Ryan N Ptashkin1, Diana L Mandelker1, Catherine C Coombs2,3, Kelly Bolton2, Zarina Yelskaya1, David M Hyman2,4, David B Solit2,4,5,6, José Baselga2,4, Maria E Arcila1, Marc Ladanyi1,6, Liying Zhang1, Ross L Levine2,6,7, Michael F Berger1,5, Ahmet Zehir1. 1. Department of Pathology, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York. 2. Department of Medicine, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York. 3. now with Department of Medicine, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill. 4. Department of Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, Cornell University, New York, New York. 5. Marie-Josée and Henry R. Kravis Center for Molecular Oncology, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York. 6. Human Oncology and Pathogenesis Program, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York. 7. Center for Hematologic Malignancies, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York.
Abstract
Importance: Although clonal hematopoiesis (CH) is well described in aging healthy populations, few studies have addressed the practical clinical implications of these alterations in solid-tumor sequencing. Objective: To identify and quantify CH-related mutations in patients with solid tumors using matched tumor-blood sequencing, and to establish the proportion that would be misattributed to the tumor based on tumor-only sequencing (unmatched analysis). Design, Setting, and Participants: Retrospective analysis of samples from 17 469 patients with solid cancers who underwent prospective clinical sequencing of DNA isolated from tumor tissue and matched peripheral blood using the MSK-IMPACT assay between January 2014 and August 2017. Main Outcomes and Measures: We identified the presence of CH-related mutations in each patient's blood leukocytes and quantified the fraction of DNA molecules harboring the mutation in the corresponding matched tumor sample. Results: The mean age of the 17 469 patients with cancer at sample collection was 59.2 years (range, 0.3-98.9 years); 53.6% were female. We identified 7608 CH-associated mutations in the blood of 4628 (26.5%) patients. A total of 1075 (14.1%) CH-associated mutations were also detectable in the matched tumor above established thresholds for calling somatic mutations. Overall, 912 (5.2%) patients would have had at least 1 CH-associated mutation erroneously called as tumor derived in the absence of matched blood sequencing. A total of 1061 (98.7%) of these mutations were absent from population scale databases of germline polymorphisms and therefore would have been challenging to filter informatically. Annotating variants with OncoKB classified 534 (49.7%) as oncogenic or likely oncogenic. Conclusions and Relevance: This study demonstrates how CH-derived mutations could lead to erroneous reporting and treatment recommendations when tumor-only sequencing is used.
Importance: Although clonal hematopoiesis (CH) is well described in aging healthy populations, few studies have addressed the practical clinical implications of these alterations in solid-tumor sequencing. Objective: To identify and quantify CH-related mutations in patients with solid tumors using matched tumor-blood sequencing, and to establish the proportion that would be misattributed to the tumor based on tumor-only sequencing (unmatched analysis). Design, Setting, and Participants: Retrospective analysis of samples from 17 469 patients with solid cancers who underwent prospective clinical sequencing of DNA isolated from tumor tissue and matched peripheral blood using the MSK-IMPACT assay between January 2014 and August 2017. Main Outcomes and Measures: We identified the presence of CH-related mutations in each patient's blood leukocytes and quantified the fraction of DNA molecules harboring the mutation in the corresponding matched tumor sample. Results: The mean age of the 17 469 patients with cancer at sample collection was 59.2 years (range, 0.3-98.9 years); 53.6% were female. We identified 7608 CH-associated mutations in the blood of 4628 (26.5%) patients. A total of 1075 (14.1%) CH-associated mutations were also detectable in the matched tumor above established thresholds for calling somatic mutations. Overall, 912 (5.2%) patients would have had at least 1 CH-associated mutation erroneously called as tumor derived in the absence of matched blood sequencing. A total of 1061 (98.7%) of these mutations were absent from population scale databases of germline polymorphisms and therefore would have been challenging to filter informatically. Annotating variants with OncoKB classified 534 (49.7%) as oncogenic or likely oncogenic. Conclusions and Relevance: This study demonstrates how CH-derived mutations could lead to erroneous reporting and treatment recommendations when tumor-only sequencing is used.
