Sarah B Bateni1, Robert J Canter1, Frederick J Meyers2, Joseph M Galante3, Richard J Bold4. 1. Divison of Surgical Oncology, Department of Surgery, University of California, Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA. 2. Hematology/Oncology, Department of Internal Medicine, University of California, Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA. 3. Division of Trauma, Acute Care Surgery and Surgical Critical Care, University of California, Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA. 4. Divison of Surgical Oncology, Department of Surgery, University of California, Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA. Electronic address: rjbold@ucdavis.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Surgical decision-making in patients with advanced cancer requires careful thought and deliberation to balance the high risks with the potential palliative benefits. We sought to compare surgical decision-making and palliative care training among surgeons and medical physicians who commonly treat advanced cancer patients. We hypothesized that surgeons will report less palliative care training compared with medical physicians, and deficits in palliative care training will be associated with more aggressive treatment recommendations in clinical scenarios of advanced cancer patients with symptomatic surgical conditions. STUDY DESIGN: Practicing surgeons, medical oncologists, intensivists, and palliative care physicians from a large urban city and its surrounding areas were surveyed with a 32-item questionnaire consisting of a survey addressing palliative care training and 4 clinical vignettes depicting patients with advanced cancer and symptomatic surgical conditions. RESULTS: Of the 299 physicians surveyed, 102 responded (response rate 34.1%). Surgeons reported fewer hours of palliative care training during residency, fellowship, and continuing medical education combined (median 10, IQR 2-15) compared with medical oncologists (median 30, IQR 20-80) and medical intensivists (median 50 IQR 30-100), P < .05. Additionally, 20% of surgeons reported no history of any palliative care training. Analysis of physician recommendations for treatment of the 4 clinical vignettes showed minimal consensus regardless of physician specialty. Absence of palliative care training was associated with recommending major operative intervention more frequently compared with physicians with ≥40 hours of palliative care training (0.7 ± 0.7 vs 1.6 ± 0.8, P =.01). CONCLUSION: Substantial deficiencies in palliative care training persist among surgeons and are associated with more aggressive recommendations for treatment for the selected scenarios presented in patients with advanced cancer. These findings highlight the need for greater efforts systemwide in palliative care education among surgeons, including incorporation of a structured palliative care training curriculum in graduate and continuing surgical education.
BACKGROUND: Surgical decision-making in patients with advanced cancer requires careful thought and deliberation to balance the high risks with the potential palliative benefits. We sought to compare surgical decision-making and palliative care training among surgeons and medical physicians who commonly treat advanced cancerpatients. We hypothesized that surgeons will report less palliative care training compared with medical physicians, and deficits in palliative care training will be associated with more aggressive treatment recommendations in clinical scenarios of advanced cancerpatients with symptomatic surgical conditions. STUDY DESIGN: Practicing surgeons, medical oncologists, intensivists, and palliative care physicians from a large urban city and its surrounding areas were surveyed with a 32-item questionnaire consisting of a survey addressing palliative care training and 4 clinical vignettes depicting patients with advanced cancer and symptomatic surgical conditions. RESULTS: Of the 299 physicians surveyed, 102 responded (response rate 34.1%). Surgeons reported fewer hours of palliative care training during residency, fellowship, and continuing medical education combined (median 10, IQR 2-15) compared with medical oncologists (median 30, IQR 20-80) and medical intensivists (median 50 IQR 30-100), P < .05. Additionally, 20% of surgeons reported no history of any palliative care training. Analysis of physician recommendations for treatment of the 4 clinical vignettes showed minimal consensus regardless of physician specialty. Absence of palliative care training was associated with recommending major operative intervention more frequently compared with physicians with ≥40 hours of palliative care training (0.7 ± 0.7 vs 1.6 ± 0.8, P =.01). CONCLUSION: Substantial deficiencies in palliative care training persist among surgeons and are associated with more aggressive recommendations for treatment for the selected scenarios presented in patients with advanced cancer. These findings highlight the need for greater efforts systemwide in palliative care education among surgeons, including incorporation of a structured palliative care training curriculum in graduate and continuing surgical education.
Authors: Katya Robinson; Sharyn Sutton; Charles F von Gunten; Frank D Ferris; Nicholas Molodyko; Jeanne Martinez; Linda L Emanuel Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2004-10 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: Laurence E McCahill; Robert S Krouse; David Z J Chu; Gloria Juarez; Gwen C Uman; Betty R Ferrell; Lawrence D Wagman Journal: J Am Coll Surg Date: 2002-09 Impact factor: 6.113
Authors: Craig C Earle; Mary Beth Landrum; Jeffrey M Souza; Bridget A Neville; Jane C Weeks; John Z Ayanian Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2008-08-10 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Megan Winner; Stephen J Mooney; Dawn L Hershman; Daniel L Feingold; John D Allendorf; Jason D Wright; Alfred I Neugut Journal: Dis Colon Rectum Date: 2013-07 Impact factor: 4.585
Authors: Ronald M Epstein; Paul R Duberstein; Joshua J Fenton; Kevin Fiscella; Michael Hoerger; Daniel J Tancredi; Guibo Xing; Robert Gramling; Supriya Mohile; Peter Franks; Paul Kaesberg; Sandy Plumb; Camille S Cipri; Richard L Street; Cleveland G Shields; Anthony L Back; Phyllis Butow; Adam Walczak; Martin Tattersall; Alison Venuti; Peter Sullivan; Mark Robinson; Beth Hoh; Linda Lewis; Richard L Kravitz Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2017-01-01 Impact factor: 31.777
Authors: Catherine R Butler; Margaret L Schwarze; Ronit Katz; Susan M Hailpern; William Kreuter; Yoshio N Hall; Maria E Montez Rath; Ann M O'Hare Journal: J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2019-02-19 Impact factor: 10.121
Authors: Penelope J Slater; Anthony R Herbert; Sarah J Baggio; Leigh A Donovan; Alison M McLarty; Julie A Duffield; Lee-Anne C Pedersen; Jacqueline K Duc; Angela M Delaney; Susan A Johnson; Melissa G Heywood; Charlotte A Burr Journal: Adv Med Educ Pract Date: 2018-12-14
Authors: Sarah B Bateni; Alicia A Gingrich; Susan L Stewart; Frederick J Meyers; Richard J Bold; Robert J Canter Journal: BMC Cancer Date: 2018-11-26 Impact factor: 4.430