all religious beliefs. Faith is not as strict as the concept of religion, which is not confined to a particular religion or belief system. Older men were underrepresented | Three themes identified: (a) perceptions of PCa; (b) coping through faith in God, and (c) provider, self, and family, reframing perceptions |
| Jones et al. (2008)
U.S.A. | Purpose: To examine the interactions and impact of family and friends of PCa survivorsSetting: Data were collected in several clinic meeting rooms, participants’ homes, or a nonintimidating convenient setting for the participantsSample: 14 AA men between the ages of 51 and 83 yearsFramework: None identified | Design: QualitativeMethods: The primary investigator, an AA male, sensitive and knowledgeable about the cultural background of the participants led the interviews. Semistructured interviews lasting 1 to 1.5 hr. Interviews were audiotaped, and actions were observed and recorded in field notes | Factors/instrument(s): Two dominant themes emerged: (a) family involvement with PCa treatment decisions and (b) effect of PCa on relationships with womenDomains: Psychosocial, psychological | Strengths: Use of qualitative design to obtain a rich experience from AA PCa survivors. Focus of open communication and exploring the role of family and friend support for AA PCa survivorsLimitations: Small sample size | Participants indicated family involvement with cancer treatment as well as support from family and friends was critical during their treatment and experiences with PCa. The men did not feel their role as a male in their relationship was negatively impacted. The participants’ wives/partners indicated they would remain with them throughout their experience with PCa. There was a gap in communication between the participants and their wives/partners regarding the effects of the treatments on their relationship. Despite the men indicating that the quality of their erection was an important aspect in their lives, it did not take precedent over their health or their relationship |
| Palmer et al. (2013)
North Carolina, U.S.A. | Purpose: To examine AA PCa survivors’ involvement in treatment decision-making (TDM), and examine the association between TDM and QOL, using secondary dataSetting: North Carolina, U.S.A.Sample: 181 AA PCa survivors, aged 40–75 years from the North Carolina Central Cancer RegistryFramework: None identified | Design: Quantitative, cross-sectionalMethods: Secondary data analysis from a cross-sectional, case control study investigating genetic risks of PCa in AAs. Descriptive statistics, χ2, Fischer’s exact test ANOVA, Tukey honestly significant difference (HSD), and Multivariate analysis of covariance (MANCOVA), conducted for analysis | Factors/instrument(s): The participant’s sense of treatment decision-making, was measured by five questions, from a previous study involving white men and two additional questions from the modified Control Preference Scale. The EPIC measured QoL.Domains: Psychological; TDM and QoL | Strengths: Believed to be the first study to examine TDM and posttreatment QoL for AA PCa patientsLimitations: Due to cross-sectional secondary data analysis, causal inferences cannot be made. Possible selection bias. TDM factors were assessed using single-item measures. Self-report of PCa treatment. Sample consisted of highly educated AA PCa survivors from one state, which may not be representative of the population | Majority of AAs preferred an active or collaborative role in medical decision-making, the roles influenced them, helped decide their choice of treatment, passive PCa patients reported better QoL compared to active patients. Higher QoL scores for bowel and hormonal domains and lower scores in the urinary and sexual domains |
| Rivers et al. (2011)
U.S.A. | Purpose: To identify and describe the most salient psychosocial concerns related to sexual functioning among AA PCa survivors and their spousesSetting: Not statedSample: 12 AA PCa survivors and their spouses, age ranged between 51 and 70 yearsFramework: None identified | Design: QualitativeMethods: Purposive sampling strategy. In-person interviews with AA PCa survivors and their spouses, concurrently, but seemingly separate. Interviews were audiotaped and professionally transcribed. Interview guide was pilot tested and 8 primary questions developed along with 15 potential probe questions | Factors/instrument(s): QoL in relation to sexual functioning among AA men PCa survivors and their spousesDomains: Psychosocial issue of QoL in relation to sexual functioning among survivor AA couples of PCa | Strengths: First qualitative study to examine and describe the psychosocial issues related to the sexual functioning of AA couples surviving PCaLimitations: No limitations identified by authors. Specific population indicates results cannot be generalized to population of AAs | Key themes: (a) spousal support; (b) communication effects; (c) emotional effects; (d) physical effects; (e) sexuality-related effects; (f) erectile dysfunction; (g) incontinence. New information regarding sociocultural factors of seeking medical information, social support, communication strategies, management techniques, martial role delineation, and temporal orientation. Increased need for social support, which was reported by most couples. Difficulty in receiving social support due to lack effective communication and coping strategies. Lack of available information adversely affected couple’s communication. A strong marriage with good communication helped deflect the psychological distress of PCa |
| Rivers et al. (2012)
Florida, U.S.A. | Purpose: To explore the perceptions of AA PCa survivors and their spouses of psychosocial issues related to QoLSetting: In-person interview at a location of their selectionSample: 12 married AA PCa survivors aged between 40 and 70 years, recruited from a National Cancer Institute Comprehensive Cancer Center registry and a state-based nonprofit organization to participate in individual interviewsFramework: None identified | Design: QualitativeMethods: Semistructured individual interviews of PCa survivor and spouse lasting 1.5 hr. Interviews audio-recorded and led by an AA interviewer and AA note taker. A total of 12 couples with the age of PCa survivors ranging from 51 to 70 and a mean of 59.75 years | Factors/instrument(s): QoL was indicated by four domains, which were psychological, social, physical, and spiritual well-beingDomains: Psychological and psychosocial | Strengths: One of few studies to explore the psychological issues encountered by AA men and their spouses. An exploration of QoL beyond the physical dimensions; explores the role of spouses and psychosocial issues of AA men treated for PCa; and examines the role and influence of psychosocial issues experienced by AA men and their spouses Limitations: Few studies to compare the results of the study | Key themes: Under the four domains of QoL, the following themes emerged: (1) psychological well-being (a) fears; (2) social well-being (a) marital communication, (b) social support; (3) physical well-being (a) sexual functioning, (b) lifestyle; and (4) spiritual well-being. There was a lack of knowledge and limited information that was culturally appropriate regarding side effects of treatments; there was an absence of coping and problem-solving strategies that are culturally appropriate, a lack of communication strategies among the marital couples and health-care providers |