Authors: Catherine C Coombs; Ahmet Zehir; Sean M Devlin; Ashwin Kishtagari; Aijazuddin Syed; Philip Jonsson; David M Hyman; David B Solit; Mark E Robson; José Baselga; Maria E Arcila; Marc Ladanyi; Martin S Tallman; Ross L Levine; Michael F Berger Journal: Cell Stem Cell Date: 2017-08-10 Impact factor: 24.633
Authors: Lynette M Sholl; Khanh Do; Priyanka Shivdasani; Ethan Cerami; Adrian M Dubuc; Frank C Kuo; Elizabeth P Garcia; Yonghui Jia; Phani Davineni; Ryan P Abo; Trevor J Pugh; Paul van Hummelen; Aaron R Thorner; Matthew Ducar; Alice H Berger; Mizuki Nishino; Katherine A Janeway; Alanna Church; Marian Harris; Lauren L Ritterhouse; Joshua D Campbell; Vanesa Rojas-Rudilla; Azra H Ligon; Shakti Ramkissoon; James M Cleary; Ursula Matulonis; Geoffrey R Oxnard; Richard Chao; Vanessa Tassell; James Christensen; William C Hahn; Philip W Kantoff; David J Kwiatkowski; Bruce E Johnson; Matthew Meyerson; Levi A Garraway; Geoffrey I Shapiro; Barrett J Rollins; Neal I Lindeman; Laura E MacConaill Journal: JCI Insight Date: 2016-11-17
Authors: Donavan T Cheng; Talia N Mitchell; Ahmet Zehir; Ronak H Shah; Ryma Benayed; Aijazuddin Syed; Raghu Chandramohan; Zhen Yu Liu; Helen H Won; Sasinya N Scott; A Rose Brannon; Catherine O'Reilly; Justyna Sadowska; Jacklyn Casanova; Angela Yannes; Jaclyn F Hechtman; Jinjuan Yao; Wei Song; Dara S Ross; Alifya Oultache; Snjezana Dogan; Laetitia Borsu; Meera Hameed; Khedoudja Nafa; Maria E Arcila; Marc Ladanyi; Michael F Berger Journal: J Mol Diagn Date: 2015-03-20 Impact factor: 5.568
Authors: Ryan J Hartmaier; Lee A Albacker; Juliann Chmielecki; Mark Bailey; Jie He; Michael E Goldberg; Shakti Ramkissoon; James Suh; Julia A Elvin; Samuel Chiacchia; Garrett M Frampton; Jeffrey S Ross; Vincent Miller; Philip J Stephens; Doron Lipson Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2017-02-24 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Justin Lee; Jennifer Axilbund; W Brian Dalton; Daniel Laheru; Stanley Watkins; David Chu; Karen Cravero; Berry Button; Kelly Kyker-Snowman; Ian Waters; Christopher D Gocke; Josh Lauring; Ben Ho Park Journal: J Natl Compr Canc Netw Date: 2016-12 Impact factor: 11.908
Authors: Genevieve M Boland; Sarina A Piha-Paul; Vivek Subbiah; Mark Routbort; Shelley M Herbrich; Keith Baggerly; Keyur P Patel; Lauren Brusco; Chacha Horombe; Aung Naing; Siqing Fu; David S Hong; Filip Janku; Amber Johnson; Russell Broaddus; Raja Luthra; Kenna Shaw; John Mendelsohn; Gordon B Mills; Funda Meric-Bernstam Journal: Oncotarget Date: 2015-08-21
Authors: Shuyu D Li; Meng Ma; Hui Li; Aneta Waluszko; Tatyana Sidorenko; Eric E Schadt; David Y Zhang; Rong Chen; Fei Ye Journal: Genome Med Date: 2017-10-30 Impact factor: 11.117
