Lucia M Walsh1, McKenzie K Roddy1, Kelli Scott2,3, Cara C Lewis3,4, Amanda Jensen-Doss1. 1. Department of Psychology, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL, USA. 2. Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA. 3. Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Indiana University Bloomington, Bloomington, IN, USA. 4. MacColl Center for Health Care Innovation, Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute, Seattle, WA, USA.
Abstract
Objective: This meta-analysis synthesized the literature regarding the effect of therapist experience on internalizing client outcomes to evaluate the utility of lay providers in delivering treatment and to inform therapist training. Method: The analysis included 22 studies, contributing 208 effect sizes. Study and client characteristics were coded to examine moderators. We conducted subgroup meta-analyses examining the relationship of therapist experience across a diverse set of internalizing client outcomes. Results: Results demonstrated a small, but significant relationship between therapist experience and internalizing client outcomes. There was no relationship between therapist experience and outcomes in clients with primary anxiety disorders. In samples of clients with primary depressive disorders and in samples of clients with mixed internalizing disorders, there was a significant relationship between experience and outcomes. The relationship between therapist experience and outcomes was stronger when clients were randomized to therapists, treatment was not manualized, and for measures of client satisfaction and "other" outcomes (e.g., dropout). Conclusions: It appears that therapist experience may matter for internalizing clients under certain circumstances, but this relationship is modest. Continuing methodological concerns in the literature are noted, as well as recommendations to address these concerns.
Objective: This meta-analysis synthesized the literature regarding the effect of therapist experience on internalizing client outcomes to evaluate the utility of lay providers in delivering treatment and to inform therapist training. Method: The analysis included 22 studies, contributing 208 effect sizes. Study and client characteristics were coded to examine moderators. We conducted subgroup meta-analyses examining the relationship of therapist experience across a diverse set of internalizing client outcomes. Results: Results demonstrated a small, but significant relationship between therapist experience and internalizing client outcomes. There was no relationship between therapist experience and outcomes in clients with primary anxiety disorders. In samples of clients with primary depressive disorders and in samples of clients with mixed internalizing disorders, there was a significant relationship between experience and outcomes. The relationship between therapist experience and outcomes was stronger when clients were randomized to therapists, treatment was not manualized, and for measures of client satisfaction and "other" outcomes (e.g., dropout). Conclusions: It appears that therapist experience may matter for internalizing clients under certain circumstances, but this relationship is modest. Continuing methodological concerns in the literature are noted, as well as recommendations to address these concerns.
Authors: Benedetto Saraceno; Mark van Ommeren; Rajaie Batniji; Alex Cohen; Oye Gureje; John Mahoney; Devi Sridhar; Chris Underhill Journal: Lancet Date: 2007-09-29 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Ronald C Kessler; Olga Demler; Richard G Frank; Mark Olfson; Harold Alan Pincus; Ellen E Walters; Philip Wang; Kenneth B Wells; Alan M Zaslavsky Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2005-06-16 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Melinda A Stanley; Nancy L Wilson; Amber B Amspoker; Cynthia Kraus-Schuman; Paula D Wagener; Jessica S Calleo; Jeffrey A Cully; Ellen Teng; Howard M Rhoades; Susan Williams; Nicholas Masozera; Matthew Horsfield; Mark E Kunik Journal: Depress Anxiety Date: 2014-02-27 Impact factor: 6.505
Authors: Gregory L Fricchione; Christina P C Borba; Atalay Alem; Teshome Shibre; Julia R Carney; David C Henderson Journal: Harv Rev Psychiatry Date: 2012 Jan-Feb Impact factor: 3.732
Authors: Anke Ehlers; Nick Grey; Jennifer Wild; Richard Stott; Sheena Liness; Alicia Deale; Rachel Handley; Idit Albert; Deborah Cullen; Ann Hackmann; John Manley; Freda McManus; Francesca Brady; Paul Salkovskis; David M Clark Journal: Behav Res Ther Date: 2013-09-10
Authors: Michele Settanni; Monica Bronzini; Giuseppe Carzedda; Giuseppe Godino; Maria Luisa Manca; Luisa Martini; Gianluca Provvedi; Francesco Quilghini; Alberto Zucconi; Gianni Francesetti Journal: Res Psychother Date: 2022-08-01