| Moore et al. (2012)
North Carolina, U.S.A. | Purpose: To determine if a particular set of health behaviors of health-care providers and AA and Jamaican men influence patient satisfaction from the AA’s perspectiveSetting: North Carolina, U.S.A.Sample: 505 AA and Jamaican men of African descentFramework: Modified form of Andersen’s Behavioral Model of Health Services, which included two domains as opposed to four, which were: (a) health behaviors with two subdomains (process of medical care and use of personal health service) and (b) health outcomes evaluated by patient satisfaction | Design: Descriptive, correlation designMethods: Secondary data analysis of cross-sectional data from the North Carolina-Louisiana Prostate Cancer Project (PCaP) | Factors/instrument(s): Issues of health behaviors of health-care providers and AA and Jamaican menDomains: Psychosocial factors (patient-to-provider communication, interpersonal treatment, provider-to-patient communications, and habits of health-care utilization). | Strengths: Increased literature on patient satisfaction as an outcome variable in association with treatment, decision-making, QoL, or survivorship outcomes based on experiences with health-care useLimitations: Causality could not be assumed due to the use of cross-sectional data. Generalization is not possible due to the specific characteristics of subjects in the data set. Most of the subjects in the study were highly educated, had higher levels of health literacy, and had increased use of the physician’s office. Patterns of communication were based on self-report, which was probably influenced by memory and recall. There was no consideration of interactions among the predicted variables | Interpersonal treatment was one of the most important determinants for patient satisfaction. There must be a combination of adequate communication from health-care providers and good interpersonal treatment. There was an association between communication scores and increases in patient satisfaction. Provider-to-patient communication and patient satisfaction were associated. No association between health-care utilization and usual site for receiving health care and patient satisfaction |
| Nelson, Balk, and Roth (2010)
U.S.A. | Purpose: To clarify emotional well-being, distress, anxiety, and depression in AA men with PCaSetting: Two databasesSample: Total of 723 men (55 AA men were sampled)Framework: None stated | Design: Secondary data analysisMethods: Descriptive statistics, independent measures t-test, and χ2 analysis | Factors/instrument(s): Instruments consisted of QoL measured with the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy, Distress Thermometer, and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression ScaleDomains: Psychological, emotional well-being, distress, anxiety, and depression | Strengths: Limited research on depression, anxiety, emotional well-being, and distress in AA men with PCa. Mix of early- and late-stage PCa patients and various treatmentsLimitations: Lack of nonspecificity for a type of AA PCa patient. Small sample size of AA men. No measures on resilience, no data on socioeconomic status. The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale has not been validated in AA men with PCa | After matching the sample, AA men seem to display a sense of resilience, demonstrating greater emotional well-being and a lower incidence of clinically significant depressive symptoms, compared with Caucasian men |
| Sajid, Kotwal, and Dale (2012)
U.S.A. | Purpose: A systematic literature review on interventions to improve (a) informed decision-making about PCa in screening eligible minority men and (b) QoL in minority PCa survivorsSetting: U.S.A. Sample: Databases of MEDLINE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, CINAHL, and PsycINFOFramework: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) | Design: Systematic review of the literatureMethods: PRISMA; studies were evaluated for quality using the Downs and Black algorithm | Factors/instrument(s): Studies grouped by educational program, printed material/booklets, telephone/videotape/DVD, and web-basedDomains: Knowledge and self-efficacy for informed decision-making in screening eligible men, QoL and symptom management self-efficacy among PCa survivors | Strengths: Systematic review of the literature to identify gaps in knowledge regarding decision-making to reduce racial and ethnic disparities in managing PCaLimitations: No assessment for risk of publication bias. Meta-analysis not performed. Lack of validity of several PCa knowledge scales, variation in the type of PCa knowledge, and knowledge levels in the study was assessed on the same day and no follow-up was performed | Few articles regarding interventions to reduce disparities. Main strategy for PCa is informed decision-making, screening for PCa has fallen out of favor. Improved knowledge increased self-efficacy and appropriate interventions have increased QoL. Educational interventions were the most effective in improving knowledge among screening eligible minority men; cognitive behavioral strategies improved QoL for minority men with PCa |
| Jones et al. (2011)
Maryland and Virginia, U.S.A. | Purpose: To examine social support and economic barriers related to cancer care and assess whom the participants relied on for financial support and other resource issues during diagnosis and treatmentSetting: Churches, barbershops, diners, and primary clinics in central Virginia and Maryland, U.S.A.Sample: 23 AA PCa survivorsFramework: None stated | Design: Qualitative.Methods: Five focus groups that were matched by gender and race Semistructured interview, conducted lasting 45–75 min, were tape-recorded and transcribed. Qualitative analysis program FolioViews™ and descriptive statistics. Thematic analysis method with a multistep analysis plan used | Factors/instrument(s): Semistructured interviews to gather data regarding cancer support and financial issuesDomains: Psychosocial | Strengths: Qualitative design to explore cancer support among older AA men with PCaLimitations: Sample characteristics did not have much variance; most AA men were married, had health insurance, and lived with at least one other person | There were two common themes: (a) Family and physician support are important, and (b) insurance is a necessity for appropriate health care. There were also differences in spirituality during diagnosis and treatment between rural and urban AA PCa survivors |