Authors: Ahmet Zehir; Ryma Benayed; Ronak H Shah; Aijazuddin Syed; Sumit Middha; Hyunjae R Kim; Preethi Srinivasan; Jianjiong Gao; Debyani Chakravarty; Sean M Devlin; Matthew D Hellmann; David A Barron; Alison M Schram; Meera Hameed; Snjezana Dogan; Dara S Ross; Jaclyn F Hechtman; Deborah F DeLair; JinJuan Yao; Diana L Mandelker; Donavan T Cheng; Raghu Chandramohan; Abhinita S Mohanty; Ryan N Ptashkin; Gowtham Jayakumaran; Meera Prasad; Mustafa H Syed; Anoop Balakrishnan Rema; Zhen Y Liu; Khedoudja Nafa; Laetitia Borsu; Justyna Sadowska; Jacklyn Casanova; Ruben Bacares; Iwona J Kiecka; Anna Razumova; Julie B Son; Lisa Stewart; Tessara Baldi; Kerry A Mullaney; Hikmat Al-Ahmadie; Efsevia Vakiani; Adam A Abeshouse; Alexander V Penson; Philip Jonsson; Niedzica Camacho; Matthew T Chang; Helen H Won; Benjamin E Gross; Ritika Kundra; Zachary J Heins; Hsiao-Wei Chen; Sarah Phillips; Hongxin Zhang; Jiaojiao Wang; Angelica Ochoa; Jonathan Wills; Michael Eubank; Stacy B Thomas; Stuart M Gardos; Dalicia N Reales; Jesse Galle; Robert Durany; Roy Cambria; Wassim Abida; Andrea Cercek; Darren R Feldman; Mrinal M Gounder; A Ari Hakimi; James J Harding; Gopa Iyer; Yelena Y Janjigian; Emmet J Jordan; Ciara M Kelly; Maeve A Lowery; Luc G T Morris; Antonio M Omuro; Nitya Raj; Pedram Razavi; Alexander N Shoushtari; Neerav Shukla; Tara E Soumerai; Anna M Varghese; Rona Yaeger; Jonathan Coleman; Bernard Bochner; Gregory J Riely; Leonard B Saltz; Howard I Scher; Paul J Sabbatini; Mark E Robson; David S Klimstra; Barry S Taylor; Jose Baselga; Nikolaus Schultz; David M Hyman; Maria E Arcila; David B Solit; Marc Ladanyi; Michael F Berger Journal: Nat Med Date: 2017-05-08 Impact factor: 53.440
Authors: Michael Allgäuer; Jan Budczies; Petros Christopoulos; Volker Endris; Amelie Lier; Eugen Rempel; Anna-Lena Volckmar; Martina Kirchner; Moritz von Winterfeld; Jonas Leichsenring; Olaf Neumann; Stefan Fröhling; Roland Penzel; Michael Thomas; Peter Schirmacher; Albrecht Stenzinger Journal: Transl Lung Cancer Res Date: 2018-12
Authors: Kelly L Bolton; Nancy K Gillis; Catherine C Coombs; Koichi Takahashi; Ahmet Zehir; Rafael Bejar; Guillermo Garcia-Manero; Andrew Futreal; Brian C Jensen; Luis A Diaz; Dipti Gupta; Simon Mantha; Virginia Klimek; Elli Papaemmanuil; Ross Levine; Eric Padron Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2018-11-07 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Francesco Marass; Dennis Stephens; Ryan Ptashkin; Ahmet Zehir; Michael F Berger; David B Solit; Luis A Diaz; Dana W Y Tsui Journal: Clin Chem Date: 2020-04-01 Impact factor: 8.327
Authors: Peter Libby; Robert Sidlow; Amy E Lin; Dipti Gupta; Lee W Jones; Javid Moslehi; Andreas Zeiher; Siddhartha Jaiswal; Christian Schulz; Ron Blankstein; Kelly L Bolton; David Steensma; Ross L Levine; Benjamin L Ebert Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2019-07-30 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Matthew D Hellmann; Barzin Y Nabet; Hira Rizvi; Aadel A Chaudhuri; Daniel K Wells; Mark P S Dunphy; Jacob J Chabon; Chih Long Liu; Angela B Hui; Kathryn C Arbour; Jia Luo; Isabel R Preeshagul; Everett J Moding; Diego Almanza; Rene F Bonilla; Jennifer L Sauter; Hyejin Choi; Megan Tenet; Mohsen Abu-Akeel; Andrew J Plodkowski; Rocio Perez Johnston; Christopher H Yoo; Ryan B Ko; Henning Stehr; Linda Gojenola; Heather A Wakelee; Sukhmani K Padda; Joel W Neal; Jamie E Chaft; Mark G Kris; Charles M Rudin; Taha Merghoub; Bob T Li; Ash A Alizadeh; Maximilian Diehn Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2020-02-11 Impact factor: 12.531