K Gbyl1, P Videbech1. 1. Centre for Neuropsychiatric Depression Research, Mental Health Centre Glostrup, Glostrup, Denmark.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The main purpose of this review was to synthesise evidence on ECT's effects on brain's structure. METHOD: A systematic literature review of longitudinal studies of depressed patients treated with ECT using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and meta-analysis of ECT's effect on hippocampal volume. RESULTS: Thirty-two studies with 467 patients and 285 controls were included. The MRI studies did not find any evidence of ECT-related brain damage. All but one of the newer MRI volumetric studies found ECT-induced volume increases in certain brain areas, most consistently in hippocampus. Meta-analysis of effect of ECT on hippocampal volume yielded pooled effect size: g = 0.39 (95% CI = 0.18-0.61) for the right hippocampus and g = 0.31 (95% CI = 0.09-0.53) for the left. The DTI studies point to an ECT-induced increase in the integrity of white matter pathways in the frontal and temporal lobes. The results of correlations between volume increases and treatment efficacy were inconsistent. CONCLUSION: The MRI studies do not support the hypothesis that ECT causes brain damage; on the contrary, the treatment induces volume increases in fronto-limbic areas. Further studies should explore the relationship between these increases and treatment effect and cognitive side effects.
OBJECTIVE: The main purpose of this review was to synthesise evidence on ECT's effects on brain's structure. METHOD: A systematic literature review of longitudinal studies of depressedpatients treated with ECT using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and meta-analysis of ECT's effect on hippocampal volume. RESULTS: Thirty-two studies with 467 patients and 285 controls were included. The MRI studies did not find any evidence of ECT-related brain damage. All but one of the newer MRI volumetric studies found ECT-induced volume increases in certain brain areas, most consistently in hippocampus. Meta-analysis of effect of ECT on hippocampal volume yielded pooled effect size: g = 0.39 (95% CI = 0.18-0.61) for the right hippocampus and g = 0.31 (95% CI = 0.09-0.53) for the left. The DTI studies point to an ECT-induced increase in the integrity of white matter pathways in the frontal and temporal lobes. The results of correlations between volume increases and treatment efficacy were inconsistent. CONCLUSION: The MRI studies do not support the hypothesis that ECT causes brain damage; on the contrary, the treatment induces volume increases in fronto-limbic areas. Further studies should explore the relationship between these increases and treatment effect and cognitive side effects.
Authors: Takahiro Soda; Declan M McLoughlin; Scott R Clark; Leif Oltedal; Ute Kessler; Jan Haavik; Chad Bousman; Daniel J Smith; Miquel Bioque; Caitlin C Clements; Colleen Loo; Fidel Vila-Rodriguez; Alessandra Minelli; Brian J Mickey; Roumen Milev; Anna R Docherty; Julie Langan Martin; Eric D Achtyes; Volker Arolt; Ronny Redlich; Udo Dannlowski; Narcis Cardoner; Emily Clare; Nick Craddock; Arianna Di Florio; Monika Dmitrzak-Weglarz; Liz Forty; Katherine Gordon-Smith; Mustafa Husain; Wendy M Ingram; Lisa Jones; Ian Jones; Mario Juruena; George Kirov; Mikael Landén; Daniel J Müller; Axel Nordensköld; Erik Pålsson; Meethu Paul; Agnieszka Permoda; Bartlomiej Pliszka; Jamie Rea; Klaus O Schubert; Joshua A Sonnen; Virginia Soria; Will Stageman; Akihiro Takamiya; Mikel Urretavizacaya; Stuart Watson; Maxim Zavorotny; Allan H Young; Eduard Vieta; Janusz K Rybakowski; Massimo Gennarelli; Peter P Zandi; Patrick F Sullivan; Bernhard T Baune Journal: Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci Date: 2019-12-04 Impact factor: 5.270
Authors: Mike M Schmitgen; Katharina M Kubera; Malte S Depping; Henrike M Nolte; Dusan Hirjak; Stefan Hofer; Julia H Hasenkamp; Ulrich Seidl; Bram Stieltjes; Klaus H Maier-Hein; Fabio Sambataro; Alexander Sartorius; Philipp A Thomann; Robert C Wolf Journal: Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci Date: 2019-07-05 Impact factor: 5.270
Authors: Heikki Laurikainen; Iina Isotupa; Mikko Nyman; Tuula Ilonen; Teija Nummelin; Raimo K R Salokangas; Jarmo Hietala Journal: BMC Psychiatry Date: 2019-05-10 Impact factor: 3.630
Authors: Christoph Kraus; Rene Seiger; Daniela M Pfabigan; Ronald Sladky; Martin Tik; Katharina Paul; Michael Woletz; Gregor Gryglewski; Thomas Vanicek; Arkadiusz Komorowski; Siegfried Kasper; Claus Lamm; Christian Windischberger; Rupert Lanzenberger Journal: Int J Neuropsychopharmacol Date: 2019-08-01 Impact factor: 5.176
Authors: Lucas Borrione; Helena Bellini; Lais Boralli Razza; Ana G Avila; Chris Baeken; Anna-Katharine Brem; Geraldo Busatto; Andre F Carvalho; Adam Chekroud; Zafiris J Daskalakis; Zhi-De Deng; Jonathan Downar; Wagner Gattaz; Colleen Loo; Paulo A Lotufo; Maria da Graça M Martin; Shawn M McClintock; Jacinta O'Shea; Frank Padberg; Ives C Passos; Giovanni A Salum; Marie-Anne Vanderhasselt; Renerio Fraguas; Isabela Benseñor; Leandro Valiengo; Andre R Brunoni Journal: Braz J Psychiatry Date: 2020-03-16 Impact factor: 2.697
Authors: Olga Therese Ousdal; Giulio E Brancati; Ute Kessler; Vera Erchinger; Anders M Dale; Christopher Abbott; Leif Oltedal Journal: Biol Psychiatry Date: 2021-05-31 Impact factor: 13.382