| Literature DB >> 29857585 |
Ourania Koutzampasopoulou Xanthidou1, Liyana Shuib2, Dimitrios Xanthidis3,4, David Nicholas5.
Abstract
An Electronic Medical Record (EMR) is a patient's database record that can be transmitted securely. There are a diversity of EMR systems for different medical units to choose from. The structure and value of these systems is the focus of this qualitative study, from a medical professional's standpoint, as well as its economic value and whether it should be shared between health organizations. The study took place in the natural setting of the medical units' environments. A purposive sample of 40 professionals in Greece and Oman, was interviewed. The study suggests that: (1) The demographics of the EMR should be divided in categories, not all of them accessible and/or visible by all; (2) The EMR system should follow an open architecture so that more categories and subcategories can be added as needed and following a possible business plan (ERD is suggested); (3) The EMR should be implemented gradually bearing in mind both medical and financial concerns; (4) Sharing should be a patient's decision as the owner of the record. Reaching a certain level of maturity of its implementation and utilization, it is useful to seek the professionals' assessment on the structure and value of such a system.Entities:
Keywords: Electronic Medical Record (EMR); Entity Relationship Diagram (ERD); contents and structure; demographics; economic feasibility; qualitative study
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29857585 PMCID: PMC6025308 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph15061137
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Figure 1A Contents and structure of EMR system.
Contents and structure of the EMR—significant statements.
| Alias, Position, Country, Hospital Type | Quotes |
|---|---|
| P7, M.D., Greece, Private | “Race: It is important. For example, there are medicines that affect people from different races in different ways. Someone could say that the MDs have a visual contact of the patient and, thus, they know their race. However, even then, it would be nice to have this data recorded for statistical purposes.” |
| P8, Nursing practitioner, Greece, Private | “I believe that, the ID number must be not only unique but, also, not the same as the Social Security Number (SSN) or personal insurance number or other. This can make it more secure and private. In that case, no patient would have to worry about whether his/her medical data is centrally recorded and accessed or not.” |
| P9, Lab/Pharmacist, Greece, Private | “It would be nice and helpful to include, somewhere and somehow, hereditary diseases.” |
| P10, ICT, Greece, Private | “In the demographics category data should be divided into three levels, i.e., basics, sensitive and administrative. In the sensitive level data like race and religion could be included if necessary. In the administrative level any data related to the medical unit and the patient could be included.” |
| P12, M.D., Greece, Private | “Occupation, Race, Religion are important since they are associated with certain diseases. Also, the education level and the language are important because they may assist in communicating with the patient.” |
| P13, Nursing practitioner, Greece, Private | “If we know the education level of the patient, then, the medical personnel will be able to communicate with the patient accordingly. However, I feel it is rather racist behavior to ask for it even for that reason.” “It is necessary to have the Race and the Nationality, especially nowadays, with all these immigrants and refugees moving from one country to another often with their diseases and not speaking our language. It so happens that, at the end of the day, the medical and nursing practitioners adapt to these people and not vice versa.” |
| P17, CEO/Admin, Greece, Public | “There is no need to have all the demographics in one level-view. Especially, the medical doctors don’t have enough time to see everything.” “In particular, as to the patient’s ID, it would be better off if each patient would have his/her own ID at a national level instead of a different one in every medical organization. There is an effort to do that now.” “As far as for the Race element, especially now that huge refuge waves are going to different countries including Greece, maybe it is appropriate to include it in the record.” |
| P16, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Greece, Private | “No: Name, Address, email, Race, Language, Size of family, Income level.” “The most important is not to have access to all this medical information to anyone.” |
| P18, M.D., Greece, Public | “No: Race, Income level, Language.” “There is no need and it is not good to ask for the income level. If there is an issue of whether the patient can cover his/her medical treatment and/or medication expenses or not the level of insurance coverage will indicate.” “In medication list it is suggested to have all the substances under one label e.g., Use of Substances.” “All categories should be able to accept additional entries (elements).” |
| P19, Nursing practitioner, Greece, Public | “Medicine and nursing are practices that are to be provided equally to everybody.” “It is possible that someone comes to the ER unconscious. In that case we will help him/her and provide everything necessary to save his/her life without looking into religious, race or other matters.” “For the category of Surgery, it would be better if it is by the biological systems for the human body.” |
| P30, Lab/Pharmacist, Oman, Public | “Blood group is important and must be included.” |
| P37, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Oman, Private | “Sometimes I feel that the medical organizations asked from me for more medical exams than necessary knowing my financial status. So, I believe Income level should not be included.” |
Figure 2A suggestion of an Entity Relationship Diagram for the EMR system.
