Shyuan Ching Tan1,2, Sarah J Barber1. 1. Department of Psychology, San Francisco State University, California. 2. Department of Human Development and Family Studies, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Research has shown that stereotype threat can impair older adults' memory in Western cultures. We tested whether this also occurs for older adults from the East Asian Chinese culture. We also tested whether an intervention that highlighted Confucian principles would protect Chinese older adults from stereotype threat's detrimental effects. METHOD: Culturally-Chinese older adults residing in the United States completed a memory test either under age-based stereotype threat about cognitive decline or not. Prior to this, some participants were also reminded of Confucian traditions of filial piety and were assured these values had been transmitted to the younger generation. RESULTS: Stereotype threat impaired Chinese older adults' memory performance. However, our intervention was effective in eliminating this deficit. When the Chinese participants were reminded of the Confucian principle of filial piety they did not exhibit stereotype threat effects. DISCUSSION: Confirming that younger adults have an obligation to respect their elders can eliminate the social-evaluative pressure of stereotype threat for Chinese older adults. These findings are noteworthy since population aging is happening at an unprecedented pace in East Asia. Although our results suggest that stereotype threat can adversely affect older adults' cognitive performance in these societies, we also identify a culturally-based intervention to alleviate this impairment.
OBJECTIVES: Research has shown that stereotype threat can impair older adults' memory in Western cultures. We tested whether this also occurs for older adults from the East Asian Chinese culture. We also tested whether an intervention that highlighted Confucian principles would protect Chinese older adults from stereotype threat's detrimental effects. METHOD: Culturally-Chinese older adults residing in the United States completed a memory test either under age-based stereotype threat about cognitive decline or not. Prior to this, some participants were also reminded of Confucian traditions of filial piety and were assured these values had been transmitted to the younger generation. RESULTS: Stereotype threat impaired Chinese older adults' memory performance. However, our intervention was effective in eliminating this deficit. When the Chinese participants were reminded of the Confucian principle of filial piety they did not exhibit stereotype threat effects. DISCUSSION: Confirming that younger adults have an obligation to respect their elders can eliminate the social-evaluative pressure of stereotype threat for Chinese older adults. These findings are noteworthy since population aging is happening at an unprecedented pace in East Asia. Although our results suggest that stereotype threat can adversely affect older adults' cognitive performance in these societies, we also identify a culturally-based intervention to alleviate this impairment.
Authors: Thomas M Hess; Corinne Auman; Stanley J Colcombe; Tamara A Rahhal Journal: J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci Date: 2003-01 Impact factor: 4.077
Authors: Corinna E Löckenhoff; Filip De Fruyt; Antonio Terracciano; Robert R McCrae; Marleen De Bolle; Paul T Costa; Maria E Aguilar-Vafaie; Chang-kyu Ahn; Hyun-nie Ahn; Lidia Alcalay; Juri Allik; Tatyana V Avdeyeva; Claudio Barbaranelli; Veronica Benet-Martinez; Marek Blatný; Denis Bratko; Thomas R Cain; Jarret T Crawford; Margarida P Lima; Emília Ficková; Mirona Gheorghiu; Jamin Halberstadt; Martina Hrebícková; Lee Jussim; Waldemar Klinkosz; Goran Knezević; Nora Leibovich de Figueroa; Thomas A Martin; Iris Marusić; Khairul Anwar Mastor; Daniel R Miramontez; Katsuharu Nakazato; Florence Nansubuga; V S Pramila; Anu Realo; Jean-Pierre Rolland; Jerome Rossier; Vanina Schmidt; Andrzej Sekowski; Jane Shakespeare-Finch; Yoshiko Shimonaka; Franco Simonetti; Jerzy Siuta; Peter B Smith; Barbara Szmigielska; Lei Wang; Mami Yamaguchi; Michelle Yik Journal: Psychol Aging Date: 2009-12