Economic feasibility—significant statements.
| Alias, Position, Country, Hospital Type | Quotes |
|---|---|
| P5, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Greece, Public | “I don’t believe that the EMR will reduce the repetition of the medical examinations.” |
| P8, Nursing practitioner, Greece, Private | “It will help reduce costs and repetitions. Usually the expensive medical tests are the ones the results which don’t change quickly. So, there is no reason to ask between hospitals the same expensive tests very often.” “It’s everything for the patients and not for the profit. At the end some hospitals might lose profit, especially the private ones, but what is important is the quality of the patient diagnosis and treatment.” “This will make the MDs and the health professionals of all types, in private and public hospitals together, to cooperate for the benefit of the patient.” |
| P14, Lab/Pharmacist, Greece, Private | “The best health system is the one that a country can pay for. The problem is that you, also, have to pay for retirement plans, medical and pharmaceutical expenses, cancer treatment, heart disease treatment, economy growth, and more. Money is never enough for everyone for everything.” |
| P15, ICT, Greece, Private | “I believe a system like that will not reduce the repetition of medical exams but it will help to provide better health care.” |
| P17, CEO/Admin, Greece, Public | “It is important to implement the medical record system but not all medical organizations need to do so in the same depth. They need to study the economic feasibility first and then decide the depth.” “No need to fully deploy a medical record system if the cost is too high and the medical organization cannot bear it but start small and gradually move up. Make it using open architecture which means, implement the first part, check it and if everything works well then move to the next part.” |
| P18, M.D., Greece, Public | “In the case of Greece, and just for the case of the diabetic foot in which 250 million euros are spent every year, the savings will be enough to justify the cost for the implementation of the medical record management system” |
| P19, Nursing practitioner, Greece, Public | “It will cut the costs but it will increase the amount of work of the MDs. There are already complains of some MDs about the time they spend in entering data, even in simple similar programs, instead of practicing medicine. It is a big benefit but at the moment it is not practical especially if we want to record all the data, especially also given the economic crisis in the country.” |
| P20, Lab/Pharmacist, Greece, Public | “It needs an economic feasibility study to decide on the implementation of such as a system if it is too expensive. If we see it from the side of the patient the benefits are more.” |
| P22, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Greece, Public | “Is the implementation of such a system, regardless of the cost, a panacea? Not really.” |
| P28, M.D., Oman, Public | “A system like this will not save time, we will continue as doctors to spend the same time to treat a patient but what is important is it will help us not to forget anything important in the treatment. We will have everything in the system where we should report and update it. We are human beings and we forget some times.” “In a matter of health, we don’t talk about money. The most important is the health.” |
| P29, Nursing practitioner, Oman, Public | “Sometimes the patients are complaining about that the doctors are spending more time in front of the computer instead of examining them. The doctors have to do that because sometimes the patients are losing their medical reports or exams or even they are forgetting to inform the doctors about some of their own health issues. With a system like that a doctor can know always about the full patient’s history and they don’t have to do everything from the beginning. This can save patient’s life.” |
| P32, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Oman, Public | “When a country’s economy is in recession like it happens now in Oman and in other countries, it is very important to be able to cut the costs whatever you can. For example, if a person has made an X-ray recently there is no reason to ask to do it again. It costs money and affects their health since we know it may cause cancer. Similar with MRI.” “It will certainly save money. Maybe in the beginning it will cost a lot but if one thinks how much savings it will make just from the X-rays it is enough to understand how important it is.” |
Sharing medical records—significant statements.
| Alias, Position, Country, Hospital Type | Quotes |
|---|---|
| P17, CEO/Admin, Greece, Public | “The medical exams belong to the patient since the patient had paid for them and s/he can do anything s/he wants with them. This is a practice applied not only in Greece but in Europe in general.” “It is necessary and wise to use the medical insurance coverage from patients from other European countries, since this way the Greek hospitals can benefit financially from charging these insurance companies instead of providing medical treatment and medication for free. This is especially important now that many foreigners come to Greece and many times they get medical services for free.” |
| P28, M.D., Oman, Public | “In some special cases with critical diseases, no matter if the patient doesn’t want to give to other doctors their personal medical information, as a doctor I am giving the information to save the patient’s life.” |
| P32, Legal/Lawyer/QA, Oman, Public | “It will be great to share medical information worldwide because we don’t share the patient but the patient’s data and this will help a lot to develop any research related to it and also make statistics based on it.” |
| P33, CEO/Admin, Oman, Private | “The Omani government is planning to implement a system that will allow any patient to have access to his medical record anywhere, anytime in Oman.” |
| P40, M.D., Oman, Private | “If it is properly secured is ok under authorization to exchange medical information.” “We trust people but we also mistrust them.” |